User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by SCACE

superman, the current sim is set to pass when behind. New AI WILL allow you to OVERRIDE the SIM AI...meaning if you want to run the entire game, you should be able to, as long as the situation is covered off in your advanced AI settings.

So next season, you can test the idea.


Im just saying that since the sim knows if the run isnt working, you should pass. It should also know if the pass isnt working, you should run.


That's what the ultimate scapegoat and hated auto-adjust does. But it can't do it if you turn it off like most people do.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
Originally posted by jdbolick

You guys keep ignoring the fact that the 10 INTs (which is obviously ridiculous itself) weren't the only statistical aberration. As they noted, the pancakes were 23-0, and despite being a strong rushing team, Nashville averaged less than a yard per carry. The result is not remotely realistic, not even on a team's absolute worst day. It's basically like something in the simulation transformed Nashville into a much lower level team.

I have no dog in this fight, I'm just concerned about the reliability of a game I've already spent money on and planned to spend more on. Those of you who think you are doing the right thing by sucking up to Bort are not doing him any favors. Consumer confidence is critically important for any service, and people need to believe that the results are both realistic and justified. Nashville getting blown out by Miami is possible even though they're similarly ranked. Nashville experiencing that many extraordinary statistical anomalies is not in any way realistic, and is clear proof of something being faulty in the simulation programming.


Okay...wait a strong rushing team shut down in the playoffs. Like the 2006 Kansas City Chiefs? Okay they didn't have 10 INTs, but individually any one of these occurrences doesn't prove the SIM is broken. As a collection they are separate random events. Does it suck...yes. But remember when the QB is sucking and he is your "field general" I'm guessing just like he would pick your team up, he drags your team down!!!


I doubt that part. I'd be pretty certain that an SA (especially the expensive one at the end of the tree like that) can never hurt your team.

At worst, if your QB's morale goes too low, his ability to help as a Field General is much less or even zero (but never negative).
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by jdbolick

Do I really need to point out that 6 < 10? If I have to give basic arithmetic lessons in this thread then I don't really think it's worth the effort. And again, nowhere in actual football do you see a horrible game by the quarterback (even if we momentarily overlook the fact that this was a worse performance than any in real history) coupled with such utter futility by a running game, plus absurd domination by the lines. This kind of result should only be possible if a AA team was playing an A team. It's just not remotely realistic, which is a huge problem for a simulation that people obviously expect to produce believable results.

Peyton Manning would equate to a level 100 quarterback. Why is it not feasible that a quarterback at 25% his level and probably 10% his actual ability, at his very worst, would have 166% as many interceptions as Peyton did at his worst? If anything he should be thanking Bort because he didn't throw 24 INTs, as at least that would match up mathematically.


No, that would be a poor anaysis. There is no such thing, rl or GLB, as a Level 100 QB. No one will ever reach level 100, and exp is given out more slowly as one levels partially to limit how high one can go.

Manning can only be what the best QB's can be when they peak, which is probably level 50-60. The difference between a level 25 and a level 60 is about a quarter of that between a level 1 and a level 25, because of the soft caps on attributes (which doesn't end at 2 but becomes 3, 4, 5, and maybe even higher) as well as the increasing cost of SA's.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by oldskool

Originally posted by jdbolick



18 times is not insignificant, but I'm not talking about expecting them to have equal numbers of pancakes. Miami having the edge is reasonable. 23-0 is not reasonable at all. If those types of outcomes are common in GLB, then GLB is guilty of being an inaccurate simulation and not representative of high level organized football.

25/100 is not high level, especially when the build's so bad it's more like 16/100.


Are you suggesting players are going to get to level 100?


I'm saying if you assume that 100 is the level cap, you have to assume that the best of the best players in the best of the best "high level organized football" leagues (read: the NFL) are going to be at level 100.

If a "level 100" Manning can throw 6 INTs in a competitive matchup, how can you say it's not feasible for a "level 25" to throw 10, especially when it's such a horrible level 25?


The effective level cap is the one that can actually be reached. No one will reach 100 or anywhere near it, so you can't treat that as if the best QB's are that level.

The highest anyone will reach is most likely 55-60. And every level means less than the one before it (beyond 20ish) due to soft caps.

There are some arguments I'm reading that have me questioning whether this result is unreasonable, but this isn't one of them.

The argument for it being reasonable is, his build was bad and his confidence very low for a QB his level, the defense had a lot of intimidation abilities and played the pass, and as much as I hate the fact the Season 3 sim is strongly in favor of defense over offense (the winning team's averages would be poor in the NFL).

So, you take a sim that strongly favors defenses (say, the game is played in a blizzard, as has every Season 3 game been played), a QB playing major college competition with high school level Confidence (and the morale spiral), and I can start to see it.

The Season 3 defense overpowering is hopefully going to be fixed for Season 4. It will at least be lessened. Larry wanted the changes this season, and I'd have preferred them this season; but Bort would have had to deal with the flak if he had made the change in-season, and only he knows what that is.

BUT, stop saying these players are pee wees or something, as if you take 100 as the top level (when it isn't; it's closer to 55 or 60) and ignore that level means less and less as they get higher and higher, we should be expecting to see pro-like stats.

The argument you're making basically would allow people forever, even past Beta, to say, "100 is the max, so at your level 55 peak it's Division 3 college football" so that anything unrealistic can be made to sound acceptable.

That does lots of harm.

This Season 3 sim is broken, and that's a part of what happened. Defenses have a big edge. The confidence spiral was another big part, as were things that quite rightly mattered, such as the build of the QB and the tactics of the defense.

This is an example of the Season 3 sim being broken, also combined with some factors that were entirely legitimate, none of which is the player level factor though.

If the sim for Season 4 is as good as I'd hope in my best dreams for it, there'd have been only, say, 6 interceptions (due to the legitimate factors), because offenses won't be overpowered by defenses.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 06:24:51
 
karma99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LordEvil
Here is a freebie
Sub Randomizer()
Dim x As Long, y As Long, z As Long, tempnum As Long
Dim flag As Boolean
Dim i As Integer
Dim foundCell As Range
Application.ScreenUpdating = False
x = Application.InputBox("Enter starting Random Number" _
, "Random Number Generation", 1, , , , , 1)
y = Application.InputBox("Enter ending Random Number" _
, "Random Number Generation", 1000, , , , , 1)
z = Application.InputBox("How many random numbers would" _
& "you like to generate (<15000)?" _
, "Random Number Generation", 100, , , , , 1)
If z = 0 Then Exit Sub
If z > 15000 Then z = 15000
If z > y - x + 1 Then
MsgBox "You specified more numbers to return than " _
& "are possible in the range!"
Exit Sub
End If
Randomize
Cells(1, 1) = Int((y - x + 1) * Rnd + x)
For i = 2 To z
Do
flag = False
Randomize
tempnum = Int((y - x + 1) * Rnd + x)
Set foundCell = Range("a1", _
Range("a1").End(xlDown).Address).Find(tempnum)
If Not (foundCell Is Nothing) Then
flag = True
End If
Loop Until Not flag
Cells(i, 1) = tempnum
Next
End Sub


http://support.microsoft.com/kb/213290
Cut and paste for code from the MSDN, nice job! LMAO!
So coder boy, fancy pasting the entire sim script for GLB next? As someone already said, you obviously have NO idea how the sim works. To generate a score and then backdate the replays to match the score is infinately more complex (and rediculous) than running each play and determining the events within it, as GLB does.
If you think interceptions need to be a bit harder for the D player to bring in, so be it, a tweak to the algorithm. If you think QB's shouldn't get fazed so easily, then the same.
But to expect a hardcap on the outcome based on individually simmed events.. you have all the credibility of a chocolate teapot mate!
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 05:33:11
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
The difference between a level 25 and a level 60 is about a quarter of that between a level 1 and a level 25, because of the soft caps on attributes (which doesn't end at 2 but becomes 3, 4, 5, and maybe even higher) as well as the increasing cost of SA's.


Imagine if the formula for an interception looked something like:

(1+.01*SumReleventQBSAs)^(SumReleventQBAttribs) compared with a similar layout for the Defenders attributes

As the relevant attributes grew, the total impact would grow exponentially... very much like the compounding of interest rates over period of time, because you are gaining interest on the interest. I'm not saying that GLB uses exponential formulas for it's calculations - but I don't have the formulas to look at, and without those formulas - it's really hard to know whether the impact from going from level 1 to 10 is greater or less than the impact of going from level 25 to 40.
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Alright. I made it to page 27 before I finally couldn't stand laughing anymore.


It was mentioned, by Bort and a one or two others, but not really acknowledged by Larry, Ken, and the "This Game Sucks!" Orchestra. So, let me reintroduce the most obvious reasoning for how this happened.

Miami's secondary was a freakish collection of ball hawks before they boosted. Whatever they're doing with those guys is working exceedingly well, and then they each added 15 SP? Um...yeah. Stands to reason that a group of outstanding DBs would benefit greatly from 15 added SP, not to mention the 4 extra equipment points that I assume a couple of those guys got.


Now you put a poorly built QB on the field against this secondary that's Hall of Fame caliber by comparison, and you're surprised they ate his lunch?


I have to echo an earlier sentiment. Rather than go ballistic over a defensive performance that doesn't look all that far fetched when you take the basic facts into account, thank the football sim gods this didn't happen on a regular basis.


My team's defense plucked 6 passes out of the air against our conference's best pass offense that features a QB who doesn't turn the ball over very often. There are reasons that things like this happen, and it's not always the evil sim monster. Half the reason we play this game is to figure how to make those things happen.


Priority 1 for Nashville should be finding a real QB. Use the "playoff team" schtick as a sales pitch. Just make sure you check out the QB's build before you sign him. Replacing Tim Couch with Alex Smith won't help.



In any event, as an unbiased observer, let me tip my hat to Miami for an unparalleled defensive performance. You bad.
 
dkgojackets
offline
Link
 
lol at this entire thread, especially op
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Wow over 20 pages since I stopped reading....

Did anyone tell Larry that he is the biggest crybaby in the History of GLB?... or how about that he should take his one player and just go home?!
 
jamyp
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by superman8456

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by jdbolick



Originally posted by driftinggrifter




Can you tell me the biggest blow out in college football history? Hint: one team had over 100pts scored against them.

Cumberland vs. Georgia Tech. Try asking me something I didn't know when I was ten years old.
Originally posted by




People have already given real life NFL and College stats that prove these games DO happen in RL.

No, these types of results do not happen. Those trying to kiss Bort's ass have repeatedly pointed out that the highest interception totals in the history of the NFL almost equaled what happened here, and that's momentarily ignoring the fact that this wasn't a match-up between two clearly disparate opponents.


Except that, these two teams WERENT EQUAL, A. you had a Miami team that had CLEARLY BETTER BUILDS, and they had BOOSTED RIGHT BEFORE THE GAME, B. you had a Nashville QB who couldn't hit the broadside of a barn, let alone, see it.


These teams were equal. Bad QB build doesnt mean the whole team has bad builds.


It's a great indication of it,


no it isn't. i gave my entire team complete freedom when it came to their builds. All of the members of the team give suggestions and such to the other players but i havne't ever demanded anything. I think our players have some awesome builds.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by jamyp
no it isn't. i gave my entire team complete freedom when it came to their builds. All of the members of the team give suggestions and such to the other players but i havne't ever demanded anything. I think our players have some awesome builds.


I'm sure some of your players do, but the QB needs a lot of help/patience to get back to form or you need a new QB.
 
Intimnasc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
As many here will attest, I've been one of the more ardent defenders of Goal Line Blitz--I've argued against crappy suggestion after crappy suggestion because I've trusted the developers had a vision for the game that would in time make it great.

But not any more.

Our 11-5 team (seeded sixth overall) just played a 13-3 team (seeded third overall) in an opening round playoff game. We lost 45-0.

But I'm just getting started.

Our starting QB threw only 15 INTs all season long. He threw NINE in today's game.

Our backup QB threw another, putting us at TEN INTs for the day.

Add in 3 sacks and 7 hurries.

Add in a "running game" that amassed 17 yards on 18 carries ("Yes", I already backed out the sack yardage--"Yes", even with the sacks removed, we averaged less than a yard a carry).

In short, Season #3's sims have demonstrated all year long that they are far from acceptable when it comes to realism. Myself and others have documented in other threads that the offensive side of the sim is BROKEN--that neither the run nor the pass works well when 2 "roughly similar" teams square off in the higher level leagues. And I went on record more than once pointing out that it would be a MISTAKE to allow this nonsense to continue on thru the playoffs without fixing the offenses.

But to pretend that our entire team (which nearly every member of paid to boost the entire 3 levels for this season, last season, and the innaugural one) is supposed to be satisified with such a BULLSHIT playoff sim as being the end to our "season" is an absolute joke.

Sorry Bort, I tried to support you. But you should have stepped in and fixed the sims before it ever got to the PLAYOFFS of "Season 3". 10 freaking interceptions in a game belongs nowhere in your coding--particularly so when its a playoff game between 2 teams with roughly similar records and roughly similar levels.

You owe Nashville a refund--and not in flex points that could only be spent on a BROKEN sim. Cash please--no "sim" worth paying pretends that a PLAYOFF TEAM throws 10 picks in a single game. There's not an excuse you can offer as to why we're supposed to be happy having our "season" end with TEN interceptions in a SINGLE GAME--NINE of them by our starter who threw only 15 all season.


I agree 100% man we were the number 2 seede team Threw only a couple of interceptions all season and now throws 4 in one game with 2 and a sack coming in the 4th quarter on comeback drives. I don't mind losing but until I read this I thought we were just VERY unlucky. Now I think theres something in the sims.
 
jamyp
offline
Link
 
Well I am curious to see how Miami does in tomorrow's game. I think it will be very telling about this situation and I personally will feel a lot better if it is another blowout wiht about 13 picks. LOL!!!

If we do just have a bad QB build in combination with being "unlucky" as Bort put it then so be it.

 
BigCowboysFan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
As many here will attest, I've been one of the more ardent defenders of Goal Line Blitz--I've argued against crappy suggestion after crappy suggestion because I've trusted the developers had a vision for the game that would in time make it great.

But not any more.

Our 11-5 team (seeded sixth overall) just played a 13-3 team (seeded third overall) in an opening round playoff game. We lost 45-0.

But I'm just getting started.

Our starting QB threw only 15 INTs all season long. He threw NINE in today's game.

Our backup QB threw another, putting us at TEN INTs for the day.

Add in 3 sacks and 7 hurries.

Add in a "running game" that amassed 17 yards on 18 carries ("Yes", I already backed out the sack yardage--"Yes", even with the sacks removed, we averaged less than a yard a carry).

In short, Season #3's sims have demonstrated all year long that they are far from acceptable when it comes to realism. Myself and others have documented in other threads that the offensive side of the sim is BROKEN--that neither the run nor the pass works well when 2 "roughly similar" teams square off in the higher level leagues. And I went on record more than once pointing out that it would be a MISTAKE to allow this nonsense to continue on thru the playoffs without fixing the offenses.

But to pretend that our entire team (which nearly every member of paid to boost the entire 3 levels for this season, last season, and the innaugural one) is supposed to be satisified with such a BULLSHIT playoff sim as being the end to our "season" is an absolute joke.

Sorry Bort, I tried to support you. But you should have stepped in and fixed the sims before it ever got to the PLAYOFFS of "Season 3". 10 freaking interceptions in a game belongs nowhere in your coding--particularly so when its a playoff game between 2 teams with roughly similar records and roughly similar levels.

You owe Nashville a refund--and not in flex points that could only be spent on a BROKEN sim. Cash please--no "sim" worth paying pretends that a PLAYOFF TEAM throws 10 picks in a single game. There's not an excuse you can offer as to why we're supposed to be happy having our "season" end with TEN interceptions in a SINGLE GAME--NINE of them by our starter who threw only 15 all season.


Well, for starters, you knew it was a BETA game and that it is still a WORK IN PROGRESS. Second of all, how could you say that there is no way your team could throw 10 picks? It's all about game planning.

I am reminded in this instance of a 1992 Buffalo Bills team that was destined to destroy a 1992 Dallas Cowboys team that was just starting out and had a young QB, HB, and WR that one day became known as "The Triplets" and went on a tear through the NFL for several years.

I do believe that the highly rated Buffalo Bills lost that game 52-17. You must remember that any team can be game planned for. The Bills had several key fumbles and interceptions in that game that led to several points for the Cowboys and if it hadn't been for one moron showboating they would hold the record for the most points ever scored in a Super Bowl.

Long story short...

1. THIS IS A BETA GAME! NOTHING IS PERFECT YET, BUT I've played other BETA and MMORPG games and I love this one. Even if there are a few bugs.

2. IT SAYS BETA GAME AND "WE ARE CONSTANTLY WORKING TO IMPROVE THE SITE" all over the site. You know that it is a work in progress and therefore have spent money knowing this. I too have spent money on this game. Its not great when something doesn't go right, but cry me a river, build me a bridge and then get over it.

3. Everybody has to lose and regardless of whether it is one point or 100 points, that's the nature of the game. Get use to it.

M
 
BigCowboysFan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dmac2008
Originally posted by Serenity

Originally posted by Deuceswild26


Strength: 34 Blocking: 9
Speed: 18.37 Tackling: 9
Agility: 22.68 Throwing: 59
Jumping: 14.5 Catching: 14.5
Stamina: 52.66 Carrying: 14.5
Vision: 47.75 Kicking: 9
Confidence: 29.12 Punting: 9


Confidence killed him.
WTF @ 52 stamina.


no wonder..... no re-sim needed lol

As soon as your QB threw an INT he probably went and cried.


Hahahaha
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.