User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Corners are too fast
Page:
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JD Cuda
Originally posted by j10er

Using the GLB attributes, if you were coding speed while running a route, what would you include?


speed, agility, stamina, vision, strength


I'd go with speed for top end speed. Agility for acceleration and cutting. Stamina for energy levels, vision to have the WR see the ball coming and make catches, strength to break tackles and block.

There should be no major correlation between most stats. Without agility a WR can't get to top speed, I actually think this should be adjusted upwards as it is. Without vision he can't make the catch, without strength he can't break tackles.

130 speed without any other attributes would be like a track start that tries to play football and fails miserably because he can't run clean routes and can't catch shit. 130 speed with other great attributes would be like Randy Moss or Steve Smith.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas

130 speed without any other attributes would be like a track start that tries to play football and fails miserably because he can't run clean routes and can't catch shit. 130 speed with other great attributes would be like Randy Moss or Steve Smith.


This is exactly the point I was trying to make.

So, if you were coding the game, how would you control or express speed during a route? Let's just focus on general speed (and/or acceleration), and not cutting or other factors.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by PierreThomas


130 speed without any other attributes would be like a track start that tries to play football and fails miserably because he can't run clean routes and can't catch shit. 130 speed with other great attributes would be like Randy Moss or Steve Smith.


This is exactly the point I was trying to make.

So, if you were coding the game, how would you control or express speed during a route? Let's just focus on general speed (and/or acceleration), and not cutting or other factors.


Ok, so lets say a 130 speed with no points in agility, vision, catching, etc

The play starts he accelerates so slow that he can't get past anyone.


Lets say a 130 speed, 80 agility guy with no points in vision, catching, etc.

He blasts off the line when the ball is snapped then runs past corners with speed in the 90s, the QB bombs it out to him and he drops it, just about every time.

A WR with 130 speed, 80 agility, 61 catching, 60 vision, 48 confidence, 48 stamina, 48 jumping WR.

The defense better game plan.
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
They run faster than WRs with the same attributes, and just as fast as WRs with better attributes. This could be the cause of shutdown coverage VA but I really don't think that is the case because they also run down RBs that are faster.

Deathblade's script show this constantly. A WR with 115 speed and 80 agility runs about the same as a CB with 85 speed and 80 agility.

It also shows corners running down faster players like this.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=662426&pbp_id=2284165


terrible CB vision paths anyway, bort made it up to him by giving him a tackle.
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
Originally posted by PierreThomas

They run faster than WRs with the same attributes, and just as fast as WRs with better attributes. This could be the cause of shutdown coverage VA but I really don't think that is the case because they also run down RBs that are faster.

Deathblade's script show this constantly. A WR with 115 speed and 80 agility runs about the same as a CB with 85 speed and 80 agility.

It also shows corners running down faster players like this.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=662426&pbp_id=2284165


terrible CB vision paths anyway, bort made it up to him by giving him a tackle.


If he hadn't bobbled the catch, and that WR didn't 'push' the CB in the right direction, probably would've been a TD.
 
SikoraP13 DTD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by j10er

Originally posted by PierreThomas



130 speed without any other attributes would be like a track start that tries to play football and fails miserably because he can't run clean routes and can't catch shit. 130 speed with other great attributes would be like Randy Moss or Steve Smith.


This is exactly the point I was trying to make.

So, if you were coding the game, how would you control or express speed during a route? Let's just focus on general speed (and/or acceleration), and not cutting or other factors.


Ok, so lets say a 130 speed with no points in agility, vision, catching, etc

The play starts he accelerates so slow that he can't get past anyone.


Lets say a 130 speed, 80 agility guy with no points in vision, catching, etc.

He blasts off the line when the ball is snapped then runs past corners with speed in the 90s, the QB bombs it out to him and he drops it, just about every time.

A WR with 130 speed, 80 agility, 61 catching, 60 vision, 48 confidence, 48 stamina, 48 jumping WR.

The defense better game plan.


no, the corner better jam him at the line since the WR only has about 10 str and the WR gets knocked flat on his ass because he neglected strength...give corners the ability to jam WRs or leave it alone...

Breakdown of a corner......Breakdown of a WR
Speed...................................Speed
Agility......................................Agility
Vision......................................Jumping
Str.............................................Vision
Tackling...................................Catching
Catching..................................Carrying
Jumping.....................................Confidence
Confidence............................

Cbs need more skills to be successful than WRs since they also need to stop HBs and other guys with over 10 str...they need the extra bit of speed given to them to be able to keep up since they can't just jam the incredibly weak WRs at the line...Give CBs the ability to jam the WR at the line, then I'd be okay with giving up the speed boost we have...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SikoraP13

no, the corner better jam him at the line since the WR only has about 10 str and the WR gets knocked flat on his ass because he neglected strength...give corners the ability to jam WRs or leave it alone...


I agree 100%
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by SikoraP13


no, the corner better jam him at the line since the WR only has about 10 str and the WR gets knocked flat on his ass because he neglected strength...give corners the ability to jam WRs or leave it alone...


I agree 100%


Me too but if a corner tries to jam a stronger WR he better be ready to get put on his butt as the WR runs open down the field with nobody covering him.
 
JD Cuda
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by SikoraP13



no, the corner better jam him at the line since the WR only has about 10 str and the WR gets knocked flat on his ass because he neglected strength...give corners the ability to jam WRs or leave it alone...


I agree 100%


Me too but if a corner tries to jam a stronger WR he better be ready to get put on his butt as the WR runs open down the field with nobody covering him.


Pretty sure ITS, of all people, would agree with you on that one.

I also agree. It needs to go both ways.
 
฿ones
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by SikoraP13



no, the corner better jam him at the line since the WR only has about 10 str and the WR gets knocked flat on his ass because he neglected strength...give corners the ability to jam WRs or leave it alone...


I agree 100%


Me too but if a corner tries to jam a stronger WR he better be ready to get put on his butt as the WR runs open down the field with nobody covering him.


Careful, both quoted outcomes should be extremely hard to attain (albeit the first one quoted will be 'easy' for the first 1/2 a season). The outcome that should occur the most often is 'CB slows down the WR' and disrupts the QBs' vision checks by extension.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23

Originally posted by tbsteel


Originally posted by PierreThomas



Originally posted by fallingmercury




Originally posted by PierreThomas





Originally posted by fallingmercury






Originally posted by PierreThomas








On #2 I understand completely what you are saying and for most players that is completely true. Most NFL WRs aren't going to just run by people but there are some who can.

A WR with 10% more speed should be able to get some separation from a CB that doesn't give up a cushion, not much but some. A WR with 20% more speed should eat a CB alive.


That's just the thing. There shouldn't be WRs with 20% or even 10% more speed than the CB.

A WR with a 4.4 time is never going to face a CB who's 20% slower in real life. That would mean the CB has a preposterous 5.28 40-meter dash time! But in GLB terms, a 20% difference can happen even when the CB has 105 speed.

A 10% boost is the difference between a 4.4 time and an abysmal 4.84 time. 4.84-speed CBs don't really exist, but in GLB it's cake to get 10% more speed than a defender. If that's what it takes to get open, then everyone is going to be open.


4.84 40 CBs do exist in GLB and they do just fine, that is the whole problem.

Once I can get level 56 equipment upgrades on my DTs they will be playing with as much speed as my CBs. Every LB, SS, FS, receiving TE and speed based DE plays with a lot more speed than my CBs.


And I'm saying speed needs a code overhaul so that there's not such an amazing difference between high and low speed.


Why not just hard cap speed? Once you get to 70 natural speed you can't put any more points into it? Is that better?

If you are so worried about realism then why aren't you complaining about your CB with 55 pass deflections half way through the season? Why are you so worried about the speed of WRs when you mostly just own cornerbacks?


Seriously man, I've got my WR builds open. I have a guy with 116 speed and 78 agility that tops out at about 32.45. I have a CB with 88 speed and 77 agility that tops out at 32.06. That translates to an increase of speed by 1% on a WR that spent 75 more skill points on speed than the CB. How can anyone in their right mind say that if you increase the points in speed by 13.5% it should only make the WR go 1% faster and then bitch about speed being too powerful? This doesn't even take into consideration the owner of the game flat out saying that speed does not have diminishing returns when it is so obvious that the diminishing returns are incredibly huge for all but a few WRs.

It isn't like I am asking for Cbs to have bricks put on their feet, just that they should be on a level playing field. I bet when the pass mechanics were tested before season 8 that they weren't testing 85 speed, agiilty and vision CBs against 120 speed, 80 agility WRs. They were testing them against 105 speed CBs not realizing a CB could drop speed down incredibly low, pump up vision and agility and do far better than was intended.

It isn't like I think CBs are too good and asking for them not to be able to deflect passes, hell, I am asking for a fix to CB cushions, first step, jumping routes and missing and to increase interceptions. I want to make CBs better but I also want them to live by the same standards as every other position.

It would allow more types of WR builds to be successful, it would allow for more types of CB builds to be successful, it would allow for a more realistic passing game, it would allow for offenses to gameplan for certain corners and force defenses to be aware of the different types of WRs and were they line up.



I know you look at the 5-6 WRs in this thread that are the exception rather than the rule to base your argument off of but for every one of those guys there are a thousand that don't go near as fast as they should.



That's a great way of summing this up.


PierreThomas, I agree with what you're posting. FWIW, I'm a cornerback builder. However, I don't think it's fair to implement such changes until press coverage is added. Without press coverage, it is impossible for a slower corner to stop streaks unless there's a safety over the top.


I've explained it over and over again. You can stop a streak quite easily but the CB is going to need about 105 speed to keep up with the fastest WRs without giving up a huge cushion. First, the reaction of CBs will have to be fixed when they give the WR a cushion but exactly what is wrong with fixing a broken sim mechanic? If a 105 speed CB is lined up against a 125 speed WR and all other things are equal then the WR would run about 1 yard faster for every 10 yards the Cb is covering him. That means a 5 yard cushion and the WR wouldn't be able to get past him until they were 50 yards down the field. That doesn't even include the speed boost from shutdown coverage SA. The difference now is that an 85 speed CB can line up directly in front of a 120 speed WR with no cushion and not get beat. Again, there are a handful of WRs that can absolutely fly for whatever reason but there are also a handful of receivers in real football that can absolutely fly and get open that teams can't just shutdown with one guy. But just like real football, defenses will have to scout and gameplan to stop him by using safety help and cushions. It really isn't a new concept and has been around since the forward pass was invented so I'm not sure why it is so hard for everyone to understand.


It'll be impossible for the defense to know what kind of cushion to give. You can only pick one cushion that you have to use for the whole game. If you pick 5, sure, you'll stop streaks but you'll get eaten alive by short/medium passes. It works in real life because the defensive coordinator can see exactly where the offensive WRs are lining up and roll coverage / back off accordingly. In GLB, that's not possible because a DC cannot react to the offensive personnel. Therefore, the CB must chooseone tactic setting to stop every possible kind of WR on a team. There is no "game planning" for a player in GLB... only the offense as a whole. You cannot gameplan coverage around a player because you don't know if he'll be in or not.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23
It'll be impossible for the defense to know what kind of cushion to give. You can only pick one cushion that you have to use for the whole game. If you pick 5, sure, you'll stop streaks but you'll get eaten alive by short/medium passes. It works in real life because the defensive coordinator can see exactly where the offensive WRs are lining up and roll coverage / back off accordingly. In GLB, that's not possible because a DC cannot react to the offensive personnel. Therefore, the CB must chooseone tactic setting to stop every possible kind of WR on a team. There is no "game planning" for a player in GLB... only the offense as a whole. You cannot gameplan coverage around a player because you don't know if he'll be in or not.


Pretty much.

You can't use what happens in real life when the play calling and tactics are stagnant, unlike real life.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23

It'll be impossible for the defense to know what kind of cushion to give. You can only pick one cushion that you have to use for the whole game. If you pick 5, sure, you'll stop streaks but you'll get eaten alive by short/medium passes. It works in real life because the defensive coordinator can see exactly where the offensive WRs are lining up and roll coverage / back off accordingly. In GLB, that's not possible because a DC cannot react to the offensive personnel. Therefore, the CB must chooseone tactic setting to stop every possible kind of WR on a team. There is no "game planning" for a player in GLB... only the offense as a whole. You cannot gameplan coverage around a player because you don't know if he'll be in or not.


This is a huge problem in GLB, imo.

Many of the individual tactics are counter-intuitive, rigid and unrealistic. Football is way too dynamic to stick to one setting for the entire game.

Coverage is the worst. There are times when a CB should be aggressive, and times when he shouldn't be. There are times when the cushion should be non-existant, and times when it should be large. Etc., etc.

Coverage options should be handled in the DAI, not by the player. It doesn't make any sense in its current form.

Some individual tactics need to go away, period.
 
Meteor53
offline
Link
 
Height = longer strides
he probably has other higher attributes like vision jumping ( for diving tackle ) ect..
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23


It'll be impossible for the defense to know what kind of cushion to give. You can only pick one cushion that you have to use for the whole game. If you pick 5, sure, you'll stop streaks but you'll get eaten alive by short/medium passes. It works in real life because the defensive coordinator can see exactly where the offensive WRs are lining up and roll coverage / back off accordingly. In GLB, that's not possible because a DC cannot react to the offensive personnel. Therefore, the CB must chooseone tactic setting to stop every possible kind of WR on a team. There is no "game planning" for a player in GLB... only the offense as a whole. You cannot gameplan coverage around a player because you don't know if he'll be in or not.


This is a huge problem in GLB, imo.

Many of the individual tactics are counter-intuitive, rigid and unrealistic. Football is way too dynamic to stick to one setting for the entire game.

Coverage is the worst. There are times when a CB should be aggressive, and times when he shouldn't be. There are times when the cushion should be non-existant, and times when it should be large. Etc., etc.

Coverage options should be handled in the DAI, not by the player. It doesn't make any sense in its current form.

Some individual tactics need to go away, period.


I made a suggestion about situational tactics. Most people liked it, but you would be suprised how many people said stuff along the lines of "but i dont want someone else telling my player what to do"
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.