Haterade.....now thats funny! I missed that one somewhere.
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
joemiken
offline
offline
Sounds like a good start. Two requests that I'd like to make..
1.) Make sure the player receiving the endorsement is still in said conference. Seems pretty pointless to have a WR get an endorsement in USA Pro if he's moved onto a team in CPL.
2.) PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE, thoroughly test the idea. Whether it's endorsements, play creators, or whatever, I would much rather that something be pushed back a season if it means that it'll be better executed when it is unveiled.
I like the idea of a conference and league championship MVP award too. Might have to make an exception to the "one award/player" condition for this though. It'd be pretty bad if a HB ran for 3 TDs and 150+ yards, yet didn't get the MVP because he's already getting a league endorsement.
1.) Make sure the player receiving the endorsement is still in said conference. Seems pretty pointless to have a WR get an endorsement in USA Pro if he's moved onto a team in CPL.
2.) PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE, thoroughly test the idea. Whether it's endorsements, play creators, or whatever, I would much rather that something be pushed back a season if it means that it'll be better executed when it is unveiled.
I like the idea of a conference and league championship MVP award too. Might have to make an exception to the "one award/player" condition for this though. It'd be pretty bad if a HB ran for 3 TDs and 150+ yards, yet didn't get the MVP because he's already getting a league endorsement.
PackMan97
offline
offline
As the winner of an endorsement...I like it. Even if it means losing mine.
Comments:
1. MVP Calculation - I would like to see it weight equally among each position. Basically calculate the top threats of all players but rank them by position. So, the top OT, NT, WR, QB all receive the same "top threat" score, modified by fame which should give a slight edge to the glam positions, but doesn't kill the chances of a non-glam breaking through.
My biggest concern is that these endorsements become something that only glamor players will receive and an OT or C that lead the league in pancakes has no prayer. Or the best NT in the league has no chance because he doesn't get the stats.
If ya catch my drift? I really like the idea but your current suggestion really has it limited to the guys that get top threats, which I'm just not sure is the best way to go about it especially since defense and lineman hardly ever make it up there.
Comments:
1. MVP Calculation - I would like to see it weight equally among each position. Basically calculate the top threats of all players but rank them by position. So, the top OT, NT, WR, QB all receive the same "top threat" score, modified by fame which should give a slight edge to the glam positions, but doesn't kill the chances of a non-glam breaking through.
My biggest concern is that these endorsements become something that only glamor players will receive and an OT or C that lead the league in pancakes has no prayer. Or the best NT in the league has no chance because he doesn't get the stats.
If ya catch my drift? I really like the idea but your current suggestion really has it limited to the guys that get top threats, which I'm just not sure is the best way to go about it especially since defense and lineman hardly ever make it up there.
notgoing2argue
offline
offline
Sorry I'm a little late to the discussion, but allow me to offer a new idea. This is probably well beyond the scope of this project for this season, but it would be a nice tweak to the endorsements.
Loyalty Endorsements. The regional and national endorsements are cool, but why not do something to reward the team first guys. You can probably combine this idea with the other endorsements, but my initial thought is to make these a separate endorsement that has nothing to do with fame or produciton. It's just a way to pick out a couple characters from your team who have stuck with you. This idea would obviously need some fleshing out because I haven't thought too deeply about its implementation.
My first thought is to have loyalty endorsements be permanent until you choose to relenquish it or leave the team. The bonus increases the longer you've been with the team. Have loyalty endorsements only be assigned once per season at the beginning of the season. As a player, you can choose to give up your endorsement any time so someone else can have a chance to have one, but they would have to wait until they are assigned at the beginning of the next season. This would give different players a shot at getting one if someone feels it doesn't really help them that much. How would they be assigned? Hell, I don't know, maybe randomly, assign them randomly to the guys who've been with the team the most seasons, have the owner select some people - maybe a mix of those ways. I like the random assignment myself.
As far as the bonus, I'd suggest making the bonus be Veteran points/skills instead of attributes and SAs. I know those are basically the same things, but it fits with the idea of loyalty better. I'm not sure exactly how you'd assign Veteran skills to these endorsements, but it would be cool if the loyalty endorsement VPs reset at the beginning of each season so you can reapply the VP to different skills. Kind of like using your offseason to work on new skills because you know the system well enough to allow you to do different training. Also, to make these endorsements have more character, maybe you can disable the ability to select the +1% attributes with these endorsements, that way the players have to choose the more colorful veteran skills.
How the bonus increases:
2 seasons = +2 VP
4 seasons= +4 VP
6 seasons= +6 VP
8 seasons= +8 VP
10 seasons= +10 VP
Other thoughts:
As far as championship game MVP endorsements go I like the idea. However, I wouldn't make these endorsements affect player stats. It just opens up the great become greater argument. I doubt that one endorsement would put a team over the top for the next season, but these will probably go to the QBs a lot so why not make these kind of endorsements be cash only, or 10 shopping tokens. You could also go with the plain old notoriety route. Maybe add the MVPs avatar on the league home page as last season's MVP and keep them there for a season. As long as the formula is good and that player actually deserved to be the MVP, then that person will feel pretty good that they get their props for a full season.
Loyalty Endorsements. The regional and national endorsements are cool, but why not do something to reward the team first guys. You can probably combine this idea with the other endorsements, but my initial thought is to make these a separate endorsement that has nothing to do with fame or produciton. It's just a way to pick out a couple characters from your team who have stuck with you. This idea would obviously need some fleshing out because I haven't thought too deeply about its implementation.
My first thought is to have loyalty endorsements be permanent until you choose to relenquish it or leave the team. The bonus increases the longer you've been with the team. Have loyalty endorsements only be assigned once per season at the beginning of the season. As a player, you can choose to give up your endorsement any time so someone else can have a chance to have one, but they would have to wait until they are assigned at the beginning of the next season. This would give different players a shot at getting one if someone feels it doesn't really help them that much. How would they be assigned? Hell, I don't know, maybe randomly, assign them randomly to the guys who've been with the team the most seasons, have the owner select some people - maybe a mix of those ways. I like the random assignment myself.
As far as the bonus, I'd suggest making the bonus be Veteran points/skills instead of attributes and SAs. I know those are basically the same things, but it fits with the idea of loyalty better. I'm not sure exactly how you'd assign Veteran skills to these endorsements, but it would be cool if the loyalty endorsement VPs reset at the beginning of each season so you can reapply the VP to different skills. Kind of like using your offseason to work on new skills because you know the system well enough to allow you to do different training. Also, to make these endorsements have more character, maybe you can disable the ability to select the +1% attributes with these endorsements, that way the players have to choose the more colorful veteran skills.
How the bonus increases:
2 seasons = +2 VP
4 seasons= +4 VP
6 seasons= +6 VP
8 seasons= +8 VP
10 seasons= +10 VP
Other thoughts:
As far as championship game MVP endorsements go I like the idea. However, I wouldn't make these endorsements affect player stats. It just opens up the great become greater argument. I doubt that one endorsement would put a team over the top for the next season, but these will probably go to the QBs a lot so why not make these kind of endorsements be cash only, or 10 shopping tokens. You could also go with the plain old notoriety route. Maybe add the MVPs avatar on the league home page as last season's MVP and keep them there for a season. As long as the formula is good and that player actually deserved to be the MVP, then that person will feel pretty good that they get their props for a full season.
Last edited Feb 27, 2009 12:13:04
F8n4tune
offline
offline
Originally posted by tautology
Bort:
Regarding MVPs
The biggest difficulty in determing these sorts of things has to do with palying gutted teams, and the fact some players may face 4 gutted teams while others might face one one (or none).
Does the differential in fame make up for this level of disparity?
For instance-
A level 40 HB can easily pick up 800+ yards and 20 TDs vs a gutted teams. If they play three more gutted teams than an opponent, that is perhaps an 1800 yard and 50 TD "lead" that thye establish against the rest of the league in their primary stat lines.
Solution: In order to prevent this from causing inequities, throw away the 4 best games from each player. That goes a long ways towards making things a bit more even.
This REALLY seems like a good idea , we all know guts are a serious problem when it comes to stats and it would make MEANINGFUL stats stand out imo.
Bort:
Regarding MVPs
The biggest difficulty in determing these sorts of things has to do with palying gutted teams, and the fact some players may face 4 gutted teams while others might face one one (or none).
Does the differential in fame make up for this level of disparity?
For instance-
A level 40 HB can easily pick up 800+ yards and 20 TDs vs a gutted teams. If they play three more gutted teams than an opponent, that is perhaps an 1800 yard and 50 TD "lead" that thye establish against the rest of the league in their primary stat lines.
Solution: In order to prevent this from causing inequities, throw away the 4 best games from each player. That goes a long ways towards making things a bit more even.
This REALLY seems like a good idea , we all know guts are a serious problem when it comes to stats and it would make MEANINGFUL stats stand out imo.
tjsexkitten82
offline
offline
Originally posted by F8n4tune
Originally posted by tautology
Bort:
Regarding MVPs
The biggest difficulty in determing these sorts of things has to do with palying gutted teams, and the fact some players may face 4 gutted teams while others might face one one (or none).
Does the differential in fame make up for this level of disparity?
For instance-
A level 40 HB can easily pick up 800+ yards and 20 TDs vs a gutted teams. If they play three more gutted teams than an opponent, that is perhaps an 1800 yard and 50 TD "lead" that thye establish against the rest of the league in their primary stat lines.
Solution: In order to prevent this from causing inequities, throw away the 4 best games from each player. That goes a long ways towards making things a bit more even.
This REALLY seems like a good idea , we all know guts are a serious problem when it comes to stats and it would make MEANINGFUL stats stand out imo.
Agreed. You can't just remove the gutted games because some teams play more some play less some play none. Further who's to say that an 80-0 win was or wasn't against a gutted team? Removing the 4 best games would be a great way to do it imo.
Originally posted by tautology
Bort:
Regarding MVPs
The biggest difficulty in determing these sorts of things has to do with palying gutted teams, and the fact some players may face 4 gutted teams while others might face one one (or none).
Does the differential in fame make up for this level of disparity?
For instance-
A level 40 HB can easily pick up 800+ yards and 20 TDs vs a gutted teams. If they play three more gutted teams than an opponent, that is perhaps an 1800 yard and 50 TD "lead" that thye establish against the rest of the league in their primary stat lines.
Solution: In order to prevent this from causing inequities, throw away the 4 best games from each player. That goes a long ways towards making things a bit more even.
This REALLY seems like a good idea , we all know guts are a serious problem when it comes to stats and it would make MEANINGFUL stats stand out imo.
Agreed. You can't just remove the gutted games because some teams play more some play less some play none. Further who's to say that an 80-0 win was or wasn't against a gutted team? Removing the 4 best games would be a great way to do it imo.
Last edited Feb 27, 2009 12:15:08
Makalele
offline
offline
I'm concerned that the method to determine MVP points for OL (and to a lesser extent, FB's & TE's) will be slanted too heavily towards pancakes. They are great as a "glamour" stat for an otherwise thankless position, but the majority of what makes a great blocker has nothing to do with them. I'd like to propose something that easily calculates how they help the efficiency of gaining positive yards and prevent the loss of yards, primarily sacks allowed.
I would think that coding actual sacks allowed by an individual would be difficult and time consuming, not to mention the great possibility for error, and so I would calculate based simply on being on the field when a sack occurs. If a sack is caused by a DT or NT, have it count against the C & G's on the field. A DE gets a sack, the OT's take the hit. If a LB or DB gets it, count it at half value against the entire OL (as some are inside vs. outside). I would think this very easy to gather correct data for.
As far as positive yardage goes, I would like to propose a stat based upon the average yardage gain when on the field. For example say team A gains 500 yards in 100 plays during a game, for an average of 5 per play. Lets say OT1 is on the field for 60 plays, where they gained 382 yards, and OT2 is on the field for 40 plays where they gained 118 yards. OT1's average for positive yardage while on the field is 6.367 while OT2's average is 2.95. Now take those numbers as a percentage against the team's average, and weight them with pancakes and sacks allowed to generate some values to work with for MVP scoring purposes. For TE's and FB's, who also gain yards and TD's, I would just give them a portion of this formula to factor in to their MVP calculations, so the pure blockers don't get left out in the cold.
I'm not sure how feasible this is, but I think it would be a step in the right direction to give the OL some love, without just being a pancake master.
Oh, and something similar could be worked out for NT's with rush yards allowed while on the field, to help them out.
I would think that coding actual sacks allowed by an individual would be difficult and time consuming, not to mention the great possibility for error, and so I would calculate based simply on being on the field when a sack occurs. If a sack is caused by a DT or NT, have it count against the C & G's on the field. A DE gets a sack, the OT's take the hit. If a LB or DB gets it, count it at half value against the entire OL (as some are inside vs. outside). I would think this very easy to gather correct data for.
As far as positive yardage goes, I would like to propose a stat based upon the average yardage gain when on the field. For example say team A gains 500 yards in 100 plays during a game, for an average of 5 per play. Lets say OT1 is on the field for 60 plays, where they gained 382 yards, and OT2 is on the field for 40 plays where they gained 118 yards. OT1's average for positive yardage while on the field is 6.367 while OT2's average is 2.95. Now take those numbers as a percentage against the team's average, and weight them with pancakes and sacks allowed to generate some values to work with for MVP scoring purposes. For TE's and FB's, who also gain yards and TD's, I would just give them a portion of this formula to factor in to their MVP calculations, so the pure blockers don't get left out in the cold.
I'm not sure how feasible this is, but I think it would be a step in the right direction to give the OL some love, without just being a pancake master.
Oh, and something similar could be worked out for NT's with rush yards allowed while on the field, to help them out.
Last edited Feb 27, 2009 12:23:15
baumusc
offline
offline
Originally posted by J9
Great ideas as always Bort.

Ah OK, I was wondering where the J9 from J9 Productions came from.
I was thinking that you might want to take the actual bonuses from endorsements down a notch as well so they give a decent advantage but not a huge one. The bonus equipment I got from my endorsement in AAA is about the same as a fully loaded piece of custom equipment only it gives bonuses to two SA's instead of 5. The two SA's it gives a +1 to are at the end of the ladder though so that is still pretty awesome and I heard that the Pro endorsements put the AAA ones to shame.
That being said you may have already taken care of any problems you would have with this by limiting a team to 3 working endorsements.
Great ideas as always Bort.

Ah OK, I was wondering where the J9 from J9 Productions came from.
I was thinking that you might want to take the actual bonuses from endorsements down a notch as well so they give a decent advantage but not a huge one. The bonus equipment I got from my endorsement in AAA is about the same as a fully loaded piece of custom equipment only it gives bonuses to two SA's instead of 5. The two SA's it gives a +1 to are at the end of the ladder though so that is still pretty awesome and I heard that the Pro endorsements put the AAA ones to shame.
That being said you may have already taken care of any problems you would have with this by limiting a team to 3 working endorsements.
bluur27
offline
offline
Well I was just thinking about this idea before I saw the thread and I guess it hashes out what all the flaws in my idea was. I was thinking of using the pro bowl script or threads voting for players to be used to determine who gets the endorsements but what still flawed that idea was you still have players that moved up leagues taking away endorsements from that league. What your saying pretty much makes more sense and I also like that you involve more players and teams.
geekor
offline
offline
Originally posted by
1. We come up with a MVP calculation. Base it on the current "top threats" calculations, combined with the fame value. Since you don't gain much, if any, fame from playing gutted teams, it will help to balance out the formula. With a bit of fiddling, I think it could work pretty well, and add a fun element of "MVP race" to each league. This will make glamor players more glamorous as well. We'll run a full season on the test server and tweak our formula until it looks pretty good based on the full season's stats. We do a separate MVP list for Offense, Defense, and ST players, per conference.
It need to remove all stats vs gutted teams then.
quite frankly some teams play more gutted teams than others. Using stats then is unbalanced and is basically rewarding those who play in a weak division.
And there should still be, albeit small, addition for making it and winning the title game. Players from both Zona and Pitts are more known know then ever, and are getting more endorsements now. I'm not saying like before where 10/16 went to one team, but there should be a very small addition to the chance to get one for making it to the big dance.
1. We come up with a MVP calculation. Base it on the current "top threats" calculations, combined with the fame value. Since you don't gain much, if any, fame from playing gutted teams, it will help to balance out the formula. With a bit of fiddling, I think it could work pretty well, and add a fun element of "MVP race" to each league. This will make glamor players more glamorous as well. We'll run a full season on the test server and tweak our formula until it looks pretty good based on the full season's stats. We do a separate MVP list for Offense, Defense, and ST players, per conference.
It need to remove all stats vs gutted teams then.
quite frankly some teams play more gutted teams than others. Using stats then is unbalanced and is basically rewarding those who play in a weak division.
And there should still be, albeit small, addition for making it and winning the title game. Players from both Zona and Pitts are more known know then ever, and are getting more endorsements now. I'm not saying like before where 10/16 went to one team, but there should be a very small addition to the chance to get one for making it to the big dance.
rotharek
offline
offline
How bout changing the item names around so they aren't based off some notoriously idiotic and annoying forum personality? I seriously don't want to get stuck wearing an endorsement slot with someone like Tim Harper or some random Cobra Kai member's name. Like what the fuck, am I alone here or what? I don't want that shit haha.
notgoing2argue
offline
offline
Originally posted by rotharek
How bout changing the item names around so they aren't based off some notoriously idiotic and annoying forum personality? I seriously don't want to get stuck wearing an endorsement slot with someone like Tim Harper or some random Cobra Kai member's name. Like what the fuck, am I alone here or what? I don't want that shit haha.
I'd agree on the names. Attention whores every last one of them.
How bout changing the item names around so they aren't based off some notoriously idiotic and annoying forum personality? I seriously don't want to get stuck wearing an endorsement slot with someone like Tim Harper or some random Cobra Kai member's name. Like what the fuck, am I alone here or what? I don't want that shit haha.
I'd agree on the names. Attention whores every last one of them.
Blisser
offline
offline
I don't see what the big deal about the endorsements is/was<go ahead and unleash the Barrage of insults folks, I'm waiting for them>. I would suggest setting up a poll if there is truly a concern about the way endorsements were handled, that way people who don't feel like putting up with the infantile insults on here can give their input as well. The endorsement thing has been in the works for a long time, been pretty well explained along the way, It's silly to have all these complaints now, and in my opinion sillier to be changing it now in response to them.
butler312
offline
offline
Originally posted by Blisser
I don't see what the big deal about the endorsements is/was<go ahead and unleash the Barrage of insults folks, I'm waiting for them>. I would suggest setting up a poll if there is truly a concern about the way endorsements were handled, that way people who don't feel like putting up with the infantile insults on here can give their input as well. The endorsement thing has been in the works for a long time, been pretty well explained along the way, It's silly to have all these complaints now, and in my opinion sillier to be changing it now in response to them.
I think a lot of the problem stems from the realism. Everyone thinks that the best players should get the endorsements, and that is not at all how Bort originally intended it. He wanted it to be random and for everyone to have a chance, with the best players only getting a slight advantage. It was never supposed to be realistic, just like items having bonuses in the first place isn't realistic.
The only real problem I saw with it was how it awarded winning a little too much. But it wasn't anything to get in an uproar about. There was nothing wrong with the way Bort intended to give them out in the first place. I do like this system better myself, but I still fail to see the reason everyone got so upset and demanded it to be done over right now. IMO, any new system should be held off until next season until it is thoroughly tested so we don't go through this again.
I don't see what the big deal about the endorsements is/was<go ahead and unleash the Barrage of insults folks, I'm waiting for them>. I would suggest setting up a poll if there is truly a concern about the way endorsements were handled, that way people who don't feel like putting up with the infantile insults on here can give their input as well. The endorsement thing has been in the works for a long time, been pretty well explained along the way, It's silly to have all these complaints now, and in my opinion sillier to be changing it now in response to them.
I think a lot of the problem stems from the realism. Everyone thinks that the best players should get the endorsements, and that is not at all how Bort originally intended it. He wanted it to be random and for everyone to have a chance, with the best players only getting a slight advantage. It was never supposed to be realistic, just like items having bonuses in the first place isn't realistic.
The only real problem I saw with it was how it awarded winning a little too much. But it wasn't anything to get in an uproar about. There was nothing wrong with the way Bort intended to give them out in the first place. I do like this system better myself, but I still fail to see the reason everyone got so upset and demanded it to be done over right now. IMO, any new system should be held off until next season until it is thoroughly tested so we don't go through this again.
Blisser
offline
offline
Originally posted by butler312
I think a lot of the problem stems from the realism. Everyone thinks that the best players should get the endorsements, and that is not at all how Bort originally intended it. He wanted it to be random and for everyone to have a chance, with the best players only getting a slight advantage. It was never supposed to be realistic, just like items having bonuses in the first place isn't realistic.
The only real problem I saw with it was how it awarded winning a little too much. But it wasn't anything to get in an uproar about. There was nothing wrong with the way Bort intended to give them out in the first place. I do like this system better myself, but I still fail to see the reason everyone got so upset and demanded it to be done over right now. IMO, any new system should be held off until next season until it is thoroughly tested so we don't go through this again.
It may be skewed a little too much in favor of league champions and what not, but it does still give a chance for everyone in the league to potentially get one. I don't like the new idea at all, I see lots more flaws in it to be honest. Put it to a poll, fairest way to get the opinion of the whole GLB community.
I think a lot of the problem stems from the realism. Everyone thinks that the best players should get the endorsements, and that is not at all how Bort originally intended it. He wanted it to be random and for everyone to have a chance, with the best players only getting a slight advantage. It was never supposed to be realistic, just like items having bonuses in the first place isn't realistic.
The only real problem I saw with it was how it awarded winning a little too much. But it wasn't anything to get in an uproar about. There was nothing wrong with the way Bort intended to give them out in the first place. I do like this system better myself, but I still fail to see the reason everyone got so upset and demanded it to be done over right now. IMO, any new system should be held off until next season until it is thoroughly tested so we don't go through this again.
It may be skewed a little too much in favor of league champions and what not, but it does still give a chance for everyone in the league to potentially get one. I don't like the new idea at all, I see lots more flaws in it to be honest. Put it to a poll, fairest way to get the opinion of the whole GLB community.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























