User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Never thought I'd have to soft cap vision on my DE.
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
These changes to the vision and LT are absolutely ridiculous. People with shitty builds and shitty AI's bitching and fucking moaning because they cant stand in the pocket for 3+ seconds. Good teams were not being sacked 8+ times a games. If you are getting sacked, run draws, throw short passes. Adapt to what is happening instead of whining until you get your way.

Changing the game to dumb down the builds, in the long run, will damage GLB.
 
Sockamidic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Many of the ostensibly dominant DEs were able to be stopped by some OTs. In fact, the OP in this thread complained about a DE that my team was able to hold to 1 sack. If correctly built OTs can stop the speed/agility rushers, then those that couldn't, weren't built correctly. In my opinion, it's only an exploit if it can't be stopped. If it can be stopped, but teams/agents don't know how to stop it, then that really ought to be their problem.

As things stand now, DEs built to rush with speed and agility have been nerfed (even those with decent strength and vision. . . I have a DE who was 2nd in the league to Gargus's guy in sacks, and he had vision at 50. . . today, he got nothing); OTs built to stop speed and agility DEs have been nerfed (they should have just built their players mindlessly by throwing all their points in strength, blocking and Protetor instead of wasting them on other attributes); DEs now stand around for several ticks at the line of scrimmage before rushing, so football logic has been nerfed. QBs still complete over 50% of their long passes, even into tight coverage, and now there is no way to make them pay for taking 5 seconds to throw the ball. Awesome.

There was a good, realistic fix for the unrealistic speed/agility only DEs, and that was making their lack of strength easily punished by stronger OTs (using morale/stamina hits). Hell, fixing OT pathing would also have been a solid fix that would have been football-realistic. We didn't get that. Instead we got a change (4 games into the season, after many players have already boosted) that makes little football sense and completely flips the balance of power and nerfs sensible OT and DE builds, while leaving the ridiculously successful long passing game intact. Sweet.

EDIT: Though I'm wildly unhappy about Bort's changes to pass rushing, I should add that his change to the running game was a good one. It was realistic with respect to the game of football and has had a decent effect. Even if it will decrease the success of my RBs, I have to admit that it was a quality change. Fortunately, as an offensive coordinator, I can now just throw long passes on every down and rack up 1,000 passing yards a game.


very good post. thanks Gyuri.
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
I am still trying to figure out why a DE needs as much vision as my corner.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
I just want to say that as an OFFENSIVE COORDINATOR who likes to throw the ball deep like 20 times a game and has a line that has faced one of the best pass rushing defenses in the game in the Alpine Golfers and Julius Dee conceded JUST 8 SACKS TO THE ENTIRE TEAM - BEFORE Bort started all these ridiculous nerfs, I think this is a mistake.

If you don't want to get sacked, either build an agile linemen instead of a pancake machine, or build a pancake machine like you want to and RUN THE DAMN BALL. The bad teams in this game should not run it - they should get a freaking clue what they are doing if they want to compete. Period.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 11:16:44
 
Sockamidic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Modok
These changes to the vision and LT are absolutely ridiculous. People with shitty builds and shitty AI's bitching and fucking moaning because they cant stand in the pocket for 3+ seconds. Good teams were not being sacked 8+ times a games. If you are getting sacked, run draws, throw short passes. Adapt to what is happening instead of whining until you get your way.

Changing the game to dumb down the builds, in the long run, will damage GLB.



This is easily the most questionable change to the game to date.

Makes no sense whatsoever.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 11:17:11
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Modok
I am still trying to figure out why a DE needs as much vision as my corner.


 
Jason Elliott
offline
Link
 
Last season it was fine. But people whined until they changed it.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Tweaks aren't fixing the underlying problem, they're only shifting the power back and forth (depending on who happens to be favored at the time).

How blocking is figured out needs to be changed IMHO. Lineman should engage on pretty much every play, once the players engage is where the problem is.

The system I would use would be, each play has three checks for the lineman battles. If the OT wins a check it increase the length of the block, if the DE wins the check it decreases the length of the block. So let's say 2 secs is the time it takes the DE to reach the QB if he wins all three checks, while an OT that wins all three checks holds the DE for 5 secs. Add in travel time and wah-lah, pretty accurate numbers... most DEs will reach the QB in 3-4 secs if going against an equally well built OT.

For run blocking, same thing pretty much. The primary difference would be instead of time being the primary factor, it should be drive. A DE that wins all three checks would blow up a running play, while an OT that wins all three checks would drive his assignment into the secondary.

How the checks would be worked out, would be dependent on multiple attributes and SAs would give boosts to the rolls, not the actual attributes. For example, an elusive DE would roll against say 75% of his agility and 25% of his strength and the OT would roll against 50% of his blocking and 50% of his agility... then SAs would come into play. These are just random numbers to give an idea, not exactly what I would use. Another example would be a str DE, he would roll 75% of his strength, 25% of his agility, while the OT would roll against 50% of strength and 50% of his blocking (and again then SAs would come into play). A combo rusher would use 50/50 str/agility. Obviously the numbers would kind of be dictated by testing to try and get a representation of what should happen.

This type of system would benefit everyone and still allow mismatches to be created and taken advantage of. Although, it would look much more like what actually happens in the trenches.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by Modok

I am still trying to figure out why a DE needs as much vision as my corner.




 
Link
 
surely a De can rush the passer no matter how much vision its his job dammit
 
stryves
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Never thought I'd have to soft cap vision on my DE.


Never thought I'd have to soft cap Agility and Speed on an OT.
 
Jason Elliott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mutleyddmc
surely a De can rush the passer no matter how much vision its his job dammit


Vision is also football smarts, less vision equals more penalties, less reaction time etc. Why should DE's get a break on this and pretty much every other position need it?
 
Link
 
didnt say low vision shouldnt get penalties etc, but the new need for vision makes it seem that the DE doesnt know what rushing the passer is.
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Elliott
Originally posted by mutleyddmc

surely a De can rush the passer no matter how much vision its his job dammit


Vision is also football smarts, less vision equals more penalties, less reaction time etc. Why should DE's get a break on this and pretty much every other position need it?


A retarded monkey can move at the snap of a ball. That's why DE's have a SA called first step. Wanna guess what "First Step" is supposed to do? Lemme read it to you:

"This player has a very fast reaction time."
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.