User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Interesting topic of the Week: Evolutionism versus Creationism
Page:
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Being a demagogue gets you bonus points.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
PEOPLE WHO BELIEVED IN THE CHRISTIAN GOD DID 9/11!!!
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
:bonuspoints:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Oh, so that's the problem. You think we live in a democracy. We don't.

First of all, I don't think religion is stupid. I don't think Christianity is stupid. And, while I personally don't feel the same, I have no problem with you feeling that gay couples should not mate or be wed.

However, for some reason you think that because you feel that way, that should be law? It doesn't matter HOW many people feel that way, the law is not in place to go with feelings for the sake of going with feelings. The government and it's laws are in place to PROTECT the people, not RESTRICT them. Sometimes restrictions come for the sake of protection. However, gay marriage does not affect anyone who isn't involved, so making a law against it does not protect you. It restricts another based solely on your whims.

The entire reasoning you gave is based on the fact that you think it should be illegal because you don't like it. But why don't you like it? Because your religion teaches you not to like it. Again, I'm not here to cast aspersions on that fact, regardless of my feeling (at least not right now), however, one of this country's founding principals is the separation of church and state.

Now, could you give me a justifiable reason that same-sex marriage should be against the law without falling back on the church? As I've already pointed out, religion is not an acceptable reason to create law.


Many false assumptions this paragraph. I'll just respond to the question and that should answer the most of them.


How does preventing LEGALIZED gay marriages protect me?

First of all, you incorrectly assumed that I was against gay marriages (non-legal). I, nor any person I have ever met, has any problem with 2 gays getting married. If that is what they think is best for them, go for it. I don't mind. Go have crazy butt sex and live til 100 years old together. Doesn't bother me one bit. I always throw out crazy examples to make my points more extreme and easier to understand, so I'll do it again. I don't care if someone wants to marry their pet cat or their pet dog. That is fine by me also. That doesn't change my life or anyone's life at all. If someone wants to marry 4 other people and all live together, that is 100% ok with me. You seem to think otherwise. I've said it several times, but your half of the debate isn't acknowledging that point. Christians feel you can marry anyone you want. Any by "marry" I'm going to broadly define that as making a vow to spend your entire life with someone for the rest of your lives. So that part is done.

The second part is trying to explain to you how some people might feel that LEGALIZING gay marriage could harm society. Let me say that I'm not a child. I am over 21. My sexual identity is already set. There are many different opinions on when people decide what turns them on and at what age this occurs. I'm going to broadly summarize those arguments by saying that it is likely that part of it is biological (nature) and part of it is environment (nurture). I think we are all still in agreement at this point. I often get in arguments with people who think 100% of all gay people are born gay. Then it just becomes a scientific debate on thousands of conflicting studies and I'm not going to go there. Even most on the pro-gay marriage side will concede that a person's environment plays a key role in their gender identity. And if you continue down that path further, I think you could see the harm that could be caused by confusing a child as to what their gender role is at an early age. This is also why it is so important to have 1 male and 1 female so that a male or a female child will be able to observe in general what their role as an adult will be someday. I think that is a very logical and important step in most people's lives. Does it happen ever time? No. Sometimes you have asshole or deadbeat parents or one of them dies or gets divorced. Sometimes children learn to beat their wives or WRONG things from this set-up also. Those things are unfortunate and can't be avoided though. However, if you had to devise the most efficient set-up for children to live in to produce a heathly-as-possible society, you would pick a 1 father, 1 mother family to raise the child for the gender learning reason I mentioned earlier. I think we can probably all agree on this also if you thought about it rationally. It also works out because there are an equal number of male and female children produced. I imagine that if 80% of all children were male, then a gay men lifestyle would be the more preferable pairing method for society (or a 4 men + 1 woman family).

I guarantee no one is reading this far and will instead just go back to the "there is no reason why it shouldn't be legal" argument they were saying before, but at least there is 1 well thought out reason that has NOTHING to do with the Bible or religion: that being exposed to the ACCEPTANCE of the gay lifestyle at an early age would cause severe gender confusion in many more kids. I think with all the broken homes and gay kissing and lifestyle shown on TV, we are already seeing a large rise in the number of gay and lesbian young people.

The acceptance by the government is HUGE. You can tell your kids that the 2 men kissing in the park is wrong, but when it will be taught in schools, and backed by the government, that is forcing acceptance on a large group of people who feel it isn't a good idea because it will confuse kids as to what their role in society should be.


inb4 tl;dr


I hope to get a civil response without being called names.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Gturtle




Originally posted by "SteelersInsider"



Does that mean that you think people who make $200K a year should have the same "legal right" to the same tax rate as someone who makes $25K a year?

Or do you believe that rich people and poor people should have different "legal rights"?


Questions not pertinent to the issue at hand.



Actually it is very relevant. If your point was that all people should have equal rights, this point proves that all people do not have equal rights. It also proves that rights are not given based on what YOU think, but on what the MAJORITY thinks.


I'm sure if the rich people wanted to, they could pay the same percentage on their income that the poor people do. If the poor people want to pay the same amount that the rich people pay, then they are more than welcome to do that as well.


I'm pretty sure if someone who made $200K just paid the $25K tax rate that they would soon be in deep shit with the IRS. They don't have a choice in the matter.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Originally posted by Azure Dreams


Now, could you give me a justifiable reason that same-sex marriage should be against the law without falling back on the church? As I've already pointed out, religion is not an acceptable reason to create law.


He's going to fall back on the "beneficial to society by making babies blahblahblah" thing that he used earlier and that the church also uses.


good guess, but mostly wrong.

It did have to do with children though.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 02:20:17
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Oh, so that's the problem. You think we live in a democracy. We don't.

First of all, I don't think religion is stupid. I don't think Christianity is stupid. And, while I personally don't feel the same, I have no problem with you feeling that gay couples should not mate or be wed.

However, for some reason you think that because you feel that way, that should be law? It doesn't matter HOW many people feel that way, the law is not in place to go with feelings for the sake of going with feelings. The government and it's laws are in place to PROTECT the people, not RESTRICT them. Sometimes restrictions come for the sake of protection. However, gay marriage does not affect anyone who isn't involved, so making a law against it does not protect you. It restricts another based solely on your whims.

The entire reasoning you gave is based on the fact that you think it should be illegal because you don't like it. But why don't you like it? Because your religion teaches you not to like it. Again, I'm not here to cast aspersions on that fact, regardless of my feeling (at least not right now), however, one of this country's founding principals is the separation of church and state.

Now, could you give me a justifiable reason that same-sex marriage should be against the law without falling back on the church? As I've already pointed out, religion is not an acceptable reason to create law.


Many false assumptions this paragraph. I'll just respond to the question and that should answer the most of them.


How does preventing LEGALIZED gay marriages protect me?

First of all, you incorrectly assumed that I was against gay marriages (non-legal). I, nor any person I have ever met, has any problem with 2 gays getting married. If that is what they think is best for them, go for it. I don't mind. Go have crazy butt sex and live til 100 years old together. Doesn't bother me one bit. I always throw out crazy examples to make my points more extreme and easier to understand, so I'll do it again. I don't care if someone wants to marry their pet cat or their pet dog. That is fine by me also. That doesn't change my life or anyone's life at all. If someone wants to marry 4 other people and all live together, that is 100% ok with me. You seem to think otherwise. I've said it several times, but your half of the debate isn't acknowledging that point. Christians feel you can marry anyone you want. Any by "marry" I'm going to broadly define that as making a vow to spend your entire life with someone for the rest of your lives. So that part is done.


Here you stupidly pretend that you represent all Christians. Christians don't all believe the same thing. So start with that. I'm not arguing with Christians as a whole. That's impossible. I'm arguing with you and you don't know what the fuck "Christians feel"

I've met many people who feel that being together and having crazy buttsex is horribly wrong and DO have a problem with it. So there's that. However, that's more or less irrelevant as I specified on multiple occasions that I'm discussing legal marriage.

Originally posted by SI
The second part is trying to explain to you how some people might feel that LEGALIZING gay marriage could harm society. Let me say that I'm not a child. I am over 21. My sexual identity is already set. There are many different opinions on when people decide what turns them on and at what age this occurs. I'm going to broadly summarize those arguments by saying that it is likely that part of it is biological (nature) and part of it is environment (nurture). I think we are all still in agreement at this point. I often get in arguments with people who think 100% of all gay people are born gay. Then it just becomes a scientific debate on thousands of conflicting studies and I'm not going to go there. Even most on the pro-gay marriage side will concede that a person's environment plays a key role in their gender identity. And if you continue down that path further, I think you could see the harm that could be caused by confusing a child as to what their gender role is at an early age. This is also why it is so important to have 1 male and 1 female so that a male or a female child will be able to observe in general what their role as an adult will be someday. I think that is a very logical and important step in most people's lives. Does it happen ever time? No. Sometimes you have asshole or deadbeat parents or one of them dies or gets divorced. Sometimes children learn to beat their wives or WRONG things from this set-up also. Those things are unfortunate and can't be avoided though. However, if you had to devise the most efficient set-up for children to live in to produce a heathly-as-possible society, you would pick a 1 father, 1 mother family to raise the child for the gender learning reason I mentioned earlier. I think we can probably all agree on this also if you thought about it rationally. It also works out because there are an equal number of male and female children produced. I imagine that if 80% of all children were male, then a gay men lifestyle would be the more preferable pairing method for society (or a 4 men + 1 woman family).


You're sort of all over the place here. You spend a lot of it arguing against the right of gay people to adopt and raise children. Which isn't relevant. So I'm just going to ignore this part.

Other than that. What is wrong with gay marriage being accepted? What are you talking about, gender roles? You're scared you'll be such a shitty parent that even if you and your wife portray the gender roles of which you approve, if your child sees a gay couple his world will fall apart? Well, how does the law matter? He could see a gay couple regardless. Do you expect him to go up to every grouping of 2 men he sees and ask whether they are legally married and draw conclusions based on that?

Originally posted by SI
I guarantee no one is reading this far and will instead just go back to the "there is no reason why it shouldn't be legal" argument they were saying before, but at least there is 1 well thought out reason that has NOTHING to do with the Bible or religion: that being exposed to the ACCEPTANCE of the gay lifestyle at an early age would cause severe gender confusion in many more kids. I think with all the broken homes and gay kissing and lifestyle shown on TV, we are already seeing a large rise in the number of gay and lesbian young people.


You make another incorrect assumption. I still don't see a reason it shouldn't be legal. Your logic is circular. You say it should be legal because you think it will make gayness more prevalent. So the fuck what? THE POINT IS THAT'S OKAY. You said yourself before that that's okay with you so now you're contradicting yourself. You say this part isn't about religion but IT IS. Society not making it perfectly clear what role you need to feel is not harm.

Not to mention the fact that you end that bit by completely making up statistics. And the fact that you've not considered that maybe we haven't seen an increase in gay people, we've seen an increase in people who are willing to admit they're gay because they aren't scared they'll be murdered for it.

And for what it's worth, only one gay person I've ever met (and I've asked this question to many of them) felt that it was as much a choice they made as being how they were born. Society may play a role but I think that role is very minute. If you're interested in men, you're interested in men. Now, society's stance may greatly affect whether you act on that, but it won't change how you feel in 99.9% of cases. There certainly are a few cases of kids just so confused and chemically precarious that they really don't know and society decides for them but... Society can't decide whether looking at tits makes your cock hard.


Originally posted by SI
The acceptance by the government is HUGE. You can tell your kids that the 2 men kissing in the park is wrong, but when it will be taught in schools, and backed by the government, that is forcing acceptance on a large group of people who feel it isn't a good idea because it will confuse kids as to what their role in society should be.


Again, you're determining what you want their role in society to be. There is no factual "this is the role in society boys should fulfill." so you can't use that as reasoning. As for the earlier part... What the fuck? Schools don't/wouldn't teach boys that they should teach other boys. They'd teach boys that it is legal to do so and people who do should not be prosecuted. And if that contradicts what you are trying to tell your kids, you need to be contradicted. Acceptance SHOULD occur. You don't have to like it, but you SHOULD need to accept it. This motherfucking country is HERE TO ACCEPT PEOPLE REGARDLESS OF BELIEF AND TO ALLOW LIFESTYLE OF CHOICE AS FAR AS IT DOESN'T HARM OTHERS. And no, what you said does not constitute harm.


Last edited Dec 29, 2008 02:46:49
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
You're looping around a lot but it all boils down to you feeling the need to make others conform to the norms that your religion pushes on you.

The only reason you've given that laws should force it is because if they don't, people might be more likely not to conform to the norms your religion pushes on you.

Again, that is not what laws are for.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Gturtle

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Originally posted by Gturtle





Originally posted by "SteelersInsider"




Does that mean that you think people who make $200K a year should have the same "legal right" to the same tax rate as someone who makes $25K a year?

Or do you believe that rich people and poor people should have different "legal rights"?


Questions not pertinent to the issue at hand.



Actually it is very relevant. If your point was that all people should have equal rights, this point proves that all people do not have equal rights. It also proves that rights are not given based on what YOU think, but on what the MAJORITY thinks.


I'm sure if the rich people wanted to, they could pay the same percentage on their income that the poor people do. If the poor people want to pay the same amount that the rich people pay, then they are more than welcome to do that as well.


I'm pretty sure if someone who made $200K just paid the $25K tax rate that they would soon be in deep shit with the IRS. They don't have a choice in the matter.


This is such a bad argument.

Know what is- no question at all- more of a choice than sexual orientation? Religion. How would you feel if Christians automatically incurred a 10% tax on all income? Would that be the same as people who make more money being taxed more?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
You're looping around a lot but it all boils down to you feeling the need to make others conform to the norms that your religion pushes on you.

The only reason you've given that laws should force it is because if they don't, people might be more likely not to conform to the norms your religion pushes on you.

Again, that is not what laws are for.


I just gave you a BOOK of an answer and didn't mention God or the Bible or my religion AT ALL, and you STILL say that it is religion? LOL!
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Just because you didn't mention it doesn't mean it wasn't the reasoning.

Your "reasoning" was that it harms society because it will confuse kids about gender roles or increase the amount of gay people.

However, why is that harm?

...Because you don't approve of gay marriage and you have set gender roles you want fulfilled.

And why is that?

Because it is what your religion teaches.

You can't tell me the reason is "because you believe X" or "because it will cause harm" without explaining why you believe it or why it causes harm and expect that you will have made a legitimate point.
 
Link
 
I also never said I represented ALL Christians, but as a Christian I feel I speak for Christians alot better than you (who has NO IDEA what Christians believe).

And if you don't think that environment affects a child's gender, then you are never going to agree with me. Simple as that.

The argument really boils down to that.

Show some scientific proof that gender is assigned at birth and you will win over alot more people than by falling back on a BOGUS claim that it is all about religion.

The problem you have is all the men who became gay in jail, all the guys who were happily married to a woman for many years and then decide to switch over....and the every increasing number of girls who like girls now that it is cool/popular. If sexual identity wasn't determined in part by environment, then these things wouldn't be happening.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Instead of saying "my church says this" you're saying "this is the way things are and changing them would be bad"

But don't acknowledge the fact that the reason things are that way is because your religion says it and that you've given no reason it would be bad.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
I also never said I represented ALL Christians, but as a Christian I feel I speak for Christians alot better than you (who has NO IDEA what Christians believe).

And if you don't think that environment affects a child's gender, then you are never going to agree with me. Simple as that.

The argument really boils down to that.

Show some scientific proof that gender is assigned at birth and you will win over alot more people than by falling back on a BOGUS claim that it is all about religion.

The problem you have is all the men who became gay in jail, all the guys who were happily married to a woman for many years and then decide to switch over....and the every increasing number of girls who like girls now that it is cool/popular. If sexual identity wasn't determined in part by environment, then these things wouldn't be happening.


I have no idea what Christians believe? Now you're making assumptions. For all you know, I am Christian. You have no idea what my religious or political affiliation is. You know only the following:

I'm a male.
I'm straight.
I believe that gay marriage should be legal in the USA.

You're the kind of person I would hate were I christian (and that I do hate if I am) because you feel you speak for me. Many Christian people are pro-gay marriage you know. And there are many people who aren't Christians who know a SHITLOAD more about the religion than you do.

And it doesn't fucking matter what the reason is, as stupid as your argument there is. The fact is you can't prove that it's bad, so its prevalence doesn't matter.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Just because you didn't mention it doesn't mean it wasn't the reasoning.

Your "reasoning" was that it harms society because it will confuse kids about gender roles or increase the amount of gay people.

However, why is that harm?

...Because you don't approve of gay marriage and you have set gender roles you want fulfilled.

And why is that?

Because it is what your religion teaches.

You can't tell me the reason is "because you believe X" or "because it will cause harm" without explaining why you believe it or why it causes harm and expect that you will have made a legitimate point.



what you are arguing for is completely abolishing gender roles




 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.