Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Bort
I think the main problem I can see with the 4 per region "division" idea is that it makes it possible for playoff teams to get demoted over non-playoff teams. We'd have to demote the worst of each division, and it's possible for one region to send 4 teams who will be in the playoffs via wildcard spots, while another region has no wildcards.
To that I would say .... tough. And I doubt one region would have no wildcards. If it did....it would work itself out over time. If you create set numbers from each league (which most agree you should) then parity will ensue. If you decide to just show love to USAPL, SAPL, or CPL and ignore people like EEP, OPL, SEA I fear for the future of the game and the riots that will ensue over that one.
If you demote two teams per division per season, then this is a near-certainty. If you demote only one per division, it becomes highly unlikely that you'll have one region get four playoff spots. Furthermore, an NFL-style schedule (playing your own division twice each) would make it even more unlikely.
BUT, if you REALLY worry about this, we could make a special rule that might even satisfy some of the naysayers here:
If the team that WOULD get demoted from a division (the fourth-best team) makes the playoffs, then instead of being demoted, they have the OPTION to force the worst non-demoting team in their conference to demote and take their spot in that team's division.
An example: in S11, all four USAPL teams make the playoffs. In their same conference, there are two OPL teams that do very poorly, let's say 2-14 and 1-15. The 1-15 team is marked for demotion, to be replaced by the OPL league champion. The worst USAPL team (maybe a 9-7 eighth seed) would be replaced by the USAPL champions. But if they want to give up their affiliation with USAPL and stay in the WPL, they can move to OPL and the 2-14 OPL team demotes. Either way, the USAPL champion comes up into the USA division.
The OPL team has little room to complain; they were in the same conference and had every chance to play better and keep their spot. Where do they demote, you ask? Well, the simple way would send them to USAPL, but that seems doubly unfair. I'd suggest demoting them to OPL. If you don't have a folding team in OPL that wouldn't otherwise demote (unlikely), then you continue demoting the worst non-demoting team down the chain until it resolves itself. And you promote another USA AAA team to USAPL, via normal promotion rules. With the rate of team turnover, it's probably that OPL will have at least one team who plans to fold anyway, and the "extra" OPL demotion would take their place rather than an extra O AAA promotion.
This whole thing would be pretty rare to start with, but especially in the early seasons, we'd really get to see whether USAPL deserves "more" WPL spots. If all USAPL teams make the playoffs, then BAM, they've earned that "fifth" spot. Same goes for CPL, SAPL, or whoever.
Complicated? Perhaps. But I think we're solving a non-existent problem here. Even if USAPL is as fantastic as it claims to be, odds that they'll put four teams in an eight-team playoff, when competing against the best other conferences have to offer, seems unlikely.