User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
BBVD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
IMO keep it simple:

4 go up this year from each pro conference = 32 teams

next season demote all non-playoff teams - put them in their past conf - demote more teams from the pro league to make space..

2 conf champs get promoted...

rinse repeat...

The benefits of this is that it is simple to implement and only the best of the best play the WPL. It is ridiculous to suggest any system that has a top team being demoted just because there is another top team from the same conf. The goal should be to get the best 32 teams in the WPL.


yes!

where you at bort?
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by lukin83

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by ImTheScientist



Originally posted by Bort




I think the main problem I can see with the 4 per region "division" idea is that it makes it possible for playoff teams to get demoted over non-playoff teams. We'd have to demote the worst of each division, and it's possible for one region to send 4 teams who will be in the playoffs via wildcard spots, while another region has no wildcards.


To that I would say .... tough. And I doubt one region would have no wildcards. If it did....it would work itself out over time. If you create set numbers from each league (which most agree you should) then parity will ensue. If you decide to just show love to USAPL, SAPL, or CPL and ignore people like EEP, OPL, SEA I fear for the future of the game and the riots that will ensue over that one.


I don't think there has to be a forced and arbitrary set number in the league from each region at all times. I think that teams should have to fight to stay and winning should be the factor in determining who stays and who goes. All regions would get 2 teams promoted to the world league every season. How is that not equal opportunity?


Can you keep your regional affiliation with that method?


If we don't mind the possibility of an additional team or two getting demoted (assuming there aren't enough CPUs & guts to cover demotions), then yes we can. The question is if that is an acceptable possibility or not. Between the two possibilities, I think I like it more than the possibility of playoff teams getting demoted. Heck, you could go 15-1 and get demoted because the other divisions are terrible or quit.


I don't see why that shouldn't be an acceptable possibility. Extra teams are going to get to move into all of teh pro leagues this season. So if you're the 5th worst after extra room has been made, you can't really complain about getting demoted. And it's not like they'll be blindsided by it either. v0v
 
Gabrosin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Bort

I think the main problem I can see with the 4 per region "division" idea is that it makes it possible for playoff teams to get demoted over non-playoff teams. We'd have to demote the worst of each division, and it's possible for one region to send 4 teams who will be in the playoffs via wildcard spots, while another region has no wildcards.


To that I would say .... tough. And I doubt one region would have no wildcards. If it did....it would work itself out over time. If you create set numbers from each league (which most agree you should) then parity will ensue. If you decide to just show love to USAPL, SAPL, or CPL and ignore people like EEP, OPL, SEA I fear for the future of the game and the riots that will ensue over that one.


If you demote two teams per division per season, then this is a near-certainty. If you demote only one per division, it becomes highly unlikely that you'll have one region get four playoff spots. Furthermore, an NFL-style schedule (playing your own division twice each) would make it even more unlikely.

BUT, if you REALLY worry about this, we could make a special rule that might even satisfy some of the naysayers here:

If the team that WOULD get demoted from a division (the fourth-best team) makes the playoffs, then instead of being demoted, they have the OPTION to force the worst non-demoting team in their conference to demote and take their spot in that team's division.

An example: in S11, all four USAPL teams make the playoffs. In their same conference, there are two OPL teams that do very poorly, let's say 2-14 and 1-15. The 1-15 team is marked for demotion, to be replaced by the OPL league champion. The worst USAPL team (maybe a 9-7 eighth seed) would be replaced by the USAPL champions. But if they want to give up their affiliation with USAPL and stay in the WPL, they can move to OPL and the 2-14 OPL team demotes. Either way, the USAPL champion comes up into the USA division.

The OPL team has little room to complain; they were in the same conference and had every chance to play better and keep their spot. Where do they demote, you ask? Well, the simple way would send them to USAPL, but that seems doubly unfair. I'd suggest demoting them to OPL. If you don't have a folding team in OPL that wouldn't otherwise demote (unlikely), then you continue demoting the worst non-demoting team down the chain until it resolves itself. And you promote another USA AAA team to USAPL, via normal promotion rules. With the rate of team turnover, it's probably that OPL will have at least one team who plans to fold anyway, and the "extra" OPL demotion would take their place rather than an extra O AAA promotion.

This whole thing would be pretty rare to start with, but especially in the early seasons, we'd really get to see whether USAPL deserves "more" WPL spots. If all USAPL teams make the playoffs, then BAM, they've earned that "fifth" spot. Same goes for CPL, SAPL, or whoever.

Complicated? Perhaps. But I think we're solving a non-existent problem here. Even if USAPL is as fantastic as it claims to be, odds that they'll put four teams in an eight-team playoff, when competing against the best other conferences have to offer, seems unlikely.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by HombreSinNombre2

Originally posted by lukin83

Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by lukin83

Yeah. I would rather see the WL not happen at all if it is not going to be done right. That is why am I am so invested in this. That and the fact that I wanted to put this thing together 5+ seasons ago. Turnit is a good sounding board, so I am happy that he is questioning my thoughts. If everyone approved of one idea, there would be things overlooked with it.

When I say getting it done right, I mean this...

1. Each region should have equal representation. Sure, it will not be an even playing field now, but if we give it time players will start to migrate to the inferior regions and create parity. I have always been for equality between regions since OPL has always got a bad rap and USAPL have always been the golden boys. it has never been fair in recruiting players, landing coordinators, or getting recognition from the GLB community. An equal 4 teams across the board, steers us in the right direction.

2. Regional affiliations should be kept. This is to preserve rivalries and team locations. If my team is from Ghana, I want to be in Africa.

I really think it is as simple as those two things (unless I am forgetting something - posing in this thread has gotten tiresome).

The more I do think about it I really agree with both 1 and 2. If those two things can not happen then I don't want a world league either.

I don't understand why you feel each region should have equal representation. INITIALLY that seems obvious. You have to start it out by taking the Top 4 from each region. But after that, the divisional system mucks things up in a seemingly irreparable fashion. You can't FORCE parity. That's just bullshit.

If the Conference Champions of each region all get promoted each season, the parity will happen long-term as players realize that going to League A provides them an easier path to the WPL than League C. Then League A gets overloaded a bit, so League F becomes the new "worst" Pro league. Will there be some fluctuations every few seasons? Probably, yeah. But over time it will even out.


Without equal representation, you cannot keep your regional affiliation. Whether we like it or not, regional affiliation is important to most teams in this game. Teams have created rivalries within their regions, they have friends within their regions, and their team location is from their region. My team is from Oceania. I am proud of that. I want to represent my region in the WL and I want to go back there when I am demoted. Without limiting the WL to 4 teams from each region, there is no way this is possible.

You can. You just might have to demote some extra teams from pros down to AAA and then AAA-AA and the like. For instance, if this past season had the WPL and all 4 current teams from OPL were scheduled to be demoted. You would have 4 down, 2 going up and need to demote 2 extra teams. One from each conference would be the Fiji Ventures (3-13) and the Sydney Pelicans (4-12).

If Bort wants the headache of doing that, I would not be opposed.


The only thing that might get a bit confusing is trying to fit them into the same conference.
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
it's not headahce, lukin. that script is the same script he used during reshuffling.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by lukin83

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by ImTheScientist



Originally posted by Bort




I think the main problem I can see with the 4 per region "division" idea is that it makes it possible for playoff teams to get demoted over non-playoff teams. We'd have to demote the worst of each division, and it's possible for one region to send 4 teams who will be in the playoffs via wildcard spots, while another region has no wildcards.


To that I would say .... tough. And I doubt one region would have no wildcards. If it did....it would work itself out over time. If you create set numbers from each league (which most agree you should) then parity will ensue. If you decide to just show love to USAPL, SAPL, or CPL and ignore people like EEP, OPL, SEA I fear for the future of the game and the riots that will ensue over that one.


I don't think there has to be a forced and arbitrary set number in the league from each region at all times. I think that teams should have to fight to stay and winning should be the factor in determining who stays and who goes. All regions would get 2 teams promoted to the world league every season. How is that not equal opportunity?


Can you keep your regional affiliation with that method?


If we don't mind the possibility of an additional team or two getting demoted (assuming there aren't enough CPUs & guts to cover demotions), then yes we can. The question is if that is an acceptable possibility or not. Between the two possibilities, I think I like it more than the possibility of playoff teams getting demoted. Heck, you could go 15-1 and get demoted because the other divisions are terrible or quit.


As long as you can figure out these two keep regional affiliation I would be happy tbh. It would also be cool if when a team is in the WPL they get a symbol or something that designates where they are from.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Bort


I think the main problem I can see with the 4 per region "division" idea is that it makes it possible for playoff teams to get demoted over non-playoff teams. We'd have to demote the worst of each division, and it's possible for one region to send 4 teams who will be in the playoffs via wildcard spots, while another region has no wildcards.


To that I would say .... tough. And I doubt one region would have no wildcards. If it did....it would work itself out over time. If you create set numbers from each league (which most agree you should) then parity will ensue. If you decide to just show love to USAPL, SAPL, or CPL and ignore people like EEP, OPL, SEA I fear for the future of the game and the riots that will ensue over that one.


I don't think there has to be a forced and arbitrary set number in the league from each region at all times. I think that teams should have to fight to stay and winning should be the factor in determining who stays and who goes. All regions would get 2 teams promoted to the world league every season. How is that not equal opportunity?


Can you keep your regional affiliation with that method?


If we don't mind the possibility of an additional team or two getting demoted (assuming there aren't enough CPUs & guts to cover demotions), then yes we can. The question is if that is an acceptable possibility or not. Between the two possibilities, I think I like it more than the possibility of playoff teams getting demoted. Heck, you could go 15-1 and get demoted because the other divisions are terrible or quit.


And that possibility - as I've said before - needs to be understood ahead of time, like maybe at the same time that extra AAA-to-Pro promotions are happening.

The possibility of an extra PRO-AAA demotion from a conference is offset by the possibility of an extra promotion to it from AAA each season. Same idea, two sides of it, both have to be accepted in the same thought, don't they? I'm sure no one would be complaining about an unearned promotion from AAA to Pro, why worry so much about an extra demotion.
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS

IMO keep it simple:

4 go up this year from each pro conference = 32 teams

next season demote all non-playoff teams - put them in their past conf - demote more teams from the pro league to make space..

2 conf champs get promoted...

rinse repeat...

The benefits of this is that it is simple to implement and only the best of the best play the WPL. It is ridiculous to suggest any system that has a top team being demoted just because there is another top team from the same conf. The goal should be to get the best 32 teams in the WPL.


Did you read the last 50 posts...


no...sorry...not reading 500 posts...

just posting common sense...any other solution is not meeting the goal of what the WPL should be...
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BBVD
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS

IMO keep it simple:

4 go up this year from each pro conference = 32 teams

next season demote all non-playoff teams - put them in their past conf - demote more teams from the pro league to make space..

2 conf champs get promoted...

rinse repeat...

The benefits of this is that it is simple to implement and only the best of the best play the WPL. It is ridiculous to suggest any system that has a top team being demoted just because there is another top team from the same conf. The goal should be to get the best 32 teams in the WPL.


yes!

where you at bort?


yeah, this is by far the most logical method.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by lukin83

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by ImTheScientist



Originally posted by Bort




I think the main problem I can see with the 4 per region "division" idea is that it makes it possible for playoff teams to get demoted over non-playoff teams. We'd have to demote the worst of each division, and it's possible for one region to send 4 teams who will be in the playoffs via wildcard spots, while another region has no wildcards.


To that I would say .... tough. And I doubt one region would have no wildcards. If it did....it would work itself out over time. If you create set numbers from each league (which most agree you should) then parity will ensue. If you decide to just show love to USAPL, SAPL, or CPL and ignore people like EEP, OPL, SEA I fear for the future of the game and the riots that will ensue over that one.


I don't think there has to be a forced and arbitrary set number in the league from each region at all times. I think that teams should have to fight to stay and winning should be the factor in determining who stays and who goes. All regions would get 2 teams promoted to the world league every season. How is that not equal opportunity?


Can you keep your regional affiliation with that method?


If we don't mind the possibility of an additional team or two getting demoted (assuming there aren't enough CPUs & guts to cover demotions), then yes we can. The question is if that is an acceptable possibility or not. Between the two possibilities, I think I like it more than the possibility of playoff teams getting demoted. Heck, you could go 15-1 and get demoted because the other divisions are terrible or quit.


I see the issue with the divisional method. I do still think that all 8 regions should have equal representation in the WL. I would not be opposed to all 32 teams getting demoted back to their pro league and the top 4 teams from each league getting promoted each season. The WL would essentially be a season long Tournament of Champions in place of a normal pro league schedule.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
No bailout packages for weaker leagues.

Either suck it up and demote the worst two from each league, or demote the bottom sixteen regardless of league.

Preferably the second if this is truly going to be a "best of the best" league.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by lukin83


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by ImTheScientist




Originally posted by Bort





I think the main problem I can see with the 4 per region "division" idea is that it makes it possible for playoff teams to get demoted over non-playoff teams. We'd have to demote the worst of each division, and it's possible for one region to send 4 teams who will be in the playoffs via wildcard spots, while another region has no wildcards.


To that I would say .... tough. And I doubt one region would have no wildcards. If it did....it would work itself out over time. If you create set numbers from each league (which most agree you should) then parity will ensue. If you decide to just show love to USAPL, SAPL, or CPL and ignore people like EEP, OPL, SEA I fear for the future of the game and the riots that will ensue over that one.


I don't think there has to be a forced and arbitrary set number in the league from each region at all times. I think that teams should have to fight to stay and winning should be the factor in determining who stays and who goes. All regions would get 2 teams promoted to the world league every season. How is that not equal opportunity?


Can you keep your regional affiliation with that method?


If we don't mind the possibility of an additional team or two getting demoted (assuming there aren't enough CPUs & guts to cover demotions), then yes we can. The question is if that is an acceptable possibility or not. Between the two possibilities, I think I like it more than the possibility of playoff teams getting demoted. Heck, you could go 15-1 and get demoted because the other divisions are terrible or quit.


As long as you can figure out these two keep regional affiliation I would be happy tbh. It would also be cool if when a team is in the WPL they get a symbol or something that designates where they are from.


That's a good call, flags or whatever next to our team names on all the league pages.
 
BBVD
offline
Link
 
i think we've reached a consensus...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ICRockets
Originally posted by Dirtmcgirt66

Originally posted by Dirtmcgirt66


Originally posted by Bort



I think the main problem I can see with the 4 per region "division" idea is that it makes it possible for playoff teams to get demoted over non-playoff teams. We'd have to demote the worst of each division, and it's possible for one region to send 4 teams who will be in the playoffs via wildcard spots, while another region has no wildcards.


Or you could make it a cap of 3 teams getting to the playoffs from each division so that there is always a 4th to demote. Kind of like the current BCS limit with the number of teams a conference can have in a BCS bowl game.


Keep in mind that this also helps with the parity situation. People wont want to get stuck being that 4th USA team in that division that has a good record but still keeps getting demoted. This would force players to spread out to different areas.


Or...it would force them to call the entire WPL a farce where inferior teams get to stay in by virtue of what they did in OTHER leagues instead of what they did in their current league.

That's like saying that Team X from EEPL isn't allowed to play in the playoffs because there were already 7 teams from EEAAA2 and we needed to get one from EEAAA1 so it was fair, even though Team X is 9-7 and Team Y (who was in EEAAA1 last year) was 6-10.



No. If want it to be "fair" then enjoy having 10+ USA Pro teams in the WPL at all times. I have no problem with that but im simply throwing something out there for people who dont want the "fair" way to do it. I have no idea what your stance is because there is to much shit to read lol.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
It would also be cool if when a team is in the WPL they get a symbol or something that designates where they are from.


Simple but fantastic idea. +1
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.