User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by jlong78la

Defense loses again. sigh........


The laws of physics and football fundamentals win again.
Sigh...


It was simple... my build. I created a guy that simply beat your OT. How can you expect to block someone who is 3x as fast as you? YOU CAN'T!!

Instead of creating a lineman to effectively block DE's like mine, people built their linemen like it was season 1 and 2. Have 100,000 strength and 100,000 blocking, if your speed and agility is low, that's

The laws of physics and football fundamentals win again.
Sigh...

I have an OT, and i've created him so that he doesn't get burned.

What will happen is that I'll create my DE with enough vision to cancel out this nerf, and you'll think of another excuse as to why the DE's are better.
 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
I'd say that LTs with poorer builds are much better now and the LTs with builds to stop these spd/agi rushers are worse. Why would I want a primarily agil + blocking based LT now when I can have a strength guy with protect? The strength guy can help with the run and pass, whereas the formerly good LT won't be as good with the run.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 08:45:18
 
byrongame21
offline
Link
 
If you have a poor OT build, is it the DE's fault that he is able to take advantage of it? No! So stop bitching and moaning, you've all done enough of it in other threads and Bort made another in-season change for you guys, the same type of change that you all cry about when they don't go your way.

Here's an idea (or four): keep the TE in to pass block and help with the DE; use the HB to stay in and help slow down the DE; build your god damn players correctly, if you suck, Bort should not reward you; the short passing game works wonders, just because every completion isn't twnety yards down the field doesn't mean your offense is unsuccessful.

All I hear is bitch, bitch, bitch about the offense, when they are the ones that got a HUGE overhaul in AI this offseason, and now Bort is making special inseason changes because they whined enough. It's called gameplanning, and coaches who can't do it in the NFL get FIRED. Wanna talk real life? Maybe we should be able to fire coaches who have no idea how to stop ONE SINGLE SPEED DE from wrecking their entire team. Now THAT would be realistic... just like you wanted, right?
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jlong78la
Originally posted by cdcollins

Originally posted by jlong78la


Defense loses again. sigh........


The laws of physics and football fundamentals win again.
Sigh...


Watch the plays in this thread and tell me where the laws of physics apply.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1458956


First, the dots have never been a perfectly accurate representation of the players' positions on the field. Too often we forget this.

Second, if an OT shifts 280-320 pounds of weight, it's going to look pretty significant compared to a 240-260 pound DE doing the same. Unless the builds of those LTs are open, you have no idea of their agility, vision, and SAs. It's not impossible for an OT to recover in time to shove a DE off to the side.

Third, everyone always says "if you have a bad build". I've built enough players and seen enough builds to know what's good and what's bad. And the builds that have been exploited were solid builds. Not every OT build is bad, contrary to popular opinion.

I swear, it's like people have never played on an offensive or defensive line in their lives. Not once have I seen anyone criticize this argument who themselves played football IRL on either the offensive or defensive lines. Not once.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 08:55:40
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by byrongame21
If you have a poor OT build, is it the DE's fault that he is able to take advantage of it? No! So stop bitching and moaning, you've all done enough of it in other threads and Bort made another in-season change for you guys, the same type of change that you all cry about when they don't go your way.

Here's an idea (or four): keep the TE in to pass block and help with the DE; use the HB to stay in and help slow down the DE; build your god damn players correctly, if you suck, Bort should not reward you; the short passing game works wonders, just because every completion isn't twnety yards down the field doesn't mean your offense is unsuccessful.

All I hear is bitch, bitch, bitch about the offense, when they are the ones that got a HUGE overhaul in AI this offseason, and now Bort is making special inseason changes because they whined enough. It's called gameplanning, and coaches who can't do it in the NFL get FIRED. Wanna talk real life? Maybe we should be able to fire coaches who have no idea how to stop ONE SINGLE SPEED DE from wrecking their entire team. Now THAT would be realistic... just like you wanted, right?


Bort is making changes because he isn't happy with how things are working.

The changes just means DCs will move their speed DEs to the right side, where protector doesn't work, to continue causing havoc.

Besides all of that, changes are needed IMHO, because it's not a very good simulation with DEs running right around an OT on every 3rd pass play. The reasons for such thinking, has already been beaten to death in this thread, so I won't bother saying them again.
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by byrongame21
If you have a poor OT build, is it the DE's fault that he is able to take advantage of it? No! So stop bitching and moaning, you've all done enough of it in other threads and Bort made another in-season change for you guys, the same type of change that you all cry about when they don't go your way.

Here's an idea (or four): keep the TE in to pass block and help with the DE; use the HB to stay in and help slow down the DE; build your god damn players correctly, if you suck, Bort should not reward you; the short passing game works wonders, just because every completion isn't twnety yards down the field doesn't mean your offense is unsuccessful.

All I hear is bitch, bitch, bitch about the offense, when they are the ones that got a HUGE overhaul in AI this offseason, and now Bort is making special inseason changes because they whined enough. It's called gameplanning, and coaches who can't do it in the NFL get FIRED. Wanna talk real life? Maybe we should be able to fire coaches who have no idea how to stop ONE SINGLE SPEED DE from wrecking their entire team. Now THAT would be realistic... just like you wanted, right?


Well said!
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock

Bort is making changes because he isn't happy with how things are working.


Yea, he didn't like hearing people bitch.



 
Broker Hart
offline
Link
 
I am so tired of this argument. I have 3 DE's, and I honestly hope something gets done soon to make everyone quit whining about it. As long as WE can create OUR players the way WE want to, someone will be able to figure out a way to exploit the builds. It is just the way it is going to be. I have several players including linemen. My OT doesn't seem to be getting beat as bad as what everyone elses is. He is not a starter, but we have not had these problems with our QB getting sacked 10 times a game or whatever the amount is this week.

As soon as Bort fixes this something else will be the massive bug up everyones BUTT and it will start all over again. Wouldn't surprose me if I tried to log on one of these days, and found the site turned off because of all the pissing and moaning.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by jlong78la

Originally posted by cdcollins


Originally posted by jlong78la



Defense loses again. sigh........


The laws of physics and football fundamentals win again.
Sigh...


Watch the plays in this thread and tell me where the laws of physics apply.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1458956


First, the dots have never been a perfectly accurate representation of the players' positions on the field. Too often we forget this.

Second, if an OT shifts 280-320 pounds of weight, it's going to look pretty significant compared to a 240-260 pound DE doing the same. Unless the builds of those LTs are open, you have no idea of their agility, vision, and SAs. It's not impossible for an OT to recover in time to shove a DE off to the side.

Third, everyone always says "if you have a bad build". I've built enough players and seen enough builds to know what's good and what's bad. And the builds that have been exploited were solid builds. Not every OT build is bad, contrary to popular opinion.

I swear, it's like people have never played on an offensive or defensive line in their lives. Not once have I seen anyone criticize this argument who themselves played football IRL on either the offensive or defensive lines. Not once.



Please show me one player who says that they make players with bad builds (besides Asheme, but he is just kidding).

EVERYONE thinks they make great builds....... and that is simply NOT TRUE.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Many of the ostensibly dominant DEs were able to be stopped by some OTs. In fact, the OP in this thread complained about a DE that my team was able to hold to 1 sack. If correctly built OTs can stop the speed/agility rushers, then those that couldn't, weren't built correctly. In my opinion, it's only an exploit if it can't be stopped. If it can be stopped, but teams/agents don't know how to stop it, then that really ought to be their problem.

As things stand now, DEs built to rush with speed and agility have been nerfed (even those with decent strength and vision. . . I have a DE who was 2nd in the league to Gargus's guy in sacks, and he had vision at 50. . . today, he got nothing); OTs built to stop speed and agility DEs have been nerfed (they should have just built their players mindlessly by throwing all their points in strength, blocking and Protetor instead of wasting them on other attributes); DEs now stand around for several ticks at the line of scrimmage before rushing, so football logic has been nerfed. QBs still complete over 50% of their long passes, even into tight coverage, and now there is no way to make them pay for taking 5 seconds to throw the ball. Awesome.

There was a good, realistic fix for the unrealistic speed/agility only DEs, and that was making their lack of strength easily punished by stronger OTs (using morale/stamina hits). Hell, fixing OT pathing would also have been a solid fix that would have been football-realistic. We didn't get that. Instead we got a change (4 games into the season, after many players have already boosted) that makes little football sense and completely flips the balance of power and nerfs sensible OT and DE builds, while leaving the ridiculously successful long passing game intact. Sweet.

EDIT: Though I'm wildly unhappy about Bort's changes to pass rushing, I should add that his change to the running game was a good one. It was realistic with respect to the game of football and has had a decent effect. Even if it will decrease the success of my RBs, I have to admit that it was a quality change. Fortunately, as an offensive coordinator, I can now just throw long passes on every down and rack up 1,000 passing yards a game.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 09:44:01
 
jlong78la
offline
Link
 
I couldn't agree more Gyuri
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Many of the ostensibly dominant DEs were able to be stopped by some OTs. In fact, the OP in this thread complained about a DE that my team was able to hold to 1 sack. If correctly built OTs can stop the speed/agility rushers, then those that couldn't, weren't built correctly. In my opinion, it's only an exploit if it can't be stopped. If it can be stopped, but teams/agents don't know how to stop it, then that really ought to be their problem.

As things stand now, DEs built to rush with speed and agility have been nerfed (even those with decent strength and vision. . . I have a DE who was 2nd in the league to Gargus's guy in sacks, and he had vision at 50. . . today, he got nothing); OTs built to stop speed and agility DEs have been nerfed (they should have just built their players mindlessly by throwing all their points in strength, blocking and Protetor instead of wasting them on other attributes); DEs now stand around for several ticks at the line of scrimmage before rushing, so football logic has been nerfed. QBs still complete over 50% of their long passes, even into tight coverage, and now there is no way to make them pay for taking 5 seconds to throw the ball. Awesome.

There was a good, realistic fix for the unrealistic speed/agility only DEs, and that was making their lack of strength easily punished by stronger OTs (using morale/stamina hits). Hell, fixing OT pathing would also have been a solid fix that would have been football-realistic. We didn't get that. Instead we got a change (4 games into the season, after many players have already boosted) that makes little football sense and completely flips the balance of power and nerfs sensible OT and DE builds, while leaving the ridiculously successful long passing game intact. Sweet.

EDIT: Though I'm wildly unhappy about Bort's changes to pass rushing, I should add that his change to the running game was a good one. It was realistic with respect to the game of football and has had a decent effect. Even if it will decrease the success of my RBs, I have to admit that it was a quality change. Fortunately, as an offensive coordinator, I can now just throw long passes on every down and rack up 1,000 passing yards a game.


Excellent post Gyuri1. If I had the time, i would have said something very close to that.

But all this aside, it's not going to change. So, it almost makes me want to just stop building my current DE. With all these changes, I keep adding points, and then having to keep changing my direction.

So, lets just make our builds, we'll get better soon. Whatever, life goes on. It just sucks that all these things happen after all our boosting. In-fact, my DE leveled up last night!
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I really hope Bort doesn't give in and allow Protect on the RT as well -- that is what you have the ability to hold in a TE, FB, HB, or any combination of those guys for. Strategy people -- it is a much better solution than whining.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Actually, SCACE, whining has proven to be very effective, and is really much easier than strategizing.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Actually, SCACE, whining has proven to be very effective, and is really much easier than strategizing.


lol - I'll have to agree there, unfortunately. Whining seems to be how things get done. I'd like to see that switch to strategy though, because whining just leads to more whining.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.