User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Interesting topic of the Week: Evolutionism versus Creationism
Page:
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Gturtle



Originally posted by "SteelersInsider"


Does that mean that you think people who make $200K a year should have the same "legal right" to the same tax rate as someone who makes $25K a year?

Or do you believe that rich people and poor people should have different "legal rights"?


Questions not pertinent to the issue at hand.



Actually it is very relevant. If your point was that all people should have equal rights, this point proves that all people do not have equal rights. It also proves that rights are not given based on what YOU think, but on what the MAJORITY thinks.


I'm sure if the rich people wanted to, they could pay the same percentage on their income that the poor people do. If the poor people want to pay the same amount that the rich people pay, then they are more than welcome to do that as well.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Oh, if the poor people wanted to pay the same percentage as the rich people, they'd elect the officials into office that would make that happen. But they're in the minority, and rich people are in the Majority.

That's how democracy works
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
By the way, I actually am fairly indifferent regarding whether people should mate with and/or marry others of the same sex. But that's not what I'm discussing. I'm not discussing what makes me squeamish. I'm discussing legality. The two are unrelated. You may find this hard to believe, but even if I absolutely HATED gays and the idea of gay marriage, I would feel that it should be legal. I may prefer it not being legal, but if answering about whether it, by all rights, SHOULD be legal, I would say yes.

By the by, I'm a political science major who is going to be a lawyer if I feel like going to law school. You aren't likely to gain too much ground arguing our country's founding principals or documents.

We are not a democracy, and even if we were, that isn't the way democracy works. Majority rule in that majority decides who is put in place to safeguard us, etc. etc. The basic purpose of government and of leaving the state of wild is still safety. And America's government's goal is to keep us safe with the least restrictiveness possible. That's why we broke from England. Pursuit of happiness and all that.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

Now, could you give me a justifiable reason that same-sex marriage should be against the law without falling back on the church? As I've already pointed out, religion is not an acceptable reason to create law.


He's going to fall back on the "beneficial to society by making babies blahblahblah" thing that he used earlier and that the church also uses.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
By the way, I actually am fairly indifferent regarding whether people should mate with and/or marry others of the same sex. But that's not what I'm discussing. I'm not discussing what makes me squeamish. I'm discussing legality. The two are unrelated. You may find this hard to believe, but even if I absolutely HATED gays and the idea of gay marriage, I would feel that it should be legal. I may prefer it not being legal, but if answering about whether it, by all rights, SHOULD be legal, I would say yes.

By the by, I'm a political science major who is going to be a lawyer if I feel like going to law school. You aren't likely to gain too much ground arguing our country's founding principals or documents.

We are not a democracy, and even if we were, that isn't the way democracy works. Majority rule in that majority decides who is put in place to safeguard us, etc. etc. The basic purpose of government and of leaving the state of wild is still safety. And America's government's goal is to keep us safe with the least restrictiveness possible. That's why we broke from England. Pursuit of happiness and all that.


I watch a lot of Boston Legal, where does this put me, intellectually, on the ladder of discussion.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Denny Crane.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
1) Given the fact that there are orphanages all over the place full of em, that sounds more like support of gay couples being able to adopt and raise children than condemnation of their marriage to me.

2) Making babies isn't beneficial to society. Raising good people is.

3) Wat? Allowing gay marriage doesn't prevent straight people from getting married (nor would that prevent them from copulating). It's not as if gay people are presently getting married and having babies but, were they allowed to be married to each other, they'd ditch the women. The baby-making demographic and gay-marriage demographic don't have much overlap. They ain't makin babies regardless.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

By the way, I actually am fairly indifferent regarding whether people should mate with and/or marry others of the same sex. But that's not what I'm discussing. I'm not discussing what makes me squeamish. I'm discussing legality. The two are unrelated. You may find this hard to believe, but even if I absolutely HATED gays and the idea of gay marriage, I would feel that it should be legal. I may prefer it not being legal, but if answering about whether it, by all rights, SHOULD be legal, I would say yes.

By the by, I'm a political science major who is going to be a lawyer if I feel like going to law school. You aren't likely to gain too much ground arguing our country's founding principals or documents.

We are not a democracy, and even if we were, that isn't the way democracy works. Majority rule in that majority decides who is put in place to safeguard us, etc. etc. The basic purpose of government and of leaving the state of wild is still safety. And America's government's goal is to keep us safe with the least restrictiveness possible. That's why we broke from England. Pursuit of happiness and all that.


I watch a lot of Boston Legal, where does this put me, intellectually, on the ladder of discussion.


I'm going to need you to quantify "a lot"
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Originally posted by Gturtle

Originally posted by Azure Dreams


By the way, I actually am fairly indifferent regarding whether people should mate with and/or marry others of the same sex. But that's not what I'm discussing. I'm not discussing what makes me squeamish. I'm discussing legality. The two are unrelated. You may find this hard to believe, but even if I absolutely HATED gays and the idea of gay marriage, I would feel that it should be legal. I may prefer it not being legal, but if answering about whether it, by all rights, SHOULD be legal, I would say yes.

By the by, I'm a political science major who is going to be a lawyer if I feel like going to law school. You aren't likely to gain too much ground arguing our country's founding principals or documents.

We are not a democracy, and even if we were, that isn't the way democracy works. Majority rule in that majority decides who is put in place to safeguard us, etc. etc. The basic purpose of government and of leaving the state of wild is still safety. And America's government's goal is to keep us safe with the least restrictiveness possible. That's why we broke from England. Pursuit of happiness and all that.


I watch a lot of Boston Legal, where does this put me, intellectually, on the ladder of discussion.


I'm going to need you to quantify "a lot"


I once pirated (and subsequently watched) an entire season over the course of one week
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
How long ago?
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Also, how was my definition of "legal right" I think I nailed the big points.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
How long ago?


year+ now
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
You land right above democratic med student who cares about the issues and knows the general idea of American history but is fuzzy on specifics because that knowledge took a backseat to all the med school work and right below Bill O'Reilly.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
You land right above democratic med student who cares about the issues and knows the general idea of American history but is fuzzy on specifics because that knowledge took a backseat to all the med school work and right below Bill O'Reilly.


I'm pretty sure democratic med student is above Bill O'Reilly

Unless being a demagogue gets you bonus points.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
fwiw I make a pretty good demagogue
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.