Got the cleats my first time shopping, took me about 6 times to get the second piece. After I maxed out my first piece I just couldn't find squat. I wasn't planning on doubling up the break tackle chance, but it was the only decent piece I saw out of about 20 items. IMO the AE pieces have been scaled back and the really valuable ones just don't show up that often. The first two weeks after they came out you were almost guaranteed to find something with a +2 or 3 to an skill with a +1 bonus to an SA. Now, it seems, those are much more rare.
Superior Pink Cleats +1 strength, Break block chance +4%, Force fumble chance +4% (upgraded once)
Superior Eye Black +1 strength, +1 Snarl SA (upgraded once)
Superior Blue Gloves , Force fumble chance +2% (not upgraded yet)
To open this season I will add one more upgrade to the cleats then one to the eye black. I will most likely keep upgrading the cleats because they are pretty freaking sweet!