User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
I don't want to diss the team, because that is a piss poor sim, but let me give you guys a game:

2000 NFC Championship Game
(12-4)New York Giants vs (11-5)Minnesota Vikings

Giants won 41-0.

These things happen. Sorry you got the outlyer, but hey that's why they sim the games.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
lol - you call me irritating and I say that you are irritating the rest of us, but when I say it, it isn't a compelling argument.

I don't doubt that I'm irritating you, but it's pretending that everyone agrees with you that shows posturing on your part, presumably as a result of knowing that your argument falls flat.


Once again:

* No college or pro QB with more than a handful of snaps has ever thrown 1 interception every 5 pass attempts the way that Jay Slim did. I think the guesses about this being a result of negative confidence feedback are probably on the money, and show that the way the came calculates these results is unrealistic and needs to be fixed.

* Having a 23-0 pancake discrepancy would not happen between pro or the same division college opponents. If this is actually a common result for GLB, and if GLB intends to be a realistic football sim, then that's a problem and needs to be fixed.

* Individual elements might be dismissed as an aberration, but all the weird things going on in the stats from this game conclusively prove that something is wrong with the simulation programming.


Consumer confidence in a game is critical to its success, and that confidence is built by fixing problems when they occur, not by making excuses and pretending that it's the consumer's fault.


kinglehr:
As has been repeated several times (and hopefully this is the last), the score is not what jumps out as unacceptably unrealistic. I have no problem with the idea that Miami could beat Nashville 45-0. I have a HUGE problem with how it happened.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 00:25:56
 
sully
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinglehr
I don't want to diss the team, because that is a piss poor sim, but let me give you guys a game:

2000 NFC Championship Game
(12-4)New York Giants vs (11-5)Minnesota Vikings

Giants won 41-0.

These things happen. Sorry you got the outlyer, but hey that's why they sim the games.


Quit kissing Bort's ass. As jdbolick has strongly insinuated, if you don't think this is the greatest injustice in the history of Goal Line Blitz, you are clearly biased, have used no rational thought in your argument, and are only trying to kiss Bort's ass.

I mean, clearly those who dare to defend this are in the wrong, and have been told so by someone whose football acumen consists of drafting Chris Chambers in the 3rd round and Curtis Martin in the 5th round of a published 2006 fantasy football mock draft, among other things.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by SCACE

The fact is that one team barely rushed this game, making it hard if not impossible to register pancakes as they were pass blocking the majority of the game.

18 times is not insignificant, but I'm not talking about expecting them to have equal numbers of pancakes. Miami having the edge is reasonable. 23-0 is not reasonable at all. If those types of outcomes are common in GLB, then GLB is guilty of being an inaccurate simulation and not representative of high level organized football.
Originally posted by

Given the increase in rushing this game, 23 is NOT AN ODDITY.

There are two separate issues with this argument. First, you're still seeing a substantial change in the pancake percentages from the first game, both increasing for Miami and decreasing for Nashville, so let's not pretend that they occurred at the same frequency as before even after you adjust for the changes in number of carries. Secondly and more importantly, having that kind of disparity is an inexplicable oddity for actual football. It just wouldn't happen. Now if GLB is not supposed to resemble actual football, then ok, but I was under the impression that it was intended to do so.
Originally posted by

Again, not an oddity.

Here is where your lack of knowledge about football is limiting your understanding. Teams in a blowout facing obvious passing situations don't continue to hold opponents to less than 1 yard per carry. It doesn't happen in actual football. Defenses may have great success early on in neutralizing a team's running attack, but they won't continue to stone them for less than 1 yard per carry when they're expecting the pass.
Originally posted by

The only oddity is the INT's, which I've explained both the problem and the fix. You just keep ignoring it.

Me failing to accept an irrational excuse is not ignoring you. I'm acknowledging what you've said and explaining why it's invalid. Moreover, you have yet to admit that you can't give any example of a game in reality where something like this actually happened. You've come up with examples that came close in one aspect or another, but not one that fully met these circumstances. You can't because it does not happen in reality.


Look, I am not an expert on Goal Line Blitz, but I am an expert on football. I can definitively tell you what is and what is absolutely not a reasonable result. This game unquestionably falls with the latter.


Let me get this straight, teams that are leading in obvious blow out situations like this, expect the pass, and teams that are trailing in obvious blow out situations like his, expect to throw the ball.

And you are saying this is the cause of the rushing yards being so low? Well DUH lol The scary thing is, you tried to make that out like a convincing argument, when in reality, its freaking obvious.

If a team being blown out, is expected to pass the ball, wouldn't make sense that the team leading, would be running a PASS DEFENSE? The answer to that is yes.

So, if a team is trailing, and most teams that trail pass the ball, how in the hell is their lack of pancakes a FLAW IN THE GAME??????????????????????????????????
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by SCACE

lol - you call me irritating and I say that you are irritating the rest of us, but when I say it, it isn't a compelling argument.

I don't doubt that I'm irritating you, but it's pretending that everyone agrees with you that shows posturing on your part, presumably as a result of knowing that your argument falls flat.


Once again:

* No college or pro QB with more than a handful of snaps has ever thrown 1 interception every 5 pass attempts the way that Jay Slim did. I think the guesses about this being a result of negative confidence feedback are probably on the money, and show that the way the came calculates these results is unrealistic and needs to be fixed.

* Having a 23-0 pancake discrepancy would not happen between pro or the same division college opponents. If this is actually a common result for GLB, and if GLB intends to be a realistic football sim, then that's a problem and needs to be fixed.

* Individual elements might be dismissed as an aberration, but all the weird things going on in the stats from this game conclusively prove that something is wrong with the simulation programming.


Consumer confidence in a game is critical to its success, and that confidence is built by fixing problems when they occur, not by making excuses and pretending that it's the consumer's fault.



Except you and Larry over there, I dont think anyone is losing "confidence" in the game, pretty much everyone can wrap their heads around a high school LVL QB throwing 9 INT against a NFL defense.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
I'd like to understand more about the 23-0 Pancakes to be honest. One of the teams I play on just had our Playoff game today. We lost a close game, but... well take a look at it yourself - and while you are looking at the box score - pay attention to the pancakes; after looking at everything else.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=72153
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
So, if a team is trailing, and most teams that trail pass the ball, how in the hell is their lack of pancakes a FLAW IN THE GAME??????????????????????????????????

Congratulations on flunking basic reading comprehension. I very clearly stated that in a blowout where the defense is clearly expecting a pass, they don't keep holding the trailing team to less than 1 yard per carry. That's unrealistic. Having fewer pancakes when you run less often is understandable, although the rate at which Miami achieved them and Nashville didn't was still significantly different from what they experienced during their first meeting. But I'm probably confusing you at this point, so let me reiterate the point using as few syllables as possible.


Defenses that are playing the pass will not continue to hold offenses to less than 1 yard per carry because they are not playing up against the run.


Xiong Yoshi:
Nice example. I don't think pancakes are implemented very well in this game.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 00:31:15
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by sjmay

So, if a team is trailing, and most teams that trail pass the ball, how in the hell is their lack of pancakes a FLAW IN THE GAME??????????????????????????????????

Congratulations on flunking basic reading comprehension. I very clearly stated that in a blowout where the defense is clearly expecting a pass, they don't keep holding the trailing team to less than 1 yard per carry. That's unrealistic. Having fewer pancakes when you run less often is understandable, although the rate at which Miami achieved them and Nashville didn't was still significantly different from what they experienced during their first meeting. But I'm probably confusing you at this point, so let me reiterate the point using as few syllables as possible.


Defenses that are playing the pass will not continue to hold offenses to less than 1 yard per carry because they are not playing up against the run.



Except for one small fact, THE OFFENSE WAS PASSING THE BALL.

Congrats on that.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
I'd like to understand more about the 23-0 Pancakes to be honest. One of the teams I play on just had our Playoff game today. We lost a close game, but... well take a look at it yourself - and while you are looking at the box score - pay attention to the pancakes; after looking at everything else.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=72153


Well, they rushed the ball more, so more opportunity A.

B. their front four out leveled your Oline
C. their Oline out leveled your front four.

Without knowing build its hard to be accurate, but assuming you dont have a 70-60 strength - block on the oline, it will be hard for you to pancake a front four that is higher levelled than you, assuming the builds are right.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay


Well, they rushed the ball more, so more opportunity A.

B. their front four out leveled your Oline
C. their Oline out leveled your front four.

Without knowing build its hard to be accurate, but assuming you dont have a 70-60 strength - block on the oline, it will be hard for you to pancake a front four that is higher levelled than you, assuming the builds are right.


I play for Omaha, so you might want to re-evaluate your answer.

EDIT - but you are atleast partially correct on your main points. I just found it odd that the pancakes were 19-0.. it just stuck out at me as interesting.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 00:45:01
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Except you and Larry over there, I dont think anyone is losing "confidence" in the game, pretty much everyone can wrap their heads around a high school LVL QB throwing 9 INT against a NFL defense.

Good grief, this is like arguing with the Short Bus All-Stars.

Miami and Nashville are in the same league, not vastly different levels of competition. Jay Slim had the 6th best interception percentage in that conference, at 1 every 34 pass attempts (which was very close to the third best percentage at 1 every 35.7 for Brandon Street). Meanwhile Miami had 39 interceptions during the regular season, tied with Nashville and well short of conference leader Orlando Pirates' 61.

So it's not as if Slim was a poor performing QB who routinely threw interceptions in this conference. In this one playoff game he threw 60% of his entire total during their sixteen regular season games. And Miami was not some incredible ball-hawking secondary that terrorized quarterbacks during the regular season either. Their 10 in this game matched a full quarter of what they achieved during the sixteen regular season games.

Also, stop pretending that Larry and I are the only ones who had a problem with the result. I just started getting involved with this argument a couple of pages ago, while Larry seems to have given up a while back. There's no way this thread makes it to this many pages if everyone but us agreed with your nonsensical excuses.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Except for one small fact, THE OFFENSE WAS PASSING THE BALL.

Congrats on that.

Try arguing some mathematical question with a sixth grader and you will begin to understand the headache you are giving me. Once again, I am not talking about the total number of rushing yards. A team trailing by 30+ probably isn't going to rush for 100+ yards. I'm talking about the yards per carry. So on the times when Nashville did run, it's unrealistic to think that Miami would continue to hold them to less than 1 yard per carry when they'd clearly be expecting the pass. That doesn't happen in real football.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by sjmay

Except you and Larry over there, I dont think anyone is losing "confidence" in the game, pretty much everyone can wrap their heads around a high school LVL QB throwing 9 INT against a NFL defense.

Good grief, this is like arguing with the Short Bus All-Stars.

Miami and Nashville are in the same league, not vastly different levels of competition. Jay Slim had the 6th best interception percentage in that conference, at 1 every 34 pass attempts (which was very close to the third best percentage at 1 every 35.7 for Brandon Street). Meanwhile Miami had 39 interceptions during the regular season, tied with Nashville and well short of conference leader Orlando Pirates' 61.

So it's not as if Slim was a poor performing QB who routinely threw interceptions in this conference. In this one playoff game he threw 60% of his entire total during their sixteen regular season games. And Miami was not some incredible ball-hawking secondary that terrorized quarterbacks during the regular season either. Their 10 in this game matched a full quarter of what they achieved during the sixteen regular season games.

Also, stop pretending that Larry and I are the only ones who had a problem with the result. I just started getting involved with this argument a couple of pages ago, while Larry seems to have given up a while back. There's no way this thread makes it to this many pages if everyone but us agreed with your nonsensical excuses.


Ok,

First of all genius, if you actually look at their games, they are a RUSHING TEAM, they rush the ball MUCH MORE THAN THEY PASS, so the during regular season, the teams are going to try and focus on the run to shut them down, The only problem was, they didn't have a game like this BEFORE, with that QB build a game like this was going to happen, pure and simple, the guy is fucking BRUTAL, what part about this do you not get?

Say the game is flawed, etc etc etc.

You are saying that Nashville's QB should be compared to the top QB in the league, which is BULLSHIT, he has low strength, low confidence, low vision, low throwing, HOW does that make him a TOP QB?

So this pisspoor QB faces a TOP NOTCH secondary, why is everyone surprised he got picked off like this? seriously?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by sjmay

Except for one small fact, THE OFFENSE WAS PASSING THE BALL.

Congrats on that.

Try arguing some mathematical question with a sixth grader and you will begin to understand the headache you are giving me. Once again, I am not talking about the total number of rushing yards. A team trailing by 30+ probably isn't going to rush for 100+ yards. I'm talking about the yards per carry. So on the times when Nashville did run, it's unrealistic to think that Miami would continue to hold them to less than 1 yard per carry when they'd clearly be expecting the pass. That doesn't happen in real football.


Except that MIAMI TOLD YOU they defended the rush, are you dense or stupid? They GAMEPLANNED to STOP THE RUSH, to FORCE Nasvhille to throw, it happened, now you are surprised by it????
 
MrMike
offline
Link
 
Here's why you should stop complaining, because I need to come to the aid of SCACE, my punter:

A big argument tends to be this: In the Pros, this would never happen. How often do you see a Pro QB throw 9 Picks in a game? How often do you see a Pro QB do that badly?

Every situation has a mathematical solution. I don't think anyone would say that its impossible for a Pro QB to ever throw 9 Picks in a game vs. a reasonably evenly matched team. It would be incredibly rare, with an extremely small percentage chance of having it happen--so small that its never happened to this point--but it wouldn't be truly impossible.

What people really seem to forget about the GLB Universe is that there's a ridiculous amount of teams. So, you'll see things with very small chances of happening, happen.

Consider this: Since the AFL and NFL decided to play a Championship game together, there have been 42 seasons. That means, there have been 42 seasons of 32 (and less) team leagues. This is an incredibly small sample size when you compare it to the GLB Universe. In a quick count, I count 92 leagues in the GLB Universe. Just in this season, you have twice the sample size of the entire existence of the NFL in its entire existence--and that doesn't take into account the previous two years.

As long as this isn't happening commonly, its not a true problem in the realism in the game. Because eventually, someone in an evenly matched game in the NFL is going to throw 9 picks in a game--for it not to happen would be a statistical anomaly.

What you need to remember is that in every season GLB is simmed, you're getting the range of results as would happen over the span of 100 years in the NFL. So you're going to have times when guys do stuff that hasn't happened in the NFL yet.


Now, there are some system things to fix, like the effectiveness of the run game and possibly a slight tweak to the Pancake system. In the rushing game, I think you guys are dealing with the problem that everyone else is--that running isn't effective enough in this game. And that problem is being fixed already.

But for your Interceptions--especially in a world where people are usually halfway to 100 in abilities on a 100-point scale--you just had an unlucky sim. Its going to happen every once and a while to an unlucky team, and they will complain about it. But its not that realistic, if you think about the volume of games being simmed. As long as a QB throwing 9 picks in an evenly-matched game doesn't become a common occurance, there's no real problem with that part of the realism.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.