User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > A WPL WITHOUT MM-OFGand WW IS BS
Page:
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by The Duff Man

Originally posted by ImTheScientist



Many of them were good or are good currently just because they out level people.


Level 64 vrs level 62 means a lot at this point. LOL. If you believe this you need a clue.


Im in the WPL so obviously I know something


I hope you know how to win 5-6 games a season.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
Originally posted by PatricktheDookie

Originally posted by MrMoose


Using any player created system to determine teams in the WPL is a bad idea. Any system needs to be 100% objective to be fair. I wouldn't put it beyond some committee teams to vote USA squads slightly higher to get them into the WPL faster if that mattered, or to set up the brackets in the PWT to make it a bit easier for certain teams to get to the WPL.

If the system is not 100% objective, there will be a shitstorm of epic proportions.


BCS


Yeah, pretty much.

Fans bitch enough about how bad the BCS is. Imagine if the BCS style setup had a direct effect on something people are paying money for.


Whats not objective about beating other top opponents?
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by MrMoose

Originally posted by PatricktheDookie


Originally posted by MrMoose



Using any player created system to determine teams in the WPL is a bad idea. Any system needs to be 100% objective to be fair. I wouldn't put it beyond some committee teams to vote USA squads slightly higher to get them into the WPL faster if that mattered, or to set up the brackets in the PWT to make it a bit easier for certain teams to get to the WPL.

If the system is not 100% objective, there will be a shitstorm of epic proportions.


BCS


Yeah, pretty much.

Fans bitch enough about how bad the BCS is. Imagine if the BCS style setup had a direct effect on something people are paying money for.


Whats not objective about beating other top opponents?


Because top teams are not forced to play other top teams in GLB, and it costs money for teams to play anyone outside of their normal scheduled 16 games.

Additionally, there are many top teams that refuse to play anyone not in the top 25 or some such -- how can a non-top 25 team prove themselves at that point?

Basically, it isn't objective because people and opinions are involved. If the #1 team refuses to play the #10 team, the #10 team has that much of a tougher road to move up in the rankings. If that same #10 team refuses to play a team not in the top 25 so that they don't lose their top 10 spot, that makes it much harder for the non top 25 team to crack the rankings, especially when they come from a weaker division like OPL. If a large amount of the top 25 teams refuse to play an OPL squad, for example, the OPL squad likely won't crack the top 25 since there aren't any other top 25 teams there to play and the strength of their schedule will be weaker.

Basically, the reason is that humans and opinions are involved. Those have to be removed from the equation for things to be fair.
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by The Duff Man

Originally posted by ImTheScientist



Many of them were good or are good currently just because they out level people.


Level 64 vrs level 62 means a lot at this point. LOL. If you believe this you need a clue.


Im in the WPL so obviously I know something


 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5STAR
Originally posted by Timetoshine-Beta

Originally posted by tdm13


if they lost in the format, they don't deserve to go imo. Should have won their semi if they were that good :|


yet they'd all be there if they played in OPL


if my aunt had a dick she would be my uncle


 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by MrMoose

Originally posted by PatricktheDookie


Originally posted by MrMoose



Using any player created system to determine teams in the WPL is a bad idea. Any system needs to be 100% objective to be fair. I wouldn't put it beyond some committee teams to vote USA squads slightly higher to get them into the WPL faster if that mattered, or to set up the brackets in the PWT to make it a bit easier for certain teams to get to the WPL.

If the system is not 100% objective, there will be a shitstorm of epic proportions.


BCS


Yeah, pretty much.

Fans bitch enough about how bad the BCS is. Imagine if the BCS style setup had a direct effect on something people are paying money for.


Whats not objective about beating other top opponents?


The fact that it's not the only criteria and human opinion still exists. Otherwise, why have multiple voters. You'd only need 1 person if it was simply by who you beat.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by silenthatred
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by MrMoose


Originally posted by PatricktheDookie



Originally posted by MrMoose




Using any player created system to determine teams in the WPL is a bad idea. Any system needs to be 100% objective to be fair. I wouldn't put it beyond some committee teams to vote USA squads slightly higher to get them into the WPL faster if that mattered, or to set up the brackets in the PWT to make it a bit easier for certain teams to get to the WPL.

If the system is not 100% objective, there will be a shitstorm of epic proportions.


BCS


Yeah, pretty much.

Fans bitch enough about how bad the BCS is. Imagine if the BCS style setup had a direct effect on something people are paying money for.


Whats not objective about beating other top opponents?


The fact that it's not the only criteria and human opinion still exists. Otherwise, why have multiple voters. You'd only need 1 person if it was simply by who you beat.


Yes, it cannot have a human factor at all. However, efforts should be made to ensure that it's legitimate. Some major sports tournaments (e.g. FIFA world cup, UEFA championship) give more slots to stronger divisions / continents. The strength of the divisions is assigned based upon inter-division play.
 
Coach RW
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23
Originally posted by silenthatred

Originally posted by islander1


Originally posted by MrMoose



Originally posted by PatricktheDookie




Originally posted by MrMoose





Using any player created system to determine teams in the WPL is a bad idea. Any system needs to be 100% objective to be fair. I wouldn't put it beyond some committee teams to vote USA squads slightly higher to get them into the WPL faster if that mattered, or to set up the brackets in the PWT to make it a bit easier for certain teams to get to the WPL.

If the system is not 100% objective, there will be a shitstorm of epic proportions.


BCS


Yeah, pretty much.

Fans bitch enough about how bad the BCS is. Imagine if the BCS style setup had a direct effect on something people are paying money for.


Whats not objective about beating other top opponents?


The fact that it's not the only criteria and human opinion still exists. Otherwise, why have multiple voters. You'd only need 1 person if it was simply by who you beat.


Yes, it cannot have a human factor at all. However, efforts should be made to ensure that it's legitimate. Some major sports tournaments (e.g. FIFA world cup, UEFA championship) give more slots to stronger divisions / continents. The strength of the divisions is assigned based upon inter-division play.


This makes the most sense. USAPro is by FAR stronger then anywhere else...in fact all the USA leagues are stronger. We got moved to South America from USA and have had immediate success...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Coach RW
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23

Originally posted by silenthatred


Originally posted by islander1



Originally posted by MrMoose




Originally posted by PatricktheDookie





Originally posted by MrMoose






Using any player created system to determine teams in the WPL is a bad idea. Any system needs to be 100% objective to be fair. I wouldn't put it beyond some committee teams to vote USA squads slightly higher to get them into the WPL faster if that mattered, or to set up the brackets in the PWT to make it a bit easier for certain teams to get to the WPL.

If the system is not 100% objective, there will be a shitstorm of epic proportions.


BCS


Yeah, pretty much.

Fans bitch enough about how bad the BCS is. Imagine if the BCS style setup had a direct effect on something people are paying money for.


Whats not objective about beating other top opponents?


The fact that it's not the only criteria and human opinion still exists. Otherwise, why have multiple voters. You'd only need 1 person if it was simply by who you beat.


Yes, it cannot have a human factor at all. However, efforts should be made to ensure that it's legitimate. Some major sports tournaments (e.g. FIFA world cup, UEFA championship) give more slots to stronger divisions / continents. The strength of the divisions is assigned based upon inter-division play.


This makes the most sense. USAPro is by FAR stronger then anywhere else...in fact all the USA leagues are stronger. We got moved to South America from USA and have had immediate success...

Your in AA
 
Link
 
Originally posted by The Duff Man
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by The Duff Man


Originally posted by ImTheScientist




Many of them were good or are good currently just because they out level people.


Level 64 vrs level 62 means a lot at this point. LOL. If you believe this you need a clue.


Im in the WPL so obviously I know something


I hope you know how to win 5-6 games a season.


I know that USAPL is full of a bunch of pretenders while SLAP is full of contenders. SLAP runs AI circles around USAPL.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
I hope this WPL works out better than the weak-ass one from USA AAA2 a few seasons back.
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by The Duff Man

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


Originally posted by The Duff Man



Originally posted by ImTheScientist





Many of them were good or are good currently just because they out level people.


Level 64 vrs level 62 means a lot at this point. LOL. If you believe this you need a clue.


Im in the WPL so obviously I know something


I hope you know how to win 5-6 games a season.


I know that USAPL is full of a bunch of pretenders while SLAP is full of contenders. SLAP runs AI circles around USAPL.


its true, i think USAPL has higher level dots. SLAP has better builds and coordinators

 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
its true, i think USAPL has higher level dots. SLAP has better builds and coordinators


LOLOLOLOLOL
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Ubasstards

its true, i think USAPL has higher level dots. SLAP has better builds and coordinators


LOLOLOLOLOL


http://encyclopediadramatica.com/Don%27t_feed_the_trolls
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
I hope this WPL works out better than the weak-ass one from USA AAA2 a few seasons back.


The one that produced a USA Pro Champ, 2 teams with undefeated USA Pro regular seasons, and a downright dominant perennial top 5 team with some playoff issues?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.