User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
Grim Truth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zadith

Perhaps all the elusive backs should just stop expecting games of 200+ yards a game and then they would focus on things like Cover Up or getting confidence or carrying or strength to 48 after they have their speed/agility to 70+


But... Powerbacks CAN expect 200 yard games when just focusing on 2 attributes and an SA and pushing two others MAYBE to the cap... maybe..?

So, again, Speed/Elusive RB's need to make sure to cap 6 attributes, 2nd cap three of them, while also having at least 4 SA's to a good amount...

 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
Originally posted by trentw

Originally posted by ShakeNBake


Originally posted by trentw



We haven't even talked about kick offs where you had damn well better have a Powerback or a Fullback return now, because WR's and Cb's have no cover up option, and imo returns is where fumbles are out of control. That said once again you have thousands of ST'ers who have pumped power tackling who will expect a reset if fumbling is nerfed.


my wr never fumbled


Just wait he will, especially if he is returning kicks:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=476265


he returns kicks, no fumbles tho


After one game? Lets see how many has at the end of the season providing there is no nerf.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trentw
Originally posted by ShakeNBake

Originally posted by trentw


Originally posted by ShakeNBake



Originally posted by trentw




We haven't even talked about kick offs where you had damn well better have a Powerback or a Fullback return now, because WR's and Cb's have no cover up option, and imo returns is where fumbles are out of control. That said once again you have thousands of ST'ers who have pumped power tackling who will expect a reset if fumbling is nerfed.


my wr never fumbled


Just wait he will, especially if he is returning kicks:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=476265


he returns kicks, no fumbles tho


After one game? Lets see how many has at the end of the season providing there is no nerf.


and 4 scrimmages
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zadith
Originally posted by CapnEnnui

Originally posted by Zadith


Originally posted by Grim Truth



Originally posted by Bukowski



Originally posted by Zadith



Originally posted by Grim Truth



It's not one CB, it's all CB's. We're not talking about a specialized CB with uber strength, I was being SARCASTIC about the strength build CB's, proving the point that NO ONE builds them but they too are force fumble machines, as you called it.

Players shouldn't be immune to everything, but when a CB with likely 20-30 strength can cause a RB to fumble 3x it's a bit much, wouldn't you say?


Not if the HB has low confidence, and by that I mean less than 50...


Yeah.

Elusive RBs should have every attribute at 50.

Then they would be really good.


Apparently. You can be a Powerback with just Strength, Carrying, and PowerThru and be great, but you're ****ed if you are a Speed/Elusive back and don't have 60 Spd, 60Agl, 60Carry, 50 Str, Cover Up, Quick Cut, Head Fake, Juke, First Step, 50 Vision, and 50 Confidence


Perhaps all the elusive backs should just stop expecting games of 200+ yards a game and then they would focus on things like Cover Up or getting confidence or carrying or strength to 48 after they have their speed/agility to 70+


I think a great deal of elusive backs with fumbling problems are at 48 in those attributes, minus confidence maybe. Even then, should they fumble every game because it's only 35?

70+ speed/agility is the only way elusive backs have been good so far. What you're proposing is that they should suck either way.



No I am telling you to do the same thing the defense had to do. Suffer through it for a season or so until you can fix your build...


It's not "my" build. I have a power back, 10 defensive players and a punter.

LBs had many seasons to adjust to power backs. This change happened overnight.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
he won't fumble tomorrow either because he doesn't suck
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnEnnui
Originally posted by Zadith

Originally posted by CapnEnnui


Originally posted by Zadith



Originally posted by Grim Truth




Originally posted by Bukowski




Originally posted by Zadith




Originally posted by Grim Truth




It's not one CB, it's all CB's. We're not talking about a specialized CB with uber strength, I was being SARCASTIC about the strength build CB's, proving the point that NO ONE builds them but they too are force fumble machines, as you called it.

Players shouldn't be immune to everything, but when a CB with likely 20-30 strength can cause a RB to fumble 3x it's a bit much, wouldn't you say?


Not if the HB has low confidence, and by that I mean less than 50...


Yeah.

Elusive RBs should have every attribute at 50.

Then they would be really good.


Apparently. You can be a Powerback with just Strength, Carrying, and PowerThru and be great, but you're ****ed if you are a Speed/Elusive back and don't have 60 Spd, 60Agl, 60Carry, 50 Str, Cover Up, Quick Cut, Head Fake, Juke, First Step, 50 Vision, and 50 Confidence


Perhaps all the elusive backs should just stop expecting games of 200+ yards a game and then they would focus on things like Cover Up or getting confidence or carrying or strength to 48 after they have their speed/agility to 70+


I think a great deal of elusive backs with fumbling problems are at 48 in those attributes, minus confidence maybe. Even then, should they fumble every game because it's only 35?

70+ speed/agility is the only way elusive backs have been good so far. What you're proposing is that they should suck either way.



No I am telling you to do the same thing the defense had to do. Suffer through it for a season or so until you can fix your build...


It's not "my" build. I have a power back, 10 defensive players and a punter.

LBs had many seasons to adjust to power backs. This change happened overnight.


get over it
 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grim Truth
Originally posted by Zadith


Perhaps all the elusive backs should just stop expecting games of 200+ yards a game and then they would focus on things like Cover Up or getting confidence or carrying or strength to 48 after they have their speed/agility to 70+


But... Powerbacks CAN expect 200 yard games when just focusing on 2 attributes and an SA and pushing two others MAYBE to the cap... maybe..?

So, again, Speed/Elusive RB's need to make sure to cap 6 attributes, 2nd cap three of them, while also having at least 4 SA's to a good amount...



You won't get any argument from me there. Power Backs have it good right now, but eventually Bort will find the sweet spot in the SIM where they will be in the same boat with the rest of the HBs. Until then all you can do is do exactly what every LB and D-lineman has had to do for the last 2-3 seasons. Adjust your build to fit the system. Yeah it sucks but we all have to live with it...
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by tpaterniti

It's your confidence.


Look at my FB especially. A lot in Cover Up and a lot of carrying, but still fumbling a lot. I am sure now it is his confidence.


I agree. I think confidence gets massively overlooked.
 
Grim Truth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zadith

No I am telling you to do the same thing the defense had to do. Suffer through it for a season or so until you can fix your build...


Speed/Elusive RB's have had the short end of the stick for 3 seasons now. First it was that they couldn't have any production, now they can have some production but they'll fumble 4x. "fix your build" is idiot speak for "build powerbacks"
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
So why is ShakeNBake allowed to just troll this thread without anything constructive other than COVER UP AND CARRYING, DEAL
 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
And it didn't happen over night. It happened because we had a long preseason where we were able to toy with VAs and all the LBs and D-lineman went with Power Tackler because it is one of the few GOOD VAs they have while the offense has a ton of good VAs...
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
he won't fumble tomorrow either because he doesn't suck


You just better hope you don't face a Kick Off team with all there Power tackling bumped to 15 imo. But yeah I am sure he will be fine, you build much better players than everyone else in this game.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
he won't fumble tomorrow either because he doesn't suck


Well, he does suck (he's a mediocre receiver and a poor returner) he just doesn't fumble.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnEnnui
So why is ShakeNBake allowed to just troll this thread without anything constructive other than COVER UP AND CARRYING, DEAL


i don't know y u keep bitching when u know the answer
 
chazutx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
FWIW, I'll admit that the fumble distribution may have swung too far to the other side of reasonable behavior... seems like a lot of the time when the sim has a "minor" adjustment, some pretty big effects are seen in game results. I think a lot of that may just be because folks need to adjust (equipment, team AI, player tactics, long-term builds, etc) from previously extreme setups, which takes a few games to figure out -- typically 10-12 weeks of the season before the community as a whole figures out how to adapt.


Bingo. I don't think us that are complaining about fumbles are saying take them away...it's that they go from one extreme to the next. Teams combining for 10+ fumbles a game isn't realistic period!

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.