User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Page:
 
Rumble Bee
offline
Link
 
"let people keep their cash, and maybe give some BT's or something for their trouble."

This is a great idea since I am losing my new equipment already. People that think this is a bad idea are the people that didnt get them to begin with.

Overall I like the new ideas and think this should be fun!
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
If the top endorsements are given out to the top offensive, defensive, and ST players, and not just random people, does anyone else think Bort could actually get real advertisers to make a little additional money? He could make the O,D, and ST endorsements the same for every league. I would think he could find 3 advertisers to sponsor the top player in every league, considering how many leagues there are. Put a little button on the players profile page with the sponsors logo, and that would help show off that you got a top endorsement. It wouldn't make Bort rich, but it would be a little extra money, and then hopefully some of it would get funneled back in
 
JCJayhawk
Achoothulhu
offline
Link
 
How do other MMORPGS hand out rare EQ? Isn't it basically luck of the draw?
 
shadow67
offline
Link
 
Most of the major ideas and counters have been disucss at length. I just want to make it clear that fame is a big part of the problem. It's easily exploitable, random at times and just not a good value. Any formula you add this tainted value to just becomes tainted exponentially.

Before you fix the endorsements, that number has to be tossed or fixed.
 
dhannon1881
offline
Link
 
well the endorsements that have been handed out so far seem to be luck of the draw... my punter got on and he only had 5 punts all last season and none of my players who actually got solid stats got anything
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JCJayhawk
How do other MMORPGS hand out rare EQ? Isn't it basically luck of the draw?


no - it's not luck of the draw in other MMORPGS -

first you've got to be a part of a group that is able to complete a (normally) very difficult and time consuming quest of some kind -

if you ARE able to complete it - then yes - often times that super rare loot is randomly assigned to one of the members in the group...



but the level 1 dude sitting back in town killing rats certainly can't access that upper end gear
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shadow67
Most of the major ideas and counters have been disucss at length. I just want to make it clear that fame is a big part of the problem. It's easily exploitable, random at times and just not a good value. Any formula you add this tainted value to just becomes tainted exponentially.

Before you fix the endorsements, that number has to be tossed or fixed.


Also they really need to do something about level 5s and 10s sitting on a AAA roster racking up big time fame holding a clipboard.
 
shadow67
offline
Link
 
That's exactly one of the exploits I'm referring to. That makes using that fame number in any calculation a big problem. One team had two or three players, lvl 9, on an upper level team get endorsements without playing a single down.
 
robb4242
offline
Link
 
I have not read the entire thread, and I'm not going to. But a couple of curious things pop into my mind just looking at who received endorsements in my leagues.

1. Why do 6 of the endorsements leave the league? Both teams promoted from A to AA each received 3 of the league endorsements, but they are no longer in the league. They should be factored into the league in which they move up into. Maybe the players were MVP players in the A league, and factor that into the decision making process in the new league to give those players an advantage over an average player in that league. Just like college going to the NFL, there are guys who were stars in college that get endorsements over established, but not as well known NFL players. You take away 6 potential endorsements from the leagues when they are given the endorsement pre-promotion.

2. What is the weight given to players who actually purchase flex points. I don't recall seeing that as a factor, but it seems that a majority (not all) of the players receiving endorsements look like players who have leveled fast due to flex point pumps. I don't have a problem with giving people who have purchased flex points a little added weight in the decision tree, but at least say that it's being done. Those are the people who are coming off with the cash to keep this game going, so it's fine if they get a little extra chance to receive an endorsement, just don't hide it if you're doing it.

Just my 2 cents from an average player who treats this as a game and is not all wrapped up in formulas & stuff.
 
DWetzel
offline
Link
 
I see a lot of problems with this. They've probably been covered in the first 40 pages.

1. First of all, what do you mean by "only three endorsements can be active in a game"? Does this mean that if Team A has two endorsements, and Team B has two endorsements, that one of them doesn't work? If so, how do you decide which one? And how far in advance would the one that doesn't get endorsements know about that?

2. Re: teams stacking endorsements, just make it so an endorsement isn't valid if it isn't with the team that it was earned with. You can get more complicated with this (leave national endorsements valid if you stay within the region, or whatever), but you don't NEED to. If you put this simple rule in, then that solves all problems with teams stacking endorsed players. (I don't necessarily think this is a good idea from a realism perspective--Peyton Manning would still be doing a zillion commercials if he were a free agent and signed somewhere else--but from a game balance perspective, fine, whatever.)

3. An MVP formula is going to be silly for certain positions (since the only stat tracked for O-linemen is pancakes, for instance, and what about say a HB/KR; do you combine his numbers or just rank him as a HB?), and merely bad for others. It also rewards stat hogs and teams running up the score on gutted teams, which is worse than pointless. Doing this by a formula is a bad idea.

4. You're shafting people at non-glamorous positions by basically taking them out of the equation for most of these awards.
 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
Seems like the lower level endorsements would only help low level players. I mean, if one of my level 49s got a +2 speed shoes from doing local ads for a car lot, it does literally nothing as it would be a downgrade to his current gear to even equip the endorsement gear.
 
Drew Brees
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Suthrner
Originally posted by Saints4Life08

This all comes down to a bunch of people whining cause they didn't get there way. If any one of the whiners on here would have gotten an endorsement they would be on the other side of the argument. Just leave the people who got them be and fix it and have the system right for next season. Why go and take away what was already given? That's a horrible idea. Whiney Babys on here are ridiculous. Grow a pair and move on.


This guy is horrible and should have never gotten an endorsement, which is probably why your so reluctant to give it up.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1204058


Duh, hes not horrible. Hes level 11 and was a backup.... Cry me a river...sucks you got no luck. Keep drinking the Haterade fool.
Last edited Feb 27, 2009 10:36:33
 
The Suthrner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by We_Rule
Seems like the lower level endorsements would only help low level players. I mean, if one of my level 49s got a +2 speed shoes from doing local ads for a car lot, it does literally nothing as it would be a downgrade to his current gear to even equip the endorsement gear.


It goes into it's own slot and you would now this if you read a little and didn't just pop up in every forum and start flaming.
Last edited Feb 27, 2009 10:40:54
 
The Suthrner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saints4Life08
Originally posted by The Suthrner

Originally posted by Saints4Life08


This all comes down to a bunch of people whining cause they didn't get there way. If any one of the whiners on here would have gotten an endorsement they would be on the other side of the argument. Just leave the people who got them be and fix it and have the system right for next season. Why go and take away what was already given? That's a horrible idea. Whiney Babys on here are ridiculous. Grow a pair and move on.


This guy is horrible and should have never gotten an endorsement, which is probably why your so reluctant to give it up.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1204058


Duh, hes not horrible. Hes level 11 and was a backup.... Cry me a river...sucks you got no luck. Keep drinking the Haterade fool.


How many NFL back-ups you know of getting endorsements. (excluding RB's who are part of a rotation)
 
bsharpe2
offline
Link
 
I believe in Bort. =-)

While I would hate to see all the stats/bonuses give to 2 of my 16 players, 1 who deserves it 1 who clearly didn't, based on stats and playing time, it is the right thing to do. Make it work for the players/agents/GLB and take as much time as necessary.

Thanks Bort.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.