User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Veteran Abilities are...
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Yeah - it's a bonus to hitting the guy as he catches the ball to jar it loose (which is not a fumble if he doesn't have control)


Glad I am waiting to see how it all plays out. I was thinking "after the catch" implied he made the catch so Jackhammer was a FF bonus.

So Long Reach gives a +3% of a second roll for a PD. If you fail to get the re roll or fail again on the re roll you would then get a bonus to knocking the ball loose on the tackle. Like a 3 way bonus to getting a PD.

I like Power Tackler with an all game +2% chance at a FF and Long Reach combo better though.
 
Cactus71
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Second Goalie
Originally posted by Bort

Yeah - it's a bonus to hitting the guy as he catches the ball to jar it loose (which is not a fumble if he doesn't have control)


Glad I am waiting to see how it all plays out. I was thinking "after the catch" implied he made the catch so Jackhammer was a FF bonus.

So Long Reach gives a +3% of a second roll for a PD. If you fail to get the re roll or fail again on the re roll you would then get a bonus to knocking the ball loose on the tackle. Like a 3 way bonus to getting a PD.

I like Power Tackler with an all game +2% chance at a FF and Long Reach combo better though.


these abilities are multiplicative so it's not a 2% chance to force a fumble it's your chance to force a fumble multiplied by that 2%
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 12:26:34
 
Link
 
Yeah that's what I meant. For my LB a +2% bonus to forced fumble for the entire game IMO is better than a +3% bonus to PD, only right after the catch, which is what Jackhammer is. As stated when it was first implemented I thought Jackhammer was a bonus to FF so I was debating between the +2% all game or +3% after catches. That cleared that decision up for me. Power Tackler first for my LB. Secondary VA still undetermined.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 16:49:12
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Second Goalie
Yeah that's what I meant. For my LB a +2% bonus to forced fumble for the entire game IMO is better than a +3% bonus to PD, only right after the catch, which is what Jackhammer is. As stated when it was first implemented I thought Jackhammer was a bonus to FF so I was debating between the +2% all game or +3% after catches. That cleared that decision up for me. Power Tackler first for my LB. Secondary VA still undetermined.


You have a better base chance to deflect a pass than you do to force a fumble, so a small percentage based increase to your PD chance is more useful than an even smaller percentage based chance to force a fumble.

Your LB forced one fumble last season, and deflected four passes. At 15 VPs, +30% force fumble or +45% PD is no question. Going by those numbers the difference would be .3 FFums, or 1.8 PDs.
 
Link
 
Power tackler is the most overrated VA.
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Power tackler is the most overrated VA.


Sometimes I think it might be worth trying to get around 10 Big Hit, Monster Hit, a bunch of Power Tackler, and enough Strength and Tackling to use Power Tackling style.

But then all empirical evidence suggests I'd have just wasted 60+ SP, 15 VP, and a lot of time.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Why would anyone choose "Short Yardage Monster" to get a 2% addition to breaking tackles ONLY when behind the line of scrimmage AS OPPOSED TO selecting "Bruiser" that gives a 3% addition to breaking tackles ALL OVER THE FIELD?


Can get both of them for a super bonus.


These skills need a bit of a rework IMO. Far too much overlap.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Power tackler is the most overrated VA.


Sometimes I think it might be worth trying to get around 10 Big Hit, Monster Hit, a bunch of Power Tackler, and enough Strength and Tackling to use Power Tackling style.

But then all empirical evidence suggests I'd have just wasted 60+ SP, 15 VP, and a lot of time.


Yeah, say it gets you another 1-2 FF per year. Well, the offense picks up about half of those... So if you get ultra-lucky and get a FF off these skills, half the time it's meaningless, right?
 
Cactus71
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


Why would anyone choose "Short Yardage Monster" to get a 2% addition to breaking tackles ONLY when behind the line of scrimmage AS OPPOSED TO selecting "Bruiser" that gives a 3% addition to breaking tackles ALL OVER THE FIELD?


Can get both of them for a super bonus.


These skills need a bit of a rework IMO. Far too much overlap.


to much overlap it's 2 skills
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Cactus71
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by Deathblade


Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader



Why would anyone choose "Short Yardage Monster" to get a 2% addition to breaking tackles ONLY when behind the line of scrimmage AS OPPOSED TO selecting "Bruiser" that gives a 3% addition to breaking tackles ALL OVER THE FIELD?


Can get both of them for a super bonus.


These skills need a bit of a rework IMO. Far too much overlap.


to much overlap it's 2 skills


... that largely overlap.
Last edited Dec 31, 2008 18:24:41
 
Cactus71
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by Cactus71

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Originally posted by Deathblade



Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader




Why would anyone choose "Short Yardage Monster" to get a 2% addition to breaking tackles ONLY when behind the line of scrimmage AS OPPOSED TO selecting "Bruiser" that gives a 3% addition to breaking tackles ALL OVER THE FIELD?


Can get both of them for a super bonus.


These skills need a bit of a rework IMO. Far too much overlap.


to much overlap it's 2 skills


... that largely overlap.


multiplicative 5% per 2 vet points while only in the backfield woo big advantage
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
I don't really mind two VAs that do functionally the same thing when they're active, but I do think it very odd that the more restrictive VA has a smaller bonus.

It would make more sense if Bruiser was a 2% bonus per level (bringing it in line with Slippery), and Short Yardage Monster was a 3% bonus since it is only active under very specific circumstances.
 
Cactus71
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
I don't really mind two VAs that do functionally the same thing when they're active, but I do think it very odd that the more restrictive VA has a smaller bonus.

It would make more sense if Bruiser was a 2% bonus per level (bringing it in line with Slippery), and Short Yardage Monster was a 3% bonus since it is only active under very specific circumstances.


it's meant to be like that everybody is going to start by maxing bruiser then in their later levels they can work on other vet abilities that don't give as much an advantage, nobody is going to start out by maxing an ability that only work behind the line of scrimmage because you don't design your HB to be good behind the line of scrimmage
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cactus71
Originally posted by Maddoc

I don't really mind two VAs that do functionally the same thing when they're active, but I do think it very odd that the more restrictive VA has a smaller bonus.

It would make more sense if Bruiser was a 2% bonus per level (bringing it in line with Slippery), and Short Yardage Monster was a 3% bonus since it is only active under very specific circumstances.


it's meant to be like that everybody is going to start by maxing bruiser then in their later levels they can work on other vet abilities that don't give as much an advantage, nobody is going to start out by maxing an ability that only work behind the line of scrimmage because you don't design your HB to be good behind the line of scrimmage


Even then very situational bonuses should always higher than bonuses that are active all or almost all the time.
 
Cactus71
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by Cactus71

Originally posted by Maddoc


I don't really mind two VAs that do functionally the same thing when they're active, but I do think it very odd that the more restrictive VA has a smaller bonus.

It would make more sense if Bruiser was a 2% bonus per level (bringing it in line with Slippery), and Short Yardage Monster was a 3% bonus since it is only active under very specific circumstances.


it's meant to be like that everybody is going to start by maxing bruiser then in their later levels they can work on other vet abilities that don't give as much an advantage, nobody is going to start out by maxing an ability that only work behind the line of scrimmage because you don't design your HB to be good behind the line of scrimmage


Even then very situational bonuses should always higher than bonuses that are active all or almost all the time.


it is higher because it stacks
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.