User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01
Originally posted by Warlock

Kind of like an OT that 2nd caps agility and blocking, with enough left over to soft cap strength?


I think you significantly overestimate the importance of blocking, I wouldn't consider it a major in either run or pass support. My LT and my RG who has become a RT since he's the only other OL with capped speed on the team both have only 1-capped blocking. My LT was on the league leaderboard for pancakes in Seasons 4 and 5, though more in the 8-10 range.

I guess that's my problem. My LT is dominant in the run game (vs. weak DEs, the subject of this discussion) and pretty good, though not completely Mr. Shutdown, against the pass. This is without TE help, without keeping backs in to block and running mostly medium with the occasional long pass play. Anything that makes him block the pass better at this point would IMO be game-breaking for pass rushers.



Dominant you say, what's dominant to you? Run blocking in-general is dominant if you consider, not letting your assignment make the tackle. I've only witnessed one game this season where, the team that I'm on, didn't run the ball at will (averaging 5+ YPC). The one time we were shut down (comparatively speaking anyways, we still had 130 or so yards rushing), was due to a good LB corp and a good Def game plan.

Dominant run blocking IRL, is driving your opponent out of the play (optimally, into the way of other opponents) or pancake one guy and take on a second defender. This doesn't happen in GLB though. In GLB, the dots run through the other dots, so run blocking is all about putting a player on another player and hoping your RB can make two people miss (that's not dominant run blocking though, that's just standard old run blocking).

I'd agree if the OT can pancake the weak DE and move onto another defender, but that doesn't happen.

As for blocking not being that important... you're probably right and I wouldn't be very surprised at this point. This game was designed by the same people that made strength utterly useless in most situations. Although, if that's intended they need to rewrite some descriptions.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

omg and the same guy saying this crap about Freeney.

imo, let's just design GLB based on a Colts homer's ridiculous views of what his team is like.


I already said I was a Texans fan - I used the Colts as an example because 1) we played them yesterday, so it's on my mind and 2) they're far less obstinate about their gameplan than most teams and will change it in a second and 3) I think most NFL fans (even those of us that, like me, hate the Colts) would acknowledge that Manning has a pretty damn good grasp of what the threats to the passing game really are.

Substitute whatever sack specialist you want for Freeney. Substitute whatever NFL OL you want. They all double team elite pass-rushers. They all keep backs in to block at times. None of them are looking for a 20 yard gain on every play like 90% of GLB teams.


Redskins/Cowboys last night. One of the best pass rushers in the league who gets doubled constantly. They had him 1v1 on Chris Samuels (who is hurt) for a lot of the game.

He got one sack.

Uh-oh. Bye-bye argument.
 
lgoody
offline
Link
 
...they might have been chipping him with a RB...
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams


Redskins/Cowboys last night. One of the best pass rushers in the league who gets doubled constantly. They had him 1v1 on Chris Samuels (who is hurt) for a lot of the game.

He got one sack.

Uh-oh. Bye-bye argument.


Uh-oh. Read your own post. Or are you suggesting that the rest of the NFL are morons for doubling him? Also, wouldn't that be a 3-4 OLB you're talking about and not a DE at all?
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01
Uh-oh. Read your own post. Or are you suggesting that the rest of the NFL are morons for doubling him? Also, wouldn't that be a 3-4 OLB you're talking about and not a DE at all?


Not going to argue about NFL players, since it's not really pertinent to the conversation (since it's about football players in-general, not the NFL)... but an OLB in a 3-4 defense is basically a hybrid DE/LB. They have to generally be able to do both jobs at any given time.

Also, the best pass rushing DEs don't really get double teamed. The backs that are held in to help block, go after the largest threat generally (which could be the DE, but not always). TEs sometimes double team them, but more often than not they chip/punch and run their route.

Unfortunately, the pathing sucks for blocking backs in GLB and TEs don't chip/punch. So the OTs get left on the island most of the time and don't have good enough pathing to counter the crazy mismatches in speed/agility. Which the primary reason that DEs can reach the QB in under a second. That shouldn't happen, at the best, it should take 2 seconds and the average should be 3-4 seconds.

If pathing gets tuned, it will screw DEs, which is why I suggested tuning how blocking works. If both of these issues are addressed (with maybe some tweaks to the strength and blocking attribute), I think both sides of the fence would be satisfied... well probably not, since people will always find something to bitch about.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Originally posted by Sarg01

Originally posted by Azure Dreams


omg and the same guy saying this crap about Freeney.

imo, let's just design GLB based on a Colts homer's ridiculous views of what his team is like.


I already said I was a Texans fan - I used the Colts as an example because 1) we played them yesterday, so it's on my mind and 2) they're far less obstinate about their gameplan than most teams and will change it in a second and 3) I think most NFL fans (even those of us that, like me, hate the Colts) would acknowledge that Manning has a pretty damn good grasp of what the threats to the passing game really are.

Substitute whatever sack specialist you want for Freeney. Substitute whatever NFL OL you want. They all double team elite pass-rushers. They all keep backs in to block at times. None of them are looking for a 20 yard gain on every play like 90% of GLB teams.


Redskins/Cowboys last night. One of the best pass rushers in the league who gets doubled constantly. They had him 1v1 on Chris Samuels (who is hurt) for a lot of the game.

He got one sack.

Uh-oh. Bye-bye argument.


One sack is a very good game for an NFL player. That extrapolates to a 16-sack season which will likely lead the NFL.
 
mbking
offline
Link
 
maybe with what bort said you could have both based on vision. if a ot doesn't have much vision he wont block in his strong attribute and same for de's. But if my strong attribute is better than your strong attribute maybe I get a bonus for you trying to out push a guy who is stronger or out run a guy who is faster.



this would solve complaining both ways because you would have to do a who has higher vision check than strong attribute matches up and then check for attribute to who wins in the block. Also the risk of pilling into speed and agility for de's or strength or blocking for ot's is that someone with higher vision and better of the other attributes wins.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1458956

This is likely worth linking in this thread -- it appears there may be a change in the works. Anyone else seen an LT recover like this? These recovery movements are new to me, and I watch a lot of film.
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Per Bort regarding the LOT position and the new recovery movements:

Originally posted by Bort
Nope, I didn't change anything about how they move, but I did give "protector" an additional boost to speed/turning.


Last edited Nov 17, 2008 23:54:31
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
You guys can stop crying now.
 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
Agreed. RDE, at least, just took a pretty big hit.
 
jlong78la
offline
Link
 
Defense loses again. sigh........
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Barnsie
Agreed. RDE, at least, just took a pretty big hit.


oh wait...there is thread in the suggestions forum wanting the protect SA to work for ROT also..so LDE's are next
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jlong78la
Defense loses again. sigh........


The laws of physics and football fundamentals win again.
Sigh...
 
jlong78la
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by jlong78la

Defense loses again. sigh........


The laws of physics and football fundamentals win again.
Sigh...


Watch the plays in this thread and tell me where the laws of physics apply.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1458956
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 08:11:53
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.