Originally posted by Gturtle
Also, just so we're clear on this-
SteelersInsider, if you were to sum your position on homosexual marriage up with one sentence, that sentence would be similiar to "I don't believe homosexuals should have the same legal rights as heterosexuals" correct?
Because you see, if you exchange the bolded words for any two other different groups, you're a terrible bigot. Just because the bolded words are "homosexual" and "heterosexual" doesn't change this fact, DUCY?
"legal rights" is the tricky word here. I need that term better defined.
Are you including tax treatment as a "legal right"?
Does that mean that you think people who make $200K a year should have the same "legal right" to the same tax rate as someone who makes $25K a year?
Or do you believe that rich people and poor people should have different "legal rights"?
You may say that the tax rates are known and that a person can make as much as they want to based on the rules.
I could also tell you that the rules of marriage are known and a person can choose to marry someone of the opposite sex and get those extra rights if they want to.
Am I right?
Then you would come back and say that gays don't want to play by those rules because they aren't "fair" to them and that they don't want to marry someone of the opposite sex. Of course I would turn around and tell you that rich people would say that the tax rates aren't "fair" to them either and don't want to pay a higher tax rate.
*shrugs*
Get rid of income taxes and inheritance taxes all together and that solves alot of problems.
Also, just so we're clear on this-
SteelersInsider, if you were to sum your position on homosexual marriage up with one sentence, that sentence would be similiar to "I don't believe homosexuals should have the same legal rights as heterosexuals" correct?
Because you see, if you exchange the bolded words for any two other different groups, you're a terrible bigot. Just because the bolded words are "homosexual" and "heterosexual" doesn't change this fact, DUCY?
"legal rights" is the tricky word here. I need that term better defined.
Are you including tax treatment as a "legal right"?
Does that mean that you think people who make $200K a year should have the same "legal right" to the same tax rate as someone who makes $25K a year?
Or do you believe that rich people and poor people should have different "legal rights"?
You may say that the tax rates are known and that a person can make as much as they want to based on the rules.
I could also tell you that the rules of marriage are known and a person can choose to marry someone of the opposite sex and get those extra rights if they want to.
Am I right?
Then you would come back and say that gays don't want to play by those rules because they aren't "fair" to them and that they don't want to marry someone of the opposite sex. Of course I would turn around and tell you that rich people would say that the tax rates aren't "fair" to them either and don't want to pay a higher tax rate.
*shrugs*
Get rid of income taxes and inheritance taxes all together and that solves alot of problems.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 01:15:42






























