User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Interesting topic of the Week: Evolutionism versus Creationism
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Also, just so we're clear on this-

SteelersInsider, if you were to sum your position on homosexual marriage up with one sentence, that sentence would be similiar to "I don't believe homosexuals should have the same legal rights as heterosexuals" correct?

Because you see, if you exchange the bolded words for any two other different groups, you're a terrible bigot. Just because the bolded words are "homosexual" and "heterosexual" doesn't change this fact, DUCY?



"legal rights" is the tricky word here. I need that term better defined.

Are you including tax treatment as a "legal right"?


Does that mean that you think people who make $200K a year should have the same "legal right" to the same tax rate as someone who makes $25K a year?

Or do you believe that rich people and poor people should have different "legal rights"?


You may say that the tax rates are known and that a person can make as much as they want to based on the rules.

I could also tell you that the rules of marriage are known and a person can choose to marry someone of the opposite sex and get those extra rights if they want to.


Am I right?


Then you would come back and say that gays don't want to play by those rules because they aren't "fair" to them and that they don't want to marry someone of the opposite sex. Of course I would turn around and tell you that rich people would say that the tax rates aren't "fair" to them either and don't want to pay a higher tax rate.

*shrugs*


Get rid of income taxes and inheritance taxes all together and that solves alot of problems.





Last edited Dec 29, 2008 01:15:42
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Speaking of holding onto archaic beliefs-

http://uk.reuters.com/article/lifestyleMolt/idUKTRE4BL2FE20081222

What's that Mr. Pope? Homosexuals and transgendered people represent the same threat to humanity as the depletion of the earths natural resources? Irreparable ecological damage is being done by men who like to stick their penis into another man?

Archaic no longer seems sufficient.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Gturtle

Also, just so we're clear on this-

SteelersInsider, if you were to sum your position on homosexual marriage up with one sentence, that sentence would be similiar to "I don't believe homosexuals should have the same legal rights as heterosexuals" correct?

Because you see, if you exchange the bolded words for any two other different groups, you're a terrible bigot. Just because the bolded words are "homosexual" and "heterosexual" doesn't change this fact, DUCY?



"legal rights" is the tricky word here. I need more definition of what that means.

Are you including tax treatment as a "legal right"?


Does that mean that you think people who make $200K a year should have the same "legal right" to the same tax rate as someone who makes $25K a year?

Or do you believe that rich people and poor people should have different "legal rights"?


You may say that the tax rates are known and that a person can make as much as they want to based on the rules.

I could also tell you that the rules of marriage are known and a person can choose to marry someone of the opposite sex and get those extra rights if they want to.


Am I right?


Then you would come back and say that gays don't want to play by those rules because they aren't "fair" to them and that they don't want to marry someone of the opposite sex. Of course I would turn around and tell you that rich people would say that the tax rates aren't "fair" to them either and don't want to pay a higher tax rate.

*shrugs*


Get rid of income taxes and inheritance taxes all together and that solves alot of problems.







How's this for a definition of legal right-

It is impossible for a man and another man to be legally married in the state of California. Not bringing in tax brackets, income tax, sales tax, any tax-related reasoning. It is impossible for the state of California to issue a certificate that says that Adam and Steve were united in marriage. It cannot be done
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
He may be calling names, but I'm not. Yet I can't help but notice that you aren't acknowledging my posts.

I'd honestly love for a counter-argument. I know you can't make one, but please: surprise me.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


you didn't answer my question:

if you want to get married in a church, don't you think you should abide that church's beliefs?


What if I want to get married in the secretary of states office. Why do I need to abide by that church's beliefs in the secretary of state's office?


1.) You didn't answer my question (a yes or no answer would suffice)
2.) I have no idea what you are talking about with your question back to me
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
He may be calling names, but I'm not. Yet I can't help but notice that you aren't acknowledging my posts.

I'd honestly love for a counter-argument. I know you can't make one, but please: surprise me.


did you have a question I didn't answer?


I just saw you state a couple times that there is no argument against. or ask rhetorical questions.

I've given you several arguments against already imo.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle

How's this for a definition of legal right-

It is impossible for a man and another man to be legally married in the state of California. Not bringing in tax brackets, income tax, sales tax, any tax-related reasoning. It is impossible for the state of California to issue a certificate that says that Adam and Steve were united in marriage. It cannot be done


Every time I ask you a question, you say.....let's put your question aside and answer my completely different question.

At least admit that I am right, then move on to another question. A simple "yes" to my question would do.


Let me try again:


Does someone who makes $200K have the "right" to be taxed at the same rate as someone who makes $25K?

Last edited Dec 29, 2008 01:28:08
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Gturtle

Originally posted by SteelersInsider



you didn't answer my question:

if you want to get married in a church, don't you think you should abide that church's beliefs?


What if I want to get married in the secretary of states office. Why do I need to abide by that church's beliefs in the secretary of state's office?


1.) You didn't answer my question (a yes or no answer would suffice)
2.) I have no idea what you are talking about with your question back to me


Well the assumption here in hypothetical land is that this church doesn't condone same sex marriages, correct?

Why do I have to abide by those beliefs, in a supposedly neutral government location, such as the Secretary of State's office (where one acquires such documents as a certificate of marriage)
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

He may be calling names, but I'm not. Yet I can't help but notice that you aren't acknowledging my posts.

I'd honestly love for a counter-argument. I know you can't make one, but please: surprise me.


did you have a question I didn't answer?


I just saw you state a couple times that there is no argument against. or ask rhetorical questions.

I've given you several arguments against already imo.


I did ask a question, which you obviously already know since you acknowledged it.

However, if you've given arguments relevant to my question, I did not see them (I just rejoined this topic recently) and have no intention of going back through 600 pages of posts to find it. So a rephrasing or quoting would be lovely.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Gturtle


How's this for a definition of legal right-

It is impossible for a man and another man to be legally married in the state of California. Not bringing in tax brackets, income tax, sales tax, any tax-related reasoning. It is impossible for the state of California to issue a certificate that says that Adam and Steve were united in marriage. It cannot be done


Every time I ask you a question, you say.....let's put your question aside and answer my completely different question. o_O


do you really want me to go through your posts, piece by piece, and break it down for you?
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
"legal rights" is the tricky word here. I need that term better defined.

Are you including tax treatment as a "legal right"?


Legal rights are difficult to define. We'll settle with "Entitlements or permissions conveyed by a particular polity, codified into legal statutes by some form of legislature"

Originally posted by "SteelersInsider"
Does that mean that you think people who make $200K a year should have the same "legal right" to the same tax rate as someone who makes $25K a year?

Or do you believe that rich people and poor people should have different "legal rights"?


Questions not pertinent to the issue at hand.


Originally posted by "SteelersInsider"
You may say that the tax rates are known and that a person can make as much as they want to based on the rules.

I could also tell you that the rules of marriage are known and a person can choose to marry someone of the opposite sex and get those extra rights if they want to.


Am I right?


You're wrong. I want to make $1million dollars a nano second. Make it happen, and maybe we'll talk about how love works.


Originally posted by "SteelersInsider"
Then you would come back and say that gays don't want to play by those rules because they aren't "fair" to them and that they don't want to marry someone of the opposite sex. Of course I would turn around and tell you that rich people would say that the tax rates aren't "fair" to them either and don't want to pay a higher tax rate.

*shrugs*


Gays don't play by the rules? So suddenly wanting to join someone in marriage has a set of rules attached to it. Can I get a copy of the rulebook for the game called love, I'm pretty sure I could make a million dollars a nanosecond selling it.


Originally posted by "SteelersInsider"
Get rid of income taxes and inheritance taxes all together and that solves alot of problems.


What the fuck does the tax system have to do with anything?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams


I did ask a question, which you obviously already know since you acknowledged it.

However, if you've given arguments relevant to my question, I did not see them (I just rejoined this topic recently) and have no intention of going back through 600 pages of posts to find it. So a rephrasing or quoting would be lovely.



Here is the main argument:

There are a large number of people of several religions (and non-religious people) over the last 5,000 years who feel that people should mate with the opposite sex only.

You have your beliefs on the subject. And so does gturtle. And so does everyone else.

Why should YOUR belief be more important than anyone else's?

If your belief was in the majority, then you would be able to get congressmen and politicians to put it on their platform and then write laws to change it when they got into office.

But since you are in the minority, then you have to abide by the tax laws, marriage laws, traffic laws, and all other laws made by the MAJORITY. That is how the Democratic process works.

Maybe you think someone's religion is stupid. That is fine. You don't have to join their religion and no one is forcing you to. You just can't expect someone to change their entire belief system that has been in effect their entire life because you don't agree.

In a democracy, the majority rules. When more people agree with your side, then it will change. People from the other side aren't sitting in here and calling you an idiot. It would be nice if you refrained from doing the same.



Last edited Dec 29, 2008 01:37:40
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle


Originally posted by "SteelersInsider"

Does that mean that you think people who make $200K a year should have the same "legal right" to the same tax rate as someone who makes $25K a year?

Or do you believe that rich people and poor people should have different "legal rights"?


Questions not pertinent to the issue at hand.



Actually it is very relevant. If your point was that all people should have equal rights, this point proves that all people do not have equal rights. It also proves that rights are not given based on what YOU think, but on what the MAJORITY thinks.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 01:41:36
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Here is the main argument:

There are a large number of people of several religions (and non-religious people) over the last 5,000 years who feel that people should mate with the opposite sex only.


List your source please, also quantify the term "large number" how large? We talking bingo club at the YMCA large, or all of them? By the way keep in mind that Ancient China, Japan, Greece, and Rome all have homosexual acts portrayed in writing or forms of engraved art.

Originally posted by "SteelersInsider"
You have your beliefs on the subject. And so does gturtle. And so does everyone else.

Why should YOUR belief be more important than anyone else's?


Because our beliefs don't infringe on the rights of other human beings. Yours do.

Originally posted by "SteelersInsider"
If your belief was in the majority, then you would be able to get congressmen and politicians to put it on their platform and then write laws to change it when they got into office.


By this logic, jews could have saved themselves a lot of trouble by electing someone other than Hitler

Originally posted by "SteelersInsider"
But since you are in the minority, then you have to abide by the tax laws, marriage laws, traffic laws, and all other laws made by the MAJORITY. That is how the Democratic process works.


I wouldn't call this "working"

Originally posted by "SteelersInsider"
Maybe you think someone's religion is stupid. That is fine. You don't have to join their religion and no one is forcing you to. You just can't expect someone to change their entire belief system that has been in effect their entire life because you don't agree.

In a democracy, the majority rules. When more people agree with your side, then it will change. People are sitting in here and calling you an idiot. It would be nice if you refrained from doing the same.


Again, just because it's how a democracy works, doesn't mean it's working. Also we're a lot closer to a Theocracy than a Democracy, look at our motherfucking currency
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Oh, so that's the problem. You think we live in a democracy. We don't.

First of all, I don't think religion is stupid. I don't think Christianity is stupid. And, while I personally don't feel the same, I have no problem with you feeling that gay couples should not mate or be wed.

However, for some reason you think that because you feel that way, that should be law? It doesn't matter HOW many people feel that way, the law is not in place to go with feelings for the sake of going with feelings. The government and it's laws are in place to PROTECT the people, not RESTRICT them. Sometimes restrictions come for the sake of protection. However, gay marriage does not affect anyone who isn't involved, so making a law against it does not protect you. It restricts another based solely on your whims.

The entire reasoning you gave is based on the fact that you think it should be illegal because you don't like it. But why don't you like it? Because your religion teaches you not to like it. Again, I'm not here to cast aspersions on that fact, regardless of my feeling (at least not right now), however, one of this country's founding principals is the separation of church and state.

Now, could you give me a justifiable reason that same-sex marriage should be against the law without falling back on the church? As I've already pointed out, religion is not an acceptable reason to create law.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.