It's too bad that the best teams are in the East again. Trout, Yetis and Skins would all be undefeated and easily get promoted if they were in the West.
BobJoeJim
offline
offline
Originally posted by MiniHusk
you are confident enough to give yourselves a 6 point spread?
I couldn't justify a smaller spread given the rating differences at the time. The spreads have been based heavily on the ratings all year and I wasn't going to change that, even though I though 6 was ridiculously high, for a game that at the time I posted that, probably should have been pick'em.
Originally posted by TesT
I mean honestly....how stupid are these....
You have a team being held down in the #5 spot because they're unboosted, yet they continue to win games vs teams who do have boosted players which in turn gives those teams a better rank?
They're pretty stupid, and no I'm really not being sarcastic. That's why I created an entire new thread to discuss ways to improve them. I do think it's fair to rank an unboosted team lower though, since I'm trying to measure how dangerous that team is at the moment. Obviously I'm not criticizing the strategy, but it does make you a weaker team *at the time* than you would be if you were boosted. When you do eventually boost you will move up in the rankings accordingly.
Originally posted by TesT
I figured something like that would happen considering the amount of players who have already boosted on the Trout.
GG...I guess.
Good luck in the playoffs.
(Yeah, I'll sit here and take it all to the chin for our team. Fire away!!!)
There's nothing to fire, GG Yetis. I didn't think there was any chance we'd beat you that badly, but I also don't think there's any chance it means anything more than Ottawa's win over us does. We boosted, we beat you. Playoffs are coming, you'll boost too, and then we'll have a real game. I look forward to that one, I know it'll be much much tougher than this one was. I wish you the best of luck until then. Again, good game.
you are confident enough to give yourselves a 6 point spread?
I couldn't justify a smaller spread given the rating differences at the time. The spreads have been based heavily on the ratings all year and I wasn't going to change that, even though I though 6 was ridiculously high, for a game that at the time I posted that, probably should have been pick'em.
Originally posted by TesT
I mean honestly....how stupid are these....
You have a team being held down in the #5 spot because they're unboosted, yet they continue to win games vs teams who do have boosted players which in turn gives those teams a better rank?
They're pretty stupid, and no I'm really not being sarcastic. That's why I created an entire new thread to discuss ways to improve them. I do think it's fair to rank an unboosted team lower though, since I'm trying to measure how dangerous that team is at the moment. Obviously I'm not criticizing the strategy, but it does make you a weaker team *at the time* than you would be if you were boosted. When you do eventually boost you will move up in the rankings accordingly.
Originally posted by TesT
I figured something like that would happen considering the amount of players who have already boosted on the Trout.
GG...I guess.
Good luck in the playoffs.

(Yeah, I'll sit here and take it all to the chin for our team. Fire away!!!)
There's nothing to fire, GG Yetis. I didn't think there was any chance we'd beat you that badly, but I also don't think there's any chance it means anything more than Ottawa's win over us does. We boosted, we beat you. Playoffs are coming, you'll boost too, and then we'll have a real game. I look forward to that one, I know it'll be much much tougher than this one was. I wish you the best of luck until then. Again, good game.
sdubord
offline
offline
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
Montreal Mustangs vs. Ottawa Ambassadors [-30]
FINAL SCORE: Ottawa Ambassadors 30 - 0 Montreal Mustangs
I can only speak on my own team's numbers, but whether the rankings are stupid or not, you've been nailing the spread on my team really well this year!
Montreal Mustangs vs. Ottawa Ambassadors [-30]
FINAL SCORE: Ottawa Ambassadors 30 - 0 Montreal Mustangs
I can only speak on my own team's numbers, but whether the rankings are stupid or not, you've been nailing the spread on my team really well this year!
TesT
offline
offline
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
Originally posted by MiniHusk
you are confident enough to give yourselves a 6 point spread?
I couldn't justify a smaller spread given the rating differences at the time. The spreads have been based heavily on the ratings all year and I wasn't going to change that, even though I though 6 was ridiculously high, for a game that at the time I posted that, probably should have been pick'em.
Originally posted by TesT
I mean honestly....how stupid are these....
You have a team being held down in the #5 spot because they're unboosted, yet they continue to win games vs teams who do have boosted players which in turn gives those teams a better rank?
They're pretty stupid, and no I'm really not being sarcastic. That's why I created an entire new thread to discuss ways to improve them. I do think it's fair to rank an unboosted team lower though, since I'm trying to measure how dangerous that team is at the moment. Obviously I'm not criticizing the strategy, but it does make you a weaker team *at the time* than you would be if you were boosted. When you do eventually boost you will move up in the rankings accordingly.
Originally posted by TesT
I figured something like that would happen considering the amount of players who have already boosted on the Trout.
GG...I guess.
Good luck in the playoffs.
(Yeah, I'll sit here and take it all to the chin for our team. Fire away!!!)
There's nothing to fire, GG Yetis. I didn't think there was any chance we'd beat you that badly, but I also don't think there's any chance it means anything more than Ottawa's win over us does. We boosted, we beat you. Playoffs are coming, you'll boost too, and then we'll have a real game. I look forward to that one, I know it'll be much much tougher than this one was. I wish you the best of luck until then. Again, good game.
What good does it do to rank us higher after we've boosted and assuming we win our first playoff game? At that point there will be 4 teams and nobody will care.
We should have been given more credit winning games vs some of these "better" teams unboosted....don't ya think?
Even now if we're still #5, I dont understand how beating 2 and 3 and losing to 1 and 4 gets us there.
Originally posted by MiniHusk
you are confident enough to give yourselves a 6 point spread?
I couldn't justify a smaller spread given the rating differences at the time. The spreads have been based heavily on the ratings all year and I wasn't going to change that, even though I though 6 was ridiculously high, for a game that at the time I posted that, probably should have been pick'em.
Originally posted by TesT
I mean honestly....how stupid are these....
You have a team being held down in the #5 spot because they're unboosted, yet they continue to win games vs teams who do have boosted players which in turn gives those teams a better rank?
They're pretty stupid, and no I'm really not being sarcastic. That's why I created an entire new thread to discuss ways to improve them. I do think it's fair to rank an unboosted team lower though, since I'm trying to measure how dangerous that team is at the moment. Obviously I'm not criticizing the strategy, but it does make you a weaker team *at the time* than you would be if you were boosted. When you do eventually boost you will move up in the rankings accordingly.
Originally posted by TesT
I figured something like that would happen considering the amount of players who have already boosted on the Trout.
GG...I guess.
Good luck in the playoffs.

(Yeah, I'll sit here and take it all to the chin for our team. Fire away!!!)
There's nothing to fire, GG Yetis. I didn't think there was any chance we'd beat you that badly, but I also don't think there's any chance it means anything more than Ottawa's win over us does. We boosted, we beat you. Playoffs are coming, you'll boost too, and then we'll have a real game. I look forward to that one, I know it'll be much much tougher than this one was. I wish you the best of luck until then. Again, good game.
What good does it do to rank us higher after we've boosted and assuming we win our first playoff game? At that point there will be 4 teams and nobody will care.
We should have been given more credit winning games vs some of these "better" teams unboosted....don't ya think?
Even now if we're still #5, I dont understand how beating 2 and 3 and losing to 1 and 4 gets us there.
Last edited May 27, 2008 04:27:26
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by
What good does it do to rank us higher after we've boosted and assuming we win our first playoff game? At that point there will be 4 teams and nobody will care.
We should have been given more credit winning games vs some of these "better" teams unboosted....don't ya think?
Even now if we're still #5, I dont understand how beating 2 and 3 and losing to 1 and 4 gets us there.
Of course you don't. BJJ's rankings have been, from their start, a ranking of who the most dangerous team(s) was or were at that moment, not who was more likely to win the title. If a team is unboosted, they'll be lower in the rankings that week because boosted teams will have an edge on them. When they boost, that roster rating will reflect that.
What good does it do to rank us higher after we've boosted and assuming we win our first playoff game? At that point there will be 4 teams and nobody will care.
We should have been given more credit winning games vs some of these "better" teams unboosted....don't ya think?
Even now if we're still #5, I dont understand how beating 2 and 3 and losing to 1 and 4 gets us there.
Of course you don't. BJJ's rankings have been, from their start, a ranking of who the most dangerous team(s) was or were at that moment, not who was more likely to win the title. If a team is unboosted, they'll be lower in the rankings that week because boosted teams will have an edge on them. When they boost, that roster rating will reflect that.
Last edited May 27, 2008 09:38:55
KingDan23
offline
offline
I think the whole "boosted vs unboosted" discussion in the power rankings is never going to really be resolved, as there is no way for BJJ to know what players have and havent boosted in each team.
SGRHewitt
offline
offline
Originally posted by Kingdan23
I think the whole "boosted vs unboosted" discussion in the power rankings is never going to really be resolved, as there is no way for BJJ to know what players have and havent boosted in each team.
Yeah, you have to go by current roster rating. If a team boosts at playoffs, then so be it. Regardless, you can't predict who is going to boost at the beginning of a year, or at the end.
I think the whole "boosted vs unboosted" discussion in the power rankings is never going to really be resolved, as there is no way for BJJ to know what players have and havent boosted in each team.
Yeah, you have to go by current roster rating. If a team boosts at playoffs, then so be it. Regardless, you can't predict who is going to boost at the beginning of a year, or at the end.
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by Kingdan23
I think the whole "boosted vs unboosted" discussion in the power rankings is never going to really be resolved, as there is no way for BJJ to know what players have and havent boosted in each team.
Right, I'd almost suggest a mandatory boost at the beginning of the year (if a player is going to boost that year). It would sync everyone up and make the regular season more telling.
I get that it's a part of strategy, but it's hardly realistic that Tony Romo becomes Peyton Manning the night before a playoff game.
I think the whole "boosted vs unboosted" discussion in the power rankings is never going to really be resolved, as there is no way for BJJ to know what players have and havent boosted in each team.
Right, I'd almost suggest a mandatory boost at the beginning of the year (if a player is going to boost that year). It would sync everyone up and make the regular season more telling.
I get that it's a part of strategy, but it's hardly realistic that Tony Romo becomes Peyton Manning the night before a playoff game.
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by lump7502
get rid of the cpu formula and do them by feel their more fun that way
BJJ had said that this was only HIS way of doing it, and encouraged others to do create their own ways. I'd hope we'd a bunch of people making rankings, the more the merrier. Just don't forget, no matter what system you pick, someone will dislike it.
get rid of the cpu formula and do them by feel their more fun that way
BJJ had said that this was only HIS way of doing it, and encouraged others to do create their own ways. I'd hope we'd a bunch of people making rankings, the more the merrier. Just don't forget, no matter what system you pick, someone will dislike it.
TesT
offline
offline
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by
What good does it do to rank us higher after we've boosted and assuming we win our first playoff game? At that point there will be 4 teams and nobody will care.
We should have been given more credit winning games vs some of these "better" teams unboosted....don't ya think?
Even now if we're still #5, I dont understand how beating 2 and 3 and losing to 1 and 4 gets us there.
Of course you don't. BJJ's rankings have been, from their start, a ranking of who the most dangerous team(s) was or were at that moment, not who was more likely to win the title. If a team is unboosted, they'll be lower in the rankings that week because boosted teams will have an edge on them. When they boost, that roster rating will reflect that.
I think I was asking BJJ......not you douchebag.
Originally posted by
What good does it do to rank us higher after we've boosted and assuming we win our first playoff game? At that point there will be 4 teams and nobody will care.
We should have been given more credit winning games vs some of these "better" teams unboosted....don't ya think?
Even now if we're still #5, I dont understand how beating 2 and 3 and losing to 1 and 4 gets us there.
Of course you don't. BJJ's rankings have been, from their start, a ranking of who the most dangerous team(s) was or were at that moment, not who was more likely to win the title. If a team is unboosted, they'll be lower in the rankings that week because boosted teams will have an edge on them. When they boost, that roster rating will reflect that.
I think I was asking BJJ......not you douchebag.
TesT
offline
offline
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by lump7502
get rid of the cpu formula and do them by feel their more fun that way
BJJ had said that this was only HIS way of doing it, and encouraged others to do create their own ways. I'd hope we'd a bunch of people making rankings, the more the merrier. Just don't forget, no matter what system you pick, someone will dislike it.
Then we could have 16 threads with every owner having their team ranked #1.
YAY!
Originally posted by lump7502
get rid of the cpu formula and do them by feel their more fun that way
BJJ had said that this was only HIS way of doing it, and encouraged others to do create their own ways. I'd hope we'd a bunch of people making rankings, the more the merrier. Just don't forget, no matter what system you pick, someone will dislike it.
Then we could have 16 threads with every owner having their team ranked #1.
YAY!
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by TesT
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by
What good does it do to rank us higher after we've boosted and assuming we win our first playoff game? At that point there will be 4 teams and nobody will care.
We should have been given more credit winning games vs some of these "better" teams unboosted....don't ya think?
Even now if we're still #5, I dont understand how beating 2 and 3 and losing to 1 and 4 gets us there.
Of course you don't. BJJ's rankings have been, from their start, a ranking of who the most dangerous team(s) was or were at that moment, not who was more likely to win the title. If a team is unboosted, they'll be lower in the rankings that week because boosted teams will have an edge on them. When they boost, that roster rating will reflect that.
I think I was asking BJJ......not you douchebag.
No you weren't, you were trying to troll a great thread. If you had any interest in the answers you'd have listened the first 100 times they were given.
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by
What good does it do to rank us higher after we've boosted and assuming we win our first playoff game? At that point there will be 4 teams and nobody will care.
We should have been given more credit winning games vs some of these "better" teams unboosted....don't ya think?
Even now if we're still #5, I dont understand how beating 2 and 3 and losing to 1 and 4 gets us there.
Of course you don't. BJJ's rankings have been, from their start, a ranking of who the most dangerous team(s) was or were at that moment, not who was more likely to win the title. If a team is unboosted, they'll be lower in the rankings that week because boosted teams will have an edge on them. When they boost, that roster rating will reflect that.
I think I was asking BJJ......not you douchebag.
No you weren't, you were trying to troll a great thread. If you had any interest in the answers you'd have listened the first 100 times they were given.
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by TesT
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by lump7502
get rid of the cpu formula and do them by feel their more fun that way
BJJ had said that this was only HIS way of doing it, and encouraged others to do create their own ways. I'd hope we'd a bunch of people making rankings, the more the merrier. Just don't forget, no matter what system you pick, someone will dislike it.
Then we could have 16 threads with every owner having their team ranked #1.
YAY!
My god, what an inconvienence your life must be. You're forced to get up, forced to eat a breakfast you hate, forced to log on and play an online game you don't like, then forced to read a forum you dislike.
Poor fella.
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by lump7502
get rid of the cpu formula and do them by feel their more fun that way
BJJ had said that this was only HIS way of doing it, and encouraged others to do create their own ways. I'd hope we'd a bunch of people making rankings, the more the merrier. Just don't forget, no matter what system you pick, someone will dislike it.
Then we could have 16 threads with every owner having their team ranked #1.
YAY!
My god, what an inconvienence your life must be. You're forced to get up, forced to eat a breakfast you hate, forced to log on and play an online game you don't like, then forced to read a forum you dislike.
Poor fella.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























