Im not talking a full reset, just if a team gets sold, and gutted, then it should be moved down a league (at the end of the season) and a team should move up and replace it. If a team isnt gutted, and just has a crappy owner, then it should stay.
Forum > Suggestions > This off season will be time to realign the teams in the USA tree.
SCACE
offline
offline
Originally posted by Tito716
I'm not sure that even a full reset would be needed.
Doubling or tripling relegation would do wonders. Would also require next to no effort.
I'm sure that completely realigning the leagues is problematic, and I doubt that Bort & Co, want to do that.
I think they should, but I think they should do a lot of things that never happen...
It would do wonders increasing competition at the very top. It would still take a long-time for gutted teams to make their way down to the bottom as they have to pass through AAA, AA and A in the USA leagues.
I'm not sure that even a full reset would be needed.
Doubling or tripling relegation would do wonders. Would also require next to no effort.
I'm sure that completely realigning the leagues is problematic, and I doubt that Bort & Co, want to do that.
I think they should, but I think they should do a lot of things that never happen...
It would do wonders increasing competition at the very top. It would still take a long-time for gutted teams to make their way down to the bottom as they have to pass through AAA, AA and A in the USA leagues.
Tito716
offline
offline
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Tito716
I'm not sure that even a full reset would be needed.
Doubling or tripling relegation would do wonders. Would also require next to no effort.
I'm sure that completely realigning the leagues is problematic, and I doubt that Bort & Co, want to do that.
I think they should, but I think they should do a lot of things that never happen...
It would do wonders increasing competition at the very top. It would still take a long-time for gutted teams to make their way down to the bottom as they have to pass through AAA, AA and A in the USA leagues.
I thought like that as well, and I agree, but we are already talking about dropping the bottom 6 from each A conference and moving the top 3 up from each BBB conference in a triple relegation.
I'm not sure that its entirely fair to completely fill the BBB with teams that have been resold in the last 2 seasons that aren't headed in the right direction, and using an expanded relegation system would be the most fair.
If there was a manual adjustment that wasn't a full reset, I'm sure there would be owners complaining about being dropped from AAA to BBB and there would also be owners complaining about their teams not being gutted enough that they were moved from AA to BBB.
Originally posted by Tito716
I'm not sure that even a full reset would be needed.
Doubling or tripling relegation would do wonders. Would also require next to no effort.
I'm sure that completely realigning the leagues is problematic, and I doubt that Bort & Co, want to do that.
I think they should, but I think they should do a lot of things that never happen...
It would do wonders increasing competition at the very top. It would still take a long-time for gutted teams to make their way down to the bottom as they have to pass through AAA, AA and A in the USA leagues.
I thought like that as well, and I agree, but we are already talking about dropping the bottom 6 from each A conference and moving the top 3 up from each BBB conference in a triple relegation.
I'm not sure that its entirely fair to completely fill the BBB with teams that have been resold in the last 2 seasons that aren't headed in the right direction, and using an expanded relegation system would be the most fair.
If there was a manual adjustment that wasn't a full reset, I'm sure there would be owners complaining about being dropped from AAA to BBB and there would also be owners complaining about their teams not being gutted enough that they were moved from AA to BBB.
SCACE
offline
offline
I think the reason this hasn't been solved is that it isn't an easy fix. I do agree that an increased promotion relegation system would be helpful though. I think anyone making the conference finals should be moving up (4 teams up) vs. the current 2-up structure. But, I also like the idea of earning my way by winning the conference game.
Tito716
offline
offline
Originally posted by SCACE
I think the reason this hasn't been solved is that it isn't an easy fix. I do agree that an increased promotion relegation system would be helpful though. I think anyone making the conference finals should be moving up (4 teams up) vs. the current 2-up structure. But, I also like the idea of earning my way by winning the conference game.
Sorry if I am straying off topic, but I think its almost universally (on these forums) supported for resold teams to move down to lower leagues no matter their record or standing at the end of the season.
Additionally I think the CPU should own the team until day 40, and run everything like the D Leagues but with real players and highly improved CPU players.
Finally, I think teams transferred to GMs should be exempt from this automatic relegation, should be too difficult, since transfer to a GM requires a manual intervention from support.
Having said all this, fixing the problem going forward doesn't fix the issue as it currently exists. Although, automatic relegation would help mitigate the current problem as gutted teams would stop appearing in leagues and the ones already in those league would eventually get filtered out in the current relegation system.
I think the reason this hasn't been solved is that it isn't an easy fix. I do agree that an increased promotion relegation system would be helpful though. I think anyone making the conference finals should be moving up (4 teams up) vs. the current 2-up structure. But, I also like the idea of earning my way by winning the conference game.
Sorry if I am straying off topic, but I think its almost universally (on these forums) supported for resold teams to move down to lower leagues no matter their record or standing at the end of the season.
Additionally I think the CPU should own the team until day 40, and run everything like the D Leagues but with real players and highly improved CPU players.
Finally, I think teams transferred to GMs should be exempt from this automatic relegation, should be too difficult, since transfer to a GM requires a manual intervention from support.
Having said all this, fixing the problem going forward doesn't fix the issue as it currently exists. Although, automatic relegation would help mitigate the current problem as gutted teams would stop appearing in leagues and the ones already in those league would eventually get filtered out in the current relegation system.
sully
offline
offline
This is something which needs to be done. Figuring out the method for doing so, however, is a different story.
tsherr
offline
offline
The real solution is, of course, to figure out ways to make the game more appealing and fun so that people don't give up on it. I'm hoping that Bort is going to do that this offseason, which will solve the problem pretty much completely.
T
T
Forbin
offline
offline
Originally posted by tsherr
The real solution is, of course, to figure out ways to make the game more appealing and fun so that people don't give up on it. I'm hoping that Bort is going to do that this offseason, which will solve the problem pretty much completely.
T
Raise the cost of buying a team so Little Johnny's mommy won't just hand him her credit card to spend $10.
The real solution is, of course, to figure out ways to make the game more appealing and fun so that people don't give up on it. I'm hoping that Bort is going to do that this offseason, which will solve the problem pretty much completely.
T
Raise the cost of buying a team so Little Johnny's mommy won't just hand him her credit card to spend $10.
SCACE
offline
offline
Originally posted by Forbin
Originally posted by tsherr
The real solution is, of course, to figure out ways to make the game more appealing and fun so that people don't give up on it. I'm hoping that Bort is going to do that this offseason, which will solve the problem pretty much completely.
T
Raise the cost of buying a team so Little Johnny's mommy won't just hand him her credit card to spend $10.
That's a failed assumption that $$$ = successful owner. I don't disagree with raising the cost of teams, as I feel they are underpriced, but I don't believe the low cost of teams is the underlying reason for bad owners, nor do I believe that kids who own teams are necessarily the problem.
Originally posted by tsherr
The real solution is, of course, to figure out ways to make the game more appealing and fun so that people don't give up on it. I'm hoping that Bort is going to do that this offseason, which will solve the problem pretty much completely.
T
Raise the cost of buying a team so Little Johnny's mommy won't just hand him her credit card to spend $10.
That's a failed assumption that $$$ = successful owner. I don't disagree with raising the cost of teams, as I feel they are underpriced, but I don't believe the low cost of teams is the underlying reason for bad owners, nor do I believe that kids who own teams are necessarily the problem.
outus
offline
offline
Originally posted by Tito716
Some people probably like beating up on 5 or 6 gutted teams a season and having an almost guaranteed playoff spot too...
Too bad. If they want easy games, they can play chutes & ladders.
Gutted and cupcake teams need to be moved OR a plan should be put in place so better owners and GMs (those who can field a competitive squad quickly) can grab these teams. Since the latter is unlikely the former is the only option.
+1 for promoting & relegating more teams.
+1 for moving sold teams down a notch. Unsure who fills the next slot, though.
Again, I think teams that are about to be sold should have their slots offered for auction to current teams in lower leagues. For example: a solid AA team can compete in AAA, but a new team with an unproven owner likely cannot. This will take some time and some handholding, so maybe just bump up the team with the highest average player value.
If I do not want my team to be promoted, I can always grab a few really low level guys to keep my average low. This is gaming the system, but also a way to say "please do not promote my team."
Just some thoughts.
Having 4-5 cupcakes in the division is no fun. Having more, especially when you can't move your team, is a bad product.
Some people probably like beating up on 5 or 6 gutted teams a season and having an almost guaranteed playoff spot too...
Too bad. If they want easy games, they can play chutes & ladders.
Gutted and cupcake teams need to be moved OR a plan should be put in place so better owners and GMs (those who can field a competitive squad quickly) can grab these teams. Since the latter is unlikely the former is the only option.
+1 for promoting & relegating more teams.
+1 for moving sold teams down a notch. Unsure who fills the next slot, though.
Again, I think teams that are about to be sold should have their slots offered for auction to current teams in lower leagues. For example: a solid AA team can compete in AAA, but a new team with an unproven owner likely cannot. This will take some time and some handholding, so maybe just bump up the team with the highest average player value.
If I do not want my team to be promoted, I can always grab a few really low level guys to keep my average low. This is gaming the system, but also a way to say "please do not promote my team."
Just some thoughts.
Having 4-5 cupcakes in the division is no fun. Having more, especially when you can't move your team, is a bad product.
Last edited Sep 8, 2008 11:24:11
ckshowtime
offline
offline
I have to say that I bought my team during season 4, I was a GM and the owner just didn't have the time anymore. We are in the BBB #9 and I have completely over-hauled the roster, and have several players committed for Season 5 that will make us more competitive. They tell me this team was in a higher league in season 3, and was dropped because they hadn't won a game in 2 years.
phthalatemagic
offline
offline
Hey Bort, could you just grunt or something so we know you at least read this? 

phthalatemagic
offline
offline
If you want to keep 6-7 cupcakes in each conference you could at least be more descriptive and rename this game Pac-10 Blitz 

You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























