User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This is some BS..INT out of bounds lost our game
Page:
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by firehazard
Originally posted by VikesRule

Originally posted by firehazard


I'm wrong? Are you kidding? Interceptions are marked as incompletions in QB statistics in real life football and the 2D view in GLB is rarely accurate. Don't be stupid.

There have been other plays that don't result in a touch back when it should have; I saw a thread around here about it a week or so ago.



Have you watched football before? Interceptions are NOT marked as "inco+mpletions" in QB statistics. There is a little category for "INT" that shows INTs.


Please tell me that you're kidding. Nope, doesn't look like you are. Seriously, know what you're talking about before opening your mouth.

As far as an "interception out of bounds" issue. Have you guys ever seen any other evidence that would lead you to believe that a receiver caught it but was out of bounds? I haven't, so I'd think that it's probably not coded that way and that the interception had to have happened in bounds.

But whatever, I guess Occam's razor doesn't apply to logic in the bugs forum.


Yes I have, I posted it about it. It is a known bug and the explanation we were given is the ball was caught out the back of the endzone.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
I did a little forum searching, the old fashioned way. This is the exact same thing. In this thread, firehazard is spouting the interceptions are incompletes, so he is no rookie to this issue. But Bort says that this play should be an incomplete. HUH!


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=891860
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
Nice research Jose!
 
kjayb51
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
I did a little forum searching, the old fashioned way. This is the exact same thing. In this thread, firehazard is spouting the interceptions are incompletes, so he is no rookie to this issue. But Bort says that this play should be an incomplete. HUH!


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=891860


Nice info..I wonder what will happen to our game. Was biggest game of our season.
 
rivergato
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=891860


And within that thread of same example:

Originally posted by Bort

I think we ran into this before - an int on the line gives you the int but not a touchback. It should just be incomplete (not an int), methinks.

I think this used to happen sometimes with passes as well, counting them as complete, so the fix is probably the same (hafta find it)


Bingo---Proof...Nice job.
Shit playcalling or not, that is a bs way to end the game and possibly a season.
Needs to be reviewed, bad bug.

 
firehazard
offline
Link
 
Yep, that's what I was referring to. INTs in the endzone don't result in a touchback as it should. Not sure how "spouting" comes into play here, but whatever floats your boat.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by firehazard
Yep, that's what I was referring to. INTs in the endzone don't result in a touchback as it should. Not sure how "spouting" comes into play here, but whatever floats your boat.


Its spouting because your factoid, be it true or nor, does not apply here. In GLB, a play is either reported via the text as incomplete, interception, or as a gain or loss. It is not reported as both an interception and incomplete. So your opinion that interceptions are incomplete is spouting. If you could show me one time where a play is reported as both interception and incomplete when the ball was not out the back or near the back of the endzone I would give your arguments some weight.

My second reason for calling it spouting is that you showed up in that thread to say your little unhelpful opinion and then never checked back on the thread. If you had, you would have seen Bort claim that they play should have been ruled incomplete. Then you would have shared that knowledge with us. No, you are not being helpful to this thread or that, so kindly take your own advice and move along.
 
Link
 
bumb for bort!!
 
Stokes36
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
Originally posted by firehazard

Yep, that's what I was referring to. INTs in the endzone don't result in a touchback as it should. Not sure how "spouting" comes into play here, but whatever floats your boat.


Its spouting because your factoid, be it true or nor, does not apply here. In GLB, a play is either reported via the text as incomplete, interception, or as a gain or loss. It is not reported as both an interception and incomplete. So your opinion that interceptions are incomplete is spouting. If you could show me one time where a play is reported as both interception and incomplete when the ball was not out the back or near the back of the endzone I would give your arguments some weight.

My second reason for calling it spouting is that you showed up in that thread to say your little unhelpful opinion and then never checked back on the thread. If you had, you would have seen Bort claim that they play should have been ruled incomplete. Then you would have shared that knowledge with us. No, you are not being helpful to this thread or that, so kindly take your own advice and move along.


JOSE JOSE JOSE!!!!

*Continues chant*
 
BP
offline
Link
 
What people don't seem to understand is that the "REPLAYS" are visual representations of a completed mathmatical sim....the dots are not playing the frickin game...the "visual" is just something to give you an idea about what occured during the play...IF A PLAY DOESN'T LOOK ON THE REPLAY LIKE THE "TEXT" REPORT OF WHAT OCCURED ON THAT PLAY DOES, IT'S BECAUSE BORTS VISUAL AID ISN'T THAT ADVANCED..BUT THE PLAY DID HAPPEN THE WAY IT'S DESCRIBED IN THE TEXT!!.

The Dots aren't diving...the dots aren't making plays...the dots aren't doing anything but just giving you something to look at that kind of represents the simulated play that has been determined by the sim engine.

Time for you less then savvy GLB users to take a step back and think outside of the cube....the game would still occur if there were no blue and yellow circles...if things don't look right on the replay, blame Bort for having a crappy code...don't say "THAT DOT WAS OUT OF BOUNDS"..lol...damn corky's...

 
Yung1King
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
What people don't seem to understand is that the "REPLAYS" are visual representations of a completed mathmatical sim....the dots are not playing the frickin game...the "visual" is just something to give you an idea about what occured during the play...IF A PLAY DOESN'T LOOK ON THE REPLAY LIKE THE "TEXT" REPORT OF WHAT OCCURED ON THAT PLAY DOES, IT'S BECAUSE BORTS VISUAL AID ISN'T THAT ADVANCED..BUT THE PLAY DID HAPPEN THE WAY IT'S DESCRIBED IN THE TEXT!!.

The Dots aren't diving...the dots aren't making plays...the dots aren't doing anything but just giving you something to look at that kind of represents the simulated play that has been determined by the sim engine.

Time for you less then savvy GLB users to take a step back and think outside of the cube....the game would still occur if there were no blue and yellow circles...if things don't look right on the replay, blame Bort for having a crappy code...don't say "THAT DOT WAS OUT OF BOUNDS"..lol...damn corky's...


but my dots are better than your dots, BP
 
kjayb51
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
What people don't seem to understand is that the "REPLAYS" are visual representations of a completed mathmatical sim....the dots are not playing the frickin game...the "visual" is just something to give you an idea about what occured during the play...IF A PLAY DOESN'T LOOK ON THE REPLAY LIKE THE "TEXT" REPORT OF WHAT OCCURED ON THAT PLAY DOES, IT'S BECAUSE BORTS VISUAL AID ISN'T THAT ADVANCED..BUT THE PLAY DID HAPPEN THE WAY IT'S DESCRIBED IN THE TEXT!!.

The Dots aren't diving...the dots aren't making plays...the dots aren't doing anything but just giving you something to look at that kind of represents the simulated play that has been determined by the sim engine.

Time for you less then savvy GLB users to take a step back and think outside of the cube....the game would still occur if there were no blue and yellow circles...if things don't look right on the replay, blame Bort for having a crappy code...don't say "THAT DOT WAS OUT OF BOUNDS"..lol...damn corky's...



This has nothing to do with replays. READ THE SUMMARY OF THE PLAY!
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kjayb51
Originally posted by BP

What people don't seem to understand is that the "REPLAYS" are visual representations of a completed mathmatical sim....the dots are not playing the frickin game...the "visual" is just something to give you an idea about what occured during the play...IF A PLAY DOESN'T LOOK ON THE REPLAY LIKE THE "TEXT" REPORT OF WHAT OCCURED ON THAT PLAY DOES, IT'S BECAUSE BORTS VISUAL AID ISN'T THAT ADVANCED..BUT THE PLAY DID HAPPEN THE WAY IT'S DESCRIBED IN THE TEXT!!.

The Dots aren't diving...the dots aren't making plays...the dots aren't doing anything but just giving you something to look at that kind of represents the simulated play that has been determined by the sim engine.

Time for you less then savvy GLB users to take a step back and think outside of the cube....the game would still occur if there were no blue and yellow circles...if things don't look right on the replay, blame Bort for having a crappy code...don't say "THAT DOT WAS OUT OF BOUNDS"..lol...damn corky's...



This has nothing to do with replays. READ THE SUMMARY OF THE PLAY!


Your point is that interceptions aren't counted as incomplete passes and because it was intercepted it should have said "incomplete" right? Maybe that is a bug....maybe the bug is the "imcompleted" part and not the interception part..the interception part does come first...lol. I dunno..maybe you have a point, the text description does look wrong..so my little rant didn't hit the mark on your argument..my bad...but it's still a valid argument...

The bug that interceptions aren't counted as incomplete passes is the issue here..but there maybe something wrong with the code...you are right
Last edited Sep 1, 2008 16:57:22
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yung1King
Originally posted by BP

What people don't seem to understand is that the "REPLAYS" are visual representations of a completed mathmatical sim....the dots are not playing the frickin game...the "visual" is just something to give you an idea about what occured during the play...IF A PLAY DOESN'T LOOK ON THE REPLAY LIKE THE "TEXT" REPORT OF WHAT OCCURED ON THAT PLAY DOES, IT'S BECAUSE BORTS VISUAL AID ISN'T THAT ADVANCED..BUT THE PLAY DID HAPPEN THE WAY IT'S DESCRIBED IN THE TEXT!!.

The Dots aren't diving...the dots aren't making plays...the dots aren't doing anything but just giving you something to look at that kind of represents the simulated play that has been determined by the sim engine.

Time for you less then savvy GLB users to take a step back and think outside of the cube....the game would still occur if there were no blue and yellow circles...if things don't look right on the replay, blame Bort for having a crappy code...don't say "THAT DOT WAS OUT OF BOUNDS"..lol...damn corky's...


but my dots are better than your dots, BP



Legacy..lol..you should know by now that my dots aren't the best at GLB..but they certainly seem to own YOU!!
 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kjayb51
Yea Im waiting to see what Bort say about this...


He's answered it before...acknowledged it was a bug, but hadn't yet tracked it down. This is actually the 3rd of 4th time I've seen it reported.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.