User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Using teams as "growth vats" for a single individual player
Page:
 
Hampe
offline
Link
 
Harper is a Belichick fan.....seriously, what did you guys expect?
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
I'm pretty sure that in the world of football the 'win at any cost' mentality is pretty prevalent, so you could imagine that's somewhat realistic.

But in any case, this isn't an accurate simulation. It's a good approximation of one, but it's still going to differ from the real thing. If you want an accurate experience of the game, go play/coach football for real.


Fully agree - and this is where the disparity comes in.

I KNOW that this game isn't realistic - especially in it's current form. But when you roll out ideas like respecs to enable GAME PLAYERS to keep up with the constant changes, then the defence is that they should have built the player 'realistically'.

And the thing is, a lot of those who bang on about realistic builds are also the ones that go along the exploitation route too.

As I say - either this is a game, or it's a simulation. In either case, we (the players) need a set of OFFICIAL guides that allow us to know how to 'play' the game (ie build players) and we need to know that the 'rules' or 'spirit' of the game applies to everyone - and those rules need to be made obvious as to what is, and what isn't allowed.

At the moment, we've got a vague thing that says 'no cheating' and that's pretty much it. The definition of cheating varies too much for my liking..........

Two teams?? Depends who you are.

Two accounts?? Depends who you are.

Bought an account and want to merge it? Depends who you are.

Exploiting a potential bug instead of reporting it? Depends who you are.

But it's not just me who's seeing these things - plenty of new players are too. And I'd imagine that there'll be plenty who'll just jump on the bandwagon and think that exploiting the game is the way to go.

I simply don't see how that's good for anyone in the long run??
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Vando, you are a polite and respectful poster.

I must express incredulity at your estimate that there would be little demand for "clown" teams.

At any given moment there are, what, about 20 or more players for each team in existence? Each and every one of those players wants to be the best in the world. So each and every one of those players (excepting only the team owner who already owns his 1 allowable team) has every motivation to get on the owner waiting list, get a team, and start gaining extra levels by manipulating the game to his benefit.

I completely believe that as many as 50% on the current waiting list intend to use their team for this purpose.
 
Intimnasc
offline
Link
 
Theres always the assholes that look for an exploit to gain that little edge at everyones expense. They used to have a Mod that did that too but now he's not a Mod anymore and not leading by example, maybe they can start getting the players that look for exploits in line.


edit::Content was inaccurate and made no sense in the wording.
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 05:56:12
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Vando, you are a polite and respectful poster.

I must express incredulity at your estimate that there would be little demand for "clown" teams.

At any given moment there are, what, about 20 or more players for each team in existence? Each and every one of those players wants to be the best in the world. So each and every one of those players (excepting only the team owner who already owns his 1 allowable team) has every motivation to get on the owner waiting list, get a team, and start gaining extra levels by manipulating the game to his benefit.

I completely believe that as many as 50% on the current waiting list intend to use their team for this purpose.


But each team used in this way can accommodate 30+ players. They don't each need a team to do it.
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
I KNOW that this game isn't realistic - especially in it's current form. But when you roll out ideas like respecs to enable GAME PLAYERS to keep up with the constant changes, then the defence is that they should have built the player 'realistically'.

And the thing is, a lot of those who bang on about realistic builds are also the ones that go along the exploitation route too.


Actually, I'd be inclined to say that the opposite is true. The players that want respecs are the ones that have exploited to the maximum degree a slight foible in the match engine (uber speed players, for example). All along Bort has said that his intention is for people to, for the most part, build players in a somewhat balanced manner. I don't know about 'realistic', but definitely balanced.
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
Originally posted by didymus

Vando, you are a polite and respectful poster.

I must express incredulity at your estimate that there would be little demand for "clown" teams.

At any given moment there are, what, about 20 or more players for each team in existence? Each and every one of those players wants to be the best in the world. So each and every one of those players (excepting only the team owner who already owns his 1 allowable team) has every motivation to get on the owner waiting list, get a team, and start gaining extra levels by manipulating the game to his benefit.

I completely believe that as many as 50% on the current waiting list intend to use their team for this purpose.


But each team used in this way can accommodate 30+ players. They don't each need a team to do it.


It's my understanding that the primary XP cheat is to have players kick and punt, as well as play O and D. I have seen comments that say non-kickers can't be put in those slots anymore, but I've seen others saying that nearly 1000 xp per game can be gleaned from doing just that.

 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Originally posted by Vando

Originally posted by didymus


Vando, you are a polite and respectful poster.

I must express incredulity at your estimate that there would be little demand for "clown" teams.

At any given moment there are, what, about 20 or more players for each team in existence? Each and every one of those players wants to be the best in the world. So each and every one of those players (excepting only the team owner who already owns his 1 allowable team) has every motivation to get on the owner waiting list, get a team, and start gaining extra levels by manipulating the game to his benefit.

I completely believe that as many as 50% on the current waiting list intend to use their team for this purpose.


But each team used in this way can accommodate 30+ players. They don't each need a team to do it.


It's my understanding that the primary XP cheat is to have players kick and punt, as well as play O and D. I have seen comments that say non-kickers can't be put in those slots anymore, but I've seen others saying that nearly 1000 xp per game can be gleaned from doing just that.



If true, it should be fixed by capping the xp in a more sensible way for kickers and punters, and not allowing any bonuses associated with the position for non-specialists in these roles.

If not true, then there really isn't the need for this whole argument.
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Also this thread has kind of derailed onto the 'are farm teams fair?', which there is already a thread for. Probably best to stick to the K/P issue in this thread.
 
Tim Harper
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Originally posted by Tim Harper

As for pointing the finger at moderators and alpha testers, that can be considered harrassment and slander especially since it is such a general statement.


Slander is actually the spoken word, so you actually mean libel - if you want to get pedantic, at least be accurate.

However - for either to be true, then the accusations would need to be false. As it stands, they aren't.

You were responsible for more loopholes being closed than perhaps anyone, not because you reported everything, but because you were caught by other regular players who then reported it (shame the search function doesn't work, because I'm sure the links to the threads would be pages long).

Your answer was always the same - 'It wasn't illegal when I did it' - like that was some sort of excuse.

Serenity admitted having two accounts - so another true fact there.

And if this practice has being going on since alpha, it doesn't make it right - in fact, it begs the question as to what the f**k the alpha testers were actually 'testing' - if not just ways to give themselves an unfair advantage.

What happened to the spirit of the game??

Legal or not, all of these actions break what I'd imagine most people see as the 'sprit of the game'

You keep trying to get me to quit, because I ask for the bugs and loopholes in the game to be fixed (you want harrassment Harper - now THAT constitutes harrassment) - I can see now why you're so keen on that - because despite everything, you still think that these sorts of things are OK.

Win at any cost is NOT the way I like to do things..........

Anyway - if that's the way people want to play, then that's up to them, but you can't have it both ways.

Realistic simulation, or exploitable game??


Libel is spoken word as well, just spoken over some sort of media outlet which reaches more people. They are both considered a form of slander, once again you lose.

As for loopholes, outside of my farm team name a loophole that I exposed. That is right you can't, because your slandering my name again with nothing to back it. I never gutted money, I never played players out of their positions, I never took "loans" from other teams to pump my stadium to the maximum like other owners have done, I never misled any players in any sort of sign and trades, I never kept players hostage against their will. I dare you to find something outside of my farm team and moving of 7 players that I have done wrong. Even the moving and practice of a farm team in season one wasn't illegal. You can talk about that one all you want, Bort said it was legal and it was covered in the rules at one time. So, once again your slandering my name.

As for Serenity using two accounts, multiple accounts are illegal. But, she didn't run a team, gm a team or have a player on it. So once again, your pulling at straws with that accusation.

As for why the K/P issue wasn't fixed, no clue there. It has/was reported numerous times.

As for what constitutes "the spirit of the game", no one knows that. What I think is within the spirit may not be for someone else. I see no rules for it up anyway, so I believe that is up to the admins for interpretation. So until I start seeing the admins make a stand against these people that are against "the spirit of the game" I am going to assume some of the practices being done like farm teams are legal. So if that is the case, your argument holds no water once again.

 
Tim Harper
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
You keep trying to get me to quit, because I ask for the bugs and loopholes in the game to be fixed (you want harrassment Harper - now THAT constitutes harrassment) - I can see now why you're so keen on that - because despite everything, you still think that these sorts of things are OK.

Win at any cost is NOT the way I like to do things..........

Anyway - if that's the way people want to play, then that's up to them, but you can't have it both ways.

Realistic simulation, or exploitable game?


I forgot to add something.....

I don't need to try to get you to quit the game, you have already said numerous times your done spending money on the game. Oh and here is a quote for reinforcement on that issue.

Originally posted by 1VBChaos

Do you spend money on flex points? Not anymore

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=921465&page=3
There is the link to customer questionnaire just posted this morning.

Like I said, your a total tool.

+1 Tim Harper
+0 Chaos

Edit: Another one I found.

Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Too much!! Must be well over $100 but that's me done spending money


Last edited Aug 29, 2008 06:57:54
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
"Libel is spoken word as well, just spoken over some sort of media outlet which reaches more people. They are both considered a form of slander, once again you lose."

If you want a pissing contest Harper, please do it over another topic - preferably one you know something about. May I suggest 'How to cheat at online games', seeing as it seems to be a specialist subject matter :

"If the offending material is published in some fleeting form, as by spoken words or sounds, sign language, gestures and the like, then this is slander. If it is published in more durable form, for example in written words, film, compact disc (CD), DVD, blogging and the like, then it is considered libel"

As for me spending money - I make no bones about the fact that I won't be spending any more - so what?? I'm probably just like quite a number of players who've come to realise that, without the right contacts, we seem to be just making up the numbers so people like you can pretty much run roughshod over the entire game at will.

You'd think that losing your moderator status and being perhaps the most universally disliked person on GLB would have kept you quiet, but it seems your ego over compensates for your complete lack of class.
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
If teams costed more, it would discourage people from purchasing farm teams, and using teams as growth vats.

At the moment, 1000 Flex is nothing...A QB with 3 boosts costs more.
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Yay, semantics!

May I, without further ceremony, invite the pair of you to shut up because it doesn't matter?
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
If teams costed more, it would discourage people from purchasing farm teams, and using teams as growth vats.

At the moment, 1000 Flex is nothing...A QB with 3 boosts costs more.


Unfortunately it would also discourage other players from purchasing teams. And to reiterate: Bort has said there is nothing wrong with farm teams from his perspective.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.