User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
GmanV2
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I'll get this rolling this evening.
 
countsnake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tareton
<--- 3000+ yards and 70 TD's

What were you saying about MVP again?!?



I went game by game you had a couple of those idiot 330 yard 7 TD games to a much weaker team one of the teams was all level 4 your whole team was level 12 or higher.it's not your fault you play who ever is put in front of you. But come on stats don't mean that much. i saw a DE get 31 sacks in one game and finish the year with 39 should he be a defensive MVP.
 
jmorgalis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by countsnake
Originally posted by Tareton

<--- 3000+ yards and 70 TD's

What were you saying about MVP again?!?



I went game by game you had a couple of those idiot 330 yard 7 TD games to a much weaker team one of the teams was all level 4 your whole team was level 12 or higher.it's not your fault you play who ever is put in front of you. But come on stats don't mean that much. i saw a DE get 31 sacks in one game and finish the year with 39 should he be a defensive MVP.


The point of this being? Tell me the MVP candidate that _didn't_ beat up on some weak sisters along the way? Seriously, take a look at the candidates and tell me there is a better candidate, no matter how "inflated" the stats seem. The reality is, we all played the same people give or take. It's not like Hermann threw up 1000 yards on a single opponent with 25 TDs. It's not like Reese had 31 sacks against one opponent like you reference. These guys did it week in and week out and were consistent through the season. Hell Hermann only got 342 of our team's 786 carries. We had a 1700 yard 24 TD back and a 700 yard 6 TD back as well. For the math impaired among you, that's only 43.5% of the team's carries. Hell what would he have done if we actually featured him as much as we should have?

I can buy good logical arguments back and forth on the legitimacy of these candidates, but let's not get into stat bashing because every single nominee here has had the opportunity to play weaker teams, and has scored big stats while doing it. If they didn't, well they probably aren't that good anyway, beacuse there is no way to really stop running up the score on a team you outclass.

/rant. Basically, vote for Hermann and Reese.
 
Tareton
offline
Link
 
Yeah 330 is my high for a single game but if you want to get nitpicky that is roughly half of what some other candidates put up against the same outclassed opponents.

For sake of your arguement there were other backs in the league that put up over 450 yards in a game. Never once did I pad it like that. Furthermore, one of those 320 yard performances was only on 16 carries. 20 YPC is pretty impressive.

It's all about consistency and when you average over 4 TD's a game and almost 200 yards I would say you are consistent.
 
countsnake
offline
Link
 
how was your stat line aganist the best team you faced all year 10 carries for 31 yds.
 
jmorgalis
offline
Link
 
well i am sure that the 10 carries had a bit to do with that.
 
Guppy, Inc
online
Link
 
defense is the hard one to vote for. Sometimes the best players get no stats due to position or teams avoid that area of the field completely. I always see CBs brag about their number of tackles. One guy was bragging about his 14 tackles so I posted that the other team completed half their total passes and 2/3 of the yards to the WRs he was supposedly guarding. Give me the CB that the other team only tries 3 passes against and he deflects 2 and gives up 1 completion.
 
Tareton
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by countsnake
how was your stat line aganist the best team you faced all year 10 carries for 31 yds.


Kade Dunco, another MVP candidate, same game, 10 carries for 45 yards.

I would say when 2 of the very top teams in our league go up against one another it is tough to run the ball for both sides.

Against the #2 seed in Alpha = 22 carries 108 yds 4 rec 18 yds 3 TD
Against #4 = 31 carries 225yds 3 TD

So are you saying that one game against the only undefeated team in the league where neither featured back from either team was able to run the ball is enough to not award a player an MVP?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jmac1727
Medellin nominations

Offense Marion the Barbarion
Defense Norton Williams

these are the nom. from my team although I don't expect them to win. haha


thanks for the shout out, not in real running for the competition but nice to be mentioned at least. and i'll do my best to prove that week 3 was no fluke!
 
thomdunco32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tareton
Originally posted by countsnake

how was your stat line aganist the best team you faced all year 10 carries for 31 yds.


Kade Dunco, another MVP candidate, same game, 10 carries for 45 yards.


In this game against you when I had the 10 carries for 45 yards I also had two 80+ yard kick return touchdowns and was the player of the game. Maybe I got a little tired from those runs.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=119625
Last edited Sep 3, 2008 07:56:00
 
Tareton
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thomdunco32
Originally posted by Tareton

Originally posted by countsnake


how was your stat line aganist the best team you faced all year 10 carries for 31 yds.


Kade Dunco, another MVP candidate, same game, 10 carries for 45 yards.


In this game against you when I had the 10 carries for 45 yards I also had two 80+ yard kick return touchdowns and was the player of the game. Maybe I got a little tired from those runs.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=119625


Wasn't a shot at ya bro. But by snakes definition we shouldn't consider the rest of your season because of your 45 yd performance. More of a comparison.

 
jmorgalis
offline
Link
 
Basically I think the point of this is that no one ran on the Bushmasters, so using that game as reasoning for or against an MVP is like using the Santiago game as proof why they SHOULD be MVP.

Pointless. In any statistical analysis, the value of outliers should be diminished. I thikn Hermann's body of work stands up quite well to every other back in the league, especially when you consider the 43.5% number.

NO MORE KRTDs FOR DUNCO!
 
drewsky
offline
Link
 
I don't know, I am more of a Stuckey Adams fan myself. He has 3281 rushing yards compared to Hermann's 3076. And, sure, a lot of that could be because he has great blockers. But he also has 229 broken tackles compared to Hermann's 213, which is all due to the Stuckey and has nothing to do with the O-line. Stuckey shared carries with Kade Dunco who is a TD hawk, otherwise he would be a lock for MVP. Stuckey's worst game was 90.5 yards rushing 0 TD's and his best game was 450 yards and 8 TD's; both are better than Hermann's best and worst.

Hell, the only way I see that Hermann is more of an MVP than Stuckey is that without Hermann the RHCP would have lost more games. BBB would have still had Kade Dunco running the ball and our record would have been identical.
 
drewsky
offline
Link
 
I also like our fullbacks, Human Shield, who prolly made more blocks 5 yards past the line of scrimmage then the rest of the fullbacks in the league combined, and Wolfwood Peng, who plays every position on the offense and special teams well.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by drewsky

Hell, the only way I see that Hermann is more of an MVP than Stuckey is that without Hermann the RHCP would have lost more games. BBB would have still had Kade Dunco running the ball and our record would have been identical.


which brings up a point about mvp's that not even professionals can agree on.. is it the most valuable player award, or is it the best offensive player on the best team award.
Last edited Sep 3, 2008 09:18:33
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.