User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
Seeing as this wont get implemented I wont bother posting any further, but I totally disagree with giving XP based on playing time.. it is already bad enough as it is now.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by drifter



Originally posted by turnerhero




Originally posted by Snakebite99





I think he means 600 XP at prestige level 1, 520 (or whatever) at level 2, so on and so forth, like regular XP we gain now. I really like this idea. I dont know how easy it would be to program, but Bort's pretty much a genius, so im sure he can figure it out


In my opinion, I like the overall idea very much, but the exp gain should be the same as originally thought of, such as the above, but each lvl of prestige or whatever should take twice as much to hit the next level as normal player lvling, just so it doesn't have a cascade effect of a player reaching around lvl 50 or so and each one lvls so horribly slow it's to the point of wanting to pull your hair out.

I'm not sure if this made any sense...I haven't fully absorbed the idea yet...hehe


Are you saying that the XP gain should be based on the original chart but that you Prestige level at 2000, 4000, 6000, etc?


If he is, I'd disagree with him. But perhaps partially to address his concerns and partially to address TreMetal's, prestige exp from playing could be halved but from training could be doubled-- so that playing time still matters, but less, and leveling is slowed, but not slowed by half?


I'm not convinced that it needs to be slowed. Without being able to boost the Prestige Level, a player who hit level 31 in their 4th season, would probably just about get to Prestige Level 35 or so by the time they hit the 10 year decline mark. That's 175 Prestige Points. If they had poured all of that into raising only one specific soft cap, I think that would put their soft cap in that one skill at about 70. I don't think that's too bad considering they would have had to sacrifice all other Prestige development to do it.


I'm not fully convinced it needs to be slowed, either; but, how about the general thought of having it less dependent on game exp and more on training? Maybe halve the game exp and triple the amount from training, so it's somewhere near as fast but less dependent on whether you get lots of playing time?

Maybe even make prestige exp more dependent on the type of training as well, with game exp halved? (Relaxed = 2 * normal training exp, Normal = 3 * normal training exp, Intense = 4 * normal training exp?)



Let's not talk about training. These Prestige Points should not be able to be trained - they are purely from levelling up. Now if you are talking more based on daily XP than game XP, maybe. I was trying to keep implementation as simple as possible by using the same XP table that is in existence. If it would be just as easy to modify the table to give moe daily and less game Prestige XP and it made sense, then I don't have an issue with it.
 
hoyaboy1
offline
Link
 
Great idea. There needs to be much more differentiation at high levels and this seems like a good way to achieve that.
 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal
Seeing as this wont get implemented I wont bother posting any further, but I totally disagree with giving XP based on playing time.. it is already bad enough as it is now.


if you are a back-up and aren't happy with your playing time, ask for a trade to a team that needs starters. There are PLENTY of teams that need starters.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dannyg28
Originally posted by TreMetal

Seeing as this wont get implemented I wont bother posting any further, but I totally disagree with giving XP based on playing time.. it is already bad enough as it is now.


if you are a back-up and aren't happy with your playing time, ask for a trade to a team that needs starters. There are PLENTY of teams that need starters.


Exactly. The game needs some pressures to shake teams up and make guys want to go looking for a better gig.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I like the idea in general, would need a lot more fleshing out as far as skills per position, etc go. I think it makes more sense to approach the idea as "veteran skills" instead of "prestige skills" since that's basically what you're talking about - the guy gets to a high enough level and he opens up a whole new tree of abilities.

I'm not sure about the "cap raising" ones. I worry that they might be too powerful and give you no reason to go for anything else.

Some of the skills listed kinda remind me of the perks in Fallout, which isn't necessarily a bad thing. Hmm...that might be kinda neat too, as in you get to choose a couple "perks" when you create your guy...but that's a different thread.
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dannyg28
if you are a back-up and aren't happy with your playing time, ask for a trade to a team that needs starters. There are PLENTY of teams that need starters.


Incoming circular argument..
What if your owner wont trade you?
What if you do not want to play on a team in a shitty league?
What if you do not want to play on a shitty team?
 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal
Originally posted by Dannyg28

if you are a back-up and aren't happy with your playing time, ask for a trade to a team that needs starters. There are PLENTY of teams that need starters.


Incoming circular argument..
What if your owner wont trade you?
What if you do not want to play on a team in a shitty league?
What if you do not want to play on a shitty team?


1. Then you are SOL
2 and 3. Then stop complaining about not getting enough exp.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I like the idea in general, would need a lot more fleshing out as far as skills per position, etc go. I think it makes more sense to approach the idea as "veteran skills" instead of "prestige skills" since that's basically what you're talking about - the guy gets to a high enough level and he opens up a whole new tree of abilities.

I'm not sure about the "cap raising" ones. I worry that they might be too powerful and give you no reason to go for anything else.

Some of the skills listed kinda remind me of the perks in Fallout, which isn't necessarily a bad thing. Hmm...that might be kinda neat too, as in you get to choose a couple "perks" when you create your guy...but that's a different thread.


Ken has talked about the Fallout Perks system for some time now as an alternative and that definitely is what I had in mind.

The cap raising ones can just be made more expensive if you think they need to be. I think they're a good addition. As I pointed out, by the time the player hits season 10 he would have had to focuse ALL of his prestige points (or veteran points) into one soft cap just to get it to around 70. That's a big sacrifice and if he wants to do it, more power to him.

Finally - Try and avoid "position perks". Make all prestige (or veteran) skills available to all positions. Also, later in the thread, if you didn't see it, I suggested another set that would reduce the position penalty for playing any given position. One "perk" for every position.
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
Luckily for me, I do not give a shit about your opinion and I will still state mine.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dannyg28
Originally posted by TreMetal

Originally posted by Dannyg28


if you are a back-up and aren't happy with your playing time, ask for a trade to a team that needs starters. There are PLENTY of teams that need starters.


Incoming circular argument..
What if your owner wont trade you?
What if you do not want to play on a team in a shitty league?
What if you do not want to play on a shitty team?


1. Then you are SOL
2 and 3. Then stop complaining about not getting enough exp.


Exactly. Look at Matt Hasselbeck. He could have stayed on the Packers and been a backup to Favre his whole career at the expense of playing for a good team or he could strike out for Seattle, who at the time was not very good and get a chance to start and grow a team from being crappy to being a Super Bowl contender.
 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal
Luckily for me, I do not give a shit about your opinion and I will still state mine.


At this point in the game if you are not happy with your playing time there is practically no reason to not be able to get more playing time on another team. If you don't want to play on a crappy team or in a crappy league then those are decisions you are making that has nothing to do with the game, as there are ways to get more playing time.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Finally - Try and avoid "position perks". Make all prestige (or veteran) skills available to all positions.


That would certainly make it easier to come up with the list of abilities.

Originally posted by drifter
Also, later in the thread, if you didn't see it, I suggested another set that would reduce the position penalty for playing any given position. One "perk" for every position.


Didn't see that - good idea.
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter

Exactly. Look at Matt Hasselbeck. He could have stayed on the Packers and been a backup to Favre his whole career at the expense of playing for a good team or he could strike out for Seattle, who at the time was not very good and get a chance to start and grow a team from being crappy to being a Super Bowl contender.


Matt Hasselback is not earning experience points based on how often he enter the game either.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I like the idea in general, would need a lot more fleshing out as far as skills per position, etc go. I think it makes more sense to approach the idea as "veteran skills" instead of "prestige skills" since that's basically what you're talking about - the guy gets to a high enough level and he opens up a whole new tree of abilities.

I'm not sure about the "cap raising" ones. I worry that they might be too powerful and give you no reason to go for anything else.

Some of the skills listed kinda remind me of the perks in Fallout, which isn't necessarily a bad thing. Hmm...that might be kinda neat too, as in you get to choose a couple "perks" when you create your guy...but that's a different thread.


I like some ability to cap-raise, but maybe limit the cap-raising ones even more, so the first point of a cap raiser cost 4 VP's (veteran points), the second point for the same one cost 8 VP's, up 4 VP's every time. So few people would raise a cap more than 2 or 3 points, as the 4th point would take 3 levels plus to get one point (likely a better investment just to pay the extra SP's for the skill).

But with or without cap raisers, I also prefer at least an emphasis on what would amount to a different form of SA. And I'm thrilled that you're willing to consider them, as I wondered if this was possible.

I'd urge that once you get the Elusive bug fixed that between this and the daily planner/personality system, you move toward more player customization as the top priority. That's especially important for player-only agents.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.