User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
dusk883
Zone Monster
offline
Link
 
I agree with the notion that DTs should be 100 Flexers. Regardless of whether there is change coming for them or not.But certainly if things are to remain the same for them.
 
SoCalWhoDat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dusk883
I agree with the notion that DTs should be 100 Flexers. Regardless of whether there is change coming for them or not.But certainly if things are to remain the same for them.


Exactly. I certainly don't have a problem with, and sometimes enjoy, just being the big space-eater while my DE brethren and DT counterpart get sacks and hurries while I'm at NT. But when it comes time to boost I do feel a little ripped on it b/c in all honesty, NT is a non-glamor position.

I've also really only noticed the downfall in "production" to be amongst NTs primarily. I still see, and have had some success personally, playing from the DT position this season. That level 26 getting smacked around in that replay by the level 6 is my NT. The Center had his build open and I can guarantee you he didn't have diddly-poo that would allow him to throw around a solidly built NT like that.

The coasting issue is perhaps what caused that particular issue in that game, but I've seen the exact same animations occur in games that were not total blowouts but there was still a level difference between the NT and C/G combo. This may be explained away as the animations not reflecting what really happens, which I can understand.

I do appreciate the fact that offensive numbers are more realistic this season, but I feel the NT got the short end of the stick with some of the compromises made. I just don't think it's outside the realm of possibilities, what with all the other pathing/calculations bugs this season, that something may be amiss in the trenches. Not knocking anyone who doesn't see it that way, but I do think it's well within reasonable thinking for me to make that assumption based on what I've seen so far.
Last edited Aug 27, 2008 09:31:07
 
Troymk1
offline
Link
 
My suggestion to Bort was to increase holding calls (penalities ) on the offense. Would explain these obscene blocks
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Troymk1
My suggestion to Bort was to increase holding calls (penalities ) on the offense. Would explain these obscene blocks


Except that the current penalty system has nothing to do with what actually happens on a play and everything to do with attributes + randomness. I don't think the code is sound enough for penalties on the play yet, which is why we don't have them. I know Bort was having a tough time with pass interference, which would have to happen during the play. The same would be true for holding.

He has already scaled back the ability to hold a block for the obscene length of time that was happening throughout the first half of the season.

I think it really depends on the build though. If I look at my team, a 12-1 club in Oceania AAA#1, the DT's are as follows:

Starting DT: 27 tackles, 3 hurries, 0 sacks
Backup DT: 58 tackles, 15 hurries, 6 sacks

Starting NT: 27 tackles, 5 hurries, 1 sack
Backup NT: 44 tackles, 3 hurries, 0 sacks

As you can see, one build has been far more effective while the other 3 have been pretty even.
 
mogs01gt
offline
Link
 
but the backup players are usually playing the second stringers more than the starters are.
 
shylock
offline
Link
 
allowing the NT to dominate (based upon a significantly higher level and stats) basically wrecks the offense, causing too many glamour positions to complain... downgrading the capability of the NT only hurts half the population of DT, being a normal position anyway and that just might be acceptable to them... it really doesn't matter how much stronger, faster or great tackler you are at NT, they will handle you one on one, two on one and the HB will break a good amount of your tackles to add insult to injury... i'd say that is less than non-glamour... let's see some justice here
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
I would like to see some specials that WORKED.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SmithersOT
I would like to see some specials that WORKED.


DT specials work fine
 
Faux Bear
offline
Link
 
my guy hasn't had any problems.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84048&pbp_id=6786195

I should say most of his sacks have come from the DT position, but in the last few games he's gone back to his natural NT position and done ok, including this sack here against a lvl 30 guard and 29 center.
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by SmithersOT

I would like to see some specials that WORKED.


DT specials work fine



Do they? Let's review:

The Glare: Lowers a QB's "morale" by some unknown and unknowable amount. Since QB's have high confidence to start with, this particular skill isn't doing a damn thing. The main function of this skill is to raise the cost of the others that follow it. Pointless.

Shed Block: This is one of the few DT skills that might work, but then no one knows for sure since DT's aren't regularly shedding blocks. None the less, let's list this skill as "working."

Swat Ball: Dt's, whether they have this skill or not, are NOT swatting balls. Period.

Strong Base: In theory this skill allows the DT to push blockers out of the way. Since DT's are NOT puching blockers anywhere I think we can safely say this skill belongs in the worthless group. Broken.

Big Sack: If you sack the same QB a bunch of times in the same game this skill will lower their morale. You also risk causing a fumble, which will magically leap into the nearest offensive players hands and allow him the chance to turn a sack for a loss into a gain. Exciting stuff there. In any case, this is irrelevant. DT's rarely get sacks unless they grossly outlevel the other teams line. Pointless.

Wall: In theory this makes you harder to push back. In practice, not so much. Again, the main purpose of this skill is to make your other pointless skills more expensive. Broken.

Break Through: Not actually a special move at all. This skill increases your almost non-existant chance to break a double team block by some miniscule amount. DT's are not regularly breaking single team blocks, let alone double team blocks. Working very poorly.

Snarl: If you happen to get a bunch of tackles in a single game against the same guy, snarl will lower his morale and make him easier to tackle. Since this doesn't actually HAPPEN in GLB, this skills main purpose is to make other skills cost more. If they didn't have to no one would put a point in this. Silly.

Big Hit: Big waste is what this should have been called. Increases your chances of causing a fumble IF you happen to tackle the same guy repeatedly. Like that's gonna happen. Pointless.

D-Line General: No one actually knows if this does anything at all. There's no way to tell. Certainly there is nothing "special" about the ability. Let's go ahead and list this one as well under worthless.

 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Faux Bear
my guy hasn't had any problems.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=84048&pbp_id=6786195

I should say most of his sacks have come from the DT position, but in the last few games he's gone back to his natural NT position and done ok, including this sack here against a lvl 30 guard and 29 center.


Okay, so what's your secret then?
 
Steeeve
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SmithersOT
Originally posted by Robbnva

Originally posted by SmithersOT


I would like to see some specials that WORKED.


DT specials work fine



Do they? Let's review:

The Glare: Lowers a QB's "morale" by some unknown and unknowable amount. Since QB's have high confidence to start with, this particular skill isn't doing a damn thing. The main function of this skill is to raise the cost of the others that follow it. Pointless.

Shed Block: This is one of the few DT skills that might work, but then no one knows for sure since DT's aren't regularly shedding blocks. None the less, let's list this skill as "working."

Swat Ball: Dt's, whether they have this skill or not, are NOT swatting balls. Period.

Strong Base: In theory this skill allows the DT to push blockers out of the way. Since DT's are NOT puching blockers anywhere I think we can safely say this skill belongs in the worthless group. Broken.

Big Sack: If you sack the same QB a bunch of times in the same game this skill will lower their morale. You also risk causing a fumble, which will magically leap into the nearest offensive players hands and allow him the chance to turn a sack for a loss into a gain. Exciting stuff there. In any case, this is irrelevant. DT's rarely get sacks unless they grossly outlevel the other teams line. Pointless.

Wall: In theory this makes you harder to push back. In practice, not so much. Again, the main purpose of this skill is to make your other pointless skills more expensive. Broken.

Break Through: Not actually a special move at all. This skill increases your almost non-existant chance to break a double team block by some miniscule amount. DT's are not regularly breaking single team blocks, let alone double team blocks. Working very poorly.

Snarl: If you happen to get a bunch of tackles in a single game against the same guy, snarl will lower his morale and make him easier to tackle. Since this doesn't actually HAPPEN in GLB, this skills main purpose is to make other skills cost more. If they didn't have to no one would put a point in this. Silly.

Big Hit: Big waste is what this should have been called. Increases your chances of causing a fumble IF you happen to tackle the same guy repeatedly. Like that's gonna happen. Pointless.

D-Line General: No one actually knows if this does anything at all. There's no way to tell. Certainly there is nothing "special" about the ability. Let's go ahead and list this one as well under worthless.



+100

Give me one reason why a DT with 82 strength shouldnt be destroying an OG with 48 strength, regardless of other attributes.

Broke.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
I disagree on D-Line General it definately helps. Otherwise the rest are crap, except maybe shed block, I have seen it work a few times, but usually theres a second blocker that picks me up right away.
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EagleOtto
I disagree on D-Line General it definately helps.


How do you know? Do you, for example, have two NT's -- one with and one without -- who alternate plays while the other linemen stay in?


 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mogs01gt
but the backup players are usually playing the second stringers more than the starters are.


My player who has the best stats was starting at NT when he racked up about half of them. And we rotate evenly all game, so the backups aren't playing only when the backups come in.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.