User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Remove Teams from Sandbagging Owners
Page:
 
bamaplaya1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by msupoke
The schedule clearly showed who was up next. All of the players could have played on relaxed, and there could have been a ton of substituting done to preserve energy.


they haven't been so Fg happy. That k was just made and then they did this
Last edited Aug 22, 2008 11:01:32
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AirMcMVP
Originally posted by rbedgood


All that needs to be done to fix it, is lower the max XP for kickers. Sure they gain XP faster because they are in less plays. So it's simple max them out at about the same number and the motivation for doing this is gone. The bug isn't being able to put your kicker anywhere...its being rewarded for doing so.


I would contend that it is a bug that a kicker can gain 4 levels in a game. Therefore, exploiting this bug is an attempt to cheat and should be dealt with accordingly.


If that is the case you could make an argument that "slow-build" teams are doing the same thing on a different scale. (oops I attacked a larger group here comes trouble )...but seriously I don't think the guy needs to be punished, lets close the loophole, remove his motivation and he'll stop.
Last edited Aug 22, 2008 11:00:18
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
While I'm here:
-No threads about how people's teams should be taken away.
 
Statbase
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Yeah try reading the TOS, there's nothing that says "You have to be competitive".

It should say it. When a team does something as blatant as this, and is obviously not trying to be competitive, they should be delt with swiftly and firmly. I agree with the OP, take the team away. then problems like this will disappear quickly.
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
You can't all of a sudden go 'zero tolerance' for something that wasn't in the rules; even if it does get put into the rules after this incident the team should only receive a warning.
Last edited Aug 22, 2008 11:03:26
 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CoachSherman
Originally posted by AirMcMVP

Originally posted by rbedgood



All that needs to be done to fix it, is lower the max XP for kickers. Sure they gain XP faster because they are in less plays. So it's simple max them out at about the same number and the motivation for doing this is gone. The bug isn't being able to put your kicker anywhere...its being rewarded for doing so.


I would contend that it is a bug that a kicker can gain 4 levels in a game. Therefore, exploiting this bug is an attempt to cheat and should be dealt with accordingly.


Who says he gained 4 levels in 1 game? You do know that your allowed to boost, right? He is a level 5 now. That can easily be explained by creating the K (Lv1), playing the game (Lv2) & boosting 3 times (Lv5). He could have even boosted prior to the game. With max XP & training he probably would have leveled from 4 to 5 anyway.


Could be. I guess that will take admin confirmation.

The effect on the league is also important to note (as others have pointed out).

Crap like this just pisses me off...
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
I think we have a case of a few friends who are using 1 team as the parent club (Bel Air), one team as a Farm club (Kansas City) and the 3rd team as their private D-league.

Is it unfair, yeah likely. But as far as I can tell unless someone can prove that the "friends" are just one guy with multiple accounts, then the practice is allowed. There are limitations in place (can't make frequent trades, etc.) but if all the players belong to a small group of friends then that's a non-issue anyhow, you just release and sign.

As for the issue of exploiting a bug is cheating...a bug is when something isn't working as designed. The kicker is getting max XP but it is by playing a ton of plays...that's the design. It is a loophole that should be closed, but the system is working as designed. Not all issues are bugs. Now this is an issue and should be addressed, but I don't see it as 'a bug' therefore I don't see 'cheating'
 
k2skier
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by supp0007
Originally posted by oldskool

Yeah try reading the TOS, there's nothing that says "You have to be competitive".

It should say it. When a team does something as blatant as this, and is obviously not trying to be competitive, they should be delt with swiftly and firmly. I agree with the OP, take the team away. then problems like this will disappear quickly.


And I bet you reported to the Admins and Mods that powerbacks were overpowered, right? You didn't? Why is that? Oh because you have one and "he is beastly"... Wait, he didn't report an exploit/bug, take away his players and account!!!
 
CoachSherman
offline
Link
 
I'm not saying the guy wasn't wrong for what he did, but many of the arguements against him are flawed and frankly he didn't break any rules.
 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
You can't all of a sudden go 'zero tolerance' for something that wasn't in the rules; even if it does get put into the rules after this incident the team should only receive a warning.


Assuming the K wasn't boosted, there is a rule against this. Read the TOS under cheating. If the Agent knew that a kicker playing in 45+ plays would result in 4000 XP, that is an exploit of a bug.

Unless this guy has a history of causing problems, his team shouldn't be taken away, but he should be given an admin "black mark" to denote his attempt to circumvent the rules.

Again...that is if the K wasn't boosted.
 
joe
46 Defense
offline
Link
 
He has almost all CPU player. this would have happen anyway. My be not beating them by that much but it would have been a big score.
 
Statbase
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by k2skier
Originally posted by supp0007

Originally posted by oldskool


Yeah try reading the TOS, there's nothing that says "You have to be competitive".

It should say it. When a team does something as blatant as this, and is obviously not trying to be competitive, they should be delt with swiftly and firmly. I agree with the OP, take the team away. then problems like this will disappear quickly.


And I bet you reported to the Admins and Mods that powerbacks were overpowered, right? You didn't? Why is that? Oh because you have one and "he is beastly"... Wait, he didn't report an exploit/bug, take away his players and account!!!

Are you serious? I make a player and try to make him competitive and it works, so I should be punished? I hope the programmers continue to make changes to the sims to make it more realistic. When my speed back was worthless last season because I built him with speed and agility, I never posted that it should be fixed I just tried to make him better. So now that they made agility more important I should have my account deleted?

All I'm saying is for this game to work, people need to try and win.
 
k2skier
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by supp0007
Originally posted by k2skier

Originally posted by supp0007


Originally posted by oldskool



Yeah try reading the TOS, there's nothing that says "You have to be competitive".

It should say it. When a team does something as blatant as this, and is obviously not trying to be competitive, they should be delt with swiftly and firmly. I agree with the OP, take the team away. then problems like this will disappear quickly.


And I bet you reported to the Admins and Mods that powerbacks were overpowered, right? You didn't? Why is that? Oh because you have one and "he is beastly"... Wait, he didn't report an exploit/bug, take away his players and account!!!

Are you serious? I make a player and try to make him competitive and it works, so I should be punished? I hope the programmers continue to make changes to the sims to make it more realistic. When my speed back was worthless last season because I built him with speed and agility, I never posted that it should be fixed I just tried to make him better. So now that they made agility more important I should have my account deleted?

All I'm saying is for this game to work, people need to try and win.


So with that logic you should be ok with this guy/girl trying to make his kicker the best he can be or competative through power leveling.

BTW, I'm pretty sure it was clear I was being rediculous with my previous post about you account being attacked.
Last edited Aug 22, 2008 11:21:01
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Oops...posted in wrong thread...too many screens open
Last edited Aug 22, 2008 11:19:18
 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood


Psst...wrong thread.

Edited so people wouldn't see what you said.
Last edited Aug 22, 2008 11:21:02
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.