User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by XUMuskie85
I just got a PM back from support saying they have noticed it too and are working on determining the problem and fixing it. Yay


good news!
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
This happened to me again tonight in a scrimmage and cost my team 3 points. I've still yet to see Bort or DD say they're working on this problem. My team is playing the #1 ranked team in our division tomorrow night. I'm not going to be happy here if this costs me the game.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=126722&pbp_id=6160227

Again, my AI is fine. I put the same exact inputs into the AI tester and the output is to kick a FG. Down to the second.
 
griz
offline
Link
 
Our game had a 4th and 7.5 from the 38.5 yard line of our opponent and we did a running play for a turnover on downs.

5:04 4th & 7.5 OPP 38.5 Seth Hinrichs pitch to Toe Blake to the right (3.5 yd gain) (turnover on downs) [tackle: Ryan Destin]
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=126168&pbp_id=5924737

The test AI with this exact scenario has no known matches.

Just thought I'd add to the thread.
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griz
Our game had a 4th and 7.5 from the 38.5 yard line of our opponent and we did a running play for a turnover on downs.

5:04 4th & 7.5 OPP 38.5 Seth Hinrichs pitch to Toe Blake to the right (3.5 yd gain) (turnover on downs) [tackle: Ryan Destin]
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=126168&pbp_id=5924737

The test AI with this exact scenario has no known matches.

Just thought I'd add to the thread.


Then you need to fix your AI...this thread is about an issue where the game does something different than the AI tester expects...on short yardage vs goal to go...
 
TheBear
Roll Tide
offline
Link
 
What about this one:
8:34 left in 2nd qtr, down by 1, 4th & 14.5 on OPP 28
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=120929&pbp_id=5865210

Input in AI tester as follows:
Quarter..Time remaining...Ball Spot................Down....yards to go....score
Second...514 seconds......Opponent's 28 yd line...fourth.....14.5.......trailing by 1

The output was:
Matching Input
Input Named: 4th down, FG range


Possible Outputs
100% Field Goal (field_goal)
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheBear
What about this one:
8:34 left in 2nd qtr, down by 1, 4th & 14.5 on OPP 28
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=120929&pbp_id=5865210

Input in AI tester as follows:
Quarter..Time remaining...Ball Spot................Down....yards to go....score
Second...514 seconds......Opponent's 28 yd line...fourth.....14.5.......trailing by 1

The output was:
Matching Input
Input Named: 4th down, FG range


Possible Outputs
100% Field Goal (field_goal)


Well it looks like something is wrong somewhere...not this specific bug/issue...what field goal range do you have? Wondering if the ".5" is messed up in the AI tester...

If you FG range is 45 yards, it may not have you in FG range...check what it does if the yard line is 29/28/27...just a thought...
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
no bug, user error move on.
 
RandomBeast
offline
Link
 
This happened to my team AGAIN today.

This play: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=118576&pbp_id=6494981

Originally posted by Offense AI Test

Matching Input
Input Named: 4th down, FG range

Possible Outputs
100% Field Goal (field_goal)


Once again, it appears to have run our 4th and short AI on 4th and goal instead of treating "and goal" like the yardage it is from and kicking the field goal.

We won easily, so it didn't effect us. But I would like this fixed before it does cost us a game.
 
TheBear
Roll Tide
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
no bug, user error move on.



I disagree.

If you input the exact parameters into the AI tester and get a different result as to what actually happened in the game, then there is a bug either in the game or the AI tester.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheBear
Originally posted by Robbnva

no bug, user error move on.



I disagree.

If you input the exact parameters into the AI tester and get a different result as to what actually happened in the game, then there is a bug either in the game or the AI tester.


ok so maybe I concede that there is an AI tester bug it was something he scraped together to make all the whiny people happy when they said my AI isn't working. The fact that you went for it on 4th down is not a bug.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
No, it's a bug. I've let enough people look at my AI and they've all agreed that my AI are fine.
 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by TheBear

Originally posted by Robbnva


no bug, user error move on.



I disagree.

If you input the exact parameters into the AI tester and get a different result as to what actually happened in the game, then there is a bug either in the game or the AI tester.


ok so maybe I concede that there is an AI tester bug it was something he scraped together to make all the whiny people happy when they said my AI isn't working. The fact that you went for it on 4th down is not a bug.


Ignore the 4th and whatever from the whereever people, there is definitively a bug in 4th and Goal situations in gameplay.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 20:55:17
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RandomBeast
This happened to my team AGAIN today.

This play: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=118576&pbp_id=6494981

Originally posted by Offense AI Test


Matching Input
Input Named: 4th down, FG range

Possible Outputs
100% Field Goal (field_goal)


Once again, it appears to have run our 4th and short AI on 4th and goal instead of treating "and goal" like the yardage it is from and kicking the field goal.

We won easily, so it didn't effect us. But I would like this fixed before it does cost us a game.


This is the issue. Any down and goal is the same as any down and 0-1 or 0-2 yards. The AI tester doesn't catch it as the "goal" is not accepted as valid input and ignored. In a game, if you have a simple 0-1 yards to go with a specific call, and you have a "goal to go" situation, it will call you "specific call" regardless of how far away from the goal you are....

Twice in games I have had different play calls on different downs result in the "special" plays being run.

You can say it is the AI tester or whatever, but the fact is in a game, the "goal to go" situation will match 0-xxx yards to go.

You can get around it a little by not using "zero" yards in the to go range...make it 1-xxx yards, but then you need to have an option for the 0-1 yards as a special coverage play calls based on where the ball is on the field. But this is VERY complicated and still doesn't cover every aspect...

 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
bort is on the prowl maybe he will tell you who is right.
 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
I'd love for him to check mine or any of the other people's AIs and let us know what's up. I'm ok with being wrong haha.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.