User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > League fix for player disparity
Page:
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
I actually think that what the OP describes would be a workable, and with some tweaking could be a great idea... for a game... But it varies too greatly from GLB for it to ever be considered realistically.

1) GLB is based around promoting teams to get to the top.
2) GLB is based around the notion that Players could remain together for their entire careers.

It might not be the best way to design a football sim with these two premises - but it is the way that GLB has been designed.


KEN1 Has the right idea to form league disparity (which is desperately needed) - incentives to encourage free agents to strive to play at the highest possible league. Experience is a great incentive, but it also doesn't "force" teams to break apart, or for Players to leave their friends.
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by demonicangel

Originally posted by Schaffer05


Demonic, You could have a league cap of LVL 13, with an exception cap of 17 (for your 3 players that you desire)


Actually that would work out. The problem now is to get the rest of the GLB community to relize that this needs to get fixed. The minute the C word comes out people start the flame wars. If someone could get majority of the GLB community to agree it would be great. No African A team wants to give up there level 29 Qb's though, and Bort just needs to stick to his guns, and call their bluff.


Well prior to capping it needs to just be a massive restructuring of the leagues. All leagues should be shuffled and teams sent into leagues with their AVG player level being that league, and that league having an AVG level cap based on the league. Once that happens teams will be even and set up properly. Gutted teams will be the bottom dwellers with the LVL 13ish caps.


Team will need a non penalty time period in order to unf-ck there rosters. Hence why I think if it did get implamented that an offseason of 1-2 weeks will be needed. It would give guys time to get adjusted to their new team and owner, also give bort time to fix any bugs he deems nec.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Just give everyone their grace period like you would a new team, but for every team (except pro teams)
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by demonicangel
Sounds like your talking about a non booster team and leagues. That wont happen. But Bort needs to grow a set of balls, and say ya know what this friend thing is killing the game. WE NEED TO MAKE SURE WE KEEP A ABUNDANT SUPPLY OF LEVEL1-4'S. Without them this game will be tanked very very very fast. If there is a cap, people will bitch and cry, but I doubt that they will have invested so much money, and then just turn around and leave. I say call their bluff.


I see what you man about the non-booster leagues. Perhaps it needs to be set up so that the "arena" leagues do not have the same perks as the pro leagues. If there was a real drawback to being in the arean league, more people would be encouraged to boost. IDK what the drawback could be...that is where you guys could definately help out.

Originally posted by Schaffer05
I don't mind that so much, The one thing I don't think many will like is the owning of a team portion. Who gets what teams? How are new players delivered to the new teams (drafting or what?) You know what I mean, will it come down to a popularity contest, or will it come down to perfomance and stat wise? If that's the case what happens when an actually really good player ends up on a pretty good team but only gets decent stats because he plays against good competition as well. Same token, what happens when a mediocre player ends up on a shitty team in HS and college, but puts up great stats because he plays shitty players.


I am not too clear on what he meant by the CPU-owned teams with the different positions you could apply for and pay flex. I am still unsure if I like that. It would be next to impossible to implement fairly.

As far as players getting onto the pro teams, I think that is why turner wanted the CPU owned teams. Less BS of letting friends on their teams - if you lose too much, you get fired.

Perhaps, the owners that win the premier bowl games are put on a list to own a pro team. If they win 2 years in a row, they are bumped up the list. 3 years, etc. When a pro team opens, they can buy it and drop their old team. The same would be true for high school leagues. People could always decline the offer if they do not want to move up. They can then bring any of their good players up, if they want to. A sort of natural farming system bond would be built between certain teams in the different levels...like a team the favors drafting from a certain college.
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 18:14:42
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
I actually think that what the OP describes would be a workable, and with some tweaking could be a great idea... for a game... But it varies too greatly from GLB for it to ever be considered realistically.

1) GLB is based around promoting teams to get to the top.
2) GLB is based around the notion that Players could remain together for their entire careers.

It might not be the best way to design a football sim with these two premises - but it is the way that GLB has been designed.


KEN1 Has the right idea to form league disparity (which is desperately needed) - incentives to encourage free agents to strive to play at the highest possible league. Experience is a great incentive, but it also doesn't "force" teams to break apart, or for Players to leave their friends.


And that is why this game is getting extremely boring. I mentioned earlier that I strive to be a league leader, I started this game a lot earlier than most did. I try to keep my guys at about league average. My guys in the PROs have no shot at being a league leader, because of all the gut jobs out their in the Pro Leagues.

Why are their pro league gut jobs? Because they cant stay competitive. Who the hell wants to own a team that keeps getting creamed 60-10 every game. Now if the score was 20-17 each game, they would most likely be willing to gut it out. Knowing that in the offseason they can try to get that one or two guys that can put them over the top. In this GLB age though, that is impossible, cause all the high level Free Agents go to what ever league they can rack up the stats in. Hence expansion teams.
Forcing the owner of Pro team to either get a level 14 to play against 25+ or suffer a 110-0 loss instead. Well they get frusterated and just give up, I dont blame them.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by turnerhero

Schaffer05, please re-read my original post, because you obviously didn't do so.


I read your post... You think Bort would like to implement something that will make agents wary to boost their players? If I knew I may have to retire my guy after just a couple of seasons, there is no way I would boost all of my players (As I do now, spending 55$ a month on this game). Then after I play 8 seasons only to find out my guy won't be able to play in the pros, I'd be pretty pissed to have to retire him and start all over.


You didn't read it, and I know that to be true because you seem to think that in 2 seasons your player would start to decline once he reached Professional level (if he did). If you had read my original post, you would have known that I still had 10 full seasons once a player gets to the Pros before they decline off...
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
Originally posted by Schaffer05

Originally posted by turnerhero


Schaffer05, please re-read my original post, because you obviously didn't do so.


I read your post... You think Bort would like to implement something that will make agents wary to boost their players? If I knew I may have to retire my guy after just a couple of seasons, there is no way I would boost all of my players (As I do now, spending 55$ a month on this game). Then after I play 8 seasons only to find out my guy won't be able to play in the pros, I'd be pretty pissed to have to retire him and start all over.


You didn't read it, and I know that to be true because you seem to think that in 2 seasons your player would start to decline once he reached Professional level (if he did). If you had read my original post, you would have known that I still had 10 full seasons once a player gets to the Pros before they decline off...


I think 10 might be a bit to much, but I would say 7-8 would be a better number. Just on a buisness aspect. You cant keep players around for to long, then you start to lose money.

 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
Originally posted by Schaffer05

Originally posted by turnerhero


Schaffer05, please re-read my original post, because you obviously didn't do so.


I read your post... You think Bort would like to implement something that will make agents wary to boost their players? If I knew I may have to retire my guy after just a couple of seasons, there is no way I would boost all of my players (As I do now, spending 55$ a month on this game). Then after I play 8 seasons only to find out my guy won't be able to play in the pros, I'd be pretty pissed to have to retire him and start all over.


You didn't read it, and I know that to be true because you seem to think that in 2 seasons your player would start to decline once he reached Professional level (if he did). If you had read my original post, you would have known that I still had 10 full seasons once a player gets to the Pros before they decline off...



I don't see anything in the original post that says anything abotu being able to play 10 seasons in the Pros and that's the 3rd time I've looked at it. Either way Bort wants a 10 season drop off, not a 18 season drop off.
 
rivergato
offline
Link
 
turnerhero---See it similar to you. Maybe you can take something from my dead thread to add to your ideas. BTW, I like a random degeneration beginning in 7th player season (maybe anywhere to 11th)...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=821914
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by demonicangel
Why are their pro league gut jobs? Because they cant stay competitive. Who the hell wants to own a team that keeps getting creamed 60-10 every game. Now if the score was 20-17 each game, they would most likely be willing to gut it out. Knowing that in the offseason they can try to get that one or two guys that can put them over the top. In this GLB age though, that is impossible, cause all the high level Free Agents go to what ever league they can rack up the stats in. Hence expansion teams.
Forcing the owner of Pro team to either get a level 14 to play against 25+ or suffer a 110-0 loss instead. Well they get frusterated and just give up, I dont blame them.


Getting rid of gutted teams is alot easier if you have the arena leagues with the XP incentive going to the pro league teams. There will be plenty of talent available in the arena leagues that would love to come over to the pros for more XP. If the relegation system I suggested were implemented, a gutted team would open for a proven successful owner (at the college level) to come in and get things in order. Eventually, the pros would be the pros and everyone would want to GM/play there.
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by demonicangel

Why are their pro league gut jobs? Because they cant stay competitive. Who the hell wants to own a team that keeps getting creamed 60-10 every game. Now if the score was 20-17 each game, they would most likely be willing to gut it out. Knowing that in the offseason they can try to get that one or two guys that can put them over the top. In this GLB age though, that is impossible, cause all the high level Free Agents go to what ever league they can rack up the stats in. Hence expansion teams.
Forcing the owner of Pro team to either get a level 14 to play against 25+ or suffer a 110-0 loss instead. Well they get frusterated and just give up, I dont blame them.


Getting rid of gutted teams is alot easier if you have the arena leagues with the XP incentive going to the pro league teams. There will be plenty of talent available in the arena leagues that would love to come over to the pros for more XP. If the relegation system I suggested were implemented, a gutted team would open for a proven successful owner (at the college level) to come in and get things in order. Eventually, the pros would be the pros and everyone would want to GM/play there.


I dont think the 5% diffrence is enough to get the players up their though. Also how would get the players to match up once one guys retires his old player? The guy that has to move up, is going to be well below the curve, do to his xp gains from a lower league. When he moves up it will be a level 20 vs level 30 again. Almost like it is now.

 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Ehh demonic I don't agree with the lower than the curve thing. As one retires one will have to move up anyway, whether it be from the college level or the Arena level. The Arena level will be higher than the college level anyway because he's been around longer, but doesn't have as long left. As the one older pro player is retiring, so is the competition he's been playing against shortly there after as well.
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Ehh demonic I don't agree with the lower than the curve thing. As one retires one will have to move up anyway, whether it be from the college level or the Arena level. The Arena level will be higher than the college level anyway because he's been around longer, but doesn't have as long left. As the one older pro player is retiring, so is the competition he's been playing against shortly there after as well.


Regardless he has missed out on alot of xp because there wasnt any room for him to play at the pro level. He has missed out on 20xp points per 100 cause he was forced to play at the college level/areana level. When he makes it up to the PRO league, he will be significantly lower than all the other players. It would take him a full 5-6 seasons just to catch up, and then he retires and another guys is the same. It would be like playing in your Prime for one season. THen you would be done.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Ehh demonic I don't agree with the lower than the curve thing. As one retires one will have to move up anyway, whether it be from the college level or the Arena level. The Arena level will be higher than the college level anyway because he's been around longer, but doesn't have as long left. As the one older pro player is retiring, so is the competition he's been playing against shortly there after as well.


It would make sense for owners to mix it up. If they were scouting correctly, they may have someone that will fill their spot in a season or two. They will then sign an arena league player to fill the spot for a year or two. Once the prospect is ready, they will lock him in for a few years. With a tiered system like turner suggested, scouting would make much more sense.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by demonicangel
Originally posted by Schaffer05

Ehh demonic I don't agree with the lower than the curve thing. As one retires one will have to move up anyway, whether it be from the college level or the Arena level. The Arena level will be higher than the college level anyway because he's been around longer, but doesn't have as long left. As the one older pro player is retiring, so is the competition he's been playing against shortly there after as well.


Regardless he has missed out on alot of xp because there wasnt any room for him to play at the pro level. He has missed out on 20xp points per 100 cause he was forced to play at the college level/areana level. When he makes it up to the PRO league, he will be significantly lower than all the other players. It would take him a full 5-6 seasons just to catch up, and then he retires and another guys is the same. It would be like playing in your Prime for one season. THen you would be done.



Yea I think the years in each league need to be adjusted, or the 10 season decline needs to be adjusted for this idea to work.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.