User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Brownseq9
offline
Link
 
I think it's the Wang-Dang-Doodle factor
 
DLight03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
For all those people that don't think missed tackle is not a problem, check this out:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88550&pbp_id=4424198

The two DT's that missed the tackle both had strength over 70, tackling and agility over 50, vision over 30. How would a level 1 HB broke those two tackles I have no idea.

I'm simply pointing out a flaw in the game that is obviously need to be addressed. Not whining here, so please don't post "stop whining" or "get higher tackling" replies.


Let's put this into percentages.

Let's say there's a 1% chance that play happens, and both of those players miss that tackle relative to their skills and the skills of the HB running. Chances are, it's not going to happen, but even a 1% chance will happen every once in a while. Even the worst players in football break tackles once in a blue moon. It's all about percentages. Nothing you do to your player is guaranteed. All you can do, is improve the percentages. Improve your chance to break a tackle, relative to your opponent, improve your chance to make a tackle, to not fumble, to get an INT, all of that is percentages.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
For all those people that don't think missed tackle is not a problem, check this out:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88550&pbp_id=4424198

The two DT's that missed the tackle both had strength over 70, tackling and agility over 50, vision over 30. How would a level 1 HB broke those two tackles I have no idea.

I'm simply pointing out a flaw in the game that is obviously need to be addressed. Not whining here, so please don't post "stop whining" or "get higher tackling" replies.


That's a lot of Wangs on the field at the same time!
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
When someone grabs 800 yards against scrubs, the analogy is always used that that game would be like NFL players playing against middle schoolers. In this case, that same analogy could be used - so what are the chances that two NFL defensive tackles are going to miss on a grade school HB? I'd say about -7%.

Might not want to use that analogy when it works against the notion that things are working as intended, though.
 
MrMike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
When someone grabs 800 yards against scrubs, the analogy is always used that that game would be like NFL players playing against middle schoolers. In this case, that same analogy could be used - so what are the chances that two NFL defensive tackles are going to miss on a grade school HB? I'd say about -7%.

Might not want to use that analogy when it works against the notion that things are working as intended, though.


The problem is, the game isn't coded to leave NO possibility for something. So, if there's a 1 in 1,000,000 chance of something happening--its a mathematical certainty happen, somewhere, since there are well over a million plays (I'd guess) being simmed.

Now, if the RB is constantly breaking tackles, that's a big problem. But he's not.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
OP, your answer lies here.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=861324
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
OP, your answer lies here.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=861324


Scoring by quarters:
1st: 52-0
2nd: 49-0
3rd: 49-0
4th: 96-0

Your Coasting = Fail!

Seriously, our guy's energy were ok after playing over 100 plays, so I'm sure they were on relaxed most of the game, which is what coasting is supposed to do. So I think in that sense it is working. Regardless, level 22 DTs playing relaxed or even at 50 energy should still be a lot better than level 1 HBs. The only person is whining here is you, everyone else is simply discussing an occurrence in the game that really should/should not happen.

If you disagree with what people are saying here, post your opinion, or just don't read it. There is no need to call people idiot, that would just make you look like a d*#$@bag.

 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by tautology

OP, your answer lies here.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=861324


Scoring by quarters:
1st: 52-0
2nd: 49-0
3rd: 49-0
4th: 96-0

Your Coasting = Fail!

Seriously, our guy's energy were ok after playing over 100 plays, so I'm sure they were on relaxed most of the game, which is what coasting is supposed to do. So I think in that sense it is working. Regardless, level 22 DTs playing relaxed or even at 50 energy should still be a lot better than level 1 HBs. The only person is whining here is you, everyone else is simply discussing an occurrence in the game that really should/should not happen.

If you disagree with what people are saying here, post your opinion, or just don't read it. There is no need to call people idiot, that would just make you look like a d*#$@bag.



Nope - you're wrong.

Coasting reduces the player's effectiveness/attributes AND lowers the energy he uses during play. Therefore, once you dominant, you play worse. And you might, oh say... miss a tackle or two?

I mentioned this very early on in the thread, but you chose to ignore it then. It's exactly the reasoning for what happened, and a play where someone misses a tackle in a complete and utter blowout is not a bug.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by tautology


OP, your answer lies here.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=861324


Scoring by quarters:
1st: 52-0
2nd: 49-0
3rd: 49-0
4th: 96-0

Your Coasting = Fail!

Seriously, our guy's energy were ok after playing over 100 plays, so I'm sure they were on relaxed most of the game, which is what coasting is supposed to do. So I think in that sense it is working. Regardless, level 22 DTs playing relaxed or even at 50 energy should still be a lot better than level 1 HBs. The only person is whining here is you, everyone else is simply discussing an occurrence in the game that really should/should not happen.

If you disagree with what people are saying here, post your opinion, or just don't read it. There is no need to call people idiot, that would just make you look like a d*#$@bag.



Nope - you're wrong.

Coasting reduces the player's effectiveness/attributes AND lowers the energy he uses during play. Therefore, once you dominant, you play worse. And you might, oh say... miss a tackle or two?

I mentioned this very early on in the thread, but you chose to ignore it then. It's exactly the reasoning for what happened, and a play where someone misses a tackle in a complete and utter blowout is not a bug.


Thanks Bort.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
BTW, in real life, there is no coasting. Teams will simply run the ball to keep the clock rolling. Coaches never tell the players: "hey take it easy, miss a tackle or two".

The funny thing is, if I try to run the ball in big mismatched games in GLB, I would score even more points since the running game is so dominating.

So let me get this straight, when players miss tackle against good players, people need to "put more into tackling", when they miss tackles against shitty players, "it's by design".
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 20:21:38
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Nope - you're wrong.

Coasting reduces the player's effectiveness/attributes AND lowers the energy he uses during play. Therefore, once you dominant, you play worse. And you might, oh say... miss a tackle or two?

I mentioned this very early on in the thread, but you chose to ignore it then. It's exactly the reasoning for what happened, and a play where someone misses a tackle in a complete and utter blowout is not a bug.


No amount of coasting, stamina loss or any other phenomena known to man can explain how a player just created can shake off a Level 21 DT's tackle.

Defies rational explanation - no matter how hard people try.

The equivalent would be like an 8th grader running into Albert Haynesworth unblocked with a 35 yard head of steam AND not only still be standing (let alone conscious) AND still be hanging on to the ball BUT forcing Haynesworth to hang on with all his might to drag him down.

Check that - getting hit by Albert Haynesworth and Tony Brown and dragging them both for a yard.

Some things just aren't supposed to happen - this is one of them. I don't care how tired you think Haynesworth and Brown get - they aren't that tired not to knock the stuffing out of an 8th grader unblocked with a full head of steam.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Bugs, that should be posted in the BUGS forum:

"When I choose cover 2, it kicks a field goal instead."
"When I go to page X, it gives me a 500 server error."
"I tried to create a CB, but it made a G instead."
"When I select close coverage for my CB, he plays 20 yards off his man every time."


Gripes about things that are working as intended but you don't like, that should go to the SUGGESTIONS forum:

"I don't like the zone coverage on this play. Here's what I think it should be instead."
"I think RB's should break fewer tackles. Here's why, and here's what I think a better solution is."
"I think WR's should catch fewer balls. Here's why, and here's what I think a better solution is."
"I don't like this particular restriction on trading. Here's why, and here's what I think would work better."


Gripes about things that are working as intended but you don't like, that should probably not be posted at all:

"My RB doesn't work right! I have no suggestions on why I don't like it or how I think it could work better, but FIX IT."
"WR's suck! I have no suggestions on why they suck or how they could be made to not suck, but FIX IT."
"This game is stupid. FIX IT."
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
BTW, in real life, there is no coasting. Teams will simply run the ball to keep the clock rolling. Coaches never tell the players: "hey take it easy, miss a tackle or two".

The funny thing is, if I try to run the ball in big mismatched games in GLB, I would score even more points since the running game is so dominating.

So let me get this straight, when players miss tackle against good players, people need to "put more into tackling", when they miss tackles against shitty players, "it's by design".


While this is a football game and it is modeled after real life football, it is NOT a perfect representation, nor should it be.

Are you telling me the addition of coasting was a bad thing? Seriously, that's all you're saying here. What did you want? To beat the team worse?

I'm sure you could piece through that game and see low level players doing absolutely amazing things. Like tackling! And running around! And deflecting balls! And catching, even!

What do you want? To score a TD on every play? To force a fumble on every tackle? Give me a break - you won 246-0 and you have the nerve to cry foul.

Originally posted by greengoose
No amount of coasting, stamina loss or any other phenomena known to man can explain how a player just created can shake off a Level 21 DT's tackle.

Defies rational explanation - no matter how hard people try.

The equivalent would be like an 8th grader running into Albert Haynesworth unblocked with a 35 yard head of steam AND not only still be standing (let alone conscious) AND still be hanging on to the ball BUT forcing Haynesworth to hang on with all his might to drag him down.

Check that - getting hit by Albert Haynesworth and Tony Brown and dragging them both for a yard.

Some things just aren't supposed to happen - this is one of them. I don't care how tired you think Haynesworth and Brown get - they aren't that tired not to knock the stuffing out of an 8th grader unblocked with a full head of steam.


Then, in your beautifully crafted (and stolen) analogy, you essentially want the same thing as datongw. A TD on every offensive play and a turnover on every defensive play.

Please let me know when you can explain why coasting is a bad thing, and I'm all ears. Until then, spend your energy on something productive. This is ridiculous.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by datongw

BTW, in real life, there is no coasting. Teams will simply run the ball to keep the clock rolling. Coaches never tell the players: "hey take it easy, miss a tackle or two".

The funny thing is, if I try to run the ball in big mismatched games in GLB, I would score even more points since the running game is so dominating.

So let me get this straight, when players miss tackle against good players, people need to "put more into tackling", when they miss tackles against shitty players, "it's by design".


While this is a football game and it is modeled after real life football, it is NOT a perfect representation, nor should it be.

Are you telling me the addition of coasting was a bad thing? Seriously, that's all you're saying here. What did you want? To beat the team worse?

I'm sure you could piece through that game and see low level players doing absolutely amazing things. Like tackling! And running around! And deflecting balls! And catching, even!

What do you want? To score a TD on every play? To force a fumble on every tackle? Give me a break - you won 246-0 and you have the nerve to cry foul.

Originally posted by greengoose

No amount of coasting, stamina loss or any other phenomena known to man can explain how a player just created can shake off a Level 21 DT's tackle.

Defies rational explanation - no matter how hard people try.

The equivalent would be like an 8th grader running into Albert Haynesworth unblocked with a 35 yard head of steam AND not only still be standing (let alone conscious) AND still be hanging on to the ball BUT forcing Haynesworth to hang on with all his might to drag him down.

Check that - getting hit by Albert Haynesworth and Tony Brown and dragging them both for a yard.

Some things just aren't supposed to happen - this is one of them. I don't care how tired you think Haynesworth and Brown get - they aren't that tired not to knock the stuffing out of an 8th grader unblocked with a full head of steam.


Then, in your beautifully crafted (and stolen) analogy, you essentially want the same thing as datongw. A TD on every offensive play and a turnover on every defensive play.

Please let me know when you can explain why coasting is a bad thing, and I'm all ears. Until then, spend your energy on something productive. This is ridiculous.


Dude, try read the whole thread before making idiotic comments like these.

I have never said "coasting" is a bad change, so don't put words in my mouth.

I have never said I wanted to score a TD on every single play.

I have never cried foul in this post.

I simply gave an example of two level 22 well built DTs missing tackle against a level 1 HB on the same play. Now, I think there might be something wrong there. Maybe there is, maybe there isn't. If you think that's normal, fine. But there really is no need for you to get your imaginations running wild and get all worked up over here.
 
nittany2b
offline
Link
 
I have to agree with datongw here, it's absolutely ridiculous to have 2 level 20+'s whiff on a level 1, regardless of "coasting." I'm a real-life football coach and I know my scrubs can't break tackles of my best players no matter how hard they're trying. If the stars are "coasting" then the scrub just won't get leveled and cough up the football like he would in a tight game.

In response to the question raised about what a big deal it is - those missed tackles add up and look very ugly in the stat sheets. There are many people, myself included, that play the game for my player's stat lines, and when a dominant DT has 40 tackles and 12 sacks, but 9 or 10 missed "flukes" over the season, it makes his campaign seem less spectacular than it actually was. This might not matter to some of you, but many players like to compare their players and field a "pro bowl" team of their conference and these unnecessary missed tackle numbers can keep a deserving player off and an owner whining about how the whiffs "didn't really count." Again, it might not matter to some of you, but for a matter so trivial why can't we just fix the bug?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.