Originally posted by grugnur
heres another way to do it...
a DT with a strength of 50 would always be stronger than a CB with a 50 strength due to body mass (the bonus would be invisible) no matter how much blocking you put on a WR, he's not going to do much to a DT barreling down on him, best he could do is be a road-bump
... there's a reason that CB don't bench 300 pounds, it's because they would be too bulky to do their job... likewise a HB at speed 50 would always be faster than a FB with speed 50 because of body type... let's say a FB might need to pump speed up to 60 to be as fast as a HB with speed 50, but the FB might have to neglect specials or agility/strength/blocking to do so...
now a DT or an OL could decide to be a "finesse" player... he is already 300pounds so his base strength could be neglected a bit but he could really pump the agility, speed and technique... you *can* beat people stronger than you if you have the correct body position and quickness... teams like the broncos use a finess blocking system... some teams have smaller finesse type DL players as well... the 3-4 requires brutes
balancing all of this is easier said than done, but it's one way to keep the current system intact while allowing variety...
i'm afraid (and i have no proof) that currently the designers are just limiting overall ability of a general position to get an end result instead of allowing for max/min builds to be effective... they are forcing people towards balanced, which is kinda bland in my opinion
In my opinion, an easier solution would be to make effective power running depend on the HB/FB power SAs. Right now a linemen with crazy strength and decent speed can basically just swim though a pile of weak tacklers.
Sure, he's strong and great at blocking or tackling with two hands, but pancaking people should be a lot harder with only one hand free. HBs and FBs who have invested their points in being good at tackle-breaking deserve it, but a big linemen who rarely carries the ball should be a lot easier to take down.
heres another way to do it...
a DT with a strength of 50 would always be stronger than a CB with a 50 strength due to body mass (the bonus would be invisible) no matter how much blocking you put on a WR, he's not going to do much to a DT barreling down on him, best he could do is be a road-bump
... there's a reason that CB don't bench 300 pounds, it's because they would be too bulky to do their job... likewise a HB at speed 50 would always be faster than a FB with speed 50 because of body type... let's say a FB might need to pump speed up to 60 to be as fast as a HB with speed 50, but the FB might have to neglect specials or agility/strength/blocking to do so...
now a DT or an OL could decide to be a "finesse" player... he is already 300pounds so his base strength could be neglected a bit but he could really pump the agility, speed and technique... you *can* beat people stronger than you if you have the correct body position and quickness... teams like the broncos use a finess blocking system... some teams have smaller finesse type DL players as well... the 3-4 requires brutes
balancing all of this is easier said than done, but it's one way to keep the current system intact while allowing variety...
i'm afraid (and i have no proof) that currently the designers are just limiting overall ability of a general position to get an end result instead of allowing for max/min builds to be effective... they are forcing people towards balanced, which is kinda bland in my opinion
In my opinion, an easier solution would be to make effective power running depend on the HB/FB power SAs. Right now a linemen with crazy strength and decent speed can basically just swim though a pile of weak tacklers.
Sure, he's strong and great at blocking or tackling with two hands, but pancaking people should be a lot harder with only one hand free. HBs and FBs who have invested their points in being good at tackle-breaking deserve it, but a big linemen who rarely carries the ball should be a lot easier to take down.






























