User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Tracker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fumblestruck
Personally I think the changes this season were well intentioned but have gone too far. All we did was exchange a speed exploit for a strength exploit.

What is a good build these days anyhow? 90 strength right?


BINGO!
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Wrong, it's fixed now


What happens when a HB with high power and high carry(don't wanna give away builds) hits a LB with 40 tackling and 30 strength?? Flattened!! Problem? Nah, not IMO
 
fumblestruck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
Wrong, it's fixed now


What happens when a HB with high power and high carry(don't wanna give away builds) hits a LB with 40 tackling and 30 strength?? Flattened!! Problem? Nah, not IMO


That's fine if its 1 LB, but when the power back breaks a DT with 85 strength/60 tackling then breaks a LB tackle with 60 strength/50 tackling and then continues to break the tackle of a SS with 40 strenth/40 tackling and runs over a CB with 20 strength/25 tackling that it gets ridiculous. You can't even gang tackle a guy like that. Its an exploit.

How many RB's are now averaging 6 or 7 yards plus per carry now? That's not realistic. Why even throw if you can get 6 yards every carry?

 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Everybody keeps saying 'raise tackling'

People need to raise their strength.


Let's recap - to be effective, we need points in vision, then tackling, then strength?? Let's not forget we need a huge chunk of stamina - oh, and confidence - not forgetting lots of agility now - oh, and some speed, and a bit of jumping.......

Hell, let's just soft cap EVERY attribute and be done with it - I'm sure kicking will come into play for my DT at some point.........

C'mon guys - you simply CAN'T just add points everywhere - at some point you need to focus on the MAIN attributes - but the thing is, those MAIN attributes keep changing. Things that WORK keep changing.

Balanced builds is DEFINITELY the most realistic way forward - but how the hell can you balance points into 8 or more categories?? At the soft cap, that's about 400 SPs.

That's roughly level 22 without a point spent in SAs - and perhaps 2 and a bit seasons (of playing AND boosting) of being trounced by 'the builds that work' as opposed to the 'right' builds that we all want.

And even once you get there, you're going to be EXACTLY the same as every other player, so will cancel each other out.....and the ones that'll have the edge will be the ones who can afford to 'buy' the SPs, thereby getting to the caps quicker.....

As has been said, we're just bouncing from exploit to exploit and there's a fundimental change required.

Last year it was speed that 'worked', now it's power - what next??

Who knows. All I know is that whilst we're playing and not testing, the exploits will keep getting abused and the 'decent' players will generally be the ones who come off as losers - thereby being the first to leave the game.

And you'll be left, like always, with the 'uber 1337' kids trying to out exploit each other.....

Can't wait.........

 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fumblestruck
Originally posted by ShakeNBake

Wrong, it's fixed now


What happens when a HB with high power and high carry(don't wanna give away builds) hits a LB with 40 tackling and 30 strength?? Flattened!! Problem? Nah, not IMO


That's fine if its 1 LB, but when the power back breaks a DT with 85 strength/60 tackling then breaks a LB tackle with 60 strength/50 tackling and then continues to break the tackle of a SS with 40 strenth/40 tackling and runs over a CB with 20 strength/25 tackling that it gets ridiculous. You can't even gang tackle a guy like that. Its an exploit.

How many RB's are now averaging 6 or 7 yards plus per carry now? That's not realistic. Why even throw if you can get 6 yards every carry?



never seen a power back do all that. can u show me?

 
bongbreath
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crying Eagle
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=88037
We have one of the best Defenses in the league. 30 Missed Tackles???????? Are u serious??????

We are all set to Wrap-up.


I'm not sure what happened, but say you meet a guy with 60 strength, should your 47 tackler take him down all the time?

I finally think the game is starting to get "it" and it's not place all your eggs in one basket.

We've all seen the guy who does nothing but dump points into speed and takes over a game, that time thankfully is over and I couldn't be happier.
 
megaman1337
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Originally posted by Checkmate187

Everybody keeps saying 'raise tackling'

People need to raise their strength.


Let's recap - to be effective, we need points in vision, then tackling, then strength?? Let's not forget we need a huge chunk of stamina - oh, and confidence - not forgetting lots of agility now - oh, and some speed, and a bit of jumping.......

Hell, let's just soft cap EVERY attribute and be done with it - I'm sure kicking will come into play for my DT at some point.........

C'mon guys - you simply CAN'T just add points everywhere - at some point you need to focus on the MAIN attributes - but the thing is, those MAIN attributes keep changing. Things that WORK keep changing.

Balanced builds is DEFINITELY the most realistic way forward - but how the hell can you balance points into 8 or more categories?? At the soft cap, that's about 400 SPs.

That's roughly level 22 without a point spent in SAs - and perhaps 2 and a bit seasons (of playing AND boosting) of being trounced by 'the builds that work' as opposed to the 'right' builds that we all want.

And even once you get there, you're going to be EXACTLY the same as every other player, so will cancel each other out.....and the ones that'll have the edge will be the ones who can afford to 'buy' the SPs, thereby getting to the caps quicker.....

As has been said, we're just bouncing from exploit to exploit and there's a fundimental change required.

Last year it was speed that 'worked', now it's power - what next??

Who knows. All I know is that whilst we're playing and not testing, the exploits will keep getting abused and the 'decent' players will generally be the ones who come off as losers - thereby being the first to leave the game.

And you'll be left, like always, with the 'uber 1337' kids trying to out exploit each other.....

Can't wait.........



+1 Guy knows what he's talking about.
 
bongbreath
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fumblestruck
Originally posted by ShakeNBake

Wrong, it's fixed now


What happens when a HB with high power and high carry(don't wanna give away builds) hits a LB with 40 tackling and 30 strength?? Flattened!! Problem? Nah, not IMO


That's fine if its 1 LB, but when the power back breaks a DT with 85 strength/60 tackling then breaks a LB tackle with 60 strength/50 tackling and then continues to break the tackle of a SS with 40 strenth/40 tackling and runs over a CB with 20 strength/25 tackling that it gets ridiculous. You can't even gang tackle a guy like that. Its an exploit.

How many RB's are now averaging 6 or 7 yards plus per carry now? That's not realistic. Why even throw if you can get 6 yards every carry?



I disagree, you talk like all the players are at the top of their game, a true "pro" mentality.

Considering the top is 100, most of us are playing at a high school level by comparison. I can show you ton's of players averaging more than that at this level of play.

The young men with all their instant gratification mentality need to get a grip. If your guy is at 40, you aren't even 1/2 as good as you can and will be.

But if building a player from scratch isn't something you like to do, if you want to be the best of the best from day one, stick to Madden.

The level of you game is what it is, accept it and improve your player.
 
Gisty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Originally posted by Checkmate187

Everybody keeps saying 'raise tackling'

People need to raise their strength.


Let's recap - to be effective, we need points in vision, then tackling, then strength?? Let's not forget we need a huge chunk of stamina - oh, and confidence - not forgetting lots of agility now - oh, and some speed, and a bit of jumping.......

Hell, let's just soft cap EVERY attribute and be done with it - I'm sure kicking will come into play for my DT at some point.........

C'mon guys - you simply CAN'T just add points everywhere - at some point you need to focus on the MAIN attributes - but the thing is, those MAIN attributes keep changing. Things that WORK keep changing.

Balanced builds is DEFINITELY the most realistic way forward - but how the hell can you balance points into 8 or more categories?? At the soft cap, that's about 400 SPs.

That's roughly level 22 without a point spent in SAs - and perhaps 2 and a bit seasons (of playing AND boosting) of being trounced by 'the builds that work' as opposed to the 'right' builds that we all want.

And even once you get there, you're going to be EXACTLY the same as every other player, so will cancel each other out.....and the ones that'll have the edge will be the ones who can afford to 'buy' the SPs, thereby getting to the caps quicker.....

As has been said, we're just bouncing from exploit to exploit and there's a fundimental change required.

Last year it was speed that 'worked', now it's power - what next??

Who knows. All I know is that whilst we're playing and not testing, the exploits will keep getting abused and the 'decent' players will generally be the ones who come off as losers - thereby being the first to leave the game.

And you'll be left, like always, with the 'uber 1337' kids trying to out exploit each other.....

Can't wait.........



QFT

 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fumblestruck
Personally I think the changes this season were well intentioned but have gone too far. All we did was exchange a speed exploit for a strength exploit.

What is a good build these days anyhow? 90 strength right?


+1
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
Wrong, it's fixed now


What happens when a HB with high power and high carry(don't wanna give away builds) hits a LB with 40 tackling and 30 strength?? Flattened!! Problem? Nah, not IMO


Tackling is not a benching contest. Most undersized guys will tackle by taking the legs out of the ball carriers. You don't need to be benching 300 pounds 30 times to take someone's legs out or trip them up. A guy with high power will probably gain more yards after contact, but they are not going to break all the tackles. Power backs are out of whack right now. Talk about speed exploit, power exploit this season is just as bad if not worse.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bongbreath
Originally posted by Crying Eagle

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=88037
We have one of the best Defenses in the league. 30 Missed Tackles???????? Are u serious??????

We are all set to Wrap-up.


I'm not sure what happened, but say you meet a guy with 60 strength, should your 47 tackler take him down all the time?

I finally think the game is starting to get "it" and it's not place all your eggs in one basket.

We've all seen the guy who does nothing but dump points into speed and takes over a game, that time thankfully is over and I couldn't be happier.


If he has 60 strength, and the DT has over 80 strength, why would 47 tackle matter?

Now we have guys dumping all points into strength and dominates, is that really better?
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 11:35:28
 
megaman1337
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gisty
Originally posted by 1VBChaos

Originally posted by Checkmate187


Everybody keeps saying 'raise tackling'

People need to raise their strength.


Let's recap - to be effective, we need points in vision, then tackling, then strength?? Let's not forget we need a huge chunk of stamina - oh, and confidence - not forgetting lots of agility now - oh, and some speed, and a bit of jumping.......

Hell, let's just soft cap EVERY attribute and be done with it - I'm sure kicking will come into play for my DT at some point.........

C'mon guys - you simply CAN'T just add points everywhere - at some point you need to focus on the MAIN attributes - but the thing is, those MAIN attributes keep changing. Things that WORK keep changing.

Balanced builds is DEFINITELY the most realistic way forward - but how the hell can you balance points into 8 or more categories?? At the soft cap, that's about 400 SPs.

That's roughly level 22 without a point spent in SAs - and perhaps 2 and a bit seasons (of playing AND boosting) of being trounced by 'the builds that work' as opposed to the 'right' builds that we all want.

And even once you get there, you're going to be EXACTLY the same as every other player, so will cancel each other out.....and the ones that'll have the edge will be the ones who can afford to 'buy' the SPs, thereby getting to the caps quicker.....

As has been said, we're just bouncing from exploit to exploit and there's a fundimental change required.

Last year it was speed that 'worked', now it's power - what next??

Who knows. All I know is that whilst we're playing and not testing, the exploits will keep getting abused and the 'decent' players will generally be the ones who come off as losers - thereby being the first to leave the game.

And you'll be left, like always, with the 'uber 1337' kids trying to out exploit each other.....

Can't wait.........



QFT



All you can say is quit talking? Come on now, actually refute his points and someone might listen to you.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Originally posted by Checkmate187

Everybody keeps saying 'raise tackling'

People need to raise their strength.


Let's recap - to be effective, we need points in vision, then tackling, then strength?? Let's not forget we need a huge chunk of stamina - oh, and confidence - not forgetting lots of agility now - oh, and some speed, and a bit of jumping.......

Hell, let's just soft cap EVERY attribute and be done with it - I'm sure kicking will come into play for my DT at some point.........

C'mon guys - you simply CAN'T just add points everywhere - at some point you need to focus on the MAIN attributes - but the thing is, those MAIN attributes keep changing. Things that WORK keep changing.

Balanced builds is DEFINITELY the most realistic way forward - but how the hell can you balance points into 8 or more categories?? At the soft cap, that's about 400 SPs.

That's roughly level 22 without a point spent in SAs - and perhaps 2 and a bit seasons (of playing AND boosting) of being trounced by 'the builds that work' as opposed to the 'right' builds that we all want.

And even once you get there, you're going to be EXACTLY the same as every other player, so will cancel each other out.....and the ones that'll have the edge will be the ones who can afford to 'buy' the SPs, thereby getting to the caps quicker.....

As has been said, we're just bouncing from exploit to exploit and there's a fundimental change required.

Last year it was speed that 'worked', now it's power - what next??

Who knows. All I know is that whilst we're playing and not testing, the exploits will keep getting abused and the 'decent' players will generally be the ones who come off as losers - thereby being the first to leave the game.

And you'll be left, like always, with the 'uber 1337' kids trying to out exploit each other.....

Can't wait.........



OMG! You mean we can't design the perfect player who absolutely excels at everything? The horror! What's the fun in that?

You posted as a complaint but I see it as exactly the way the game should be. You can choose to be balanced and mediocre at everything or you can choose to focus in certain areas and be strong in some ways and weak in others.


 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by megaman1337
Originally posted by Gisty

Originally posted by 1VBChaos


Originally posted by Checkmate187



Everybody keeps saying 'raise tackling'

People need to raise their strength.


Let's recap - to be effective, we need points in vision, then tackling, then strength?? Let's not forget we need a huge chunk of stamina - oh, and confidence - not forgetting lots of agility now - oh, and some speed, and a bit of jumping.......

Hell, let's just soft cap EVERY attribute and be done with it - I'm sure kicking will come into play for my DT at some point.........

C'mon guys - you simply CAN'T just add points everywhere - at some point you need to focus on the MAIN attributes - but the thing is, those MAIN attributes keep changing. Things that WORK keep changing.

Balanced builds is DEFINITELY the most realistic way forward - but how the hell can you balance points into 8 or more categories?? At the soft cap, that's about 400 SPs.

That's roughly level 22 without a point spent in SAs - and perhaps 2 and a bit seasons (of playing AND boosting) of being trounced by 'the builds that work' as opposed to the 'right' builds that we all want.

And even once you get there, you're going to be EXACTLY the same as every other player, so will cancel each other out.....and the ones that'll have the edge will be the ones who can afford to 'buy' the SPs, thereby getting to the caps quicker.....

As has been said, we're just bouncing from exploit to exploit and there's a fundimental change required.

Last year it was speed that 'worked', now it's power - what next??

Who knows. All I know is that whilst we're playing and not testing, the exploits will keep getting abused and the 'decent' players will generally be the ones who come off as losers - thereby being the first to leave the game.

And you'll be left, like always, with the 'uber 1337' kids trying to out exploit each other.....

Can't wait.........



QFT



All you can say is quit talking? Come on now, actually refute his points and someone might listen to you.


You might want to do some reserach into what QFT means.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.