User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
dberner30
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dberner30
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=86662&mode=pbp

I have read a lot of threads that debate whether coverage is fixed or not etc. I present this game and our passing attack as a prime example of the problems present. This is a good test case to me. My team has several level 20 range WRs. The no. 1 and 2 are 27 and 26. The opposing defense had a level 22 CB and a bunch of level 9 CBs. Watch our passing game and you will see we were able to abuse the level 22 CB and had success there but teh level 9 guys on the other side held us down. Sometimes the QB threw as the Level 9 was loosing coverage but this seems to highlight the issue. I post this not in hopes of engaging in a long debate with many noted scholars. I think this one is a good one for the trouble shooters like Bort to look at since the wide divergence in CB skills is present from one side of the field to the other and because our WRs are all similary skilled in a general sense. This game should help sort out buggy issues with coverage and you can compare contrast what the CBs are doing.


any commentary on this issue...why do the level 9 cb do okay but the 22 gets beat up...im starting to think it has to do with is that the level 9 doesnt have a high enough skill to react at all so he just lucks out and gets in the way...

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by thunderdoozer


and CBs in Close Aggressive coverage do things like this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92461&pbp_id=3559854


I don't see what's wrong with that play? It looks like he stayed pretty close to me...the guy just made the catch.


I have to admit I didn't think that was that bad.

I'd be happy if my guy just played close, but I've been messing with his build a lot and things are getting a little brighter as far as the results.

It seems like I still get faked on almost every slant play, which is frustrating. I have points in super vision. I dunno.
 
dberner30
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by thunderdoozer



and CBs in Close Aggressive coverage do things like this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92461&pbp_id=3559854


I don't see what's wrong with that play? It looks like he stayed pretty close to me...the guy just made the catch.


WHAT!?!?!

He didn't break on the ball or even react in any way to the play. He left a huge cushion considering the situation and didn't just the route at all. The HAS to be a way to get our guy to make a play on that ball, even if he fails.


and i agree there is a lot wrong here...on the goaline a CB doesnt just backpedal away and let the WR catch the ball under him for the score...that is a rare occurence....

and for what its worth strategy seems to have come down to passing on all 3 downs because eventually you get a completion...all you need is 1 in 3 and you have it set in your mind to give a completion about 50-60%...

 
Link
 
Set to close coverage and medium on ints.

I don't understand why I play off so far here. I see my CB giving up this cushion a lot. Is this a zone play? I don't really see the cushion given up by the other CBs.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=124422&pbp_id=3265985

This play is a pain in the ass. Every time a WR cuts I get left in the dust despite having 4 points in change direction and 50+ agility.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91245&pbp_id=4221988

I can see maybe a fake, but what if anything can I do to fix it?
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dberner30
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by thunderdoozer


and CBs in Close Aggressive coverage do things like this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92461&pbp_id=3559854


I don't see what's wrong with that play? It looks like he stayed pretty close to me...the guy just made the catch.


WHAT!?!?!

He didn't break on the ball or even react in any way to the play. He left a huge cushion considering the situation and didn't just the route at all. The HAS to be a way to get our guy to make a play on that ball, even if he fails.


and i agree there is a lot wrong here...on the goaline a CB doesnt just backpedal away and let the WR catch the ball under him for the score...that is a rare occurence....



I don't think a route like that has ever worked in the endzone in the history of the sport.

In fact, a straight route like that should almost NEVER be open EVER unless the WR burns past the CB or if he button-hooks to make some room short. Instead, straight walking routes like that work 60%-75% of the time.
Last edited Aug 17, 2008 12:20:47
 
Jakemall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by dberner30

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by thunderdoozer



and CBs in Close Aggressive coverage do things like this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92461&pbp_id=3559854


I don't see what's wrong with that play? It looks like he stayed pretty close to me...the guy just made the catch.


WHAT!?!?!

He didn't break on the ball or even react in any way to the play. He left a huge cushion considering the situation and didn't just the route at all. The HAS to be a way to get our guy to make a play on that ball, even if he fails.


and i agree there is a lot wrong here...on the goaline a CB doesnt just backpedal away and let the WR catch the ball under him for the score...that is a rare occurence....



I don't think a route like that has ever worked in the endzone in the history of the sport.

In fact, a straight route like that should almost NEVER be open EVER unless the WR burns past the CB or if he button-hooks to make some room short. Instead, straight walking routes like that work 60%-75% of the time.


Without seeing several plays doing the same thing one could argue the CB was defending against a slant to the corner and then the Wr just did a stop to catch the ball.
 
dberner30
offline
Link
 
real CBs in goal line jam the WR and they stick tight...that is why the fade to the corner gets used so much...you just dont get a free release to run a slant or a free button hook route...just isnt how it works...
 
Jakemall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dberner30
real CBs in goal line jam the WR and they stick tight...that is why the fade to the corner gets used so much...you just dont get a free release to run a slant or a free button hook route...just isnt how it works...


Maybe, but we don't seem to have Jamming and bumps off the line in this game yet.
 
GreyFoxTBC
offline
Link
 
Well I guess frustration for players should count a little. I am a huge football
fan and I'd love to see the game be as realistic as possible. Yet when someone
gives you a play to look at, Wide receiver numbers, CB numbers, I would think this
is exactly what a developer would like to look at. yet every time I go to the
trouble of looking all the specifics up and asking a question (this is the 3rd
time I've given very specific numbers on a question) I usually get dumb answers
from the "all knowing" players out there and silence from Bort. So maybe I'll just
give up on actually trying to give input
 
TDmaker99
offline
Link
 
Im gonna throw my 2 cents in here, which I know doesnt mean a whole lot but here goes

Last season we had great DB's, in fact we won the league because of them, this season even when we go up against lower wr's they catch everything even in double, and triple coverage

In man coverage the DB will drop back and then stop which gives the wr a huge edge because the WR's momentum will carry him past the DB, and becasue the DB's reaction time was f'd with you cant play medium coverage or the QB will nickel and dime you to death, and to top it off wr's with low catching complained so much that now they catch everything

so DB's are pretty much screwed this season, but atleast it effects everyone so it all evens out

 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
When LBs with run focus are doing this in man coverage: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92442&pbp_id=4073848

and CBs in Close Aggressive coverage do things like this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92461&pbp_id=3559854

and when a level 7 does this to a level 26 because of whining about averages being low in season 3: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92493&pbp_id=2655910

...tactics and build become irrelevant.

Strategy becomes irrelevant.



Yeah, and when level 17 RBs do things like this to level 25 LBs that outweigh them by 70 lbs, it makes me wanna stop watching football!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PXeAG2VuBo0
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Johnny_Johnson


Good lord dude, is that avatar legal!? o_o
 
Sledge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PinTBC

Originally posted by Bort


I hope that didn't come off like I'm trying to be a jerk, because I'm not. It's just tough to balance actual work with pleasing the masses asking for answers. Sometimes I have to just ignore the forum in order to get anything done (it sucks you in, ya know?)


OK Bort, a design question for you.

If a CB and WR are equally well trained, what percentage are you looking to average for a completed pass? We won't get into what equally well trained is, but there has to be some kind of number you would be aiming for.

I'm not asking to start a flame war, I am simply asking to try to understand your theory on offense and defense, and the relevance of attributes, training, and tactics settings.

By the way, please don't let any complaining slow you down from the adjustments you feel the game needs. The longer it takes to get them in, the more complaining you are going to see. It's like a bandage, pull it off slow or fast, it still a pain.

PinTBC


I'm generally looking for completion rates in the range from 50-65% when everybody's pretty evenly matched and the QB doesn't completely suck ass. Sometimes a little higher or lower, depending on builds, etc, but I'd like to see things close to the realm of realism.


So what you mean Bort is that if I just set my tactics for long bombs that the I'm Looking at a 50% to 65 % completion rate ...Wow..I'll take that...I know in the Nfl that kinda completion rate on the long stuff is much much lower....The longer the range of the throw the lower the avg to make the play. I know you have been collecting data. Check out the over 10 yard completions from last season to this one its a real eye opener. No wonder there are so few punts .

I know you are trying to get close to nfl avg's on rb's and wr's but have you also looked at the avg number of punts in the nfl per game. When 2 good teams meet in the sim now they are lucky to have 3 to 5 punts combined between the 2 teams. I have seen games with pretty evenly matched teams where teams dont even have a punt for the game.

Send me a note and i'll give ya some links...Its getting Kinda pathetic.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sledge

So what you mean Bort is that if I just set my tactics for long bombs that the I'm Looking at a 50% to 65 % completion rate ...Wow..I'll take that...I know in the Nfl that kinda completion rate on the long stuff is much much lower....


No, I'm looking for 50-60% on short and medium length passes. Long passes are harder to catch, obviously.
 
Jakemall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Sledge


So what you mean Bort is that if I just set my tactics for long bombs that the I'm Looking at a 50% to 65 % completion rate ...Wow..I'll take that...I know in the Nfl that kinda completion rate on the long stuff is much much lower....


No, I'm looking for 50-60% on short and medium length passes. Long passes are harder to catch, obviously.


I hope that's not a blanket statement or a lot of possession WRs will be out of a job.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.