User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Undead Merchant
The dots are three yards wide. If someone is covered by three people in the game, they could easily be three yards away from him each way. Also, the replays aren't exactly what happens, the text says what happens, go by that, and don't complain if the replay is a little off. And yes, recievers in real life can catch the ball in double coverage and even triple coverage.


How often does that happen to WRs not named Moss or TO when covered by 3 guys all around them? Almost never.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Checkmate187

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by Bort



I guess you'd rather go back to 40% completion rates and 1.5 ypa? Players have to be able to catch the ball sometimes, especially when defenders play on aggressive and miss the int attempt. It's just a random roll - if the 3 players were in position, they get to make a roll vs the player's catching ability to tip the ball. If they all miss the roll, the receiver gets to make a roll vs the defenders' tipping ability to catch the ball.


No Bort but I must say when a guy is in double and triple coverage he shouldn't be able to catch the ball.


That is the most absurd thing I have ever heard you say.


How is it absurd at all? In real life, how many WRs can catch the ball when the LB and CB have them perfectly covered and the FS is sitting behind them? The only guys I can think of are guys like Moss and TO and no one on this game has 99 jumping and 99 catching.


It's absurd to say that a guy in double or triple coverage should 'never' catch a ball. Of course his chances are greatly reduced, but to say it will never happen is silly. (I was sick of saying 'absurd')
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Checkmate187


Originally posted by jrry32



Originally posted by Bort




I guess you'd rather go back to 40% completion rates and 1.5 ypa? Players have to be able to catch the ball sometimes, especially when defenders play on aggressive and miss the int attempt. It's just a random roll - if the 3 players were in position, they get to make a roll vs the player's catching ability to tip the ball. If they all miss the roll, the receiver gets to make a roll vs the defenders' tipping ability to catch the ball.


No Bort but I must say when a guy is in double and triple coverage he shouldn't be able to catch the ball.


That is the most absurd thing I have ever heard you say.


How is it absurd at all? In real life, how many WRs can catch the ball when the LB and CB have them perfectly covered and the FS is sitting behind them? The only guys I can think of are guys like Moss and TO and no one on this game has 99 jumping and 99 catching.


It's absurd to say that a guy in double or triple coverage should 'never' catch a ball. Of course his chances are greatly reduced, but to say it will never happen is silly. (I was sick of saying 'absurd')


Ok his chances should be barely anything at all but instead it happens around 5 times a game.
 
hntrr31
offline
Link
 
Then checkmate, we agree apparently. I'm not saying it never happens, and neither is jrry. But the chance of this happening should be rare. Not 40-60% of the time.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by TreMetal

Originally posted by Bort


I guess you'd rather go back to 40% completion rates and 1.5 ypa? Players have to be able to catch the ball sometimes, especially when defenders play on aggressive and miss the int attempt. It's just a random roll - if the 3 players were in position, they get to make a roll vs the player's catching ability to tip the ball. If they all miss the roll, the receiver gets to make a roll vs the defenders' tipping ability to catch the ball.


Shouldn't multiple defenders reduce the WR's catching roll as well? I mean, 2 or 3 "average" defenders should be able to shut down one "very good" WR, but if it is just their individually 3 rolls vs the WRs 1 roll, obviously 55, 60, 65 vs 80+ is not gonna win..


It does...but they can still catch the ball if the rolls go their way.


Basically, the Odds where not in the TE's favor, but he won a mini lottery...duh!
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
I agree with both of you. Should only be like 1 or 2 in a hundred. But with the way the system is (basically dice rolls), it obviously takes time to tweak it to realistic levels.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Undead Merchant

The dots are three yards wide. If someone is covered by three people in the game, they could easily be three yards away from him each way. Also, the replays aren't exactly what happens, the text says what happens, go by that, and don't complain if the replay is a little off. And yes, recievers in real life can catch the ball in double coverage and even triple coverage.


How often does that happen to WRs not named Moss or TO when covered by 3 guys all around them? Almost never.


On a very long pass, it happens, the defenders converge and go for the jump ball.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
I agree with both of you. Should only be like 1 or 2 in a hundred. But with the way the system is (basically dice rolls), it obviously takes time to tweak it to realistic levels.


And if it is a RNG, that is gonna take more time, not that I have an advanced knowledge of how the RNG works, but I see Random, and I think, hmm...no presets in the rolls
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by TreMetal


Originally posted by Bort



I guess you'd rather go back to 40% completion rates and 1.5 ypa? Players have to be able to catch the ball sometimes, especially when defenders play on aggressive and miss the int attempt. It's just a random roll - if the 3 players were in position, they get to make a roll vs the player's catching ability to tip the ball. If they all miss the roll, the receiver gets to make a roll vs the defenders' tipping ability to catch the ball.


Shouldn't multiple defenders reduce the WR's catching roll as well? I mean, 2 or 3 "average" defenders should be able to shut down one "very good" WR, but if it is just their individually 3 rolls vs the WRs 1 roll, obviously 55, 60, 65 vs 80+ is not gonna win..


It does...but they can still catch the ball if the rolls go their way.


Basically, the Odds where not in the TE's favor, but he won a mini lottery...duh!


This should be true. Making that kind of catch should be a lottery catch, or at least close to it, but right now its a 50/50 thing.
 
hntrr31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
I agree with both of you. Should only be like 1 or 2 in a hundred. But with the way the system is (basically dice rolls), it obviously takes time to tweak it to realistic levels.


Okay, so my apologies to Bort for being pissy. But realism should be the goal, even if it hurts (me).
 
Vagrant God
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Undead Merchant

The dots are three yards wide. If someone is covered by three people in the game, they could easily be three yards away from him each way. Also, the replays aren't exactly what happens, the text says what happens, go by that, and don't complain if the replay is a little off. And yes, recievers in real life can catch the ball in double coverage and even triple coverage.


How often does that happen to WRs not named Moss or TO when covered by 3 guys all around them? Almost never.


Tyree in the damn superbowl. Steve Smith of the NYG made a catch with two guys on top of him when the ball reached him in an earlier game. Shockey in the 2007 season made a catch while being hit to the ground by two people. Plaxico Burress made a catch in double coverage with a guy in front of him, and another right behind him.

IT HAPPENS!!!

Deal with it. Go watch a youtube video of the Panther's Steve Smith and you'll find a few.
Last edited Aug 15, 2008 10:57:57
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
In all fairness, I have been making tweaks on the test server and running test sims, looking at passing/catching, as well as blocking. I'm just avoiding uploading any drastic changes to avoid the "waah...moving target" crowd.
 
hntrr31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Undead Merchant
...and you'll find a few.


QFT.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stahu miguel
Originally posted by Checkmate187

I agree with both of you. Should only be like 1 or 2 in a hundred. But with the way the system is (basically dice rolls), it obviously takes time to tweak it to realistic levels.


Okay, so my apologies to Bort for being pissy. But realism should be the goal, even if it hurts (me).


Eh, no biggie, you caught me early in the day before the processed yeast and hops hit my system.

There are some things that aggravate me with the sim, too... but I know Bort is working VERY hard to make this game as realistic as possible. And I can't imagine the length of the list of things he is working on, but I know that this is one of them.

When I get pissed off I just fall back on my Jedi training. Very useful.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
In all fairness, I have been making tweaks on the test server and running test sims, looking at passing/catching, as well as blocking. I'm just avoiding uploading any drastic changes to avoid the "waah...moving target" crowd.


Wise move . . . as long as the changes aren't drastic, and I don't think they need to be drastic, there's no need to give peeps an excuse.

I just know good pass defenses have been drastically impacted by the latest publicized tweaks.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.