User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by xeef

My DTs work. Break through works, Ive found it to be very helpful. You have to realize that most OL are as strong as most DL, or stronger. Its not realistic for a DT to break through 2 guys as strong as he is on every play.




arteryman, here's Bort's answer.
 
cbo0485
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by cbo0485

Originally posted by datongw


Originally posted by xeef



My DTs work. Break through works, Ive found it to be very helpful. You have to realize that most OL are as strong as most DL, or stronger. Its not realistic for a DT to break through 2 guys as strong as he is on every play.


I assume you are talking about "Son of Doo Rag"? By work do you mean 0 sacks, 10 hurries in 3 seasons? 3 missed tackles and 0 tackle for losses in 6 games this season?


I think he means that he takes on the double team, and makes it so there is one less blocker in the secondary for his defense to worry about.


Doesn't the NT gets double teamed most of the time even if you don't have a single point in break through?


My comment is more towards the fact that if you don't have a very good build, you won't get a long double team, it'll be a quick one where either the guard or center runs further and gets a block on a LB or a safety. If your guy is good enough that it takes two people to block you, it leaves a LB or safety un-blocked.
 
arteryman
offline
Link
 
Woops I'm blind thanks Datongw
 
xeef
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by xeef

My DTs work. Break through works, Ive found it to be very helpful. You have to realize that most OL are as strong as most DL, or stronger. Its not realistic for a DT to break through 2 guys as strong as he is on every play.


I assume you are talking about "Son of Doo Rag"? By work do you mean 0 sacks, 10 hurries in 3 seasons? 3 missed tackles and 0 tackle for losses in 6 games this season?


Technically, if you had selected a DT that STARTS, like Hilo Stud, you might get a more accurate assesment.
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by xeef

My DTs work. Break through works, Ive found it to be very helpful. You have to realize that most OL are as strong as most DL, or stronger. Its not realistic for a DT to break through 2 guys as strong as he is on every play.





Not really buying it Bort. I see O-line specials working all the time. I never see D-line specials working. Single or double teamed, unless you outlevel them by a ridiculous amount your NT isn't going anywhere and he isn't making plays.

No one expects their NT to blow through the defenders every play, but we would damn sure love to see it every now and then.

Let me put this another way. The NT's build is a GIVEN. There is nothing to get creative with, no way to get a mismatch or advantage. The matchup is based puring on your strength and agility versus one or two almost identical opponents, and THEY have the advantage of special abilities that actually function working for them as well. There's no variety in build, no variety in tactics, your NT isn't going to actually DO anything in the game, and your specials don't even create an outside random chance of success. Your character is just an imobile dot on the field.

Lame. This needs to be fixed.
Last edited Aug 14, 2008 21:41:42
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbo0485
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by cbo0485


Originally posted by datongw



Originally posted by xeef




My DTs work. Break through works, Ive found it to be very helpful. You have to realize that most OL are as strong as most DL, or stronger. Its not realistic for a DT to break through 2 guys as strong as he is on every play.


I assume you are talking about "Son of Doo Rag"? By work do you mean 0 sacks, 10 hurries in 3 seasons? 3 missed tackles and 0 tackle for losses in 6 games this season?


I think he means that he takes on the double team, and makes it so there is one less blocker in the secondary for his defense to worry about.


Doesn't the NT gets double teamed most of the time even if you don't have a single point in break through?


My comment is more towards the fact that if you don't have a very good build, you won't get a long double team, it'll be a quick one where either the guard or center runs further and gets a block on a LB or a safety. If your guy is good enough that it takes two people to block you, it leaves a LB or safety un-blocked.


I hear ya, but this thread is about a specific special skill not working. NT should be double teamed, but with "break through" you would think that the NT will actually "break through" once in a while. Not every play, but at least once in a while.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xeef
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by xeef


My DTs work. Break through works, Ive found it to be very helpful. You have to realize that most OL are as strong as most DL, or stronger. Its not realistic for a DT to break through 2 guys as strong as he is on every play.


I assume you are talking about "Son of Doo Rag"? By work do you mean 0 sacks, 10 hurries in 3 seasons? 3 missed tackles and 0 tackle for losses in 6 games this season?


Technically, if you had selected a DT that STARTS, like Hilo Stud, you might get a more accurate assesment.


Ok didn't see him. But Hilo Stud plays the DT position, at least he played DT for the game in which he had all his 5 sacks (0 sacks in other games this season).

Again, we are talking about a special skill that's supposed to help the NT break double teams.
 
arteryman
offline
Link
 
I completely agree that Break Thru (with enough points invested) should work 2-4 times per game. In real football there are always those plays where the lineman slips through two blocks, why can't the same be true with our linemen? We aren't necessarily out strengthening the double team, simply "breaking through" between the blocks because the OL couldnt get a full block on the player.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by arteryman
I completely agree that Break Thru (with enough points invested) should work 2-4 times per game. In real football there are always those plays where the lineman slips through two blocks, why can't the same be true with our linemen? We aren't necessarily out strengthening the double team, simply "breaking through" between the blocks because the OL couldnt get a full block on the player.


Yeah, you would think that's what this SA should do. Maybe you should pump more SPs into it.
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by arteryman

I completely agree that Break Thru (with enough points invested) should work 2-4 times per game. In real football there are always those plays where the lineman slips through two blocks, why can't the same be true with our linemen? We aren't necessarily out strengthening the double team, simply "breaking through" between the blocks because the OL couldnt get a full block on the player.


Yeah, you would think that's what this SA should do. Maybe you should pump more SPs into it.


At what point should it work? Five? Seven? Ten? More?

Right now the NT is the most uniquely unrewarding class in the game. If you build it correctly, just like every other NT, you are rewarded by a character that basically does nothing at all on passing plays, and gets shoved aside on runs. If you deviate from the norm you get flattened. Worse still, the O-lines abilities work just fine, so you get the dubious pleasure of watching your character get hurled sideways every few seconds.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
You have to take pleasure in others sucess. You gobble up double, sometimes triple teams. (thats how I know break thru works, sometime they throw the FB at me, sometimes they don't). Plus you get to be a general and make everyone better. NT are cool.
 
SoCalWhoDat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
You have to take pleasure in others sucess. You gobble up double, sometimes triple teams. (thats how I know break thru works, sometime they throw the FB at me, sometimes they don't). Plus you get to be a general and make everyone better. NT are cool.


It's the healer class of GLB it seems
 
grugnur
offline
Link
 
in my opinion, this game can only approach a certain level of realism... i don't believe that it really matters (anymore) how you build your DL player, you will be limited... if the DL becomes too dominant, the it stifles the entire offense and how can that be fun??? it's obvious that the game has become more friendly to the offense... it's obvious that my NT no longer runs over any OL anymore, not even on occasion (yeah, i'm sure some will cry "bad build" but lower level OL easily contain me)... now, when i'm engaged with the OL and the FB or HB comes along, it causes me to miss the tackle (which i think is fair)... last week my toon stopped the FB 2 yards short of the goal (looked like a loss to me) but somehow he miraculously made it into the end zone... was it his special ability to gain extra yards??? is it that the sim is not a reliable representation??? when do my special abilities kick in??? they happened last season, but no more

bottom line, let's be fair and drop them from the normal position to the non-glamour category to coincide with this season's changes
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sleepingazure
Originally posted by Jose Bagg

You have to take pleasure in others sucess. You gobble up double, sometimes triple teams. (thats how I know break thru works, sometime they throw the FB at me, sometimes they don't). Plus you get to be a general and make everyone better. NT are cool.


It's the healer class of GLB it seems


Not so... in other MMO's the "healer" is noticeable. He is casting flashy spells keeping everyone alive and moving lifebars. It might be electronic whack-a-mole, but there is at least that -- and it often takes incredible skill (that often gets recognized).

Here the perfect NT does nothing at all. His every point is pre-alocated (as there is only one way to build the class) so there is no pleasure in watching the toon grow and improve. Even the non-glory Offensive linemen get the satisfaction of watching their guy shove the D-line around.
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by grugnur
in my opinion, this game can only approach a certain level of realism... i don't believe that it really matters (anymore) how you build your DL player, you will be limited... if the DL becomes too dominant, the it stifles the entire offense and how can that be fun??? it's obvious that the game has become more friendly to the offense... it's obvious that my NT no longer runs over any OL anymore, not even on occasion (yeah, i'm sure some will cry "bad build" but lower level OL easily contain me)... now, when i'm engaged with the OL and the FB or HB comes along, it causes me to miss the tackle (which i think is fair)... last week my toon stopped the FB 2 yards short of the goal (looked like a loss to me) but somehow he miraculously made it into the end zone... was it his special ability to gain extra yards??? is it that the sim is not a reliable representation??? when do my special abilities kick in??? they happened last season, but no more

bottom line, let's be fair and drop them from the normal position to the non-glamour category to coincide with this season's changes


Fair enough. Make it a non-glory class and refund the SP people have spent boosting them.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.