User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Bort, KR has to be fixed soon please.
Page:
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
It has to do with the "elusive bug" guys (I modified things KR's wouldn't stutter around all the time) - that's the real problem that I haven't worked out yet.


It'd be nice to see this get high priority (over things like friendly scrimmages and the like) because the elusive has ruined elusive HBs, damaged WRs and PR/KR. That seems like it should merit some priority attention. (I realize it's probably not an easy fix, and I realize that you have thousands of people dragging you in thousands of directions, but I'd like to vote to move this problem up the priority list.)

T
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Wayland
Why not just keep the vision radius high but reduce the radius on stutter step so they will only do it when the tackler is close? (I know things may not be coded that way, but I like the concept).


perfect, bort if you can code it like this it should be fine.
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by Wayland

Why not just keep the vision radius high but reduce the radius on stutter step so they will only do it when the tackler is close? (I know things may not be coded that way, but I like the concept).


perfect, bort if you can code it like this it should be fine.


I think what Bort was saying was that elusive running causes stutter stepping, stutter stepping is not something that is specifically programmed into the game, it is an unfortunate byproduct of the elusive pathfinding.

I do agree though, that he should revert to those previous settings and that there should be a statement in bold caps on everyone's home page saying:

DON'T USE ELUSIVE RUNNING, IT SUCKS

Or better yet, just remove combo running and make it elusive and have two settings, power and elusive.



 
danpenc918
offline
Link
 
I don't know -- the returners on both of the teams that I GM have had returns of 57.5, 60 and 87.5 in the last week plus several other long ones.

One is a HB and the other is a CB.

Maybe it is because I gave my brother the ST Coordinator job -- if it worked for the Schottenheimers .......
 
Gtalover16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
my KR/CB has plenty of vision and agility and still runs straight. He also has the KR Specialist SA and it doesn't seem to help. I am not the only person to bring this up. Here are some replays.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91171&pbp_id=3219919

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91171&pbp_id=3220672

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91171&pbp_id=3221685
maybe he just sucks? my KR is killing his league and he is only level 5

 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Your kick returner average 27.5 yds per return. That is far from killing.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Bort - Tough to speak to this without knowing exactly how the parsing works, but it seems like there should be two circles of awareness. One for pathfinding and one for "move making".

I'm guessing that the current problem is that the player makes a pathfinding decision based on what it perceives as the best option, yet as players move around the field, another option may suddenly be better and then a second later, yet another option is seen as better.

If you have two circles of awareness, set the pathfinding circle to make a determination, say every 5 yards with current direction being weighted more favorably as well as a decreasing weighting ranging form 0 degrees to +/- 110 degrees (I'm guessing there's something like the second part of this already in place). This keeps the player from stutter stepping to change directions to constantly changing options when players are some distance from them.

The second circle of awareness, is set up pretty much as it is now with a very small radius, allowing the player to make "move" decisions more quickly based on players within a close range and occurs very quickly (at whatever rate it's set to make that determination now).

Both circles are operating concurrently, with one making a decision either every 5 yards or every so many ms and the other closer range one making constant determinations.

Would that work?
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I think going back to the old "vision" for KR/PR is the best course, and if people choose to put their guys on elusive with the well known bug, that is their choice.

That said, I think it is worthwhile to make combo the new elusive, set up a new combo in between power and combo, and leave power as it is. Then keep playing with the "elusive" setting on a test server until you get it how you want it Bort (i.e. Barry Sanders-esque moves)
 
bruser23
offline
Link
 
It seems the runners are just indecisive they seem to stubble around rather than hitting a hole and only changing directions when it's necessary

Just pointing out the obvious.

Last edited Aug 15, 2008 16:08:20
 
hep
offline
Link
 
I'm just speculating on the game mechanics, and I am assuming that the problem with elusive running style is a pathing problem, but why not just make elusive running style (for both HBs and KR/PRs) use agility to break a tackle (or a block in a RDEs case) like strength currently does for a power runner (i.e. a calculation at the point of contact instead of a pathing consideration). Seems elusive is tied too much to vision (pathing) right now (and broken). SAs like juke, return specialist would heighten the chance to break a tackle much like lower shoulder does for a power runner. Maybe tweak the text derived graphic to give the guy a lil' shimmy or something to add realism
Last edited Aug 15, 2008 17:08:49
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Bort - Tough to speak to this without knowing exactly how the parsing works, but it seems like there should be two circles of awareness. One for pathfinding and one for "move making".

I'm guessing that the current problem is that the player makes a pathfinding decision based on what it perceives as the best option, yet as players move around the field, another option may suddenly be better and then a second later, yet another option is seen as better.

If you have two circles of awareness, set the pathfinding circle to make a determination, say every 5 yards with current direction being weighted more favorably as well as a decreasing weighting ranging form 0 degrees to +/- 110 degrees (I'm guessing there's something like the second part of this already in place). This keeps the player from stutter stepping to change directions to constantly changing options when players are some distance from them.

The second circle of awareness, is set up pretty much as it is now with a very small radius, allowing the player to make "move" decisions more quickly based on players within a close range and occurs very quickly (at whatever rate it's set to make that determination now).

Both circles are operating concurrently, with one making a decision either every 5 yards or every so many ms and the other closer range one making constant determinations.

Would that work?


 
hep
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by drifter

Bort - Tough to speak to this without knowing exactly how the parsing works, but it seems like there should be two circles of awareness. One for pathfinding and one for "move making".

I'm guessing that the current problem is that the player makes a pathfinding decision based on what it perceives as the best option, yet as players move around the field, another option may suddenly be better and then a second later, yet another option is seen as better.

If you have two circles of awareness, set the pathfinding circle to make a determination, say every 5 yards with current direction being weighted more favorably as well as a decreasing weighting ranging form 0 degrees to +/- 110 degrees (I'm guessing there's something like the second part of this already in place). This keeps the player from stutter stepping to change directions to constantly changing options when players are some distance from them.

The second circle of awareness, is set up pretty much as it is now with a very small radius, allowing the player to make "move" decisions more quickly based on players within a close range and occurs very quickly (at whatever rate it's set to make that determination now).

Both circles are operating concurrently, with one making a decision either every 5 yards or every so many ms and the other closer range one making constant determinations.

Would that work?




I am talking more of a 'point of contact' calculation than a very narrow 'inner circle' (if I understand your post correctly). Similar, but not quite the same thing. If set to elisive the tackle/mis-tackle calculation uses primarily agility/carrying/SAs/etc. on the runner's part (vs. the agility/tackling/etc. of the defender). If set to power, the calculation becomes more of a strength/carrying/SAs/etc. vs. the defender's strength/tackling/etc. (as it is now). Vision would affect pathing only (the "outer circle" you describe), not unlike vision affects power backs as it is now (????). Graphics derived from the text based outcome could give a little wiggle on an 'elusive mis tackle' to let us know what happened

Last edited Aug 15, 2008 18:03:08
 
HERO
offline
Link
 
I would also like to see this fixed. Now, since this is not the NFL I don't mind seeing CBs with an added "advantage" to run kick returns. However, my guy does not stutter step anymore but he does pick a defender and run right into the guy. That's incredible frustrating. I know Bort said that returners wouldn't be able to see guys coming as soon as they used to but this is ridiculous. My returner is averaging over 4 yards less on kick returns (30.4 last year/26.2 this year) and almost 5 yards less on punt returns (16 last year/11.1 this year).

However, I really enjoy this game even through the bugs and I'll continue to build my guy the way I think he should be built having faith that Bort will fix this and my guy will be lights out. We don't all get the areas that we want fixed right away but I've played a lot of games and I haven't seen any other owner/developer work as hard, be quick to respond, or as active in the forums as Bort. He has a lot of work to do and I believe he is doing it.

This part of the game is broken in a sense, he's aware of it, and he's working on it so let's have some patience.
 
DAKING
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
my KR/CB has plenty of vision and agility and still runs straight. He also has the KR Specialist SA and it doesn't seem to help. I am not the only person to bring this up. Here are some replays.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91171&pbp_id=3219919

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91171&pbp_id=3220672

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91171&pbp_id=3221685


Actually the front office had defenders on the first KOS
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Bort - Tough to speak to this without knowing exactly how the parsing works, but it seems like there should be two circles of awareness. One for pathfinding and one for "move making".

I'm guessing that the current problem is that the player makes a pathfinding decision based on what it perceives as the best option, yet as players move around the field, another option may suddenly be better and then a second later, yet another option is seen as better.

If you have two circles of awareness, set the pathfinding circle to make a determination, say every 5 yards with current direction being weighted more favorably as well as a decreasing weighting ranging form 0 degrees to +/- 110 degrees (I'm guessing there's something like the second part of this already in place). This keeps the player from stutter stepping to change directions to constantly changing options when players are some distance from them.

The second circle of awareness, is set up pretty much as it is now with a very small radius, allowing the player to make "move" decisions more quickly based on players within a close range and occurs very quickly (at whatever rate it's set to make that determination now).

Both circles are operating concurrently, with one making a decision either every 5 yards or every so many ms and the other closer range one making constant determinations.

Would that work?


Might work...in a modified fashion...at least for the kick returning. I would have to give it a try. I've tried other suggested solutions (like updating the path only X number of ticks) and they haven't worked very well, though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.