User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Boost DBs back to 40-50% of what they were before the nerf
Page:
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Just a general note on all of this stuff - I'll be working on balance for a while through testing with the live team data I dumped about a week ago. I think the main problem in perception is that people are seeing the WR still not getting open as often as I'd like, and passes get completed when the dots overlap. This is generally just the WR winning the swat vs catch check. The odds are actually 50/50 if the two guys are even in comparison of those two skill formulas. It's possible the penalty for being covered isn't high enough, or that the fake out delay needs to have a longer delay chance to allow for a little more separation in general.

Also, most of the CB's are playing "aggressive" style in which they will go for the interception every time. This gives them less chance to bat the ball down if they don't make their INT check.

I'm pretty much planning on keeping the sim as is for a while though, unless I find some bugs to fix, since everybody's been complaining about the "moving target" syndrome.


Thanks for the tips, they may be able to help some of us. While these may help, I believe there is an even larger issue at stake here.

From what I have learned through bitter experience, if a customer is to be loyal and a business sustainable, certain key things need to be in place. I believe I know of a possible solutio to not only keep the customer happy, but keep them returning for the long run while even improving the realism of this game.

From what I have learned from starting and running 2 of my own businesses, the "rich get richer" and the "poor get poorer" mentality is best to be avoided as much as possible. Every customer is my businesses most valuable asset and if the product I offer keeps costing them even more money every time they use it, eventually they will stop purchasing from me. In this same respect, I believe everyone should have the chance to make their players winners throughout the season or else undesirable consequences can and are likely to eventually take place to this game's customer base.

That which will IMO be the most realistic solution is the same one that will keep this business in it for the long run. Example, the New York Giants didn't let their early season losses get to them as it is with morale here. They persevered, stuck to their guns, improved and against all odds, and consistently beat teams that were obvious favorites all the way through the Super Bowl. The Giants turned a poor first half into the best second half that anyone could ever ask for, even beating teams that had earlier handed them large losses earlier in the season.

The way GLB is now, it is nearly impossible to pull together this type of Championship comeback with the morale loss you incur in the beginning of the season from playing teams who currently outmatch you. This is doubly so when you face the very toughest teams in the league first. The morale loss you incur vs that competition is liable to make your team inferior to a team that you could have just as easily beaten normally.

My team is currently in this situation and I feel like I'm letting my players down because of it, when in reality it's just how the game is designed to be. I am a dedicated player, but I know of some who are not as dedicated as me who are liable to send their money elsewhere if it seems hopeless to get anything out of this game, let alone win vs similar competition or even make the playoffs.

For what is in my opinion in the best interest of this business and its customers alike, I ask that if these new changes are to stay the same another element be added allowing us have "come-back potential" or something of that nature just like the Giants showed us was entirely within the realm of possibility last season. This may be able to reduce customer turnover, increase sales, reduce complaints, add to realism, and just be win-win situation in general for everyone involved here.
 
tedtinker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
This is in response to the "Nerf WR's back somewhat" thread. Personally, I don't think that's the problem so much as Bort nerfing the DBs too much (over correcting seems to be a problem in every walk of life). Now, against good WRs, it's like the DBs' only purpose is to make TKLs, as they get eaten alive by good WRs, even when the WRs are blanketted in double coverage. I just think Bort took the nerf too far and everything would be about right if he shot for around the 1/2 way point between where they were and where they are now. For teams with good WRs, it's almost foolish to even run.


I actually think that it is more realistic now. Good CBs need to be very close in agility/speed, and have their vision over 50. Too many CB owners have dumped all their skill points into SAs and speed only. Big mistake. We have a CB with 60/60 speed/agility, and 55 vision who has shut down all comers with medium coverage. You must have high agility to make breaks on the ball.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Just like it was true in my topic, it's still true that stats are unrealistic now. Just because the offense looks good doesn't mean the defense isn't completely fucked. I can't fathom how I can keep saying this and a handful of you who were in my topic as well just ignore it and keep saying that it's realistic when it obviously isnt.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Magnitude
So...basically what you mean is

"OMG I'M GETTIN' MOSSED, COS I CANNOT MAKE A DECENT DB!"


My CB is playing just as well it seems, just not as many picks as last year but hey, every other stat is on pace to match.

 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
If going for an INT reduces your chance for a swat we really need an option to go for the INT based on downs and length of pass. That way you can bat down longer pass (if you choose) and passes on downs of your choice, while still allowing you to go for the INT in some scenarios.

Edit: For example:

Style: [Always go for it, if cover over the top, never go for it]
Unless: Pass is [_] to [_] yards or it is down [_] to [_]
Last edited Aug 13, 2008 12:32:31
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GO TEXANS
All we hear about is how agents building CB's ignored base skills.Well guess what so did the agents building WR's and trust me I know cause I own both.My WR has no catching skills yet he eats CB's alive and this should not be so.


My WR has has a very solid build and still only puts up decent numbers most games. My CB's with low strength and tackling are missing some tackles now, but I've got pretty balanced builds there too and they're still respectable. Interceptions are down, but as a team owner and someone with both a high level WR and CB, I'm happy with how things are now.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
I admit to my DBs in general having a very good game today with some tweaking to our settings. I haven't watched the replay, but if those tweaks managed to stop the dot on dot but WR still catches the ball every time, then I am OK with the settings. That was by far my biggest beef with the way things were going.

PinTBC
 
Jathin
offline
Link
 
you know i read this whole forum and the only thing i could come up with is that some of you have crappy builds on your WR. My lvl 24 WR isnt a speed demon and he isnt super agile. He is balanced. going into his thrid season. Was on the conference top ten for most catches/ first downs/ and yardage last season.

Seems to me you just want to bitch cause your guy isnt breaking for a touchdown everytime anymore. DEAL!

And look at the pro's since it was mentioned. How often do you really see a solid CB get an int that wasnt a QB screw up. the percentages arent that high. CBs are there to make it a difficult situation and to pervent end zone runs.

Learn the game

JMHO
Last edited Aug 13, 2008 23:09:13
 
Nat Belmont
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Revelation


The way GLB is now, it is nearly impossible to pull together this type of Championship comeback with the morale loss you incur in the beginning of the season from playing teams who currently outmatch you. This is doubly so when you face the very toughest teams in the league first. The morale loss you incur vs that competition is liable to make your team inferior to a team that you could have just as easily beaten normally.


I disagree. Last year I was on a team that started the season 0-7-0 and finished 7-9-1, with no significant roster changes. We just needed one more upset to make the playoffs. The morale damage can't have been very significant.
Last edited Aug 14, 2008 02:53:20
 
fakesanta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GO TEXANS
....you can tell who has QB,s and WR,s along with who has CB's.


i have built both up to level 29 and i can say that the CB's are WAY underpowered. interceptions are down big time, and they don't deflect shit anymore
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
I own a CB myself and have no complaints.
 
nitetrain
offline
Link
 
Stop with the nerfs, stop with the changes, and for the love of god. If there is a change please make an announcement to the effect "we are changing this position".

But when is this nerfing crap going to stop, you change one position someone is going to cry change at the opposite position. This will just go back and forth between offense and defense, it is a never ending process..

I dont understand what all the complaints are for. I have 3 WR's and 3 CB's. One is leading in PD, one has 3 INT. 2 of my WR's are in top ten of receiving yards..

And dont pull this crap about crappy competition. I faced 4 of the top 5 teams in the conference already..2 teams had 6-9 more points then my team in the overall matchup score..

I used common sense with my builds and it has paid off. You know why, because I have searched and searched throughout threads of Borts postings, and the common denominator of his comments was "Use Common Sense"

Just because someone cries about their crappy builds, of course there is going to be a hundred more, due to the fact of the numbers involved with this game..

So,BORT, please stop with the changes, let the game be played..Stop giving in to the users that have not used common sense when building their players..

 
keedon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
Originally posted by Magnitude

So...basically what you mean is

"OMG I'M GETTIN' MOSSED, COS I CANNOT MAKE A DECENT DB!"


Oh, great come back. Between my 7 DBs and the 4 other teams I work with (one I'm not a GM of), we have every conceivable CB build out there. We have speed guys, we have balanced, we have high catch and jump, ton in shutdown and swat ball, some with super vision that Superman would envy and so on, yet every time any of them come up against a good WR they get absolutely owned? You're right....Since they all are getting absolutely toasted since the nerf, none of the 20 or so agents is capable of making a decent DB. I think after you get out of grade school, you may want to look into becoming a rocket scientist or brain surgeon. I knew I'd get ripped for this post, and I'm OK with that, but at least be somewhat original in it instead of dragging out the same old tired shit that comes with every thread involving a suggestion for builds.



yep. I agree. My guys would be all over the WR and they still would catch the ball.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by somecut8
Originally posted by PP

Originally posted by Magnitude


So...basically what you mean is

"OMG I'M GETTIN' MOSSED, COS I CANNOT MAKE A DECENT DB!"


Oh, great come back. Between my 7 DBs and the 4 other teams I work with (one I'm not a GM of), we have every conceivable CB build out there. We have speed guys, we have balanced, we have high catch and jump, ton in shutdown and swat ball, some with super vision that Superman would envy and so on, yet every time any of them come up against a good WR they get absolutely owned? You're right....Since they all are getting absolutely toasted since the nerf, none of the 20 or so agents is capable of making a decent DB. I think after you get out of grade school, you may want to look into becoming a rocket scientist or brain surgeon. I knew I'd get ripped for this post, and I'm OK with that, but at least be somewhat original in it instead of dragging out the same old tired shit that comes with every thread involving a suggestion for builds.



yep. I agree. My guys would be all over the WR and they still would catch the ball.


You might like it if offenses never scored as in Season 3, but the fact is passing stats are still lower this season than in real life-- just not as horrendously lower than they used to be.

I see passed batted down all the time, but your post suggests you think they should all get batted down, that WR vs. CB, the CB should always win even though the WR knows the play and the CB doesn't.

The whining is ridiculous.
 
Link
 
Our defense is giving up more yards, offenses are sustaining more drives, that part is better when I look at it in terms of keeping things realistic. There are still some weird things happening in the sims though. To an extent the DB`s were nerfed too much.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.