User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Azerouth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai
Originally posted by Azerouth

Originally posted by chiefy27


Week 7 up


Hey Chiefy, wanted to say thanks.
I know your chart things has some flaws in it and is not 100% on but I enjoy looking at them. But hey no person is 100% on with there rankings either

-Dag


I'm insulted.


LOL I like your rankings too. they are another reason I keep coming back here to read these forums. seeing you guys and your rankings has me thinking of doing my own version of them.

I just don't want Chiefy to be discouraged by the negative posts/feedback about his computer based rankings and stop doing them
Last edited Aug 15, 2008 12:41:08
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azerouth
Originally posted by SpearSrai

Originally posted by Azerouth


Originally posted by chiefy27



Week 7 up


Hey Chiefy, wanted to say thanks.
I know your chart things has some flaws in it and is not 100% on but I enjoy looking at them. But hey no person is 100% on with there rankings either

-Dag


I'm insulted.


LOL I like your rankings too. they are another reason I keep coming back here to read these forums. seeing you guys and your rankings has me thinking of doing my own version of them.

I just don't want Chiefy to be discouraged by the negative posts/feedback about his computer based rankings and stop doing them


If he's still doing them at this point, I think he's pretty much made up his mind to keep doing them no matter what anyone says, lol.

And it would be great to get more people involved...A lot of guys like to come on and look at what everyone else posts, but don't ever think to post anything themselves. I originally started my top 25 as a joke, because someone asked me to do a ranking, and I said I couldn't do all 32, but I'd do a Top 25. If you can come up with some new twist or original idea about a column or ranking, then it will only enhance these forums. Every season we lose a bunch of active forum members, so other guys need to step up and start doing things, or this place will begin to lose its charm as all the active posters start to move up to Canada AAA.
 
chiefy27
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai


If he's still doing them at this point, I think he's pretty much made up his mind to keep doing them no matter what anyone says, lol.

And it would be great to get more people involved...A lot of guys like to come on and look at what everyone else posts, but don't ever think to post anything themselves. I originally started my top 25 as a joke, because someone asked me to do a ranking, and I said I couldn't do all 32, but I'd do a Top 25. If you can come up with some new twist or original idea about a column or ranking, then it will only enhance these forums. Every season we lose a bunch of active forum members, so other guys need to step up and start doing things, or this place will begin to lose its charm as all the active posters start to move up to Canada AAA.


I am going to keep doing them. I know its not perfect, but I can't think of a better way to use facts and not opinions to do them. The formula is being adjusted all the time and will only get better down the road.
 
NastyLLoyd
offline
Link
 
it's all worth the discussion they start.
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
I just wish the formula wouldn't penalize a team that runs or passes more then the other or penalize a team that has a tougher schedule so far. In all honesty do any of you guys think the Jays actually rank that low?
 
fastmover
offline
Link
 
yup, haha.


Semper fi
 
chiefy27
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Wolf
I just wish the formula wouldn't penalize a team that runs or passes more then the other or penalize a team that has a tougher schedule so far. In all honesty do any of you guys think the Jays actually rank that low?


Strength of schedule is factored in.

Do you have any suggestions on how to improve it?
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
There has to be a way to factor in games played and who they beat. We soundly bet JetNation and Windsor but both are ranked ahead of us. There has to be some weight in that not just for the win but big wins. Its just crazy to have the 1st place team ranked midpack. If that is factored in it needs to carry a lot more weight for the ranking as that is the true test of who is better/stronger.

Its to bad that there is no history input for this either. Your record form last year should carry a bit of weight as well.

The biggest factor though is balance. If you are a run dominate team and pass very little (or the other way around) you shouldn't be penalized by the lower of the 2. Our team ranks in the top 5 for run and the bottom 10 for pass and that is what is hurting us in the rankings. Just think where the Baltimore Ravens would of been ranked in their SuperBowl winning year.

Your current record in combination with the strength of opponents needs to be changed as well. No way a 7-1 team should be so low when they have played 3 top teams and won them all.

Maybe doing this Olympic style for judging and have your best game and worse game thrown out before calculations, This would overlook any tactical errors you or an opponent made. You shouldn't benefit/suffer from an unintentional error or glitch.

Thats a few improvements that need to be changed for this program to become more legit.

Last edited Aug 16, 2008 10:06:33
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
The Ravens wouldn't have expected to be ranked highly in offense in 2000. But their overall ranking would be high because they set a record for rushing defense and total defense.
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai
The Ravens wouldn't have expected to be ranked highly in offense in 2000. But their overall ranking would be high because they set a record for rushing defense and total defense.


By the end of the year, not during week 8 so their overall would not of been as high as it would a then end of the season despite them being the same team.

 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Wolf
Originally posted by SpearSrai

The Ravens wouldn't have expected to be ranked highly in offense in 2000. But their overall ranking would be high because they set a record for rushing defense and total defense.


By the end of the year, not during week 8 so their overall would not of been as high as it would a then end of the season despite them being the same team.



Actually, Tony Banks was their starting QB until week 9. Trent Dilfer didn't take over until midway through game 8.

Since the point here is that the Ravens obviously ended up winning the Super Bowl, then you can't use the first half of their season as an indication, because they would not have won it if they had kept their starting lineup the same.
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 10:40:15
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
And with all the leveling that goes on around here its basically the same thing. And lets face facts, the team was not much better or worse if they put the water boy in at QB for them.
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Wolf
And with all the leveling that goes on around here its basically the same thing. And lets face facts, the team was not much better or worse if they put the water boy in at QB for them.


#1: Love the new avatar.

#2: Evidenced by their repeat the next year, having returned the entire defense and almost the entire offense. Except, of course, their Super Bowl winning QB.

Dilfer was never as bad as he was made out to be. And it didn't help that he had to play in Billick's shitty offense.

(The Ravens are my team, btw.)
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
Totally agree with you about Dilfer not getting kudos.


And ty
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 10:49:29
 
SE49erFan
offline
Link
 
Dilfer sucks ASS.... He only did one thing right, and that was not fing up to help the Ravens win the SuperBowl.

Now come up with anything else that he was able todo in the NFL.. beside flop around!!!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.