User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Problem with Stamina/Substitution/Depth?
Page:
 
bulletbait
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stevegamer
This is frankly, a major problem - for all practical purposes in this game, stamina doesn't matter. All you need to do is make sure your energy is at 100 going into the game, and you're mostly good.

The utter lack of coverage of how this works (and other things as well) in the FAQ, led most new players to make reasonable guesses about things. This isn't the first beta game I've seen with a horrible FAQ - most of them are that way, actually.

Realism is not happening the way things are, and it's VERY counter-intuitive - you don't want to have any depth. As we all know, pro players don't play every snap anymore - If this was Chuck Bednarik's Goal Line Blitz, I might expect this kind of strategy being good.

The real problem is that you've let power gamers who want MAX numbers dictate what makes sense, and the game is screwed up in such a way that it is so unlike modern (post-1960) football, that you really should call it something else - it is NOT a football simulation at all.

When you see teams with no depth in real life, you punish them by forcing them to continuously play players until they are tired.

I'd really like to find out what other bass-ackwards things the alpha testers know about that all of us new players don't. I don't want hings handed to me, I can figure most things out just fine - but when you're dealing with things that are this screwed up, it's a problem.

You've got my money for this upcoming season, and my attention. Let's see if you can keep it by fixing the product.


Very well said.

 
flames54
offline
Link
 
I actually like how vague they are about the mechanics of the game keeps teams "playing" and adds some variety to the players.

If everybody knew exactly how things work we'd see everybody nailing things down.

As far as the Kona Gold game, two things happened. He played the pass thinking i'd try to throw the ball and my PR went off with 4 pr touchdowns so the game ended in a blowout despite the rosters.
 
bulletbait
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
I actually like how vague they are about the mechanics of the game keeps teams "playing" and adds some variety to the players.

If everybody knew exactly how things work we'd see everybody nailing things down.

As far as the Kona Gold game, two things happened. He played the pass thinking i'd try to throw the ball and my PR went off with 4 pr touchdowns so the game ended in a blowout despite the rosters.


That's the problem though, a completely irrational strategy turns out to be the best one. Hardly fun to "figure out."
 
aeakers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
I actually like how vague they are about the mechanics of the game keeps teams "playing" and adds some variety to the players.

If everybody knew exactly how things work we'd see everybody nailing things down.



I agree except for one HUGE thing. The realism is not where it needs to be. If things are not realistic/sim, it makes the system look bad.

Even now i know certain things (to state the obvious for example, having no depth is a good thing). But I refuse to play like that. I'm here to play a realistic football game, not glitch my way into winning games.
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bulletbait
Originally posted by flames54

I actually like how vague they are about the mechanics of the game keeps teams "playing" and adds some variety to the players.

If everybody knew exactly how things work we'd see everybody nailing things down.

As far as the Kona Gold game, two things happened. He played the pass thinking i'd try to throw the ball and my PR went off with 4 pr touchdowns so the game ended in a blowout despite the rosters.


That's the problem though, a completely irrational strategy turns out to be the best one. Hardly fun to "figure out."


whats irrational about my depth chart? it mimics an NFL one in many ways.

Take injuries out of the NFL and the need for a huge depth chart changes, many players don't even hit the field in an NFL game. Most teams use two running backs with a third seeing the field every now and then, most teams use 7 offensive lineman. Most teams use 7-8 defensive lineman and most teams use 3-4 linebackers in a game unless they have different skill sets. Most teams play one FS and one SS the entire game, I use 2 at both spots and most NFL teams have 4 corners/ 4 wr's active for a game.

Again without injuries the need for a deep depth chart wouldn't exist in the NFL.
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
Bort and DD, if yall do decide to update the fatigue can we be given chemisty immunity for a few days to add players to fill in the roster. If it happens before the off season then it works out because chemistry is frozen in the off season right? I currently have a team with depth, but if the game is set up for no depth then everyone will be setting up that way.

EDIT: Nevermind if you set up your roster that way in the first place you should take the chemistry hit.

Also to help out back ups, each spot on the depth chart should get a minimum game xp for each game no matter how many plays they get and make xp curve steeper the more plays you play.(if your guy is 4th string CB but 2nd string FS then you earn the 2nd string xp amount) Starters get the overall bonus of being the starters and getting more plays. Maybe 65 plays can be the where XP becomes minimal. Maybe even add situational xp to the game. Like if you are blowing someone out your xp per play drops a bit. You wouldn't be really earning xp playing against powder puffs. But if you are playing in the 4th quarter to win, the last few minute drive you earn a bonus to your xp.

This could cause teams to lock in their depth chart at least 12 to 6 hours before their games, so that XP factors can be set for calculation.
Last edited Apr 17, 2008 23:35:21
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
To further that point I have 41 players right now and use ALL of them a lot, I also plan on adding 3 more and going up to 44 total players which is 10 off an active NFL roster.

2backup quarterbacks that never play
1third string running back that never plays
1third string TE than only plays the goalline formation plays
2backup linebackers that may only play special teams
2third string defensive lineman that never play
1long snapper that only long snaps

That means I'm really only off an NFL roster by 1 player, and without long term injuries I don't need to get any closer.
 
claystone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Hey, I have no problem with making energy affect you more, for next season. It used to be, but people got me second guessing myself. I should probably go with my gut more often than letting the internets sway me.


I'll second that. I hope you could make it that way.

 
claystone
offline
Link
 
This is a football sims game..right. so lets put all the things in football into this game to get that realism.

1. Stamina matters (Makes owners use depth)
2. Penalties
3. Injuries

These are important things that make football, football. Why aren't these items in the game?
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by claystone
This is a football sims game..right. so lets put all the things in football into this game to get that realism.

1. Stamina matters (Makes owners use depth)
2. Penalties
3. Injuries

These are important things that make football, football. Why aren't these items in the game?


They're finicky things to put in, and people don't want to see their players get tired/penalized/injured because they think it reflects poorly on them as player daddies (I was going to say "player owners" but it sounds like player/owner and well, everyone who has a player isn't an owner.)
 
chevyman~Cult~
like a rock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Hey, I have no problem with making energy affect you more, for next season. It used to be, but people got me second guessing myself. I should probably go with my gut more often than letting the internets sway me.


I would love to see this done. I based the season off the thought that this was supost to be realistic. So I made sure I had depth. Alot of talk was about how stamina was important. How it is now it is not important at all. All you need is one backup per type of position is not real football. It really sucks to be beaten by a team that has no depth. When you have depth and all players play a good amount of plays across the board. Not just the starters getting all the playing time. Had the belief that energy afected how well you played so to guys with very close builds same level but one with 80% energy will play better then the other guy with 60-70% energy. That seams not the case. If this game is supost to be a realisic as it can then energy and depth need to play a bigger part. Non of this one guy can play 90+ plays. Unrealistic. If you want realism then "max numbers" can not play a part. That is my thought.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
If they are going to make stamina matter it needs to be position specific. Positions that hardly ever require subbing in real life should be the same here. Honestly the only positions I see acting unrealistically right now are RB's, maybe WR's a little bit... OL seldom ever come out of a game... maybe DL and LB's a bit as well.

Here's a game where I set the stamina to 0 out/30 in... was testing... starters never came out. With the exception of the RB and maybe a few too many plays by the OL, I don't see many abnormalities.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=2813

A small fix would be nice but please don't make it to where you HAVE to bring in back ups at a position where you would never ever use one.
 
chevyman~Cult~
like a rock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by claystone
This is a football sims game..right. so lets put all the things in football into this game to get that realism.

1. Stamina matters (Makes owners use depth)
2. Penalties
3. Injuries

These are important things that make football, football. Why aren't these items in the game?


I have heard penalities r coming into this game. don't know when but it is to be an update.
 
chevyman~Cult~
like a rock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
If they are going to make stamina matter it needs to be position specific. Positions that hardly ever require subbing in real life should be the same here. Honestly the only positions I see acting unrealistically right now are RB's, maybe WR's a little bit... OL seldom ever come out of a game... maybe DL and LB's a bit as well.

Here's a game where I set the stamina to 0 out/30 in... was testing... starters never came out. With the exception of the RB and maybe a few too many plays by the OL, I don't see many abnormalities.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=2813

A small fix would be nice but please don't make it to where you HAVE to bring in back ups at a position where you would never ever use one.


What were the players energys at after the game?
 
claystone
offline
Link
 
It will blow if mostly everyone can use one player at every position without any depth. The admin will have to create even more teams to take the overspill of players because teams will not use them since they don't need depth.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.