User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Teams with no backups have to be penalized
Page:
 
jkocurek
offline
Link
 
Injuries and situational substitutions mandate depth in the NFL. Since injuries are not an issue here, it has to be done with endurance.

Depending on how injuries are handled they can look over this. But no team should have less than 40 players and no team should actively play less than 30, probably.

Plus, there is no monetary benefit to sitting on the bench like in real life, in fact there is a cost to the player. Everyone should play. Not start, but at least play. You'd think the devs would want to encourage more players, not less.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I disagree a little with the endurance as mandatory although it would help. I think the best suggestions are to combine the following:

1.) Decrease the max plays for XP from 90 to 40-50. NFL games are typically 55-65 plays so 90 is WAY too many. If there were no XP incentive to playing your guys more than 40-50 plays, there would be more depth.

2.) Change the in-game energy-to-effectiveness ratio. it doesn't have to be 1 to 1, but some ratio. It could be a parabolic curve where you lose little at the top and as you drop you lose more and more.

3.) Change the post-game energy situation. You should be able to lose more than 30 energy in a game. It shouldn't be 1 to 1, but again like a parabolic curve where the lower your in-game energy goes the more it affects how much or little you will have after the game.

4.) Add complexity to the offensive and defensive depth charts and game plan to allow for player specialization. Having 3rd down backs, Goalline backs, nickle and dime DBs, pash rush specialists, etc. actually gives owners a reason to have depth that is strategic and meaningful rather than just so it seems more realistic or fair.

Last edited Apr 18, 2008 03:40:29
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
I disagree a little with the endurance as mandatory although it would help. I think the best suggestions are to combine the following:

1.) Decrease the max plays for XP from 90 to 40-50. NFL games are typically 55-65 plays so 90 is WAY too many. If there were no XP incentive to playing your guys more than 40-50 plays, there would be more depth.

2.) Change the in-game energy-to-effectiveness ratio. it doesn't have to be 1 to 1, but some ratio. It could be a parabolic curve where you lose little at the top and as you drop you lose more and more.

3.) Change the post-game energy situation. You should be able to lose more than 30 energy in a game. It shouldn't be 1 to 1, but again like a parabolic curve where the lower your in-game energy goes the more it affects how much or little you will have after the game.

4.) Add complexity to the offensive and defensive depth charts and game plan to allow for player specialization. Having 3rd down backs, Goalline backs, nickle and dime DBs, pash rush specialists, etc. actually gives owners a reason to have depth that is strategic and meaningful rather than just so it seems more realistic or fair.



This is the best set of ideas concerning this yet. Thank you! I sure hope Bort can see this.

 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CONN CHRIS
Originally posted by tpaterniti

I disagree a little with the endurance as mandatory although it would help. I think the best suggestions are to combine the following:

1.) Decrease the max plays for XP from 90 to 40-50. NFL games are typically 55-65 plays so 90 is WAY too many. If there were no XP incentive to playing your guys more than 40-50 plays, there would be more depth.

2.) Change the in-game energy-to-effectiveness ratio. it doesn't have to be 1 to 1, but some ratio. It could be a parabolic curve where you lose little at the top and as you drop you lose more and more.

3.) Change the post-game energy situation. You should be able to lose more than 30 energy in a game. It shouldn't be 1 to 1, but again like a parabolic curve where the lower your in-game energy goes the more it affects how much or little you will have after the game.

4.) Add complexity to the offensive and defensive depth charts and game plan to allow for player specialization. Having 3rd down backs, Goalline backs, nickle and dime DBs, pash rush specialists, etc. actually gives owners a reason to have depth that is strategic and meaningful rather than just so it seems more realistic or fair.



This is the best set of ideas concerning this yet. Thank you! I sure hope Bort can see this.



Agreed. Very good posting.
 
TubbyChooChoo
offline
Link
 
We need to have injuries in the game. Players should get knocked out of a game and even miss another on occasion.
That would add strategy and require team sto at least put a guy in the back up role.
Of course they can set the sub/in/out so that he never plays [so some sort of min/max needs to be put in place there as well - or at least a mandatory 10% minimum rule - thus a player subbing out at 50% would have to wait until 60% to come in...not 51%.]

 
CoachMauler
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
I disagree a little with the endurance as mandatory although it would help. I think the best suggestions are to combine the following:

1.) Decrease the max plays for XP from 90 to 40-50. NFL games are typically 55-65 plays so 90 is WAY too many. If there were no XP incentive to playing your guys more than 40-50 plays, there would be more depth.

2.) Change the in-game energy-to-effectiveness ratio. it doesn't have to be 1 to 1, but some ratio. It could be a parabolic curve where you lose little at the top and as you drop you lose more and more.

3.) Change the post-game energy situation. You should be able to lose more than 30 energy in a game. It shouldn't be 1 to 1, but again like a parabolic curve where the lower your in-game energy goes the more it affects how much or little you will have after the game.

4.) Add complexity to the offensive and defensive depth charts and game plan to allow for player specialization. Having 3rd down backs, Goalline backs, nickle and dime DBs, pash rush specialists, etc. actually gives owners a reason to have depth that is strategic and meaningful rather than just so it seems more realistic or fair.



I am hoping on this train...Good post Tpat...

I love the parabolic energy-to-effectiveness ratio, idea.

BORT and DD you guys should read this...
 
Hagetaka
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Most positions in football CAN play an entire game and be fine. QB,FB,TE OL, LB, DB all typically do it for the entire game.


Uh...what? Most teams run a primary and secondary TE. The fullback gets subbed out a lot in modern offenses for another receiver/TE.

Starting linebackers and DBs actually do get spelled on quite a few plays. It's not a very common thing for them to be on every defensive snap.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hagetaka
Originally posted by bigtisme

Most positions in football CAN play an entire game and be fine. QB,FB,TE OL, LB, DB all typically do it for the entire game.


Uh...what? Most teams run a primary and secondary TE. The fullback gets subbed out a lot in modern offenses for another receiver/TE.

Starting linebackers and DBs actually do get spelled on quite a few plays. It's not a very common thing for them to be on every defensive snap.


Dunno about that. I think it's dependent on the team and talent. I'm a Packers fan and I can tell you with certainty that Nick Barnett, A.J. Hawk, Charles Woodson, and Al Harris came out of the game on only the rarest of occasions. Occasionally you'd see an OL substitution but for the most part the starters there played the entire game. The one place I saw a lot of rotation was in dime/nickel packages (with extra DB's coming in and LB's going out) and with the defensive line, other than that the starters I would say played a majority of the snaps. As I said in a post yesterday, a realistic depth chart would be to have +1 at each position except for QB/P/K (those players never come out), so something like this:

QB - 1
HB - 2
FB - 2
WR - 4
TE - 2
C - 2
T - 3
G - 3
P - 1
K - 1
DT - 3
DE - 3
LB - 4
CB - 3
SS - 2
FS - 2

That's 38 players. My starting rosters for next season will all be very similar to this except I will have 4 CB's and 5 WR's ... so I'll have a 40 man roster.
Last edited Apr 18, 2008 09:11:41
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
I disagree a little with the endurance as mandatory although it would help. I think the best suggestions are to combine the following:

1.) Decrease the max plays for XP from 90 to 40-50. NFL games are typically 55-65 plays so 90 is WAY too many. If there were no XP incentive to playing your guys more than 40-50 plays, there would be more depth.

2.) Change the in-game energy-to-effectiveness ratio. it doesn't have to be 1 to 1, but some ratio. It could be a parabolic curve where you lose little at the top and as you drop you lose more and more.

3.) Change the post-game energy situation. You should be able to lose more than 30 energy in a game. It shouldn't be 1 to 1, but again like a parabolic curve where the lower your in-game energy goes the more it affects how much or little you will have after the game.

4.) Add complexity to the offensive and defensive depth charts and game plan to allow for player specialization. Having 3rd down backs, Goalline backs, nickle and dime DBs, pash rush specialists, etc. actually gives owners a reason to have depth that is strategic and meaningful rather than just so it seems more realistic or fair.




Great suggestion! I hope its acted upon.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
I love suggestion #4, I'd love to be able to sub in 3rd down running backs, goal line backs, and pass rushing specialists.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
I love suggestion #4, I'd love to be able to sub in 3rd down running backs, goal line backs, and pass rushing specialists.



Yeah--that would encourage the building of a wide variety of players rather than everyone attempting to build the next Walter Payton at RB (to cite just one example).
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
I added this thread to the master stickey. But lets be sure to keep things civil in here as well!

PS....i think the some of the #4 suggestion is in the works either this upcoming tactic or the next.
 
Skywolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
In the USA pro...all of those teams are already beat out of the playoffs. All that reamain are teams with depth.


The number one team is still in without that depth

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=10
Last edited Apr 18, 2008 10:26:28
 
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Most positions in football CAN play an entire game and be fine. QB,FB,TE OL, LB, DB all typically do it for the entire game.



Sorry, but that's simply not the case. Even "durable" offensive linemen inevitably get a nick here and a nick there that causes them to miss "only" 3 or 4 plays in a game. FBs and TEs rotate out all of the time (even Antonio Gates and Tony Gonzalez don't play EVERY offensive play).
 
fullxtension
offline
Link
 
If a team can actually roll with any position (except kickers) at one deep, then there is something very wrong. That should just not be possible.

In 2007, NFL teams averaged 43.5 rushing plays and 56.5 passing plays per game. The numbers are probably slightly higher in college. 32,133 total plays in ’07.
http://www.jaguars.com/news/Article.aspx?id=6727

For the sake of argument, if you have 100 offensive plays per game, your linemen will probably only be able to play 60-70% of those plays. The same goes for halfbacks, wideouts and for that matter, the defensive lineman going against you. Running backs getting 75 plays a game? That's rediculous. No one has that kind of stamina. Not even TE's can run their routes 75 times in one game. Even if you don't touch the ball, being in there will take it out of you.

Do you want to get into players taking plays off? Getting less value from plays they take off? IMHO its just better to have to rotate in some backups like they do IRL.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.