User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This is clearly an exploit and should be addressed ASAP
Page:
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fins88
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

The fix is simple. Lock the Off. DC 30 min before gametime, that way, owners have time to adjust (if you aren't able to be there, then have GMs). Give warning on the DC page (ex. "DCs will be locked in 15 min") and then lock them so teams have enough time to adjust.

Not particularly fair to the offense, but it's not really easy to exploit either. There isn't a lot the Def. can do once the offense is locked except match the best CBs up to the best WRs and switch the DEs around, neither of which would seem to be a big issue.


the depth chart already gets locked like 30-45 mins before a game


He's saying just lock the offensive DC, letting the defense have time to adjust afterwards. While it does address the problem, it doesn't address the time zone problems that this creates that the admins have tried to avoid.
 
nancywhiskey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by fins88

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


The fix is simple. Lock the Off. DC 30 min before gametime, that way, owners have time to adjust (if you aren't able to be there, then have GMs). Give warning on the DC page (ex. "DCs will be locked in 15 min") and then lock them so teams have enough time to adjust.

Not particularly fair to the offense, but it's not really easy to exploit either. There isn't a lot the Def. can do once the offense is locked except match the best CBs up to the best WRs and switch the DEs around, neither of which would seem to be a big issue.


the depth chart already gets locked like 30-45 mins before a game


He's saying just lock the offensive DC, letting the defense have time to adjust afterwards. While it does address the problem, it doesn't address the time zone problems that this creates that the admins have tried to avoid.



Agreed, teams do not get to pick when their games are simmed and since they are simmed at all hours (including working hours) people will have conflicts.

Also, I am not starting a fight, I am pointing out that there are issues like these which should take precedence over the addition of Porsches for players to buy.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi

Originally posted by drifter


you can counter a team doing this by setting your CBs up the same way


Not a bug.

/thread


Never said it's a bug. It's an exploit and you conveniently left off the second part of that sentence where I said that he original team can then switch their WRs back shortly before game time creating the same exploitive mismatch.

Nice try. See my note for IQ requirements to posting in here


IQ eh? I can assure you that IQ means very little. As for whether you call this a bug or an exploit - I get the feeling that you are not Bort. If Bort wants to call this an exploit - that's his prerogative; not yours. And as for the problem being that Offenses can just change their DC -- umm.. Defenses can do this as well.. then it becomes a game of who changes their DC last.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi


Originally posted by drifter



you can counter a team doing this by setting your CBs up the same way


Not a bug.

/thread


Never said it's a bug. It's an exploit and you conveniently left off the second part of that sentence where I said that he original team can then switch their WRs back shortly before game time creating the same exploitive mismatch.

Nice try. See my note for IQ requirements to posting in here


IQ eh? I can assure you that IQ means very little. As for whether you call this a bug or an exploit - I get the feeling that you are not Bort. If Bort wants to call this an exploit - that's his prerogative; not yours. And as for the problem being that Offenses can just change their DC -- umm.. Defenses can do this as well.. then it becomes a game of who changes their DC last.



Exactly - which has been stated several times, is something the devs have clearly said they want to avoid as it provides advantages for those who can be by their computers at game time.


 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
It really just sounds like a job for CB -> WR matchup priorities. Of course that wouldn't apply to zone defenses -- only man-to-man -- but it would probably help.

The new DC 1/2/3 positions were supposed to help in this regard but I think they have caused more problems than they have solved really, which is too bad.

I don't know if it would be very easy to just lock the offense part of the DC earlier than the defense, since they are on the same page and part of the same form submission. It would take some doing, and it doesn't really address the problem completely. More of a band-aid than anything.
 
VietCampo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
It really just sounds like a job for CB -> WR matchup priorities. Of course that wouldn't apply to zone defenses -- only man-to-man -- but it would probably help.

The new DC 1/2/3 positions were supposed to help in this regard but I think they have caused more problems than they have solved really, which is too bad.

I don't know if it would be very easy to just lock the offense part of the DC earlier than the defense, since they are on the same page and part of the same form submission. It would take some doing, and it doesn't really address the problem completely. More of a band-aid than anything.


I'll take a band-aid.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
It really just sounds like a job for CB -> WR matchup priorities. Of course that wouldn't apply to zone defenses -- only man-to-man -- but it would probably help.

The new DC 1/2/3 positions were supposed to help in this regard but I think they have caused more problems than they have solved really, which is too bad.

I don't know if it would be very easy to just lock the offense part of the DC earlier than the defense, since they are on the same page and part of the same form submission. It would take some doing, and it doesn't really address the problem completely. More of a band-aid than anything.


I agree with the "band-aid over a chest wound" thing, but wouldn't having CBs match up to the "Best" WR (and the god awful levels of describing "best" in such a way the AI can understand and apply it) be murder.

I mean, maybe a simple match-up by name would work (assuming it didn't go off the other team's DC because people would just leave it blank for a while so the Def. couldn't plan) but I have no idea the amount of work required.
 
Juan Fiddy
offline
Link
 
If it takes more work to apply a band-aid then it does to suture the damn thing, then lets get some needles and thread.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


More of a band-aid than anything.


Not really what a lot of the player base wants right now. I think most of us want fixes and I know I am trying to be as patient as possible. Good luck and I hope you get some of the issues figured out before the playoffs.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Bort

It really just sounds like a job for CB -> WR matchup priorities. Of course that wouldn't apply to zone defenses -- only man-to-man -- but it would probably help.

The new DC 1/2/3 positions were supposed to help in this regard but I think they have caused more problems than they have solved really, which is too bad.

I don't know if it would be very easy to just lock the offense part of the DC earlier than the defense, since they are on the same page and part of the same form submission. It would take some doing, and it doesn't really address the problem completely. More of a band-aid than anything.


I agree with the "band-aid over a chest wound" thing, but wouldn't having CBs match up to the "Best" WR (and the god awful levels of describing "best" in such a way the AI can understand and apply it) be murder.

I mean, maybe a simple match-up by name would work (assuming it didn't go off the other team's DC because people would just leave it blank for a while so the Def. couldn't plan) but I have no idea the amount of work required.


Yeah, I'm talking about matchups that the team owner enters.

Like he can edit his list of CB's and use some pulldowns to select the name of the WR he wants to to be the #1 priority for each CB. If that WR's in the game, the CB covers him. If not it just falls back to the same logic as now.

There's probably some conflict stuff that might get hairy, like if you choose the same matchup on more than one player, but you get the idea.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Bort

It really just sounds like a job for CB -> WR matchup priorities. Of course that wouldn't apply to zone defenses -- only man-to-man -- but it would probably help.

The new DC 1/2/3 positions were supposed to help in this regard but I think they have caused more problems than they have solved really, which is too bad.

I don't know if it would be very easy to just lock the offense part of the DC earlier than the defense, since they are on the same page and part of the same form submission. It would take some doing, and it doesn't really address the problem completely. More of a band-aid than anything.


I agree with the "band-aid over a chest wound" thing, but wouldn't having CBs match up to the "Best" WR (and the god awful levels of describing "best" in such a way the AI can understand and apply it) be murder.

I mean, maybe a simple match-up by name would work (assuming it didn't go off the other team's DC because people would just leave it blank for a while so the Def. couldn't plan) but I have no idea the amount of work required.


One more thing for inactive owners players to complain about.
 
chapnis
offline
Link
 
KFC
 
AgentTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Like he can edit his list of CB's and use some pulldowns to select the name of the WR he wants to to be the #1 priority for each CB. If that WR's in the game, the CB covers him. If not it just falls back to the same logic as now.


I've been saying this is the way you're going to have to end up going for some time now. Last time was 2 days ago in the flames receiver thread. There really is no getting around it. Otherwise offense will always have an incredible advantage in finding mismatches.

It also, as I point out in the flames receiver thread, helps solve the problem with builds like Plotz with 96 speed and nothing else. Right now that breaks things because the defense can't just make all their CBs have 90 speed to cover him as the other WRs will eat them alive. And if the defense has one CB with 90 speed there is simply no way to get him to cover Plotz as the offense can switch him around on the depth chart to find a mismatch.

I have no idea how much work it will be to allow the defensive coordinator to assign matchups by name for CB/WR, but the truth is you'll have to do it eventually so you might as well think about it now.

 
ZephyrFox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uofi316
The depth chart should only be used to determine what WR/CB will see the field on a particular play. Once the WR are on the field, the CB should matchup accordingly based somehow on the "overall" rating (like any regular college/pro/HS team would do).

There is no way that the Carolina Panthers can "sneak" Steve Smith onto the field and have him line up across from the #3 CB.


+1
 
AgentTBC
offline
Link
 
Here is my post on the necessity and inevitability of this sort of matchup dropdown from a couple days ago

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=750917&page=8#5802202

Yes, I am good.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.