User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Yellow

Why not just reset the passing game mechanics to exactly what they were last season?.


They are the same as they were last season. That's the whole problem of why this is confusing and I'm trying to sort it out.


I think that the problem lies in the builds and the AI settings. People are trying to do the same thing as last season with same builds even the game has changed. This is what happens when you try and stick a square peg in a round hole. I am not sure there is enough data and people have worked hard enough on their tactics for us to all this a AI issue.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Yellow

Why not just reset the passing game mechanics to exactly what they were last season?.


They are the same as they were last season. That's the whole problem of why this is confusing and I'm trying to sort it out.


Well damn, lol

Maybe it has to do with the CB1 CB2 CB3 and WR1 WR2 WR3 slots, and the respective players getting confused when they're in those positions?

For example, last season, when there was just a generic depth chart for CBs, the number 1 CB on that chart would always line up on the defensive left side. The second CB on the chart would line up defensive right. For WRs, the first WR would always be on the offensive right, and the second WR would always be offensive left.

What i have noticed this season, is that even with the exact same depth chart and energy settings, we're seeing our number 1 WR lining up on BOTH sides, and the same thing is happening to our number 1 CB.

Now what i am getting at, is that maybe the CB1 2 3 and WR1 2 3 settings are somehow confusing the players into thinking theyre in a position that they're not actually in, or just otherwise making them behave erratically?

Have you tried removing the position-specific depth charts and testing the same AI with only the standard WR and CB depth charts in place?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Yellow


Why not just reset the passing game mechanics to exactly what they were last season?.


They are the same as they were last season. That's the whole problem of why this is confusing and I'm trying to sort it out.


Well damn, lol

Maybe it has to do with the CB1 CB2 CB3 and WR1 WR2 WR3 slots, and the respective players getting confused when they're in those positions?

For example, last season, when there was just a generic depth chart for CBs, the number 1 CB on that chart would always line up on the defensive left side. The second CB on the chart would line up defensive right. For WRs, the first WR would always be on the offensive right, and the second WR would always be offensive left.

What i have noticed this season, is that even with the exact same depth chart and energy settings, we're seeing our number 1 WR lining up on BOTH sides, and the same thing is happening to our number 1 CB.

Now what i am getting at, is that maybe the CB1 2 3 and WR1 2 3 settings are somehow confusing the players into thinking theyre in a position that they're not actually in, or just otherwise making them behave erratically?

Have you tried removing the position-specific depth charts and testing the same AI with only the standard WR and CB depth charts in place?


That shouldn't matter. The AI code could care less what position the player is; it just cares what his settings are set to.

I think a good portion of the problem is that I changed the offensive plays so the players always line up in the same position against the same guys. Before, there would be mismatches created by players moving around and guarding different guys. I could change that back, but that's really just a band-aid solution that doesn't address the real problem.
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=725497&page=last#5838782

Not to be a pest, Bort. But could I get your thoughts on this DE issue?
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 20:22:22
 
Otega
12th MIManITW
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Yellow


Why not just reset the passing game mechanics to exactly what they were last season?.


They are the same as they were last season. That's the whole problem of why this is confusing and I'm trying to sort it out.


I think that the problem lies in the builds and the AI settings. People are trying to do the same thing as last season with same builds even the game has changed. This is what happens when you try and stick a square peg in a round hole. I am not sure there is enough data and people have worked hard enough on their tactics for us to all this a AI issue.


I will disagree with you, respectively. I've worked extremely hard on our defensive tactics. As well, a CB's build really hasn't changed much this season (other then potentially, jumping). Shutdown corner, in a M2M scheme, is still a shutdown corner.

Cb's shouldn't be playing off coverage if they are set to aggressive tight. That's just basic. If they get burnt deep, the risk factor should get put in, but not short . IN the examples one of our guys provided, the sim threw to the same WR, what, 9 times in a row? 9 times? I mean, most were on my CB, who's build is total shutdown in m2m defense (which we play). There is no excuse for my CB to drop 5 yards after one catch, then never get back into a play.

As well, the WR was the ONLY wr on the depth chart for his position. He played 80+ plays, and still, in the (can't remember which now) 3rd or 4th quarter, was able to shake and get open underneath every single time? Meanwhile, we played a 4 CB rotation at each of the 1/2/3/4 spots on the dc. Their receivers should never have made any catches in the 2nd half, due to being tired. Not even just tired, but totally and completely gassed. Hell, let's assume the guy had enough stamina to play 80+ plays. He still would have been tired.

So, there is something more going on. I think Bort eluded to it earlier. I think it's a combination of the risk factor penalty + the energy drain issue where receivers get slower, thus apparently harder to cover *boggle*.

We've (meaning our team) have had those discussions about builds. Luckily, we never fully tilted to one typical build style, so we're more than fine on that front and in better shape than a lot of teams. Likewise, we've been building our offense and defense sets in the UI since day 1 it was out.

So it's nothing new to us. Meaning, we've been prepared for it. That's one of the reasons why, this morning, I think I was so pissed about it. Countless hours of work installing our defense, all went to waste in the span of watching our game today (at least it felt that way before my 2nd cup of coffee).

Worst part was, our first game, didn't have this issue at all. But, that was because the DC was set up correctly by the opposing team.

And mind you, it's not sour grapes at losing, cause our opponents in EE are all good guys, and we all get along very well. It is a little bit of sour grapes in losing to the sim, as opposed to a team game planning and beating us.


 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Yellow

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Yellow



Why not just reset the passing game mechanics to exactly what they were last season?.


They are the same as they were last season. That's the whole problem of why this is confusing and I'm trying to sort it out.


Well damn, lol

Maybe it has to do with the CB1 CB2 CB3 and WR1 WR2 WR3 slots, and the respective players getting confused when they're in those positions?

For example, last season, when there was just a generic depth chart for CBs, the number 1 CB on that chart would always line up on the defensive left side. The second CB on the chart would line up defensive right. For WRs, the first WR would always be on the offensive right, and the second WR would always be offensive left.

What i have noticed this season, is that even with the exact same depth chart and energy settings, we're seeing our number 1 WR lining up on BOTH sides, and the same thing is happening to our number 1 CB.

Now what i am getting at, is that maybe the CB1 2 3 and WR1 2 3 settings are somehow confusing the players into thinking theyre in a position that they're not actually in, or just otherwise making them behave erratically?

Have you tried removing the position-specific depth charts and testing the same AI with only the standard WR and CB depth charts in place?


That shouldn't matter. The AI code could care less what position the player is; it just cares what his settings are set to.

I think a good portion of the problem is that I changed the offensive plays so the players always line up in the same position against the same guys. Before, there would be mismatches created by players moving around and guarding different guys. I could change that back, but that's really just a band-aid solution that doesn't address the real problem.


Hmm...well, i would actually prefer that my guys line up in set positions, rather than specifically matching up to a player.

I liked my WR1 to be on the right side, because we had a player who was suited perfectly to the kinds of routes that the Right-side WR gets. Likewise, i like it better when my top CB lines up on the defensive right side on every play, as he is better suited to guarding the deep routes that the right side WR gets. Now everyone just kinda lines up...randomly.

 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort



I think a good portion of the problem is that I changed the offensive plays so the players always line up in the same position against the same guys.



Also, if i'm reading this correctly, it is the offensive player who moves based on the position of the defensive player? For instance, if CB1 lines up Offensive Left, then so too will my WR1?

If that's the case, i think it should be the other way around. Ideally, the offense should be pro-active and the defense should be reactive, so that the CBs have to switch their positions to cover the WRs, not the other way around.

Or did i just read that wrong?
 
mpowell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Yellow

Why not just reset the passing game mechanics to exactly what they were last season?.


They are the same as they were last season. That's the whole problem of why this is confusing and I'm trying to sort it out.


I've been reviewing some game tape from last season to see what it looks like is different. There are plays I'm seeing where the CB looks like he is playing deeper than he ought, but it doesn't happen repeatedly so you never get the same type of crazy games. I don't know if that helps or not. I sympathize with you, trying to debug such a crazy problem with lots of time pressure! Wish I could do more to help.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Otega
Originally posted by czman

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Yellow



Why not just reset the passing game mechanics to exactly what they were last season?.


They are the same as they were last season. That's the whole problem of why this is confusing and I'm trying to sort it out.


I
think that the problem lies in the builds and the AI settings. People
are trying to do the same thing as last season with same builds even
the game has changed. This is what happens when you try and stick a
square peg in a round hole. I am not sure there is enough data and
people have worked hard enough on their tactics for us to all this a AI
issue.


I will disagree with you, respectively. I've
worked extremely hard on our defensive tactics. As well, a CB's build
really hasn't changed much this season (other then potentially,
jumping). Shutdown corner, in a M2M scheme, is still a shutdown corner.

Cb's
shouldn't be playing off coverage if they are set to aggressive tight.
That's just basic. If they get burnt deep, the risk factor should get
put in, but not short . IN the examples one of our guys provided, the
sim threw to the same WR, what, 9 times in a row? 9 times? I mean, most
were on my CB, who's build is total shutdown in m2m defense (which we
play). There is no excuse for my CB to drop 5 yards after one catch,
then never get back into a play.

As well, the WR was the ONLY
wr on the depth chart for his position. He played 80+ plays, and still,
in the (can't remember which now) 3rd or 4th quarter, was able to shake
and get open underneath every single time? Meanwhile, we played a 4 CB
rotation at each of the 1/2/3/4 spots on the dc. Their receivers should
never have made any catches in the 2nd half, due to being tired. Not
even just tired, but totally and completely gassed. Hell, let's assume
the guy had enough stamina to play 80+ plays. He still would have been
tired.

So, there is something more going on. I think Bort eluded
to it earlier. I think it's a combination of the risk factor penalty +
the energy drain issue where receivers get slower, thus apparently
harder to cover *boggle*.

We've (meaning our team) have had
those discussions about builds. Luckily, we never fully tilted to one
typical build style, so we're more than fine on that front and in
better shape than a lot of teams. Likewise, we've been building our
offense and defense sets in the UI since day 1 it was out.

So
it's nothing new to us. Meaning, we've been prepared for it. That's one
of the reasons why, this morning, I think I was so pissed about it.
Countless hours of work installing our defense, all went to waste in
the span of watching our game today (at least it felt that way before
my 2nd cup of coffee).

Worst part was, our first game, didn't
have this issue at all. But, that was because the DC was set up
correctly by the opposing team.

And mind you, it's not sour
grapes at losing, cause our opponents in EE are all good guys, and we
all get along very well. It is a little bit of sour grapes in losing to
the sim, as opposed to a team game planning and beating us.



A come back route with no underneath coverage is going to be very hard to stop. Most of the routes that appear to working well are the come back routes. Many teams play tight man to man so the LBs are in coverage or blitzing. That leaves the corners locked on an island. If a WR runs full speed at a CB and suddenly stops there is a good chance the CB will have a hard time staying with him. I think the secondary coverage is why WR #1 is covered all of the time.

First, the LB on WR#1s side has no immediate assignment and can drop back on the WR if not blitzing.

Second, the LB on WR#2 side is usually in man to man on the TE and that opens up the underneath pattern for WR2.

Third, The FS over the top on WR#1 can cause a triple coverage on that side if the LB picks him up to.

Forth, the CB in the second position has been forced to play looser coverage for at least a full season now.

What is more likely the passing mechanics mysteriously changes or with the advent of the new plays and coverage’s the WR in the #1 slot is just being focused on to much by the defense and the #2 WR is getting the benefit.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Last season, the Wide Receiver on the left side saw very little in the way of passes coming his direction. This season, the receiver on that same side is now getting open on every play.

So to answer your question, i think it is more likely that the passing mechanics mysteriously changed somehow.
 
Otega
12th MIManITW
offline
Link
 
Right Cz - not gonna quote, due to my wall of text lol.

Watch the 7 plays in a row, with the first one below...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=99552&pbp_id=1302677

Mind you, Dexter and Deyandre both are set to tight coverage, 100% of the time. That hasn't changed in 2 seasons.

Now, none of those are short buttonhook type passes. Infact, the QB hits the receiver just about in stride each time. But play after play, the coverage gets looser and looser.

Now, it's not a build issue, i'm 99% sure. Our corners are all built to shutdown. Last season those 2 corners, dex and deyandre were like 2-4 in the league in INT's. They can play man cover all day. But, they play tight man cover. Our shell, C2, shouldn't pull one off to loose coverage. IN a few of those plays, we blitz will and Mike, but never SAM. We almost never blitz Sam in order to either keep that matchup on the TE (we like our LOLB vs. TE matchup) or we run Nickel and put the 3rd CB in covering the TE.

Likwise, we never noticed our corner in the 2 slot playing loose coverage last season. Might be the case, but we never noticed it. All 5 of our corners play tight man, aggressive, all the time.

It could just be the fact that the #2 receiver is getting more looks this season. However, Bort said he hadn't changed any passing mechanic settings, so that shouldn't be the case.

Throw in the fact that in our first game of the season, we didn't have this issue at all. Only cosmetic difference between our 2 opponents, was the CB depth chart.

Finally, I would ask this: This WR would have been dead tired in that 4th quarter. 81 plays. Only the 1/2/3 receivers played in the game. Heck, looking at their roster, they only have 3 wr's. Not to mention, he played 51 plays in his first game, so he would have been hurting already, energy wise.

It just doesn't add up. C2 man zone, with tight/aggressive settings should see the corner up close and personal with the WR. And again, for the sake of this idea of "risk factor," if he gets beat on a short underneath route, then he should be adjusting closer to his assignment, not farther back giving him a cushion.

Add to the fact that this team's chemistry is 47, 69 on O and 57 on D, and these guys should never have been in this game with us.

That's all I'm saying. It just doesn't add up. It just doesn't
 
Otega
12th MIManITW
offline
Link
 
And sorry about the wall of text's, just hard to explain everything in short order for me, guess i like to type lol.
 
Otega
12th MIManITW
offline
Link
 
You know, it's strange. Watching a lot of the replays now. IN passing sets where the QB threw elsewhere, the CB on WR2 is playing tight. The plays where the QB threw to WR2, the CB's are automatically playing loose and not coming back to the WR *if* he stops. It's almost like there is a 2x4 between them, keeping the corner off of him.


strange route and 5 yard cushion. Why does the corner not come back to his assignment?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=99552&pbp_id=1301387

CB2 stays tight on his man, even though the pass goes to the other side.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=99552&pbp_id=1301430

It's just strange to me.

edit for spelling
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 22:13:57
 
DLight03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Otega
You know, it's strange. Watching a lot of the replays now. IN passing sets where the QB threw elsewhere, the CB on WR2 is playing tight. The plays where the QB threw to WR2, the CB's are automatically playing loose and not coming back to the WR *if* he stops. It's almost like there is a 2x4 between them, keeping the corner off of him.


strange route and 5 yard cushion. Why does the corner not come back to his assignment?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=99552&pbp_id=1301387

CB2 stays tight on his man, even though the pass goes to the other side.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=99552&pbp_id=1301430

It's just strange to me.

edit for spelling


I think you're connecting the dots sort of wrong there. The reason why the WR is open every time he throws to him, is because he throws to him when he's open.

This happens on streak routes almost exclusively. I know some people have said it happens at other times, but it's almost exclusively consistently reproduced on streaks, or routes where there are long stretches of verticalish lines.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 22:20:16
 
Mstr_October
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=92843

After reading this thread, I checked my game from yesterday to see if this was happening to us. I didnt see this happen from either team except for just a couple of plays where my opponent was in a 4-2-5. Maybe there is another answer here, it could just be the defensive setting.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.