User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > Happy vs. Sad
Page:
 
DaBrownsRPhat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
The universe, with all the pain and suffering is perfect. It follows the laws it was designed to. People, however, are not. Probability is against it. Grrrr....I am getting back into the determinist argument. Lets not go there again. I already won that one, lulz.


LOL
 
DaBrownsRPhat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by kretchfoop

My issue is: if everyone was happy all of the time, there would be no word for happy that really had any emotional meaning.

Is it time to start talking about how physiologic responses are natural and society forces teach us to label them as emotions?


I see it like this. If everyone was always happy, then happy would be the average.

Happiness happens from positive jump in situations. Going from a negative situation, to positive, causes happiness. With no negative situations, it is impossible to have an increase, making happiness impossible to achieve.

Edit:
Bad choice of words


I agree, happiness is relative, from a perspective. Like you stated, if you and everyone were always happy, and never experienced sad, than would you really be happy as we understand it now?
 
MHS619
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaBrownsRPhat
Originally posted by Deathblade

Starting this because of one of the God threads. Thought it might be a decent debate.

In a perfect world, where there is no sadness, can a person actually be happy?

Can sorrow exist without happiness?

Can happiness exist without sorrow?

I personally think that one cannot exist on a permanent basis without the other one.


I agree 100%!!! I have said before that I think our understanding of good and bad is incorrect. You can't have one without the other, or more specificly, you can not experience one without the other. The Ying and Yang. If you think all we are are our bodies, and that this life here on Earth is it, the main deal, or reality, then our current concept of good and bad applies. But, like I believe, we are eternal, and this life here is not reality, or who we really are, and this is just temporary for us, and most of this is an illusion from reality in order to experience and gain perspectives. Like you said, you can not know and/or experience pleasure, without knowing and/or experiencing pain. EVERYTHING is an experience, and EVERYTHING is a part of God, or the Whole, or the One, of which we all are a part of, and that is the real reality.

The thought that we and everything is separate from eachother, from nature, from the cosmos, and from God (which is Everything) is a concept that allows us to harm others, and will be the cause of our extinction. Well, the extinction of the human species and probably most if not all the species on the planet. Once we realized that everything is One, and that our bodies is a vehicle that the real us or our conscious uses to experience and interact, this world will be what everyone wants. We cause the pain and suffering to ourselves.

Anyways, thanks kretchfoop for giving me the heads up about this thread, this is a topic I feel is the most important for the future of this planet. We will always live, we can not not live, but the question is, do we want to keep this experience we currently have here on this planet? Personally, I do, there are a great many things that are too, ummmm, good , or better explained, that I love experiencing. If there is something that you love with this experience here on this planet, please don't not think about this because "it will never be answered while being here". It will never be answered if we keep puting it off.

Ok, I've got a book going here so I'll end it, but we need to really look at the big questions, the ones most of us has put off because we decide a certain religion have all the answers, or we decide that it can not be answered while we are walking this planet.


Perfect = Love = True Love = Happy because you are happy because they are happy because we are happy

Perfection is True Love. True Love is One God. One God is Universal. Anyone can experience God, for True Love disguises Himself for the human to see, feel, hear, touch, taste and smell. Buddhist can experience True Love, just how Satanists, Pagans, Muslims, Hindus, and all others can. Love is what makes life continue, but because of the lack of people that know what Love is and share it with others that don't know, life might soon come to an end. When a Pagan helps a Muslim, they thank Allah. When a Buddhist helps a Christian, they thank God. When a Christian helps a Satanist, well, I know they'd be thankful, lol. Point is, we give thanks because someone had the Love to help us have a second chance at life. That is why we breathe.

My 2 cents.
Last edited Aug 3, 2008 23:24:07
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Emotions are all labeled by what we have learned. The boy that grows up learning that increased heart-rate means reactional anger, will be angry. The boy that learns that increased heart-rate means fear, will be scared. Our physiological "emotions" are there no matter what. How we interpret them is largely based on our up-bringing.

There are physiological bases for depression, anger, etc. It is more subjective than not. We need to consider that when dealing with philosophical discussions about the nature of man.
 
pootytang
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaBrownsRPhat
Originally posted by Biitchlaw

ever stop to think that if there was a big enuff microscope to put yourself under that u would discover that you are not solid but a bunch of moving molecules?


It is already proven physics. What we think of as a solid, is mostly made up of air, or space. Also, with quantum mechanics, things are not what they appear to be, and everything on that level, sub-atomic level, not only constantly moves, but it is never at one point at one time. Let your brain chew on that for a while.

Also, to take it a step further, it is just a theory right now, and only about 30 or so years old, but string/M theory says just that. That everything is made up of vibrating stings of energy, and those strings can expand infinately, depending on the energy, and those expanded vibrating strings is what makes up our universe, or dimention, both in terms of "building blocks" and in terms of us inside one making our universe or dimention.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HOkAagw6iug&feature=related Quick breakdown for those not familiar with it. ( M-Theory )

http://www.tenthdimension.com/medialinks.php Another pretty cool video, more a demonstration but still interesting.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_rQiF2cRKdc&feature=related Double Slit Experiment

Yes, i love this type of shit lol.

Anyone heard of Schrödinger's Cat?
Last edited Aug 3, 2008 23:40:19
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
That shit is crazy. I need to read more on quantum mechanics to understand my philosophy on the universe. That is a much better alternative than reading up on religious texts.
 
DaBrownsRPhat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pootytang
Originally posted by DaBrownsRPhat

Originally posted by Biitchlaw


ever stop to think that if there was a big enuff microscope to put yourself under that u would discover that you are not solid but a bunch of moving molecules?


It is already proven physics. What we think of as a solid, is mostly made up of air, or space. Also, with quantum mechanics, things are not what they appear to be, and everything on that level, sub-atomic level, not only constantly moves, but it is never at one point at one time. Let your brain chew on that for a while.

Also, to take it a step further, it is just a theory right now, and only about 30 or so years old, but string/M theory says just that. That everything is made up of vibrating stings of energy, and those strings can expand infinately, depending on the energy, and those expanded vibrating strings is what makes up our universe, or dimention, both in terms of "building blocks" and in terms of us inside one making our universe or dimention.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HOkAagw6iug&feature=related Quick breakdown for those not familiar with it. ( M-Theory )

http://www.tenthdimension.com/medialinks.php Another pretty cool video, more a demonstration but still interesting.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_rQiF2cRKdc&feature=related Double Slit Experiment

Yes, i love this type of shit lol.

Anyone heard of Schrödinger's Cat?


I believe so. Is that where you have a cat in a sealed box with a radiation molecule and the question is is the cat alive or dead? The fact is you do not know until you open the box. The idea being that it is not real unless our conscious is involved. Kinda like does a tree make a sound when it falls in the woods while no one is around? If the sound waves do not make it to someone's ear, then it doesn't make a sound. Anyways, was that what Schrödinger's Cat is. (I know the story but always forget the doctors names, lol, I am terrible with names)
 
Godson
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by poopoomcgoop
what about that emotion where you're kinda sad, but happy because you're sad, but you go into a depressed state and shoot yourself with a gun. what's the opposite of that?


Sanity.
 
DaBrownsRPhat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Emotions are all labeled by what we have learned. The boy that grows up learning that increased heart-rate means reactional anger, will be angry. The boy that learns that increased heart-rate means fear, will be scared. Our physiological "emotions" are there no matter what. How we interpret them is largely based on our up-bringing.

There are physiological bases for depression, anger, etc. It is more subjective than not. We need to consider that when dealing with philosophical discussions about the nature of man.


I agree. Our interpretations have for the most part been told to us, either by word of mouth or watching adults as we grow up. For example, pride when people get mad at someone. "I'm not going to let it go, that was wrong and I'm pissed." Eventhough it is a medical fact that holding that anger in is bad for our health, both medically and mentally. Most times that is because we have been brought up with our friends or people telling us in school, "You just gonna let that go? That's messed up!" Maybe bad example, but I agree that for many, the way we interpret and act on our emotions is learned from seeing that reaction somewhere else at a young age.
 
DaBrownsRPhat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
That shit is crazy. I need to read more on quantum mechanics to understand my philosophy on the universe. That is a much better alternative than reading up on religious texts.


I really think that science and spirituality, not a religion but spirituality, are one. You can not separate the two. Trying to look at only one I believe is like looking at what causes blindness by only checking everything outside of the body, it is not the whole picture.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 06:25:18
 
Godson
offline
Link
 
There can definitely be happy without sad. Just like some people have A LOT of sad in their life, opposed to a billionaire who probably has very little sadness, lol. Not everyone has an equal amount of both... Though probably VERY hard to go without having ANY sadness.
 
Shadz
offline
Link
 
No, you can never be happy without sad. They exist is polar opposites and will always remain. Happiness can not exist without sadness. Happiness is objective in relation to sadness. That means that to judge how happy someone is, you have to see how sad they are not. As is sadness objective to happiness.

As the saying goes "happiness is in the eye of the beholder". It's retrospective of the person in question. And while it remains how happy they are is related to what they experience in order to make them happy or take that happiness away. Without the ability to feel a loss at something, how could you be anything but one level of satisfaction, with life itself? You can't just say everyone is so super happy, because what are they happy in relation too? It has to be compared to some sort of standard for something to be increased.

In fact everything that can be measured has to be in relation to a standard. Two people standing in the same spot on a line in relation to you must be deemed of the same positioning based on the same standard. To say there is no sadness would position everyone on the same plane, in the same spot. So how can you deem happiness to exist if there is no way to determine who is happier or not? If everyone feels the same, you can't just label that as happiness because it is in no way in relation to anything! As I said happiness is objective. One person might find something deeming to be more fulfilling than another, but without sadness at the loss of something you can't just keep getting happier and happier ad infinitum. There has to be a point where you are completely fulfilled and no longer desire anything or require anything. And without sadness everyone would reach that point.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Godson
There can definitely be happy without sad. Just like some people have A LOT of sad in their life, opposed to a billionaire who probably has very little sadness, lol. Not everyone has an equal amount of both... Though probably VERY hard to go without having ANY sadness.


Look at it this way...in sort of less than philosophical way.

Jessica Alba, worshiped by many guys as being the hottest woman on Earth. Now...if every single woman on the planet looked exactly like Alba, would she still be omghawt? No, she would just be average, she would be what you are used to seeing. Nobody would be omghawt. Nobody would be ugly. Everyone would just be there.

The same can be said about positive situations and happiness. If your entire life is nothing but one positive situation, then happiness wouldn't be there. It would just be every day life.
 
herbgiant
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Starting this because of one of the God threads. Thought it might be a decent debate.

In a perfect world, where there is no sadness, can a person actually be happy?

Can sorrow exist without happiness?

Can happiness exist without sorrow?

I personally think that one cannot exist on a permanent basis without the other one.


tis pretty much true
pleasure wouldn't feel so good if not for pain
the sunshine wouldn't be nothin, if it wasn't for rain
plus
death got to be easy, cuz life is hard

-50 cent
 
nismodragon12
offline
Link
 
sad?!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.