User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > For everybody interested in the speed nerfs, it's fine.
Page:
 
qubanti
offline
Link
 
96 Speed, 21 Vision, 27 Catching should = Troy Williamson suckiness, not this.

Tell me again how all of the attributes are intertwined in the formulas.
Last edited Aug 3, 2008 16:22:05
 
Alex44
offline
Link
 
Honestly I'm going to say it's mostly a fluke. His stats from last year aren't impressive, and I doubt he keeps that pace this season.

Hats off to a great game, but put a few more together before we bow down.
 
Justafan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
Originally posted by Justafan

What I don't understand is how your guy, who's build is open, can have less strength, catching and vision then my more "possession" WR who's much lower level and my guy drops passes like it's his job. 10 last year and one already this year. Every other attribute is close enough to be a wash and I have all 2's in possession tree so that's a wash. This game is frustrating at times. If a guy with 27 catches catches as well as a guy with 47 what's the sense? I thought attributes were suppose to mean something this season, by all rights a level 22 WR catching passes from a similar leveled Qb shouldn't catch anything with 27 catching, just my opinion.


More goes into catching a pass then just the WR's catching and the QB


Obviously, that's why I said most of our other attributes are close enough that they don't matter and the SA's are similar (on the Possession side of things). So the only difference, and it's huge, is the speed. So basicly you can ignore catching and pump up speed and be a better catching receiver then a guy who actually puts points into catching, I don't think that's how it is intended to work. If it is then I want to know why defenders have to actually put points into tackling this season, why can't they simply run fast and win like the offense does?
 
RTJakarta
offline
Link
 
I think my fav part is that when he levels up, with equipment, it will be 100 speed ez.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Justafan
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Originally posted by Justafan


What I don't understand is how your guy, who's build is open, can have less strength, catching and vision then my more "possession" WR who's much lower level and my guy drops passes like it's his job. 10 last year and one already this year. Every other attribute is close enough to be a wash and I have all 2's in possession tree so that's a wash. This game is frustrating at times. If a guy with 27 catches catches as well as a guy with 47 what's the sense? I thought attributes were suppose to mean something this season, by all rights a level 22 WR catching passes from a similar leveled Qb shouldn't catch anything with 27 catching, just my opinion.


Well it does make sense. Flames' players have the speed to get wide open. The QB can just get him the ball easily wide open because of the separation they can get. You need a lot less catching skills to catch a pass while wide open than when covered.


This is why they have so many college track stars becoming such great WR's in the NFL right? If all you need is speed to run past a CB and you get a free catch the game is just as broke as it was last season. Just over one point in catching per level shouldn't make for a quality WR, just my opinion and obviously not Borts. WR's get paid to ...

a. run fast?
b. catch the ball?

If it's A then ok, so be it. If it's B then catching should be your primary attribute, or at least not your third.. fourth.. or lower. I don't blame Flames (and others) for making the speedster WR's and obviously they are effective I simply think that Bort missed the boat when he made the changes for this season. Tackling was looked at and you see many more missed tackles this season because defenders were relying on "wrap up" and no tackling attribute points. The same thing should, again IMO, have happened to recieving.


This isn't the NFL, this is GLB. Speed isn't the only thing you need to get open, but when you have it so high like in this case, it sure helps a lot. I'm sure if you saw a player with 60 speed, the same agility, and the same catching, he wouldn't be able to get open. Anyways, there's more than one way to build a WR. I don't see it being that much of a problem. Personally, my WRs have a good mix of speed and agility, and they play well too. It's all about what kind of build you want. Many different builds work with different gameplanning. I didn't watch the game or anything, but I doubt this WR would run different routes as effectively as he runs the streak. It's fair IMO. He sacrificed the WR's other stats to go all out on speed, got it to a really high number, and he is a specialist at running go routes. I don't see a problem with that. Even more of a speed nerf isn't warranted. He has 96 speed for God's sake...of course he's gonna burn anyone. If you nerf speed to the point where 96 speed doesn't make a noticeable difference against a corner with 70 speed, then it ruins the point of getting certain skills to certain levels.
 
Justafan
offline
Link
 

Originally posted by Sik Wit It

This isn't the NFL, this is GLB. Speed isn't the only thing you need to get open, but when you have it so high like in this case, it sure helps a lot. I'm sure if you saw a player with 60 speed, the same agility, and the same catching, he wouldn't be able to get open. Anyways, there's more than one way to build a WR. I don't see it being that much of a problem. Personally, my WRs have a good mix of speed and agility, and they play well too. It's all about what kind of build you want. Many different builds work with different gameplanning. I didn't watch the game or anything, but I doubt this WR would run different routes as effectively as he runs the streak. It's fair IMO. He sacrificed the WR's other stats to go all out on speed, got it to a really high number, and he is a specialist at running go routes. I don't see a problem with that. Even more of a speed nerf isn't warranted. He has 96 speed for God's sake...of course he's gonna burn anyone. If you nerf speed to the point where 96 speed doesn't make a noticeable difference against a corner with 70 speed, then it ruins the point of getting certain skills to certain levels.


I didn't say nerf speed. I said good job on the build that works. What I said is that catching is the problem. Way to address what I said. You think it's ok for a 22nd level WR to have 27 in catching and catch everything just because he's a track star?

By the way, it's a football sim. That means that if you have an attribute it should make sense. Speed makes you go faster. Tackling, especially this season, makes you tackle better. Vision gives you better field vision to recognize plays. Catching? Doesn't matter. You can't make up any other attribute like that. They even fixed blocking for OL men so if your simply strong without any blocking you won't be as good because while your tough to move, you have no knowledge of how to block. Catching still sees, after one game, to still be a secondary skill for a WR and I don't see how that makes sense.
 
Alex44
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by Justafan

Originally posted by Sik Wit It


Originally posted by Justafan



What I don't understand is how your guy, who's build is open, can have less strength, catching and vision then my more "possession" WR who's much lower level and my guy drops passes like it's his job. 10 last year and one already this year. Every other attribute is close enough to be a wash and I have all 2's in possession tree so that's a wash. This game is frustrating at times. If a guy with 27 catches catches as well as a guy with 47 what's the sense? I thought attributes were suppose to mean something this season, by all rights a level 22 WR catching passes from a similar leveled Qb shouldn't catch anything with 27 catching, just my opinion.


Well it does make sense. Flames' players have the speed to get wide open. The QB can just get him the ball easily wide open because of the separation they can get. You need a lot less catching skills to catch a pass while wide open than when covered.


This is why they have so many college track stars becoming such great WR's in the NFL right? If all you need is speed to run past a CB and you get a free catch the game is just as broke as it was last season. Just over one point in catching per level shouldn't make for a quality WR, just my opinion and obviously not Borts. WR's get paid to ...

a. run fast?
b. catch the ball?

If it's A then ok, so be it. If it's B then catching should be your primary attribute, or at least not your third.. fourth.. or lower. I don't blame Flames (and others) for making the speedster WR's and obviously they are effective I simply think that Bort missed the boat when he made the changes for this season. Tackling was looked at and you see many more missed tackles this season because defenders were relying on "wrap up" and no tackling attribute points. The same thing should, again IMO, have happened to recieving.


This isn't the NFL, this is GLB. Speed isn't the only thing you need to get open, but when you have it so high like in this case, it sure helps a lot. I'm sure if you saw a player with 60 speed, the same agility, and the same catching, he wouldn't be able to get open. Anyways, there's more than one way to build a WR. I don't see it being that much of a problem. Personally, my WRs have a good mix of speed and agility, and they play well too. It's all about what kind of build you want. Many different builds work with different gameplanning. I didn't watch the game or anything, but I doubt this WR would run different routes as effectively as he runs the streak. It's fair IMO. He sacrificed the WR's other stats to go all out on speed, got it to a really high number, and he is a specialist at running go routes. I don't see a problem with that. Even more of a speed nerf isn't warranted. He has 96 speed for God's sake...of course he's gonna burn anyone. If you nerf speed to the point where 96 speed doesn't make a noticeable difference against a corner with 70 speed, then it ruins the point of getting certain skills to certain levels.


Very true, but if that 70 speed corner has 50 agility (which means better acceleration) he should be able to keep up. Especially since he starts with a cushion anyway.

 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
The point that many people miss with pure burners is that they make the game more interesting -- quite the opposite of encouraging cookie-cutter builds. They force defenses to consider deep zones and larger cushions in man coverage. They provide a risky offensive gamble that might pay off huge but more likely will result in a dropped pass and a lost down. They offer only one of many potential builds available for WRs. I have one, and he is the least prolific of my 5 WRs... but both my ground game and my other WRs benefit from defenses knowing that speedster will be on the field. When a defense chooses to ignore him completely by keeping the safeties in and the corners tight, they deserve to get burned with the occasionally successful gamble at a deep strike, instant TD. Of course playing him safe just opens up the field for the rest of the offense -- that's the whole point of player build diversity in a team sport.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Well... some guys really need to think about playing every WR "close" coverage distance. It just shouldn't work on everyone.

I like such builds. Not the usual stuff.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Justafan

I didn't say nerf speed. I said good job on the build that works. What I said is that catching is the problem. Way to address what I said. You think it's ok for a 22nd level WR to have 27 in catching and catch everything just because he's a track star?

By the way, it's a football sim. That means that if you have an attribute it should make sense. Speed makes you go faster. Tackling, especially this season, makes you tackle better. Vision gives you better field vision to recognize plays. Catching? Doesn't matter. You can't make up any other attribute like that. They even fixed blocking for OL men so if your simply strong without any blocking you won't be as good because while your tough to move, you have no knowledge of how to block. Catching still sees, after one game, to still be a secondary skill for a WR and I don't see how that makes sense.


I know I quoted your post, but not everything I said was meant for you. Some other people in the thread were saying nerf speed. I do agree catching should be very important, and definitely not insignificant to the point of neglecting it, it's just that his WRs have the speed to get so open, that they are under no pressure when making the catch, so the catch is a pretty easy one to make.

Originally posted by

Very true, but if that 70 speed corner has 50 agility (which means better acceleration) he should be able to keep up. Especially since he starts with a cushion anyway.


On certain routes, but on a streak I'd expect the player with the faster speed to win
 
Alex44
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by Justafan


I didn't say nerf speed. I said good job on the build that works. What I said is that catching is the problem. Way to address what I said. You think it's ok for a 22nd level WR to have 27 in catching and catch everything just because he's a track star?

By the way, it's a football sim. That means that if you have an attribute it should make sense. Speed makes you go faster. Tackling, especially this season, makes you tackle better. Vision gives you better field vision to recognize plays. Catching? Doesn't matter. You can't make up any other attribute like that. They even fixed blocking for OL men so if your simply strong without any blocking you won't be as good because while your tough to move, you have no knowledge of how to block. Catching still sees, after one game, to still be a secondary skill for a WR and I don't see how that makes sense.


I know I quoted your post, but not everything I said was meant for you. Some other people in the thread were saying nerf speed. I do agree catching should be very important, and definitely not insignificant to the point of neglecting it, it's just that his WRs have the speed to get so open, that they are under no pressure when making the catch, so the catch is a pretty easy one to make.

Originally posted by


Very true, but if that 70 speed corner has 50 agility (which means better acceleration) he should be able to keep up. Especially since he starts with a cushion anyway.


On certain routes, but on a streak I'd expect the player with the faster speed to win


It depends how long the offensive line holds and how far the QB can throw. Honestly I'd expect that corner to keep pace at least 15-20 yards down the field, maybe more if he is playing loose. Plus there should be safety help in a lot of cases.
Last edited Aug 3, 2008 16:55:47
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Justafan


By the way, it's a football sim. That means that if you have an attribute it should make sense. Speed makes you go faster. Tackling, especially this season, makes you tackle better. Vision gives you better field vision to recognize plays. Catching? Doesn't matter. You can't make up any other attribute like that. They even fixed blocking for OL men so if your simply strong without any blocking you won't be as good because while your tough to move, you have no knowledge of how to block. Catching still sees, after one game, to still be a secondary skill for a WR and I don't see how that makes sense.



By your logic:

Speed makes you run faster, catching should make you catch better.

27 catching should make you not able to catch....


.....so 27 speed means you shouldn't be able to walk. 27 speed players shouldn't be allowed to move, correct?


Oh course not.

27 speed doesn't move very fast and 27 catching doesn't catch very well (notice the bobbling that 27 catching receivers do in addition to the misses). If there was a CB anywhere near when the bobble occurred then it would be incomplete.
 
Justafan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
The point that many people miss with pure burners is that they make the game more interesting -- quite the opposite of encouraging cookie-cutter builds. They force defenses to consider deep zones and larger cushions in man coverage. They provide a risky offensive gamble that might pay off huge but more likely will result in a dropped pass and a lost down. They offer only one of many potential builds available for WRs. I have one, and he is the least prolific of my 5 WRs... but both my ground game and my other WRs benefit from defenses knowing that speedster will be on the field. When a defense chooses to ignore him completely by keeping the safeties in and the corners tight, they deserve to get burned with the occasionally successful gamble at a deep strike, instant TD. Of course playing him safe just opens up the field for the rest of the offense -- that's the whole point of player build diversity in a team sport.


I disagree to a point. I have zero problems with a speedster WR. Open things up and make the defense pay for not covering him or having slow DB's. With that said my only argument about these "speedsters" is they have no catching and still catch everything just like possession WR's. If speed works like that then can I make a SS with only speed and no tackling and have him just run really fast into guys to tackle them instead of needing tackling to bring a guy down? That's what some people are trying to justify in saying "speed makes you get open easier so you can catch better", well speed will help you tackle a guy too, but it doesn't work like that in this game. It needs to be the same for all positions, if speed wins then it should win equally for every position. 96 speed and 27 tackling is going to give you a grocery list of "missed tackles" so it doesn't seem quite right.

Bort said in the other thread about this that the WR/team simply got lucky on the randomness of sim. Said there was a very small percent chance that a guy with that build would go that game again without a drop. That tells me it was more lucky then anything and also tells me that Bort is watching that closely which is good.

Speed should defiantly have a place in the game, and a speedster WR should be able to burn the defense on occasion but in the same aspect if you can't catch you can't catch.
 
Justafan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
The point that many people miss with pure burners is that they make the game more interesting -- quite the opposite of encouraging cookie-cutter builds. They force defenses to consider deep zones and larger cushions in man coverage. They provide a risky offensive gamble that might pay off huge but more likely will result in a dropped pass and a lost down. They offer only one of many potential builds available for WRs. I have one, and he is the least prolific of my 5 WRs... but both my ground game and my other WRs benefit from defenses knowing that speedster will be on the field. When a defense chooses to ignore him completely by keeping the safeties in and the corners tight, they deserve to get burned with the occasionally successful gamble at a deep strike, instant TD. Of course playing him safe just opens up the field for the rest of the offense -- that's the whole point of player build diversity in a team sport.


I disagree to a point. I have zero problems with a speedster WR. Open things up and make the defense pay for not covering him or having slow DB's. With that said my only argument about these "speedsters" is they have no catching and still catch everything just like possession WR's. If speed works like that then can I make a SS with only speed and no tackling and have him just run really fast into guys to tackle them instead of needing tackling to bring a guy down? That's what some people are trying to justify in saying "speed makes you get open easier so you can catch better", well speed will help you tackle a guy too, but it doesn't work like that in this game. It needs to be the same for all positions, if speed wins then it should win equally for every position. 96 speed and 27 tackling is going to give you a grocery list of "missed tackles" so it doesn't seem quite right.

Bort said in the other thread about this that the WR/team simply got lucky on the randomness of sim. Said there was a very small percent chance that a guy with that build would go that game again without a drop. That tells me it was more lucky then anything and also tells me that Bort is watching that closely which is good.

Speed should defiantly have a place in the game, and a speedster WR should be able to burn the defense on occasion but in the same aspect if you can't catch you can't catch.
 
kingofgod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Det Lions Fan1
Originally posted by ultrajer

Originally posted by DaRealest


This is getting really old.






 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.