User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > The solution!! For retiring players, teams playing 100+ plays per player/penalizing depth, and rewarding team with good defenses/quick scoring offenses
Page:
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Emanbears23
Guys, 10 seasons are a VERY long time away.Over a years away, do any of you who are so worried about this even know if you will still be so heavily into this game by then? Think about it, it's a long ways away.


Even if you aren't here then you should be a decent human being and try to leave the world a better place for your existence.

When you die that's all that is going to matter. Was the world a better place for your having lived?

...what I'm telling you is that maybe you shouldn't live so much in the now. It's evil.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
So you're saying to avoid letting people play the system...instead we dont tell anyone how it works?? Im not sure i like that idea if we're trying to hide things now.

Also if we are having a combination of 2 things decide retirement...how complicated is that??? Because if its going to be hard on the admins then that will take away from tactic and other updates. When this problem could really be solved simple with lowering the cap from 90 to a lower number (such as 60)
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
...that was actually my biggest problem with this though.
Seems to reward the players that aren't playing too much.

The guys in the Hall Of Fame all played backup for most of their careers? Seems odd.


see the age limit - you can't just sit on a bench for your entire career boosting and then come in and crush people. Its a combination of the too.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
So you're saying to avoid letting people play the system...instead we dont tell anyone how it works?? Im not sure i like that idea if we're trying to hide things now.

Also if we are having a combination of 2 things decide retirement...how complicated is that??? Because if its going to be hard on the admins then that will take away from tactic and other updates. When this problem could really be solved simple with lowering the cap from 90 to a lower number (such as 60)


umm, do you know how the formula works for simming a game and comparing a player's attributes? Do you know how much of a bonus sticky hands gives you when your player is at 20 catch vs. 30 catch? If people knew how the formula's worked, then its just a matter of math to figure out the perfect player. where's the fun in that?

having a formula put 2 things together to figure out when a player stops increasing in skill isn't a very difficult thing to do for the programming...

lowering the cap to a lower number still doesn't solve the problem 90 plays in a game - starter gets 60 and backup gets 30. So whats the incentive to be a backup?
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 23:17:53
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly
Besides - if everyone just plays their starters at 100+ plays a game, then in 10 seasons everyone will be the same anyway, so I don't see your point...


Yeah, but at least the only people that get rewarded are the people who actually did do everything that the system asked of them. The "best" ones.

I'm not saying the system shouldn't be changed and we shouldn't discourage the "best" ones from making the game a little silly, I AM saying that I don't just want to give everything to everyone.
 
Emanbears23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Emanbears23

Guys, 10 seasons are a VERY long time away.Over a years away, do any of you who are so worried about this even know if you will still be so heavily into this game by then? Think about it, it's a long ways away.


Even if you aren't here then you should be a decent human being and try to leave the world a better place for your existence.

When you die that's all that is going to matter. Was the world a better place for your having lived?

...what I'm telling you is that maybe you shouldn't live so much in the now. It's evil.


Well I have always been the "live for today" type of guy so I guess I can't think about a year from now. I really don't know how long I'm gonna be into this game or even have time to play. All summer I will but then I start college so then I'm screwed.

Anyway, I actually agree with the 10000 plays idea, as for people sitting on the bench, maybe we could take off of thier total like half of what the satrter got.

1st string QB - 52 plays, so 10000-52
2nd string QB - 10000-26
3rd string QB - 10000-13
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly
see the age limit - you can't just sit on a bench for your entire career boosting and then come in and crush people. Its a combination of the too.


I only said "backup" and I mean the guy that gets plays but doesn't start. That guy, in your system, is a Hall of Famer. Of course, all the guys who started in front of him his whole career may not be Hall of Famers.
...just seems odd.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by jearly

Besides - if everyone just plays their starters at 100+ plays a game, then in 10 seasons everyone will be the same anyway, so I don't see your point...


Yeah, but at least the only people that get rewarded are the people who actually did do everything that the system asked of them. The "best" ones.

I'm not saying the system shouldn't be changed and we shouldn't discourage the "best" ones from making the game a little silly, I AM saying that I don't just want to give everything to everyone.


the people who get rewarded are the superstars that cost their teams games because they have no depth? How is that doin everytihing the system asks of them?

you need some incentive to be a backup, otherwise the game should just be changed to only have cpu backups or eliminate stamina cuz no player will want to be a backup...
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly


lowering the cap to a lower number still doesn't solve the problem 90 plays in a game - starter gets 60 and backup gets 30. So whats the incentive to be a backup?


To win i guess would be the incentive. Also i run my team trying to get the backup 50-60 plays a game as it is.

 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Emanbears23
Well I have always been the "live for today" type of guy so I guess I can't think about a year from now. I really don't know how long I'm gonna be into this game or even have time to play. All summer I will but then I start college so then I'm screwed.


I missed it.
Who asked for A/S/L?
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by jearly

see the age limit - you can't just sit on a bench for your entire career boosting and then come in and crush people. Its a combination of the too.


I only said "backup" and I mean the guy that gets plays but doesn't start. That guy, in your system, is a Hall of Famer. Of course, all the guys who started in front of him his whole career may not be Hall of Famers.
...just seems odd.


if the guy is a backup he will also get plays that in combination with his age will determine the end of the time he progresses. Besides, at some point he needs to "start" to get the stats to be a hall of famer...
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by jearly



lowering the cap to a lower number still doesn't solve the problem 90 plays in a game - starter gets 60 and backup gets 30. So whats the incentive to be a backup?


To win i guess would be the incentive. Also i run my team trying to get the backup 50-60 plays a game as it is.



sure, my team is doing that and winning right now (crushing teams in the playoffs actually), but eventually that human player will want to move on and start. If we don't give him the opportunity to progress as a backup, then why would he ever want to start his career off as a backup.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Human players might want to move on and start. But in theory that probably means you'll have to go "down" to a lower leveled league. So the question for them becomes play 50-60 plays as a backup for a high leveled team....or go start in a lesser league.
 
Ragemaster
offline
Link
 
Does anyone else hate the idea of (essentially) forcing us to retire? I'm all for the game being similar to the real deal, that is, until it makes you start all over. This is particularly a problem for people who don't want to spend a lot of money on more than one player. With that being said, I completely understand the owners of the site wanting to make themselves a pretty penny. I just wish there was a way for non-paying players to be competitive with people who pay gobs of money.

It's really to the point where I'm debating whether I want to continue playing. I think the 'diminishing skill rates' is my biggest complaint. Anyone who has played a MMORPG knows how there gets to be a certain attachment to their character or player. So, just think of how it will feel when, after 10 seasons, you have to give him/her up.

Simply putting my player in the hall of fame isn't what I'm playing for. I'm playing to continually develop and improve my character. Even if it gets to the point where I'm training for 0.01 of a skill per day.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ragemaster
Does anyone else hate the idea of (essentially) forcing us to retire? I'm all for the game being similar to the real deal, that is, until it makes you start all over. This is particularly a problem for people who don't want to spend a lot of money on more than one player. With that being said, I completely understand the owners of the site wanting to make themselves a pretty penny. I just wish there was a way for non-paying players to be competitive with people who pay gobs of money.

It's really to the point where I'm debating whether I want to continue playing. I think the 'diminishing skill rates' is my biggest complaint. Anyone who has played a MMORPG knows how there gets to be a certain attachment to their character or player. So, just think of how it will feel when, after 10 seasons, you have to give him/her up.

Simply putting my player in the hall of fame isn't what I'm playing for. I'm playing to continually develop and improve my character. Even if it gets to the point where I'm training for 0.01 of a skill per day.


Without retirement there is no way that someone can compete who starts at say...season 3! It is this way so everyone gets a chance to win not just those who started year 1.

Also since you get most of the FP back when they retire i dont think its just a scheme to get money....but thats just my opinion.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.