User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > punting bug cost us the game !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! we need the w or it needs to be resimmed
Page:
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE

I'm sorry, it appears you are the slow one here. First, those AI bugs were found a long time ago and have been fixed for a long time. Second, he never asked why default settings were set up incorrectly, he demanded a win or a re-sim because the AI did not use "football logic" and bypass his input/output structure. And finally, he did screw up his settings by not checking them before the game.

It isn't like we were just handed the AI yesterday to use today -- we've had two scrims and a lot of time to review it. He admitted to loading an old preset, so yes, it was his user error.


The bugs were not fixed a long time ago and a lot of teams are still experiencing them, his only problem was not checking the inputs created by the programmer which any sensible person would expect to be correct.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
any sensible person would test/check something before using it - get a clue
Last edited Aug 2, 2008 15:20:36
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Welsh76
Originally posted by SCACE


I'm sorry, it appears you are the slow one here. First, those AI bugs were found a long time ago and have been fixed for a long time. Second, he never asked why default settings were set up incorrectly, he demanded a win or a re-sim because the AI did not use "football logic" and bypass his input/output structure. And finally, he did screw up his settings by not checking them before the game.

It isn't like we were just handed the AI yesterday to use today -- we've had two scrims and a lot of time to review it. He admitted to loading an old preset, so yes, it was his user error.


The bugs were not fixed a long time ago and a lot of teams are still experiencing them, his only problem was not checking the inputs created by the programmer which any sensible person would expect to be correct.


So in other words he assumed they would be correct...You know what assuming does???
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
any sensible person would test/check something before using it - get a clue


This is a problem created by Bort and the least that should have happened was a pm to every team owner explaining how to rectify his mistake. I've been helping out a lot of teams over the past few days and this is not an isolated incident.
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MRIGUY

So in other words he assumed they would be correct...You know what assuming does???


He didn't assume, he expected it to be correct.

The point I'm trying to make is that people are quick to 'assume' that he screwed up his own settings which is wholly incorrect.
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Welsh76
Originally posted by MRIGUY


So in other words he assumed they would be correct...You know what assuming does???


He didn't assume, he expected it to be correct.

The point I'm trying to make is that people are quick to 'assume' that he screwed up his own settings which is wholly incorrect.


ok I'll play your game...He "expected" wrong then...just like me on my team. I've since fixed all of my outputs and inputs, so it won't happen again.
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Cruzi

I don't even use the offensive AI. I have no problems.


+1 lol...i use a very limited package on offense that we tested as best as we could with 2 scrims. And in the scrim, I found some holes and filled them.

I don't touch the defensive side, but so far, I'm happy with what my DC has strung up for us.


The defensive AI will make your eyes cross if you stare at it for too long, but it's got some good stuff. Should be a riot when the OAI catches up.
 
kaned
offline
Link
 
im not getting into this again because it's not going to make a difference at this point but the preset was not old per say, it was one that i used during the first scrimmagebut not the second, and the one that i had built in the offseason, what i said was it was not the default one in which bort apparently fixed for everyone, according to Bort's comments earlier in the thread

arrggg lol ok here goes

i didnt assume, i was following the instructions on the top of the page where it says

" If you leave a field blank, there are no matching inputs for a situation, or there are no outputs listed, play calling will default to your "basic" settings and general football logic "

now we can argue what it means and what a "field" is but until Bort comes on here and says that the statement is false or that its valid it makes no difference

if you think of a field as a box for information to be entered in an input or output then the above statement is false, if you think of a field as the input or output as scace does then the statement is true and i misread it

i guess the statement is also true if you have the updated version of the preset but i didnt and had no way of knowing that i didnt, nor did anyone else


now im done, argue away but the only thing i assumed was that the instructions were correct, im over the actual loss, sux, but we'll be ok

Last edited Aug 2, 2008 15:48:13
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Welsh76
Originally posted by MRIGUY


So in other words he assumed they would be correct...You know what assuming does???


He didn't assume, he expected it to be correct.

The point I'm trying to make is that people are quick to 'assume' that he screwed up his own settings which is wholly incorrect.


I expect my weekly paycheque to be correct too, but that doesn't mean I don't check it every week to make sure there wasn't a mistake.

We can argue all you want, and if you bothered to read back to the start of the thread, I said that this should be an autofill for the default and Bort replied that it is. It isn't that I don't feel bad, its a shitty way to lose, but it is user error to just take something at face value and not bother to ensure it is correct before rolling it out as your team tactics.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
kaned - I feel for your loss, but the fact remains there was an input and output for the play in question - not one you would ever want to see, but it was there, and that is why your team went for it. Just be happy it happened now and not in a playoff game.
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kaned
im not getting into this again because it's not going to make a difference at this point but the preset was not old per say, it was one that i used during the first scrimmagebut not the second, and the one that i had built in the offseason, what i said was it was not the default one in which bort apparently fixed for everyone, according to Bort's comments earlier in the thread

arrggg lol ok here goes

i didnt assume, i was following the instructions on the top of the page where it says

" If you leave a field blank, there are no matching inputs for a situation, or there are no outputs listed, play calling will default to your "basic" settings and general football logic "

now we can argue what it means and what a "field" is but until Bort comes on here and says that the statement is false or that its valid it makes no difference

if you think of a field as a box for information to be entered in an input or output then the above statement is false, if you think of a field as the input or output as scace does then the statement is true and i misread it

i guess the statement is also true if you have the updated version of the preset but i didnt and had no way of knowing that i didnt, nor did anyone else


now im done, argue away but the only thing i assumed was that the instructions were correct, im over the actual loss, sux, but we'll be ok



I only do the defense, I haven't even bothered to really look at the offensive AI. But I know it says this on quarter specific AI on the defensive side:

Quarter 4 Specific (Overrides Above General Settings)

Meaning anything set there will override ANYTHING you set above in the general A.I. and basic settings. Does it not say this on the offensive side?
 
seahawk10
Last name Wilson
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Binestar


Look at your "DOWN LATE" entry in the 4th quarter, the score part is empty. -300 and -1 should be entered.

Basically it's triggering even when you're not down.


Yep, common problem.


Might be worth auto-populating with the defaults?


+1

 
kr0n
offline
Link
 
WAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
 
Link
 
Question: If you have it at -300 to -1, will it know to kick a FG if you are down by 3 or less, or should you put the settings at -7 to -3?

 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forward_Lateral
Question: If you have it at -300 to -1, will it know to kick a FG if you are down by 3 or less, or should you put the settings at -7 to -3?

It depends on what order you have your inputs in, among other things.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.