User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP For Defense: Bad D=Good XP
Page:
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Easier said than done. What about when there are minimum rosters? I'm lucky, one of my players ended up in a great active team. He doesn't get as many plays, but he sees the field and is gaining xp. My other player ended up on a crappy team, but he was in 55, 66, and 53 plays. He is a backup but owner has him as #2 at both G and he played more than either starter. I'd love to see that setup.

But some people aren't as fortunate when they come into the game. They don't know how to scout owners, they just take the first contract they get or choose out of a list of contracts they receive early.

If done right there could easily be 10,000 - 20,000 people playing this game. If done wrong, and players get shafted, it could dwindle to 500.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard


If done right there could easily be 10,000 - 20,000 people playing this game. If done wrong, and players get shafted, it could dwindle to 500.


I think they're way over that number.

Roster minimums?? easy to get around. Just sign level 1 cpu's to ride the pine. That honestly wont have any effect on that type of thing!
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
I don't think it matters.

The longer your defense is on the field, the more XP and plays they get. That means your offense gets less. What's the deal?
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Not all games have same number of plays. I've seen a range from under 100 to over 160
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by Rage Kinard



If done right there could easily be 10,000 - 20,000 people playing this game. If done wrong, and players get shafted, it could dwindle to 500.


I think they're way over that number.

Roster minimums?? easy to get around. Just sign level 1 cpu's to ride the pine. That honestly wont have any effect on that type of thing!


But how many of those are active and going to stick around for the long term and spend money?
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
have you really see a game under 100 totalif that happens alot i might change my ideas.

I dont know how many are active...or how many spend money. I think only 2 people know that right now!
 
Mrstickball
offline
Link
 
IMO, I think you could do a few "bonus" EXP situations.

Like: not only would players gain EXP from the # of plays, but add bonus EXP for the types of plays that are done.

IE, if a team scores effectively, they could gain a bonus for a "quick-strike touchdown" - scoring in under 3 plays.

Likewise, the defense could gain a bonus if they held a team to a 3-and-out.

This would benefit teams with both prolific offenses, and strong defenses.
 
Ninjoe
offline
Link
 
Implement injuries, if you play too many plays you have a higher chance of injury, which will say degrade your stats 5,10, up to 50%?

You could set the game to analyze the depth chart. If someone is playing both sides of the ball consistently they could have a reduced modifier of XP.
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 19:30:30
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
have you really see a game under 100 totalif that happens alot i might change my ideas.

I dont know how many are active...or how many spend money. I think only 2 people know that right now!



I've only seen 1. I can't find it anymore. Both teams ran the ball an insane percentage of the time. That didn't count special teams plays either. Just total offensive and defensive.


I think 150 is closer to average than 120 the more I look though. So 60 plays would be a good cap.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
OK...i can live with a 60 cap. I think that seems to be the middle ground for most of the thinking!
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
if you have xp per game instead of plays, then it gives thed defense the same experience whether they dominate the offense wiht 40 plays or get shredded and are on the field for 100 plays.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly
if you have xp per game instead of plays, then it gives thed defense the same experience whether they dominate the offense wiht 40 plays or get shredded and are on the field for 100 plays.


Then wont everyone just jump ship to the best teams in the USA pro???
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly
if you have xp per game instead of plays, then it gives thed defense the same experience whether they dominate the offense wiht 40 plays or get shredded and are on the field for 100 plays.


So basically people who choose to play for idiots arent punished and idiots arent punished? Yeah there are a lot of suggestions to cater to stupid or lazy people and I dont agree with one of them.

While I dont agree with the gaming the system that is going on by some users, it would be much worse to just give exp per game .. lots of people lose a lot of snaps because of stupid owners and it is their own fault for not taking a good look at a team and really talking with an owner before they accept a contract.

I believe that the most prevalent way of getting a contract in this game is for some idiots to carpetbomb offers and then similar idiots just take the one with the biggest number. If you negotiated beforehand with select individuals before making any offer, you would filter most of the idiots out .. unless you are just stupid yourself in which case, Darwin believes that you are meant for each other anyways.
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 20:17:08
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by jearly

if you have xp per game instead of plays, then it gives thed defense the same experience whether they dominate the offense wiht 40 plays or get shredded and are on the field for 100 plays.


Then wont everyone just jump ship to the best teams in the USA pro???


you get the same xp per game whether you play in pro or CCC. So yes, there will be competition to be on the pro level but the pro level should attract the top backups.

plus, the pro teams aren't going to sign everyone and a player will ahve to decide whether he wants to be a starter on a AAA team or a backup on a pro team. Right now that's an easy decision becaus the AAA Team/starter role will allow you to progress while the backup role will hinder your development as a player. give xp per game, and it actually makes the backup/pro vs. starter/AAA a tougher decision.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Randy03Texags
Originally posted by jearly

if you have xp per game instead of plays, then it gives thed defense the same experience whether they dominate the offense wiht 40 plays or get shredded and are on the field for 100 plays.


So basically people who choose to play for idiots arent punished and idiots arent punished? Yeah there are a lot of suggestions to cater to stupid or lazy people and I dont agree with one of them.

While I dont agree with the gaming the system that is going on by some users, it would be much worse to just give exp per game .. lots of people lose a lot of snaps because of stupid owners and it is their own fault for not taking a good look at a team and really talking with an owner before they accept a contract.

I believe that the most prevalent way of getting a contract in this game is for some idiots to carpetbomb offers and then similar idiots just take the one with the biggest number. If you negotiated beforehand with select individuals before making any offer, you would filter most of the idiots out .. unless you are just stupid yourself in which case, Darwin believes that you are meant for each other anyways.


Or, people who choose to play for a team with great depth that really employs the "depth" concept or plays for a great defense, dont' get penalizd.

"stupid" players can still get a ton of xp in the current system.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.