User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Passing needs to be fixed in this game, very long post with a ton of research, don't discard as another whine post
Page:
 
TDmaker99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by dpell

Ken, all I know is that most of the teams I play on are among the best in their divisions, and we're seeing really low completion percentages suddenly this year. I understand emphasizing catching for WR's, agility for one-dimensional builds, and tackling for the defense, but the result so far as I see it is that most QB's are completing an abnormally low percentage of passes. And while Bort made an appearance in this thread, I've yet to see him show any concern about it. Surely he can run a database query and pull the overall completion percentages by leagues, and I'm sure what we'd see is that they're down quite a bit.

And I know that on my team at least the only WR we have that's close to one-dimensional is our slot WR who has 80spd/45agl. Otherwise my other WR have softcapped their agility and have 40+ catching. In a 62-0 blowout I had WR with 70spd/50agl/55catch being shut down by a lvl 13 SS out of position playing CB. Something is wrong there.


I'm not saying everything's perfect with passing. I'm just saying that it's no worse than last season, and probably a little better from the box scores I look at.

Last season, it was hard to get more than 5 yards per pass attempt, either. So if someone suggests going back to anything from the execrable Season 3, I'll yell and scream until I get a sore throat.

Again, Bort had the solution: a bit of a nerf to pass coverage. I thought it was going to happen, and maybe I'll post about it again, but it does have to be done in a measured way, and hopefully it would add a yard or so per pass attempt, the other yard or so that might be needed to mirror real life coming eventually as defenders have to improve their tackling, instead of spending all their points on pass coverage skills.


last season our qb avg 6, last game he avg 5, but thats not what im talking about, look at the replays of games the wr's are not getting open at all and we have builds, like 71 speed 58 agility 40 catching 35 vision so don’t you think that db's of the same lvl should not be able to blanket the wr the ENTIRE game, i mean some times u cant even see the damn wr dot because the DB is on top of him 5-10 yards down field, and again the db is playing tight coverage, there is no reason to play any other way this year because u wont get beat deep, so eventually everyone will stack the los and running will be crap again but this season so will passing , bank on it , it will happen
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 22:16:57
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Yea, wonder what the passing game will look like once Pass interference calls are made.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
No way passing is the same strength as last season. All of the numbers I posted say it's down. Completion percentage needs to go up and yac needs to go up a little and we'll be much more realistic compared to NFL type numbers. The problem last year with the passing game was you'd pass for 250 yards and 230 of them would be actual in the air passing yards and 20 yards would be yac. WR's caught the ball and were immediately tackled.

This year they're not completing passes at all. Some teams are seeing some long TD runs when a CB misses a tackle, but overall I'm just seeing CB's own WR's. And if you trust the dots a lot of that seems to be illegal contact.


I agree that completion percentage needs to go up, and that would solve a lot. But I was making this same argument about both halves of offense last season, and typical pass offenses in GLB were under 5 yards per attempt. That's still happening, and that still needs fixing. But last season wasn't better.

Real life yards per pass attempt are almost 7, and in GLB they should be as well. Some of that will come as people focus more on tackling, but Bort also needs to take action.

I'll put that into the Bugs forum if you'll have my back. I don't want to go in there and have certain anti-passing advocates take me on 4 on 1.
 
ramsfan222
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=721578

Conclusions - It's broken. Too many drops, CB's regularly impeding routes and committing PI to get a deflection, very low level CB's are schooling high level WR's and QB's.

No response from Bort although someone said he'd acknowledged the CB issue in another thread.


To the too many drops part.... its in the WRs build. My guy had 0 drops last year as the #2 WR on a EEP team that made it to the playoffs..... and passed 60% of the time.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
We've pushed this into the bugs forum already and Bort hasn't paid much attention. He's said that the CB interfering with the WR is something he knows about (I'm told 2nd hand), but I've yet to see him say it's going to be fixed or addressed.

With all the sim changes this season everyone is going to be trading high level WR's for power backs who can break 3 tackles on a single running play.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Again, I've got a WR with 55 catching and soft-capped vision dropping lots of passes. I'd venture that that's in the top 2-5% of GLB WR's for catching.
 
ramsfan222
offline
Link
 
I have 40 catching, no drops.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Your QB's also combined for 20/49 passing attempts your first scrimmage game too.
 
ramsfan222
offline
Link
 
I meant all of last season dumbo.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
Again, I've got a WR with 55 catching and soft-capped vision dropping lots of passes. I'd venture that that's in the top 2-5% of GLB WR's for catching.


Something else is lacking in your build then.

It's not the sim. My WR's aren't dropping passes like your guy is. My 4 WRs and starting TE combined only dropped 4 passes out of 82 attempted throws to them. Seriously. See for yourself, we ran a fun test:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=78994

this wasn't against a gutted or crap team, either.


 
ramsfan222
offline
Link
 
Plus, that was against a top 6 team in EEP.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
We've pushed this into the bugs forum already and Bort hasn't paid much attention. He's said that the CB interfering with the WR is something he knows about (I'm told 2nd hand), but I've yet to see him say it's going to be fixed or addressed.

With all the sim changes this season everyone is going to be trading high level WR's for power backs who can break 3 tackles on a single running play.


I pushed it there and had Bort ready to decrease defender reaction time (and thus deflections), then the anti-passing crusade came in.

Bort usually pays attention to my threads there; so I'm willing to go in, but not without help.
 
MeHigh7
offline
Link
 
Hmm.. after seeing that my QB had a terrible game going 9/27 for 92 yards. I decided to check every other QB who threw a pass in the 1st scrimmage, in my league, to see how they did. The Quarterbacks averaged 54.7% completion %. So now I'm sitting here wondering why my QB played so shit. He has a good build, at least i think so. Was it good game planning, where the plays they used the ones that are buggy, did my QB just have a bad game, is my QB just shit?
 
TDmaker99
offline
Link
 
i really enjoy this game, and think bort and company are great, but if the season starts as is ill be really unhappy, i really cant understand how anyone can think that what we all have seen in the scrimmages looks right to them ( im talking about the wr's )

some of the drops where the wr is wide open i can live with and atleast we can up catching and we can even add tackling ( for those tht are missing tackles ) but the speed thing where wr's cant get open is just killing me
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
I can't argue that we could probably use another scrimmage. for no other reason - to give Bort more time to squash bugs.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.