User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Does GLB almost necessitate farm teams (discussion)?
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by


maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure


I assume this means that you'll be doing a total pyramid thing? Damn


Pyramids per region. Yes, it's official (minus the announcement).

We have an idea for a short world tourney, too, to help tie everyone together. We'll announce that after we figure it out more. But those are both off-topic for this thread.


1) Thanks for the quick reply and sorry for the derail

2) Ahh I see, nice, sounds like you guys really put a lot of effort into a compromise, I look forward to it.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by thehazyone


Originally posted by Bort



I think the addition of salary caps and TEAM CHEMISTRY will help quite a bit with collusion, along with an earlier trade deadline, etc.

Salary caps will mean you can't stack your team with too many high level players (especially since there are minimum salaries based on level).

Team chemistry will mean that you have to keep a squad together for a while to keep them competitive. If you bring in too much new blood all at once, you'll hurt your team chemistry and your team will suck.

Also, we're discussing the idea of maybe having a designated "farm league" where the teams would not promote/relegate (maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure?). That on its own wouldn't keep two teams owned by two players from combining forces in an "unfair" way, however. Maybe the other stuff would cover that.



LOVE the team chemistry idea, but Bort... what's to stop someone from having 22 of their own players sticking together and building the highest possible chemistry rating?


Nothing is stopping them I guess, unless we decide on a max players on your own team rule or something, which I'm not a huge fan of.


Nor am I, but you know it's going to happen and people are going to complain about it.



People will complain about whatever we do. It's the nature of the internets.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by thehazyone

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by thehazyone



Originally posted by Bort




I think the addition of salary caps and TEAM CHEMISTRY will help quite a bit with collusion, along with an earlier trade deadline, etc.

Salary caps will mean you can't stack your team with too many high level players (especially since there are minimum salaries based on level).

Team chemistry will mean that you have to keep a squad together for a while to keep them competitive. If you bring in too much new blood all at once, you'll hurt your team chemistry and your team will suck.

Also, we're discussing the idea of maybe having a designated "farm league" where the teams would not promote/relegate (maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure?). That on its own wouldn't keep two teams owned by two players from combining forces in an "unfair" way, however. Maybe the other stuff would cover that.



LOVE the team chemistry idea, but Bort... what's to stop someone from having 22 of their own players sticking together and building the highest possible chemistry rating?


Nothing is stopping them I guess, unless we decide on a max players on your own team rule or something, which I'm not a huge fan of.


Nor am I, but you know it's going to happen and people are going to complain about it.



People will complain about whatever we do. It's the nature of the internets.


True, but isn't this game designed to be fairly immune to multiple player issues. I mean we all need XP to level and there are only so many spots, so even total coordination of a team of 1 users players shouldn't effect the game too much
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Yes, I know, I've been teaching people over the Internet for years and am quite used to it. It takes thick skin to be an admin/moderator of any Internet site with a large community. You and DD do a good job of it though.

/end suckuppage
 
remaxjon
offline
Link
 
I'm having a blast with this game so I'm not going anywhere but I still hate the idea of having any kind of farm team system. I just don't understand why they can't just be teams.

As for the internets Bort you are starting some these
http://youtube.com/watch?v=LKTH6f1JfX8
 
jkocurek
offline
Link
 
Farm systems need to go. There is no good reason to have them here, ever. This isn't real life. Everyone is assured a developmental curve, there is no point to minors at all, other than playing time.

The way GLB is set up now will more than cover that.

Nobody has made a decent argument to allow farm teams yet. Yes, it will get you higher leveled players, but if nobody does it then it won't matter. Just eliminate it all together and you remove a ton of headaches from the game.

1 player, 1 team: it's fair, it's healthy for competition, and it will encourage new owners, or owners like me, who don't want to/can't juggle 4 teams. Not to mention that leagues where the expressed goal is player development, and not competition, will suffer the inherent problem of being utterly meaningless for owners. You do that route, now you have to have rules about rosters, salaries, etc, becuase there is no downide to abuse. Who cares if you win in a farm league?

Remove it all and it's a better game for us and fewer hassles for you.
Last edited Apr 14, 2008 22:12:10
 
drkbgrk
offline
Link
 
an owner with 22 of his own players on his team isn't doing anything with money that i couldn't do with some time and effort recruiting players.

someone owning two teams and running them with all of their own players isn't doing anything that bothers me. hope they make glb rich.



Anyone that Colludes by boosting one team with players from another is doubling their Exp pool, which is the only thing that all teams receive equally, regardless of money spent!

you want to only play one string, go iron man to get 100 snaps a game for your whole team, fine. it is a gamble. you'll have no depth. your players will be tired at the end of games.

If you supplement another team with players from a less competitive team you ruin the loser team's league and the beneficiary's. Regular season stats, awards, championships, season records, ratings, standings, competition, fun, etc... They all become devalued.

i don't want to compete in a league that teams using collusion to stock their rosters, and there won't be any meaningful competition in a farm league.

The whole universe of GLB leagues creates more players than higher tiered leagues can hold, especially if (when) the leagues become a pyramid structure.

free agency pull is your farm system. collusion between teams is not necessary.

it is an abuse that corrupts the competition between active legit teams.
it ruins the competitive aspect of regular seasons in every league affected.
it replaces football strategy with spending as the measure of success.
it reduces the quality of the GLB product.
 
jkocurek
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by

free agency pull is your farm system. collusion between teams is not necessary.


I don't think this can be said enough. Don't try to CREATE rules to regulate something that is totally unnecessary anyway. The system, as is (with the new structure) will support a perfectly healthy player economy. There is nothing stopping anybody at that point from spending on the best players at any given moment. When they retire, just buy more.

Spend your time thinking of rules for actual unavoidable problems, don't create more for no reason.
 
ChromeDome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


Pyramids per region. Yes, it's official (minus the announcement).

We have an idea for a short world tourney, too, to help tie everyone together. We'll announce that after we figure it out more. But those are both off-topic for this thread.


Sweet. That's what I figured you guys would come up with.

Going to be funny to see all these guys who leave pro/aaa leagues to end up in low USA leagues before they realize what they did to themselves ;p

Last edited Apr 14, 2008 22:46:33
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jkocurek
Originally posted by


free agency pull is your farm system. collusion between teams is not necessary.


I don't think this can be said enough. Don't try to CREATE rules to regulate something that is totally unnecessary anyway. The system, as is (with the new structure) will support a perfectly healthy player economy. There is nothing stopping anybody at that point from spending on the best players at any given moment. When they retire, just buy more.

Spend your time thinking of rules for actual unavoidable problems, don't create more for no reason.



The best teams will not ever be working out of free agency (unless you consider free agency signing players that they just dropped from another team). That is the inevitable future.
 
jkocurek
offline
Link
 
With a salary cap, it's going to be impossible to lock up everybody. You will have to pare down your talent. With farm teams you can just pop in another cheap player, and it never ends.

Competitive balance should be the issue here, not trying to sell another team or two to a few miscreants. A balance universe will bring far more income in the long run, and no version of balance has farm teams in it.
 
gtbice
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think the addition of salary caps and TEAM CHEMISTRY will help quite a bit with collusion, along with an earlier trade deadline, etc.

Salary caps will mean you can't stack your team with too many high level players (especially since there are minimum salaries based on level).

Team chemistry will mean that you have to keep a squad together for a while to keep them competitive. If you bring in too much new blood all at once, you'll hurt your team chemistry and your team will suck.

Also, we're discussing the idea of maybe having a designated "farm league" where the teams would not promote/relegate (maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure?). That on its own wouldn't keep two teams owned by two players from combining forces in an "unfair" way, however. Maybe the other stuff would cover that.


Will the chemistry be different for offensive and defensive squads or will it all be rolled into one?
Last edited Apr 14, 2008 23:37:21
 
sssaiyun
offline
Link
 
farm teams is a good idea only for the purpose of having a low level league for new players created that doesn't have a chance to play in regular leagues
 
Romeorr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sssaiyun
farm teams is a good idea only for the purpose of having a low level league for new players created that doesn't have a chance to play in regular leagues


You dont need a farm team for this. Just many cpu teams where players can go to get playing time. Before all the teams were bought, my halfback was playing on a cpu team gaining xp until i found the right situation to play in. Once the new leagues come in and there is a new influx of human controlled teams and cpu teams. farm teams wont be needed
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
All I ask is it to be fair. If Bort and DD deem it to be fair, as it is their game, then I'm fine with it. I am of the firm belief that if ya don't like it, hit the road. Complaining, whining, bitching will sometimes have an adverse affect and usually doesn't accomplish anything other than to make yourself look like a crybaby. If the game is good and the competition fair, people will play. If it isn't and the numbers dwindle, then it's on the developers to change their thinking and the game. As it should be. This game requires no skill what-so-ever. You don't have to catch/throw/tackle anyone yourself. You don't need to press buttons and use eye-hand coordination to manipulate a player. All you need to do is click a mouse to change ability levels. Period. Someone could train a monkey to do that. I'm proof of that . The people that master player builds will always dominate the game as it is now. There will always be other players jumping in wanting to play mostly and probably because they like/love football and its the off season. These people will come and go. The game needs to move towards a focus that is more "team" and less "player". IMO. It's a great start.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 11:23:01
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.