User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Bort there is no passing bug, my QB passed well just like last season.
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cosmoxl
So, was the dropped balls issue solved? Is that why this thread is about DB reaction time now?


Sorta - we're speculating on whether completion %'s were down for other reasons.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by tsherr

Wouldn't the reaction time by the secondary be due to high vision/agility? Most CBs and FSs I've seen gave up on catching WRs with speed and went for high vision/agility. It would make sense then that they would figure out the play, see the ball in the air and make the play over a lower agility WR. Especially since a lot of them went for high jumping, which I would assume helps with PDs.

T


Indeed that makes sense, and that's the idea. I'm just thinking out loud: If a guy with 20 vision makes a jump on the ball in a split second every time just about as well as a guy with 70 vision, I'd say that's a problem. I'm not sure if that tends the case, though, since I don't watch every single sim that gets run out there (we're up to 1280 sims per day at this point).


I think that a big thing that has made the sim defense dominated (especially in Season 3) was that defensive players' reaction time was too good. In real life the advantage that offenses have over defenses is that they know what they're running and defenses don't.

Most of those who complain are so used to defense domination that they don't realize how great a realistically balanced sim would be. They think "How will defnses stop offenses then?" Well, they should only stop them sometimes. Sometimes there should be 80 yard TD drives even against good defenses (btw, one great thing in this sim is I think we'll finally see most points scored by TD rather than by FG).

I'd definitely base defensive reaction time on Vision and Agility, although right now it seems so good that to get it as good as it is now it would take 100 of both (although you also, for obvious reasons, don't want to overadjust it; if 30% of passes are batted down now, then it should be maybe 20% are batted down when playing against 20 vision/agility, 25% against 50 vision/agility, and the full 30% against 100 vision/agility).
 
Link
 
Originally posted by JDaniels127
Look guys, the WRs were catching everything. The QB's were making perfect throws. The game had to be tweaked or by Level 30 there would be no drops or interceptions.



And yet the average per pass attempt was far below the NFL average--and even worse when playing against "roughly similar" teams in higher leagues.
 
wctbud
offline
Link
 
The two QB's on my team performed really badly compared to their last season. Improved O-Line also...seems a little odd if you ask me.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cosmoxl
So, was the dropped balls issue solved? Is that why this thread is about DB reaction time now?


I think, personally, that dropped balls are now realistic (after yesterday's tweaks) and that completion percentages are still low for other reasons.

There are still more dropped balls than last season, but that's because there were too few last season and not too many this season.

Last season, 40 Catching caught everything and 20 Catching caught way too many passes too easily. Now, 40 Catching will still make drops on occasion and 20 Catching will drop a lot of passes, as it should be.

The key is to make sure it doesn't cripple the passing game, and I think slowing defensive reaction, having fewer tipped passes, is a great way to do that.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by JDaniels127

Look guys, the WRs were catching everything. The QB's were making perfect throws. The game had to be tweaked or by Level 30 there would be no drops or interceptions.



And yet the average per pass attempt was far below the NFL average--and even worse when playing against "roughly similar" teams in higher leagues.


There were also too many interceptions compared to real life.

But I think Bort's on the right path with defensive reaction time.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Defensive reaction time is not too good... as evidenced by linebacker plays like these:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79423&pbp_id=85543
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
You want to make this easier?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79423&pbp_id=85864
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Defensive reaction time is not too good... as evidenced by linebacker plays like these:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79423&pbp_id=85543


That doesn't show anything except that the LB's were instructed to protect the outside or play a deep zone. It's clear (as the trajectory was exactly the same on each side) that they were still running a designed play.

A big place I notice too-good reaction time on defense is when a receiver makes a cut. Unless the receiver has a big agility edge, the CB stays right with him. The CB didn't know the cut was coming, so he should fall behind at that point.

If he was playing at medium distance he should be able to recover. If he was playing at close distance, he'd better be fast and agile to catch back up.

Then, as in real life, more teams would have to play looser coverage and zones.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
You want to make this easier?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79423&pbp_id=85864


Yes, because there aren't nearly enough of those.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
No, what that shows is that LBs can't react to a run play without first completing their entire assignment, no matter how ridiculously awful it is.

And I totally disagree about route reactions for CBs. I constantly see CBs getting toasted.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
No, what that shows is that LBs can't react to a run play without first completing their entire assignment, no matter how ridiculously awful it is.

And I totally disagree about route reactions for CBs. I constantly see CBs getting toasted.


I sure don't.

Why have we never come close to realistic passing averages?

CB's don't get really beaten nearly as much as in real life.

You have to accept that defenses dominated last season, and that that needs to be ended.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

No, what that shows is that LBs can't react to a run play without first completing their entire assignment, no matter how ridiculously awful it is.

And I totally disagree about route reactions for CBs. I constantly see CBs getting toasted.


I sure don't.

Why have we never come close to realistic passing averages?

CB's don't get really beaten nearly as much as in real life.

You have to accept that defenses dominated last season, and that that needs to be ended.


What are realistic passing averages?

Yards? I think passing yards gained is WAAAAAAY out of hand, so that can't be the problem.

YPA? You think level 25s and lower should be going for 7-8 yards per attempt. That's damn high.

Completion percentage? Again, how accurate do you want level 25 and lower players to be? Our QB has no problems roasting defenses last season, and he was underleveled for the league: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=174614
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 18:34:43
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
I'd definitely base defensive reaction time on Vision and Agility, although right now it seems so good that to get it as good as it is now it would take 100 of both (although you also, for obvious reasons, don't want to overadjust it; if 30% of passes are batted down now, then it should be maybe 20% are batted down when playing against 20 vision/agility, 25% against 50 vision/agility, and the full 30% against 100 vision/agility).


Great idea! Base another important behavior on agility.

- sidewards movement/turning (slowing down also, I guess)
- shed blocks
- acceleration
- reaction time

What else?

Just create a super attribute, everyone MUST have 80+ to perform.


If a defender has 20 vision, 20 agility - he will not even be close to any receiver as the ball is thrown. He'll be outsprinted at the 7, so he'll not even has to be outcut/outfaked at the 15. If the ball is thrown anywhere close to the WR, he won't be there in time to swat anyway - exept it's a very, very bad pass and the WR needs a whole lot of time to make the catch safe.

25% against 50 vision/agility? You sure talk about the defender only, right? So you basically like to suggest any defender needs at least 50 vision, 50 agility to swat down 1/4 of all passes - no matter how badly they are thrown and how good the WR was covered?

And since Mr. Larry "couch potato averator" Roadgrader provides the numbers of NFL; that'll sure be the future of GLB: WRs not beeing able to create any separation catching 75% of all passes by any decent QB - if the CB is a perfect build within a very, very small range of possible combinations (don't forget: because of all the catched passes, the CB needs 50 confidence for sure; and 60 speed; and 40 strength/50 tackling if he wants to tackle at all, 50 jumping naturally, 50 catching if he wants some picks; besides 50 stamina naturally; and those SAs).

Well... let's see if there are any guys left wanting to create a defender by end of this season if this comes true.

/ironic

I've really seen more defensive guys with vision above 50 than offensive guys (besides QBs). So since they earned their reaction time, what's wrong with that?

What's the average of brain dead offensive guys in NFL? On average - how quickly do they react?
 
Pickster00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cosmoxl



I think, personally, that dropped balls are now realistic (after yesterday's tweaks) and that completion percentages are still low for other reasons.

There are still more dropped balls than last season, but that's because there were too few last season and not too many this season.



In one sim I had a player in yesterday with our L23 QB throwing to L20-21 TEs & WRs we had 25 completions and 20 drops. That seems well beyond realistic.
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 18:13:46
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.