User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Trades and Signings during Playoffs
Page:
 
Verloren
offline
Link
 
I think Bort is talking about adding FA players right before playoffs, and not by trade. Why not implement a thing at the trade deadline where people cannot sign with new teams as well?
Like what someone else said, there won't be a clear contender yet.
Last edited Mar 1, 2008 21:04:19
 
Juggalokai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Verloren
I think Bort is talking about adding FA players right before playoffs, and not by trade. Why not implement a thing at the trade deadline where people cannot sign with new teams as well?
Like what someone else said, there won't be a clear contender yet.


lol what happenes to a person when you drop them?

they become FA's

he doesnt want a full team dropping to join another team and winning a championship


people also discussed trade dealine

nobody can trade right now dude
 
Verloren
offline
Link
 
Lol, true. Nixed another idea I just got regarding the trades.
 
derekjeter76
offline
Link
 
I got an idea to solve all this. Make contracts end AT THE END OF THE PLAY OFFS!

Not midway through the season.

Say I sign a 1 year contract in week 6 and as of right now I would become a FA at week 6 next year, make it so I become a FA at the end of the year. Make sure signing bonuses and stuff are accordinated by how many games are left in a seaosn.
 
moonlightmerc
offline
Link
 
For Free Agents why cant we just have a Training Combine after the trading deadline? They can go through a series of training programs to improve their skills.

Its new players shouldnt expect to be thrown into a game right away they should earn their keep.

Once the season ends for a team they can begin to sign free agents. If a team dont make the playoffs they can begin signing free agents. It will give the an advantage to signing players but some players probably hold out to sign with a team in the playoffs. But non-playoff teams will still get first divs at free agents. . .And they should since there is no draft system yet.
Last edited Mar 24, 2008 11:41:53
 
holloway4263
offline
Link
 
Just a thought but have we ever thought about a draft? I know that is what I enjoy the most about these games. I am not sure how it would work but I know there are smart people out there. I think Trading and FA's are nice but we are missing a big part of football right now. The draft could take place during the playoff's it doesn't need to be after.
 
Verloren
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by holloway4263
Just a thought but have we ever thought about a draft? I know that is what I enjoy the most about these games. I am not sure how it would work but I know there are smart people out there. I think Trading and FA's are nice but we are missing a big part of football right now. The draft could take place during the playoff's it doesn't need to be after.


It will be very hard to gather everyone together at a specific time on one day. There are Europeans and people from Asia playing as well, and that makes it even harder.

Not to mention putting players on hold because they need to be drafted before they can play the game.
 
holloway4263
offline
Link
 
As for putting those players on hold you could ask if they wanted to enter the draft. If not they could be FA's

Getting everyone drafting at the same time would be hard. I am not sure I have the answer. But I think there are ways you could work around it. (I do that each year in Fan. Football yahoo leagues)

A few Idea's would be to have players from the lower levels draftable. Have one feed the other.
 
chrisko
offline
Link
 
Have everyone enter the draft with a cut-off date. After the cut off date, all the league GMs have 2 days to create a draft board of the available players. Then an auto-draft happens based on their big boards with a little AI, to make sure they don't draft too many people at the same position.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by holloway4263
Just a thought but have we ever thought about a draft? I know that is what I enjoy the most about these games. I am not sure how it would work but I know there are smart people out there. I think Trading and FA's are nice but we are missing a big part of football right now. The draft could take place during the playoff's it doesn't need to be after.


Hmmm, or for example at the end of the year everyone with 1 year's experience in the US AAA league would have the option to move on to the Pro's in a draft. This could even work for other leagues (A players drafted by AA teams). Obviously, there would be a limited number of rounds and picks, so you would risk not getting picked if you declare for the draft with a below-average player.
 
Verloren
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by San Diego Chargers

Hmmm, or for example at the end of the year everyone with 1 year's experience in the US AAA league would have the option to move on to the Pro's in a draft. This could even work for other leagues (A players drafted by AA teams). Obviously, there would be a limited number of rounds and picks, so you would risk not getting picked if you declare for the draft with a below-average player.


Might not work if players are selected by a team with a full roster of returning players. This depends on a high turnover of players reaching the top and retiring. And since there won't be XP gains for benchwarming, there isn't much point in getting drafted and playing backup. Best bet would be for a farm team, but not everybody is willing/has the time to run 2 teams.
 
djactionman
offline
Link
 
I guess this makes sense and that there isn't a perfect way to prevent playoff stacking. I just would like to be able to cut players since we are still paying for them and could be restructuring for the next season already instead of paying people we will be cutting anyways.
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
i know this thread was ghost bumped, but if you mishandle trade/FA deadlines you could have alot of new players never give this game a chance. First off, set the trade deadline whenever you want, week 8 seems reasonable. Between weeks 12 and 16, if you are released by a team, you cannot sign with teams until the regular season is over and they are not in the playoffs. If you give non-playoff teams the ability to sign players, it'll help them with a longer offseason as well as not punish any players that join late in the season. In all honesty, after week 8, if you can't even release people, your not going to want to sign a bunch of other players and raise your salary greatly while pissing off all your players who get stuck with no playing time.

The only way putting a release players deadline makes any sense is if you have all players not officially get made until the offseason, or if you make all player contracts end at the end of each year. As it stands with what you want to implement, anyone who makes a player after week 8 and signs a contract, they will forever become free-agents after most teams already consider their rosters set. Most teams don't look for a new RB week 10 unless their RB is really struggling. Putting a end to releasing players after halfway through the season is going to end up with alot of players stuck as 3rd striners on teams as well as alot of FA's who are destined to have a much harder time finding new teams each year.

I agree you shouldn't be able to sign new players in the playoffs, but doing something like having any player released after week 12 is ineligible to sign with another team until they are out of the playoffs/regular season only makes sense. Also, i don't know if its restricted now, but teams that get knocked out of the playoffs/didn't make it should not have their signing/releasing restricted, at the very least for re-signing their own players.

Also, alot of players will be getting extensions near the end of the season, this means alot of teams could potentially lose players right before the playoffs each year, which is retarded since that would never happen in real life, or if the players aren't allowed to sign with another team after their contract is up week 13, they basically either have to re-sign or not play for two weeks.

To clearify, I suggest you at least re-examine the moves you guys are considering implementing and how they effect players who are made as well as have expiring contracts and different points in the season. In my opinion, having all contracts expire at the end of the season easily makes the most sense.
 
Aoiree
offline
Link
 
wrong forum
Last edited Apr 14, 2008 21:07:12
 
Rob Mathews
offline
Link
 
I have no problem with the trade deadline idea and dropping players idea. However, what about team owners/players who want to resign with the same team? Alot of players are stuck with a low level contract that doesn't even allow for training expenses on relaxed let alone normal or intense. Their owner wants to resign them, but can't. I think you should be able to renogtiate/resign players already on your team. You still wouldn't be able to drop anyone or trade them.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.