User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Advanced Play Calling Tactics
Page:
 
Apallyon
offline
Link
 
I'm assuming that with the addition of the 3-4 defence, it might also be an idea to add a 5-3 or goalline defence for obvious running situations.

and adding a Db for 3 receiver sets is a great idea.
 
Beefeater
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I think if you're doing this in stages, the first stage should definitely be just being able to play different formations. Just make it as simple as picking how many RBs, WRs, TEs, and FBs as first. And then have percentages for how often to use each one. And then you could do the same thing with a 4-3, 3-4, 4-4, 5-2, nickel, and dime on defense.

Then, after everyone gets used to picking between 5 or 6 "normal" formations, you could make it fully customizable and let someone play 5 TEs if they want. Or maybe a 5-0 on defense with no linebackers.

I think you're probably still a ways out from getting to the point where you can set different percentages for every down and distance, differentiate between a pro set and an I-formation, etc. You don't want to make too many changes at once and confuse people either.
 
domenick2x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Beefeater
Yeah, I think if you're doing this in stages, the first stage should definitely be just being able to play different formations. Just make it as simple as picking how many RBs, WRs, TEs, and FBs as first. And then have percentages for how often to use each one. And then you could do the same thing with a 4-3, 3-4, 4-4, 5-2, nickel, and dime on defense.

Then, after everyone gets used to picking between 5 or 6 "normal" formations, you could make it fully customizable and let someone play 5 TEs if they want. Or maybe a 5-0 on defense with no linebackers.

I think you're probably still a ways out from getting to the point where you can set different percentages for every down and distance, differentiate between a pro set and an I-formation, etc. You don't want to make too many changes at once and confuse people either.



You sound like Bill Belichick. Why not 6 LBs?

I'd love to see WRs with range factors also - just like with the HB inside/outside factors, if you could set a possessiong WR to run 60-30-10 short/mid/long or a deep threat to do the opposite (10-30-60)... that would naturally enhance the playcalling.
 
paraflux
offline
Link
 
nickel packages arent necessarily 3-4, I would never really do that on my team. Id have 4 DLinemen as usual, 2 LB's, and 3 CB's. Just wanted to point that out cuz the original post doesnt mention a 4-Line nickel defense.
 
Lohengrin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

For each down/distance group, you would choose your base formation based on how many receivers there are in the opponent's formation. For example, you could set your base set to 3-4 when there are 2 or 3 receivers, switch to 3-4 nickel when there are 4 receivers, 3-4 dime when there are 5, etc.


This thought had me thinking - is there some consideration to adding a no-huddle (hurry-up) offense mode as part of tactics, in order to prevent the defense from adjusting like this?
 
Chriztian
offline
Link
 
I'd like more customization for individual tactics. Right now a DE can choose between reading pass and run plays or balancing, but not whether or not he drops back into coverage or rushes the passer. I've noticed mine continually dropping back to cover a already covered WR instead of running straight ahead.
 
Hubedi
offline
Link
 
When will we see the 3-4 formation?
I'm anxious to play with it ^^

3-4 mastermind here hehehehhehehehehehe
 
Throttle
offline
Link
 
This propably already been mentioned so flame away
I'd just like to add that it would be nice if you could add certain personnel-packages, like if you want to use a running play it would be helpful if you could have an option to choose wether to have your pass-catching TE or your run-blocking TE on the field.
Same goes for Defense, if its a short distance, get your pass-rushers out and your runstoppers in. Im a guy who likes to play my own strengths so to all you fumbleruuski GMs out there, this might not be your way to play it.
I know the idea is somewhat already mentioned but id just like to point it out
Last edited Apr 5, 2008 17:44:41
 
Bears Rule
offline
Link
 
I didnt really read through this much aside from Borts first post, but I was wondering how advanced the tactics are going to get for individual players?

I just think there should be something to do to seperate guys who are on the same level...People put these guides on how to build players and 75% of the players actually use it from what I can tell...so you come to the problem that everyone forms the same player at the same levels...something needs to seperate players...

This would also give some more stuff to do for the individual who gets bored by sitting back and watching Owner's and GM's run this game...
 
goarmy80
offline
Link
 
I would like to see instead of just middle/outside runs. Left outside, left off-tackle, middle, right off-tackle, right outside. Also being able to set up down/distance playcalling like has been mentioned.
 
Zdorab
offline
Link
 
Didn't read the thread, but I think it would be very important to assign player priorities to specific plays.

For example, short yardage, give priority to your power back over elusive back. Running plays, give priority to your blocking TE over receiving TE. Same for receivers in different situations.

This gives every player more incentive to specialize and it gives managers more incentive to play more players per game. Win win!
 
PixelNinja
offline
Link
 
Anyone play Front Office Football? They had a pretty good game planning setup.
 
dusk883
Zone Monster
offline
Link
 
I'd sell my soul if the TAMPA 2 were an option as a Defense.
 
MiniHusk
offline
Link
 
YES PLEASE, when can we do this as last game my TE2 only got 5 plays and my WR4 only got 2 plays.
 
Thaak
offline
Link
 
This would be way cool! Adding options for audibles might be a good idea too... or perhaps the advanced tactics are basically audibles anyways.

Also, might be a neat (low priority) idea for text lines in the play by play:

QB <insert name here> calls audible, throws pass to WR <insert name here> et. al.

Also might want an option when looking at play by play, to turn on or off the substitution text lines so you know when someone is subbed in and and for whom.
Last edited Apr 9, 2008 17:24:42
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.