User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Bomber085
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bruiser 1234
So how many people can we nominate from our team and how exactly is this working again


I thought we were selecting from our team based on the criteria on page 1..

Originally posted by onlyrockerfan
and its usually the owner that does the ballot, unless that owner is unwilling to then they designate a GM to do it. Here's an example of what we did in Canada AAA last season.

Originally posted by

Alright boys, so the Eastern Conference is going to have a Pro Bowl roster for their side and I want one for ours so I'm going to take charge and make sure that we get one done for ours as well. I'm going to follow much of the same format as MiniHusk did for the East because he did an excellent job and has a great setup.

Step 1 - Nominations Closed!

Step 2 - Nominees will be Posted on this Page on Saturday

The list of nominees can be found on this spreadsheet:

http://www.box.net/shared/cgp4oe288o

You do not have to sign up for anything, just click on preview. This has all of the players on there with stats as nominated by you.

Step 3 - Voting Begins Saturday and will conclude on the following Thursday (July 17)

Voting begins and just like the nominees, each team is allowed 1 ballot so they will choose a starting roster. Each team will get to choose from the list:

1 QB
1 HB
1 FB
2 WR
1 TE
1 C
1 LT
1 RT
1 LG
1 RG
1 NT
1 DT
1 LDE
1 RDE
1 MLB
1 LOLB
1 ROLB
2 CB
1 FS
1 SS
1 K
1 P
1 KR
1 PR

Offensive MVP
Defensive MVP

These choices will be submitted to me via private message and the votes will be tallied and the top two in each position (4 in WR and CB) will be announced as our Pro Bowl team.

Final Step - Team Announced on Friday, July 18

The Eastern Conference Pro Bowl Team will be announced after all of the votes are in just in time for the Eastern Conference Championship. As well, the offensive and defensive MVP's will also be announced.


Last edited Aug 26, 2008 14:54:33
 
Bomber085
offline
Link
 
Whom will be taking control of this and compiling all the stats together for the owners to review and make final selections? When are these due, after week 15? When are final results anticipated?
 
onlyrockerfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bomber085
Whom will be taking control of this and compiling all the stats together for the owners to review and make final selections? When are these due, after week 15? When are final results anticipated?


I will try to work on it...
 
Gamecock1
offline
Link
 
Dirty Boyz are in
 
Gabrosin
offline
Link
 
Late to the party on this thread, but I'd be happy to volunteer my services for running the All-Conference and All-League team choices. My proposed rules:

1. There's not really a need for teams to submit a list of choices from their team. I can compile a list of the eligible players at each position and their brief season stat line. I would limit the list to starters, though any player in the league would be eligible as a write-in.

2. The list of players would be posted on the league forums after the week 15 games, listing their current stats. Anyone in the league (owner, player, GM, whoever) can respond to the thread and lobby for someone to be selected, whether it's their own guy, another player on their team, or even someone they played against.

3. Each of the 32 team owners would have 96 hours to submit, by private message to me, the list of players that they're voting for. Each team would vote for the following players: 3 QBs, 3 HBs, 1 FB, 4 WRs, 2 TEs, 3 OTs, 3 OGs, 2 OCs, 3 DEs, 3 DTs, 5 LBs, 3 CBs, 1 SS, 1 FS, 1 K, 1 P, and one KR/PR. This is the same set of votes cast for the NFL Pro Bowl ballot, except that all LBs are grouped as one, and there's no special teams specialist vote. Owners MAY NOT vote for any player on their own team; owners only place votes for the conference they belong to, which should save everyone some time and energy here. Each vote is worth the same (no ranking of players in your voting, i.e. #1 QB, #2 QB, etc.), but you may vote for as few people as you choose (if you only want to choose one QB, you can). After all votes are in, owners may make their complete ballots public if they choose to do so, but please keep them private until voting has closed... if you want to influence the choices of others, argue your case on the discussion thread.

4. Once the voting deadline has elapsed, the teams will be compiled as follows. The starting lineup for each conference (1 QB, 1 HB, 1 FB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 2 OT, 2 OG, 1 OC, 2 DT, 2 DE, 3 LB, 2 CB, 1 SS, 1 FS, 1 K, 1 P, 1 KR/PR) will be selected by highest vote total. In the event of a tie at any position, co-starters will be named. Once the starters have been determined, the remaining roster spots (2 QB, 2 HB, 1 FB, 3 WR, 2 TE, 1 OT, 1 OG, 1 OC, 2 DT, 2 DE, 3 LB, 2 CB, 1 SS, 1 FS) will be selected by highest vote total of those remaining. If co-starters were named at a position, there is one less backup spot available there. In the event that enough people are tied for the highest total that the position would exceed its normal roster space, extra space will be allowed to ensure that no tiebreak is needed. After all starters and backups have been named, any team which does not have a representative on their all-conference roster will have one player selected, regardless of position, and added to the team; this player will be determined by highest vote total among players from that team. In the event of a tie, the player at the "least full position" will be chosen (i.e. if your QB and your FB tie, and the team has three QBs and two FBs already, your FB would be chosen). If a team does not receive a single all-conference vote for any player on its roster, the highest-level player on the team will be added; ties will be broken in the same "least full position" method described above.

5. The all-league team will be determined in the same way as the all-conference teams, except only a starting lineup will be named, including any co-starters in the event of a voting tie. There is no requirement that a team have one of their players on the all-league team.

6. Players who receive a vote on every submitted ballot for their conference will receive the title of "unanimous all-league selection". Also, they get a cookie. If an owner does not submit a ballot to the process, it will not count against a player's chances of being a unanimous choice, but if an owner submits a ballot which is empty or incomplete at a position, it will count against the players at that position.

The teams get posted as soon as they're compiled, somewhere in the middle of playoff season.

Since week 15 is fast approaching, let's get some consensus on how this is going to work. If someone else prefers to run it differently, by all means do so; I'll be ready to submit my ballot when the time comes.
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
I think you got it set pretty damn well, go ahead and do that one
 
onlyrockerfan
offline
Link
 
okay then......whatever works...........

but if you're going to do it you have to limit it to a GM or owner, if you have a dead forums or have a lot of players on your team they'll hurt in the votes.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 19:01:10
 
Gabrosin
offline
Link
 
"3. Each of the 32 team owners would have 96 hours to submit, by private message to me, the list of players that they're voting for."

I would expect that any owner who wants to get feedback from his GMs and other agents could discuss the ballot on their own boards, but there will only be one ballot submitted per team.
 
onlyrockerfan
offline
Link
 
supposed it works out best....don't know what my internet availability will be....I'll be on call up in a hotel for the RNC....incase anything drastic happens. Need to get working on my junky labtop.
 
Graevis
offline
Link
 
Count the Beavers in - I will get my GM's compiling a list on our forums and then we will submit a list to you via PM as per the above guideline.
 
Graevis
offline
Link
 
One quick question:

What if we feel we have the best all round FB in the conference, we are not supposed to submit a ballot with our own players on it - do I just leave it blank?
 
onlyrockerfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Graevis
Count the Beavers in - I will get my GM's compiling a list on our forums and then we will submit a list to you via PM as per the above guideline.


he posts a list here on the forums, then you compile your picks from that list and send them to him by the date that he chooses......I believe
 
Gabrosin
offline
Link
 
For any owner who thinks they might have availability issues, you can submit your ballot early, or you can designate a proxy (i.e. one of your GMs) to submit it for you.

Graevis, if you feel your guy is the best, you can decline to submit any other names if you'd like, but the idea is to vote for someone from another team that you think deserves recognition. Go ahead and pimp your deserving players on the thread.
 
shakirus
offline
Link
 
count the Vikings in.
 
fliphusker
offline
Link
 
I will have a gM do this, simply do not have time for it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.